Conquer Club

I don't have time to do the Night actions right now. I'll type them out later when I have an hour or two. Sorry guys.

Also, I'm going to give the premium prize away like this:

Anyone still reading this thread can nominate someone they thought played really well. Anyone on the town side is eligible to win, except those who were modkilled and saxlad (because he got reincarnated, you can't get two chances). Whoever gets the most nominations will be in the running with two people I nominate. I'm going to look back at the actions and nominate the two people who were able to use their roles' most effectively (a roleblocker who got blocked scum, a doctor who saved, a killer who killed scum, etc).

So start listing who you thought played the best.

I really enjoyed my role and since my actions were fake and I could use them as whatever I wanted, I used them to invent roles I had never heard of being used before. Aka: astral projection (intangible tracker), town crier (the idea with this role was supposed to be that if I targetted a person who died that same night, than the entire town would be given a clue as to how they were killed), drunk cop (investigations are random doesn't know he's drunk), lifeguard (saves people from drowning), and solar panel (allows whoever I target to use their abilities again during that day)

squirrel i was recently upgraded anyways. is anyone on the town side anyone who is alive or anyone who is town?

Even so. My Vote goes to karel, he played scalpel man brilliantly

Glad it's over great game, but finally I can relieve my feelings

I'm very interested as to how certain roles changed through the game (or would have, what about if flores had died before flores's bodyguard?)
Great roles, had a great gaming experience! Ended up slitting a lot of townie throats, killing 5 in total and only 1 mafia if I'm correct, but a very fun role! especially with the whole buzz around Team Rocket and the scalpal man

Squirrel, I must say you had me convinced that Yang was mafia when Yin got killed and turned up town Did you intentionally create this diversion?

herk, do you realize how much frustration you've caused me? all this info you gave away about us, I believe already on Day 1. I can't believe we survived this long

*throws philosopher cane* Y feliz navidad a todos!

Great work Squirrell, I got caught into reading the roles instead of picking a recipe for this evening, love the backgrounds
I couldn't do much but had a lot of fun with my role, prolly best game as third party for me since I was able to help town without fearing a NK after a while. I think Haggis was the most challenging scum in terms of play, glad we got him lynched at the right time. I thought it was a bit unfair for Commander to get a GF guilty like that but seeing as there were two of them, it makes more sense.

As for the nomination not sure who to pick, I think Strike & Nag played very well in the daytime but being mods they don't need the prize So who needs it besides me?

Lol Karel, I can buy that Herk was hard to deal with, his BSing about all the protects even after Flow died was probably useful in keeping you alive anyway. I liked the enabler system, there were a lot of protects but also a lot of ways for the scum to bypass them or kill safely so it balances out IMO.
In regards to the actions Commander was probably the most influential though I was really not getting how he was claiming so and so had a gun but not pursuing them for the scum they were, was a bit surreal at times
Tails role was pretty cool also, I wonder if he was responsible for killing the scum in the first nights?
Anyway straight scum lynches from day 3 to day 7, town pwned this

ga7 wrote:As for the nomination not sure who to pick, I think Strike & Nag played very well in the daytime but being mods they don't need the prize So who needs it besides me?

MEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!

TheSaxlad wrote:squirrel i was recently upgraded anyways. is anyone on the town side anyone who is alive or anyone who is town?

Even so. My Vote goes to karel, he played scalpel man brilliantly

When he was constantly killing townies?

Anyway, I know ga7 needs the premium so my vote goes to him and also if I happen to win for my mad cop skillz (even though when I investigated jace and haggis both investigations were fail) I'll donate it to him.

Oh..and fircoal.

Great game Mr. Squirell and great roles/playing by everyone. I ll have to think about who to vote for but Karels out, Not anything but 1 to 5 is tad on the bad side

Herk and karel are out. 1:5 is not good and 1+1=/= dolphin. My vote goes to commander for finding 3 scum and ga7 because he was able to survive and managed to mason up with 2 very powerful townies while searching blindly. Both in the long run did very well during the day.

Wooohoo! Congrats Town & Mod.

TheSaxlad wrote:is anyone on the town side anyone who is alive or anyone who is town?

You can nominate anyone who was town except those I mentioned. If they played well, then they are eligible for the prize regardless of whether or not they survived.

karelpietertje wrote:Squirrel, I must say you had me convinced that Yang was mafia when Yin got killed and turned up town Did you intentionally create this diversion?

Personally, I hate setups where there is a town/scum linked group. It kind of screws over both players and almost always they get killed so my linked groups are almost always town only. I don't do it to screw people up, but just because I prefer it that way.

karelpietertje wrote:herk, do you realize how much frustration you've caused me? all this info you gave away about us, I believe already on Day 1. I can't believe we survived this long

Lol. I am considering nominating herk because of how well he handled his Team Rocket. He gained the town's trust of him and his team while still keeping in the shadows enough to not get the Mafia's kill. For having no power of his own, he ensured that his teammates would live and he would live. IMO he played very well, if not a little eccentric at times.

ga7 wrote:I couldn't do much but had a lot of fun with my role, prolly best game as third party for me since I was able to help town without fearing a NK after a while.

Yea, when I was setting up the roles, I really really wanted to make your role a SK as well as a recruiter. Essentially you would be forcing players to defend the SK. I thought it would have been great. However when it came to balancing the game, the extra NK threw it off so I just made you a recruiter.

ga7 wrote:I thought it was a bit unfair for Commander to get a GF guilty like that but seeing as there were two of them, it makes more sense.

Well, in my balancing scenarios I found that the mafia was screwed unless one of the Godfathers got killed. Until the mafias could unite, they were at a great disadvantage. That is why I gave commander that ability. It actually benefited the scum rather than hurt them. It only sucks for the godfather that got caught.

Lol. I am considering nominating herk because of how well he handled his Team Rocket. He gained the town's trust of him and his team while still keeping in the shadows enough to not get the Mafia's kill. For having no power of his own, he ensured that his teammates would live and he would live. IMO he played very well, if not a little eccentric at times.

Yeah, that was pretty crazy. I made up lies up until my last post when I said Karel had extra protects. I'm quite sure I kept people alive with my claims. It was some seriously hard shit to do when I had absolutely NO POWER at all. It was a hard role, but I think I played it quite well also.

Just wanted to quickly head in and wish Merry Christmas to everyone and thank for the wonderful game. I'll try to leave some input during the weekend, but I'm off for now.

Merry Christmas all!

<3 Nag
Well I'll nominate Fir then for saving two lives that were actually targeted in one night, including mine Commander has the best actions run hands down though.

strike wolf wrote:Herk and karel are out. 1:5 is not good and 1+1=/= dolphin. My vote goes to commander for finding 3 scum and ga7 because he was able to survive and managed to mason up with 2 very powerful townies while searching blindly. Both in the long run did very well during the day.

In my defense, the obvious mafia scumsters were lynched during the day. Even though you can do a lot of profiling based on posts, the luck factor always remains, especially when there has been little discussion in the day on others.

I find it hard to nominate people. Not sure yet if I want to go for most useful in discussions, nice targetting, claiming/not claiming at the right time(s), or whatever.

I'm starting to change my mind about your gameplan herk... I suppose your claims turned out to be good for the win, but I've been sweating a lot. For instance, you clearly gave away that Flow was part of your group, and with the mafia able to read that Flow had a 2-night protect, in their shoes I would've probably tried and targetted you.

Although it was probably hard for the mafia to suspect the enabler-system to work like that... Ah well, interesting game, still thinking about it a lot

Oh, another question Mr. Squirrel: you said there would be anti-claim mechanisms, so I have been careful even until the very end to leave any info on what kind of role I was.

Would you only have acted if there was a mass-claim?

I do think Herk's antics were useful but I think it's scum's fault that you guys weren't targetted. Victor randomly chose to poison Chu for instance when Herk was the obvious target. Also dunno why you guys kept killing townies even proven ones, seems Herk was disbelieving Nag was cop for some reason. I think the anti mass claim thing refers to Thezz role, who apparently just didn't use it which is weird since we had many claims going

dangit, since when does the boss keep together the whole mafia? town could've won in two days in that case, or a day and a night with a competent vig.
Other than that, thanks squirrel, great game I loved the roles. GG town and sorry for getting lynched so fast mafia. oh well I can put some of the fake-claims I thought of in some other game

Question: so thez guessed my role right and killed me?

I nominate naxus for managing to disprove the otherwise invincible jace's claim

/ wrote:I nominate naxus for managing to disprove the otherwise invincible jace's claim

Nax had quite a few good catches. Mostly because he watched herk and mafia kept on trying to fake claim doctors who visited him.

I tracked two mafia, but as luck would have it, it was the untrackable killer and the mafia godfather who sent someone else.

Also karel: that is NOT how you play a town vig.

Yeah if you have doubts about who is scum don't take the risk targetting them.