Conquer Club

dunc_2007 wrote:As I don't want to look like an idiot, I have a quick question before I post my theory. If a cop were to investigate ani last night, would they learn his alignment? Or would they not because he died?

Are you telling us you're a cop, or are you just genuinely curious?

Because if you're a cop, we'd all love to hear your results.

No, I'm not a cop. I was curious as to what would happen.

I figure the cop/cops probably invesetigated ani last night, which is why we haven't heard anything from them yet. If they weren't told his alignment, there would be no reason for them to come out and say, "I'm a cop. I've got nothing.", especially with the possibility that ani was the doctor.

On the other hand, if they did investigate him, and he came up as town, I'm not so sure they'd tell us either. It would be worth it to expose a cop in telling us ani's alignment, would it?

This is all just speculation, though. For all I know, they could have investigated anyone.

What I think happened is a vigilante killed one and the mafia killed the other.

So now we just need to figure out who killed who. The one that the mafia killed would likely be town and we would just need to sort out who the scum are out of who voted on the bandwagon.


Of course, the mafia could've seen that coming and decided to get rid of a liability and confuse the town, which seems very likely as both of our bandwagon subjects are now dead.

Perhaps it was Mafia kill + Godfather kill?

That janitor thing fucking sucks, we won't be able to get info on any kill till he dies apparently heh. I don't think a vig would have just taken a shot on claimed power roles, or else he needs to get his shit together. But Mafia + SK is more likely. I really don't get why both kills got hidden though, pfff.

Now for the serious part...
First Holo asks for cop info. Dunc asks a question that would be kinda weird if he was indeed cop, then Holo comes again trying to make sure Dunc is a cop or not. All that while the freaking claimed doc just died. And asking results when if Dunc was indeed cop his post implied he'd have investigated Ani, making the investigation worthless since he died except for sanity purposes. I find Dunc's reasoning questionable as again, why on earth would a cop come out just because he investigated a dead guy? But the fishiest here is undoubtedly Hologram.

Vote Hologram Why the hell do you want a cop to out himself now that our probable doctor is dead?

ga7 wrote:Vote Hologram Why the hell do you want a cop to out himself now that our probable doctor is dead?

This. Definately made me cringe when you asked if he was cop. Vote Hologram

I wasn't thinking along those lines, quite honestly.

Hologram wrote:

dunc_2007 wrote:As I don't want to look like an idiot, I have a quick question before I post my theory. If a cop were to investigate ani last night, would they learn his alignment? Or would they not because he died?

Are you telling us you're a cop, or are you just genuinely curious?

Because if you're a cop, we'd all love to hear your results.

In what lines does it make sense to ask a possible cop that would have investigated Ani to tell his result? Seriously?

The lines where I wanted a lead.

Like I said, I wasn't thinking. It was a bonehead move on my part.

If only everything could be adequately explained by saying "I was stupid"...

I think Hologram could use a bit more pressure, Vote Hologram

dunc_2007 wrote:On the other hand, if they did investigate him, and he came up as town, I'm not so sure they'd tell us either. It would not be worth it to expose a cop in telling us ani's alignment, would it?

EBWOP. Jeese, I just noticed this now, so I can see how ga7 found my reasoning questionable. The cop should most definately not come out and tell us ani's alignment, if they decided to investigat ani, that is.

As for hologram, that was definately a stupid move trying to out the cop, but I'm not so sure it was a scummy move. I think scum would be a bit more subtle than trying to out the cop that blatantly.

Oh, it was a stupid move alright, but was it a stupid anti-town move or a scum slip-up? I think Holo thought he could get away with asking for a claim while hiding it as curiousity. I don't believe him at all, and I'd like a little more pressure on him.

Especially when he puts a vote on me for no reason...

Vote: Hologram

AD, the vote was only a holdover from the minor bit of suspicion you caused yesterday. I didn't mean any harm by it and I just wanted to get the ball rolling for today.


As for the rest of you, there's no way I can substantiate whether or not I'm scum, but I'm going to say right now that you don't want me dead.

Think I'm lying? Go ahead and lynch me. You'll be sorry, but you'll get over it.
Think I might be telling the truth? Get off this dangerous bandwagon and find another lead.

Oh, and unvote now that we've got more to worry about than a pseudo-lead from yesterday.

HOLO NO USING WORDS I HAVE TO LOOK UP

What, substantiate?

yes


that is now a banned word-anyone uses it they will get a pr

Okay, I'll try. No promises though as that's just the way I talk.

Unvote

We really have been missing a lot of talking from a lot of people...

1) Nark
2) Selin
3) Hologram
4) dunc
5) nag
6) kwan
7) brown
mib
9) ga7
10) Flores
11) Josh
12) Talapus
13) Stroop

I am surprised that Kwan, Nagerous, Flores, Talapus, and Mr. Incrediball have posted so little.

I LOVE being number eight.

as for hologram's little slip-up, i'm a little unsure. i've seen town make mistakes before, and with janned roles, it's easy to forget which corpses could have been what. also, i don't really know if this is the kind of slip-up hologram can honestly make, as it's also very easy to cover a scumtell by claiming ignorance. anyone know hologram's playing style, and/or past stupidity to help me out?

FoS hologram for now, but i'd rather not go jumping on wagons with so much uncertainty.

Anarkistsdream wrote:Unvote

We really have been missing a lot of talking from a lot of people...

1) Nark
2) Selin
3) Hologram
4) dunc
5) nag
6) kwan
7) brown
mib
9) ga7
10) Flores
11) Josh
12) Talapus
13) Stroop

I am surprised that Kwan, Nagerous, Flores, Talapus, and Mr. Incrediball have posted so little.

I'm sure that some of these guys are scum and just don't want to bring attention upon themselves, but I'm sure there's also power roles in there that don't want to post for the same reason.


For instance, I'm still suspicious of ani's sanity as a doc. Going off of the wikipedia article, I believe he was either a naive doc or a doc with only a slight chance of success, and I believe there's at least one other doc out there that doesn't want to counterclaim for fear of their own lives.

In short, we can't be sure of any leads that are based wholly on lurking.

Ummm... why? I don't really see how you came to that conclusion, other than wishful thinking or 'outside information'.

^^^This post is in reference to this:

Hologram wrote:For instance, I'm still suspicious of ani's sanity as a doc. Going off of the wikipedia article, I believe he was either a naive doc or a doc with only a slight chance of success, and I believe there's at least one other doc out there that doesn't want to counterclaim for fear of their own lives.

ga7 wrote:No I can't, because it's partly guts feeling and I don't know the theme at all so I can't say if there's actually a character who would make more sense. Anyway, read.

Wikipedia wrote:Touchstone is the illegitimate son of the previous Queen of the Old Kingdom and an unnamed nobleman. He served as a member of the Royal Guard when Kerrigor betrayed the family and murdered them. After the betrayal, Touchstone entered a state of beserker-like rage and the then-Abhorsen bound Touchstone in a figurehead of a ship in Holehallow, the Royal Tombs. When Sabriel entered the tomb, she released him from this bond. He claimed amnesia of the past, because he felt guilty about not protecting the Queen and princesses. While on the Sea, however, he tells Sabriel what happened when the Royal Family was murdered. He does not give his real name; instead he goes by Touchstone.

During the years between Sabriel and Lirael, he restored many of the Charter Stones that had been broken, including the Great Stones. He too is mostly absent from Lirael and Abhorsen. When he participates in the Binding at the end of Abhorsen, he revealed that his true name was Torrigan; he wielded Ranna.

Only mention about anything related to protection...
Sounds minor to me.

From this article. Granted, I haven't read the books, so it's mostly speculation. But the only mention of protection from the article is his failure to protect. Therefore I believe he must be an insane doc and chances are that there's another doctor out there.

I'm half asleep, but figured I would throw this out there to discuss. Mafia most likely would've gone for the "claimed doc" and obviously they have a janitor based off of the coverup. If what is being said is true concerning that character's inability to really protect and he was an insane doctor, it may be possible that animo inadvertently killed our other claimed townie. I'm unsure why the second death would've been covered up unless the mod decided that the janitor was cleaning up both bodies in the same place.