Conquer Club

what's interestin is that we have 4 heartsmen dead and 3 gem saloon dead. Yet hearst mafia has 3 henchman and a godfather while gem saloon has a power role, a goon and a godfather. Of course one of the mafias could be more powerful but maybe there's something more here

Iliad wrote:what's interestin is that we have 4 heartsmen dead and 3 gem saloon dead. Yet hearst mafia has 3 henchman and a godfather while gem saloon has a power role, a goon and a godfather. Of course one of the mafias could be more powerful but maybe there's something more here

Good point. The more I look at this, the more I believe that someone's been recruited.

And Crab, I understand missing diddle, but everyone should know that LSU is a vig and Wild Bill Hickok at this point. Omitting info is a handy, little scum tactic because incomplete information is similar to misinformation, and I give out FOSs appropriately.

F1fth wrote:

Iliad wrote:what's interestin is that we have 4 heartsmen dead and 3 gem saloon dead. Yet hearst mafia has 3 henchman and a godfather while gem saloon has a power role, a goon and a godfather. Of course one of the mafias could be more powerful but maybe there's something more here

Good point. The more I look at this, the more I believe that someone's been recruited.

And Crab, I understand missing diddle, but everyone should know that LSU is a vig and Wild Bill Hickok at this point. Omitting info is a handy, little scum tactic because incomplete information is similar to misinformation, and I give out FOSs appropriately.

Yes, its likely that some of the goons might of ben townie at one point. We shouldn't rule that out.

Unfortunately, we cannot get any information from the lynch of Pancake, as he was the only one really arguing on his side.

Well since there's so few scum left and so many town (assumably), we could always run a mass claim. At this point on the game if we've got 1 mafia entirely out and 1 maybe 2 scum from the other group, a mass claim can't hurt as the best they can do is take out one person and it shouldn't be too hard to find the scum in that scenario.

Just an idea for discussion, I'm not entirely sure where else to go with this but we've got awhile till deadline so no need to make a decision right now.

It can't hurt, I mean, most of us have claimed already.

Exactly, most of the decent town power roles are out already so there really shouldn't be any surprises and I know, based on my role, that all the roles out there aren't incredible power roles so we shouldn't be in to much danger.

What say the rest of you? I'll even start it I'm just not gonna claim now, perhaps needlessly, if you guys don't want to mass claim.

I have no problem. Since there are only 1 (or maybe 2) scum left, I guess it won't hurt as we are at a dead end.

yer it cant hurt
ill start

im beloved princess

woot

yer quite boring. i had a bit of gold. but i was saving for one shot vig. but never got there

my character name is Martha Bullock.

Wait why did you claim? If you are the Beloved Princess, then you have made yourself target 1 for this night and it'll be bad if you die. And on top of that you were almost cleared...

thought it was the consensus to claim.
so i lead by example
see wat would u say if i said i can claim but it only helps scum
looks more suss when everyone is agreeing to role claim.
and anyway. now ive claimed we should get more. and hopefully work out whose lying

The point is, you had already character claimed and almost cleared. What use would it be if you claim Beloved Princess? It would only give the scum to bypass the day and do another kill...

we have a watcher left do we not??

i can be jail bait!!

Guys come on!!!

I will post who I find scummy in a minute

CrabNebula 2.0
Skoffin Watcher
Clive 2.0
LSU 2.0 Vig
F1fth
Lord Voldemort Princess
Diddle mayor
Kalish

Out of the people I find 5th most scummy, followed by clive, followed by crab followed by kalish

Iliad wrote:CrabNebula 2.0
Skoffin Watcher
Clive 2.0
LSU 2.0 Vig
F1fth
Lord Voldemort Princess
Diddle mayor
Kalish

Out of the people I find 5th most scummy, followed by clive, followed by crab followed by kalish

Not liking what I said about mafia recruitment, eh?

Actually in what games I've played the people who find out the mechanics of the scum are usually the scum themselves

But I just found you most suspicious

Well, I'm just observant and overly-analytical (maybe even to a fault)

In my opinion, regardless of the fasttalking Crab does, he's still my number one suspect. He's been playing rather aggressively since he returned to the game, and I certainly don't like this omission business.

F1fth wrote:Well, I'm just observant and overly-analytical (maybe even to a fault)

In my opinion, regardless of the fasttalking Crab does, he's still my number one suspect. He's been playing rather aggressively since he returned to the game, and I certainly don't like this omission business.

well he kinda did say he may have forgotten something

I'll vote fifth

Think he's most likely scum out of who's next.

Clive why do you "believe" him to be the most likely scum?

Clive wrote:I'll vote fifth

Think he's most likely scum out of who's next.

you gotta give some reasons as to why
post stuff etc
you cant just say i beleive

He's already said that he thinks I'm scum because I got him lynched day 1... or excuse me, got "a claimed priest" lynched.

Just want to know how many people still agree to claim and what should be the order?

Do we need an order?