Conquer Club

Well the scene said a "silent" weapon was used, that might mean something other than a gun, but I doubt it.
I don't know, I wanted to rule out the possibility of one of us new recruits being the killer, but that would only leave Dito, what do you think? is it possible that you or I may be a killer?

[quote= "/?] Well the scene said a ?silent? weapon was used, that might mean something other than a gun, but I doubt it. I don't know, I wanted to rule out the possibility of one of us new recruits being the killer, but that would only leave Dito, what do you think? is it possible that you or I may be a killer? [/quote]
I'm sure all the new recruits would like to rule out the possibility of them being the killer...

So / and borox are new recruits, and I'm not? is cmckinney a new recruit?

Also, I wouldn't rule out the possibility that he killed in a way other than a gun. I guess it depends; if one or more gun-using killers have been killed already, then maybe borox's power is past usefulness. But if there haven't been any gun-using killers yet, then I suppose the remaining scum would be using one...

C'mon guys more activity, it's almost endgame!

Ditocoaf wrote:[quote= "/?] Well the scene said a ?silent? weapon was used, that might mean something other than a gun, but I doubt it. I don't know, I wanted to rule out the possibility of one of us new recruits being the killer, but that would only leave Dito, what do you think? is it possible that you or I may be a killer?

I'm sure all the new recruits would like to rule out the possibility of them being the killer...

So / and borox are new recruits, and I'm not? is cmckinney a new recruit?

Also, I wouldn't rule out the possibility that he killed in a way other than a gun. I guess it depends; if one or more gun-using killers have been killed already, then maybe borox's power is past usefulness. But if there haven't been any gun-using killers yet, then I suppose the remaining scum would be using one...[/quote]


How have the guys been killed before? And i wasn't a new recruit.

Dammit, lets get some action!

Basing this purely on my investigation, Vote Dito. If I'm wrong then cmc jumps on the bandwagon and wins, or we take down scum and win. 50/50 chance of sucess.

So you've decided to base the outcome of the game on what you claim to see as a coin flip? I just got here, and I'd like to see more go into this than that. And I'm sure that all of you (the two townies, anyway) who have put all this effort into the game so far wouldn't like to throw all that out at the endgame.

I've given my thoughts; I'll post some more later but could we please get some actual discussion going here? I can't be much use as a replacement if people aren't talking; I have very little to go on.

Vote Count

Ditocoaf 1- borox

4 alive, 3 to lynch

Hn, so that's how it is, perhaps?
i may have been under the mistaken conclusion that the reason that there was an extra kill was because an inactive was replaced, but now with the scummy behavior of one of us new recruits I can come to a conclusion.
the crew voted for one vig (Clive) and one doc (me), why throw in a gun smith this late in the game? it's also an easy role to claim without any other investigators around....
FOS borox
also CMC hasn't given us his investigation today has he, can you tell us anything?

I watched Borox last night, and he visited me.

Fine then, I'm willing to lynch dito since it's unlikely that there are two mafia together at this point, and my claim must be true since you all vote me in.
Vote Dito

Vote Count

Ditocoaf 2- borox,/

4 alive, 3 to lynch

Damn, I don't know what's going on, but I swear I'm not scum.

From what I can see, the person who must be doing the killing has to be cmc... From what you're telling me you think he's third party (that's b/c of some sort of investigation?), but he functions for all intents and purposes as town... that doesn't make sense to me. I think he must have gained a killing ability due to something that happened as the other anti-town were killed; either that or he had a one-shot kill, and he saved it until now for some reason. He couldn't have pretended borox visited mr. i (which would be the obvious scum move at the moment) because of the specific circumstances.

if borox0 was scum, then there'd have to be two of them (because then cmc would also be lying), so that doesn't make sense. So if / is really confirmed town, then borox has to be it (at least, from my perspective).

vote cmc

It's up to you two to decide now, don't let cmc hammer.

Unvote
I suppose it's very likely CMC is a bandit and a watcher, but we can't confirm weather or not he has any killing powers, as many of these role has multiple purposes. perhaps if we allow the day to run out and one of us gets killed leaving three it may be easier?

(sorry for the edit, I was fixing spelling )

But yeah, if you guys want to do the no-lynch thing, that would give a 1 in 3 chance as opposed to a 1 in 4 chance. But then, since there are only two candidates, I find it unlikely that cmc would kill me (or if I were scum, that I would kill cmc), so it would probably be a bad move, because only a confirmed townie would die. There's really a 1 in 2 chance of lynching scum either way, so a no-lynch would just remove an objective observer.

Let me be the first to assure you that I have no killing powers. Period.

All I did was track Borox last night, and it turns out that he did visit me, like he had previously stated. And what did he prove? Oh yeah...that I don't have a weapon.

cmckinney wrote:Let me be the first to assure you that I have no killing powers. Period.

All I did was track Borox last night, and it turns out that he did visit me, like he had previously stated. And what did he prove? Oh yeah...that I don't have a weapon.

Dont have a gun.

Why did you track me?

I chose it randomly.

And how have the other murders in this game been carried out?

cmckinney wrote:And how have the other murders in this game been carried out?

this one was specifically referred to as being silent.

C'mon guys, start talking!

When the new recruits came, was a new mafia person brought as well?

Vote Count

Ditocoaf 1- borox

cmckinny 1- Ditocoaf

4 alive, 3 to lynch

Eh, vote cmc. Worth a shot.

Vote Count



cmckinny 2- Ditocoaf, borox

4 alive, 3 to lynch

I don't want to have to make a deadline. Please start talking.