Conquer Club

I unvote chu. Although that was a phenomenal vote count post. Kudos.

Also, Kona Tal? You lucky bastard, what I would give to be hitting the waves in Hawaii right now...

rishaed wrote:I could be a reviver.

If you are a reviver, you'll be ressurrecting James tonight.

Which I cannot do. I was using it as an example though nothing more. Just showing that you didn't have to be a doc to make the statement that I did without being a doc. Also I don't know if you can res. Modkilled players?

Anarkistsdream wrote:

gregwolf121 wrote:okay so confirming, umm yeah it'll take awhile for me to reread everything, lets see if i ever get through it

Have fun... it'll be a doozy... One of my PhDs is in ungodly long reads...

Colton, hey, dude... Have a blast and thank God. Although, this seems a really od thing, with him being replaced...

you know i think i should be awarded that PhD after reading all of this, and yes i am finally done reading it all my analysis
Day one was super messed up and way to long, especially the last part it seemed like every post was a wall of text, which made it hard to keep things straight.
Day two was a much easier read and i went through it a lot quicker
Right now I'm willing to believe the three claims, though i think we need to figure out if saf is a real doc or what his actual role is,
i don't understand why rish has brought up these bread crumbs, it just seems to be muddying the waters which a lot of people have done from time to time,
also i'm wondering what happened to skoffin, had a post early day two which wasn't in red and hasn't been back since,
ummm don't really agree with any of the cases right now, but i like to eat lunch so i won't vote that

Fircoal wrote:

Vogt Count

Strike Wolf = 6 (ga7, FloresDelMal, Saf, MM, Jonty, Exile)

Colton = 1 (new guy1)

Anarkistsdream = 1 (Minister Masket)

rishaed = 2 (Nebuchadnezer, DoomYoshi)

No Lunch = 2 (jonty125, Rishaed)

With 21 alive and 2 days gone, it takes 9 to lynch.

it looks like Minister has two votes here, i'm assuming that one is a mistake so mod is this accurate?

gregwolf121 wrote:

Fircoal wrote:

Vogt Count

Strike Wolf = 6 (ga7, FloresDelMal, Saf, MM, Jonty, Exile)

Colton = 1 (new guy1)

Anarkistsdream = 1 (Minister Masket)

rishaed = 2 (Nebuchadnezer, DoomYoshi)

No Lunch = 2 (jonty125, Rishaed)

With 21 alive and 2 days gone, it takes 9 to lynch.

it looks like Minister has two votes here, i'm assuming that one is a mistake so mod is this accurate?

It's inaccurate and I don't know which one is the real one

Rodion wrote:

rishaed wrote:I could be a reviver.

If you are a reviver, you'll be ressurrecting James tonight.

Can modkilled players be revived? I mean it's one thing when a player is killed by mafia or lynched by town but a mod-killed player did something to break the rules and was thrown out of the game because of it.

gregwolf121 wrote:Day one was super messed up and way to long, especially the last part it seemed like every post was a wall of text, which made it hard to keep things straight.
Day two was a much easier read and i went through it a lot quicker

It took a replacement to find someone who agreed with me on this point.

Fircoal wrote:

gregwolf121 wrote:
it looks like Minister has two votes here, i'm assuming that one is a mistake so mod is this accurate?

It's inaccurate and I don't know which one is the real one

Second time that's happened. I like how he answered you when you questioned it but not me.

Unvote Vote DoomYoshi to see what happens.

Minister Masket wrote:

Fircoal wrote:

gregwolf121 wrote:
it looks like Minister has two votes here, i'm assuming that one is a mistake so mod is this accurate?

It's inaccurate and I don't know which one is the real one

Second time that's happened. I like how he answered you when you questioned it but not me.

Unvote Vote DoomYoshi to see what happens.

Fircoal can we get a vote count?

strike wolf wrote:

Rodion wrote:

rishaed wrote:I could be a reviver.

If you are a reviver, you'll be ressurrecting James tonight.

Can modkilled players be revived? I mean it's one thing when a player is killed by mafia or lynched by town but a mod-killed player did something to break the rules and was thrown out of the game because of it.

That is ultimately Fircoal's call, but I don't see a reason not to in this particular instance.

He was modkilled because his quoting of the role PM confirmed him. All dead players are, however, confirmed, so it's not like the rule he broke gave him any advantage that would be unfair if he were to revive. Since we assume he is a new player and made an honest mistake, I'd suppose he is eligible just like Commander.

Now that we've discussed it, I'd like to get the Chu's ruling on James' eligibility for a revive. I wouldn't like to see the wrong role revived (maliciously or not) because of an uncertainty regarding James.

My vote is in two places as well, to clarifiy unvote, vote no lynch

Are you saying you don't believe my doc claim because of sanity or because you think I'm lying Greg? Your post doesn't really make that clear.

safariguy5 wrote:Are you saying you don't believe my doc claim because of sanity or because you think I'm lying Greg? Your post doesn't really make that clear.

gregwolf121 wrote:Right now I'm willing to believe the three claims, though i think we need to figure out if saf is a real doc or what his actual role is,

hmm i believe i said that i believe the three claims, that includes yours, what i meant by the second part is that you targeted TWO last night and he died, we need to ascertain if that was because of you or if something else caused his death,
in other words we need to know if your a doc who protects people at night, or some other variant of doc that kills people
hopefully that clears it up

Rodion wrote: Since we assume he is a new player and made an honest mistake, I'd suppose he is eligible just like Commander.

That`s a bullshit assumption. He specifially stated that he knew about the role and even apparently asked Fircoal about the specifics.

EBWOP

DoomYoshi wrote:

Rodion wrote: Since we assume he is a new player and made an honest mistake, I'd suppose he is eligible just like Commander.

That`s a bullshit assumption. He specifially stated that he knew about the rule and even apparently asked Fircoal about the specifics.

Rodion wrote:Now that we've discussed it, I'd like to get the Chu's ruling on James' eligibility for a revive. I wouldn't like to see the wrong role revived (maliciously or not) because of an uncertainty regarding James.

I would say that yes James would be allowed to be revived. Yes he broke the rules but the rules he broke basically have to do with things you all know now (making sure you don't learn what his role is). So it is in a way moot. Kinda hard to follow but yea I think I'd allow it

My 40 PhDs read that in Foghorn Leghorn voice.

Blighters put a bit of a damper on it though.

That's a joke son. I keep pitchin' em and you keep missin' em.

Ok, since I wasn't here yesterday I'll be caught up completely by tonight...

strike wolf wrote:My 40 PhDs read that in Foghorn Leghorn voice.

I'm not saying I didn't do the same thing. However someone with 40 PHD's shouldn't have the freetime for cartoons......I think you're a fraud

Ok, Anyone know where we are with vote count compared to Chu's idea of making one less vote for each additional day? I think if this is being used we need to track it. Then at least we know where we stand and can swing the last few needed votes on someone. Chu get in here and be a mod. You know you want too.

It's been 5 days since it's been incorporated at the time of posting so 10 - 5 = 5 needed to lynch.

strike wolf wrote:

strike wolf wrote:

rishaed wrote:I have left some well.... subtle breadcrumbs to those who will listen. Don't tempt death, neb. You might regret it in the future.

Does this soft claim involve you mentioning "moving" and "directions" a lot?

Ebwop: My 40 PhDs are tired.

Fair enough, I can stick to one.

no

Minister Masket wrote:It's been 5 days since it's been incorporated at the time of posting so 10 - 5 = 5 needed to lynch.

Also if that is true then SW is at L-1 right now and after tonight will be lynched according to the counter? Do the four on him really desire his lynch or are only on long enough to actually vote him, but not unvote since then. With the amount of claims on the table currently I am sort of touchy with lynching any particular one of them. (either nark/SW) I want an inv. on one of them tonight if possible, but would like town to wait until then for the benefits that they could bring to us.