The Tick Mafia - JUSTICE PREVAILS!

[*Pixar*]

Wow, this was a great loss. Very interesting happenings, will have to go through all EW's posts to see who he knew for sure was townies.

One thing bothers me a bit, DDS played such a good game with very good analysis and summaries, why did he not use his smoke bomb on himself when he saw he was going to get lynched, we could use him very well for another day to help us finding scum.

Will give my thoughts a bit later.

DDS used the smoke bomb on Loose already. Not sure why he was protecting Loose at that point but yeah losing Cop is no bueno

[SoN!c]

Wow, this was a great loss. Very interesting happenings, will have to go through all EW's posts to see who he knew for sure was townies.

One thing bothers me a bit, DDS played such a good game with very good analysis and summaries, why did he not use his smoke bomb on himself when he saw he was going to get lynched, we could use him very well for another day to help us finding scum.

Will give my thoughts a bit later.

Yes, unbelievable EW is cop. I just don't get it. Trying to figure out why he played like he did. Hiding his cop role in extreme ways? Does not make any sense to me. After 3 nights he should have found out at least 1 scummie. So the only logic would be he visited 3 townies during the nights? We should look and see who was town for sure to EW (he won't have visited them?) and who he believed was scum? - (he would have visited them during the night and found out they were town?). Can't see another explanation.

[*Pixar*]

Well I tracked EW last night and he visited swang. Does swang have some sort of power to kill people who visit him?

[*Pixar*]

Would like to hear from strike to see who he used his night action on

[swang918]

My first thought is that Sonic is probably town and likely got visited by Extreme. My general feel of the tone of Extreme's posts re sonic was that he was leaning town on sonic on D1 and 2, but it feels like on D3 he became a lot more certain that sonic was town and was defending him much more confidently. So my guess is that he checked sonic N2 and got a town result.

[swang918]

Well I tracked EW last night and he visited swang. Does swang have some sort of power to kill people who visit him?

Nope I don't have this power

[SoN!c]

(Just read the bold section if you wanna fast scroll, these are 2 of the 3 EW lists - can't find the third in the 47 pages by now)

Well I tracked EW last night and he visited swang. Does swang have some sort of power to kill people who visit him?

Good question. But right now im still baffled by the fact that EW was the cop.


We could see who was on top of EW's "scummy list" on D1 to find a clue who he visited that night, do the same for D2.. then that should give us the 2 names he probably checked out those nights as scum (but they turned out town).

Then checking his D3 "town list" to see if that confirms it?

I found his D3 list:

As good as confirmed Town
Rag (Raz's target)
Pix (claimed tracker, shared his night results and corroborated by Strike
Pepe. Claimed the Loose kill.
90% Town in ordered fashion
Strike. While Sonic does mention that mafia has roleblockers, Strike used his roleblockers on people he found suspicious and whom town as a whole doesnt trust. It makes sense.
Sonic. I regret having to say this.

So 2 of those 5 should be players he checked out during N1 and N2 and came back town (we don't know who he was checking out on N3 as he did not survive).

I also found his D1 list:

Nicely copypasted again
I like the following so far:
- Extreme
- Strike
- DDS
- Trafalgar

I'm neutral about
- Darin
- Pepe
- Fusi

I have a hard time reading
- Razor
- Bax (for 1 reason only)
- Duke

I'm iffy about
- Loose
- Max
- Ragian
- Pixar

My favourite townies are lower in numbers this time around but I just don't like how the day is progressing. Ragian was mildly pushing on someone who was claiming to go on holiday and whom I thought (still think) to be Jester. From my POV, any claim by sonic would be bullshit because he wants to be voted out so there's nothing to gain there. In addition, for once I agree with sonic that it's a scummy timing to vote on him. There had been plenty of time to vote on sonic before for what would essentially be the same reason. Ragian was catching up though so... unsure.

Loose is now suddenly doing this game within a game, baiting softclaims. Is that inexperience or malice? Even the matchups are weird.

So i'd say on N1 EW was going for one of these 4:

-Loose
-Max
-Ragian
-Pixar

Still don't get it why he defended Loose so hard on D1 now EW turns out cop. Why do that? Does not make any sense to me. He could not have known anything on Loose at that moment.

But if i follow my own theory (before knowing the results) i'd say EW checked out Pixar on N1 like explained here above

Can't find his list for D2 in the 47 pages to cross check the second name. But yes, could be he checked me out. He changed his position on me after N2 just like on Pix after N1.

[strike wolf]

I visited Swang. So it's safe to say he did not perform the kill on EW unless I was somehow redirected.

With his thoughts on there being a Redirector and saying he thought he knew who dropped the Smoke Bomb, I thought he was soft claiming Item Cop or Role Cop but just being the Cop would explain why he was suddenly 100% convinced that Son!c was town D3. I'm a bit surprised he didn't use his investigation on Son!c N1 actually.

Only 1 kill, probably mafia but would like to hear from Pepe on who and if he targeted anyone last night.

There are probably between 3-4 mafia left so we are getting close to Myslynch & Lose or Lynch or Lose time.

Definitively town:

1. Me
2. Pix
3. Rage
4. Pepe

Almost certainly town.

5. Son!c
6. Trafalgar

That leaves

7. Darin
8. Swang
9. Bax
10. Traffic
11. Charle

As the most likely scum in my eyes. Swang does not seem to be the one who sent in the night kill. So Darin, Charle, Traffic and Bax would be the first 4 on my list to look into.

[*Pixar*]

Has anyone heard of Can-O-Man?

[TrafalgarLaw01]

Ugh, no good we have no cop and no doc.
I think there are max 3 mafia left. I feel 5 of 19 plus at least 2 third party would have been too much.

So N2 what happened was Pepe killed Loose, DDS killed Fusi and Mafia killed Duke. So we can assume mafia has 1 Night kill, but can have more ways of killing as proved with Fusi power.

Gotta check all EW posts. We gotta get a mafia today.

We have a lot of townie roles out already and with no cop and doc. Would it be a good time for a mass claim?

[TrafalgarLaw01]

Btw, If we do a mass claim Darin, Swang, Charle, traffic and Bax should be the first to speak.

[SoN!c]

Has anyone heard of Can-O-Man?

You mean "a man in a can"?

Google has:

[strike wolf]

I visited Swang. So it's safe to say he did not perform the kill on EW unless I was somehow redirected.

With his thoughts on there being a Redirector and saying he thought he knew who dropped the Smoke Bomb, I thought he was soft claiming Item Cop or Role Cop but just being the Cop would explain why he was suddenly 100% convinced that Son!c was town D3. I'm a bit surprised he didn't use his investigation on Son!c N1 actually.

Only 1 kill, probably mafia but would like to hear from Pepe on who and if he targeted anyone last night.

There are probably between 3-4 mafia left so we are getting close to Myslynch & Lose or Lynch or Lose time.

Definitively town:

1. Me-The Doorman Roleblocker
2. Pix-Tracker
3. Rage-The Tick
4. Pepe-Vigilante

Almost certainly town.

5. Son!c-Die Fledermaus
6. Trafalgar-Caped Chameleon-Absorber

That leaves

7. Darin
8. Swang
9. Bax
10. Traffic
11. Charle

As the most likely scum in my eyes. Swang does not seem to be the one who sent in the night kill. So Darin, Charle, Traffic and Bax would be the first 4 on my list to look into.

Ebwopping and noticing that none of the bottom 5 have dropped any definitive name or role claim that I can remember.

[SoN!c]

Enjoying a nice (second) bottle of wine here so could be wrong but yes, strike makes a good point about not having a role claim off some sort:

7. Darin
8. Swang
9. Bax
10. Traffic
11. Charle

Traffic said in the beginning he has reading issues so i can get that to some point. Then Charle, i know everyone of his posts by memory - no red flags there. Swang was Loose his n1 suspect but swang posted some good theories.

Bax : very little input - same for Darin.

I would wanna hear those 2 first. Bax and Darin. Just because what DDS said. Also i did not wanted to see DDS getting lynched. He bombeb Fusi so i was hoping he would have bombed another scum. Not that i knew, but i was expecting the Mad Midnight bomber all game long so when Fusi got blown up that was my first idea. Bombeb by the midnight bomber what else? And then the midnight bomber had to be 3p just like in the tick operating on his own. Like the Godfather has to be chairface chippendale and the rest of scum chairface henchmen.. or associated to Chairface in any way like Ael (fusi) visited chairface chippendale birthday party in the tick..

[PepeAtila]

We are loosing, but also it is true that probability to get some scum is bigger.
I am very sorry about the DDS linch, becase I was realizing that Bomber had help town a lot, and what to say about EW... so double big lost D3 and N3.
Really I have no clue what is happening and wh are the scums...
I will just randomly try to look for somebody who is contributing very litle to the chat... vote Bax

[SoN!c]

okay, i play along.

vote bax

Pix has to be town and i hope Traf is too. So those two could steer town. Problem of being town is you just don't know. But Pix and Traf both town would mean we win.

Pix is considered town by all by now and if you can't rely on that then it would not be a game or a real stupid one, and Traf always had good points, if he was scum that would be the perfect game and after 47 pages it's hard to still be perfect?

Like overestimating EW - sorry EW, still you got me on the wrong track by defending Loose so hard and everything else. As cop, just blend in, go with the flow, investigate a litle but not too much (just copy Inspector Columbo.. act stupid dumb in the beginning of the game, then later on say something like “Perfect murder, sir? ...
"Oh, I didn't come to ask any more questions. ...“I respect your talent, but I don't like anything else about you.” ...
"My wife says I'm the second smartest. She claims there are 80 guys tied for first."" or say the best one ever :
“I must say I found you disappointing; I mean your incompetence. You left enough clues to sink a ship. And for a man of your intelligence, you got caught in a lot of stupid lies.”
you silly slap the suspect by that and then you pose the real tricky questions

[strike wolf]

We are loosing, but also it is true that probability to get some scum is bigger.
I am very sorry about the DDS linch, becase I was realizing that Bomber had help town a lot, and what to say about EW... so double big lost D3 and N3.
Really I have no clue what is happening and wh are the scums...
I will just randomly try to look for somebody who is contributing very litle to the chat... vote Bax

So you didn't target anyone last night?

Also don't feel too sorry for DDS. The fact that he targeted Fusi who he had suggested was giving town vibes meant he was trying to hurt town not scum there. He'll be interesting to approach if rereading as he likely for the most part was giving honest reads on players.

On rereading Charle, I have to agree that I don't see any significant red flags. He isn't super active but he's not so inactive as to appear to be skating by.

Swang still feels scummy to me but he did not personally send the kill as far as I can tell (me being role blocked or redirected could still be a factor) which moves him down slightly on the list. May reread later.

Darin is quiet but admits to being overwhelmed. Not getting much from that. Early inconsistency but otherwise his posts feel mostly genuine. Don't think he's Scum.

Traffic has posted pretty much nothing of substance. He votes here and there but provides little to no relevant explanation.

Bax is also quiet but does say a bit more than Traffic. Seems to play the contrarian a lot when he does pop up. Possibly an act to buy town points but not enough substance for me to back up that hypothesis. Had been fairly consistent in suspicions of Swang since Day 2.

Right now, my list for who I'm most interested in getting more info from in order of most to least interested is:

1. Traffic
2. Bax
3. Swang
4. Charle
5. Darin

[Charle]

Ok, I think it is time for me to claim my role so that we can use it together to get our scum. If we do not find scum this day, we are going downhill.

I am a flavour cop that can taste some info from players at night.
Night 1 - Haven't had this role yet
Night 2 - I visited Pixar and I tasted lots of feet
Night 3 - Visited Swang and I tasted red tape

Now lets look at Night 2. Going through the characters I found the 4-legged man and a cockroach with lots of feet. Can it be that Pixar did a false claim and played this game very well putting us on a wrong road?

Night 3 still have to look a bit into this, red tape to try and slow things down?

Lets hear what you guys make out if this.

[Charle]

Oh and yes, I am a townie

[Charle]

Maybe Pixar and Swang can explain why they taste so funny?

[Ragian]

That was some unprovoked info...let's deal with that first:
1) Feet makes sense if you're a tracker, I would've thought.
2) Red tape is usually used for keeping something in check, right?

However, we need to hear what Pepe did last night. It's odd that he posted without saying that.

[PepeAtila]

Last night I did 'no action'.

[PepeAtila]

Well I tracked EW last night and he visited swang. Does swang have some sort of power to kill people who visit him?

Ok. Beliving that information. EW was thinking 'swang' as possible scum. But he did also vote Bax D3

Spoiler

[quote="degaston"][color=#0000FF][b][size=150]Vote Count:[/size][/b][/color] [color=#0000FF][list] [b]swang918 : 3 [/b](Charle, PepeAtila, General Bax) [b]General Bax : 2 [/b](Ragian, Extreme Ways) [b]Extreme Ways : 2 [/b](traffic133, SoN!c) [b]strike wolf : 1 [/b](swang918) [b]Darin44 : 1 [/b](*Pixar*) [b]DirtyDishSoap : 1 [/b](TrafalgarLaw01) [b]TrafalgarLaw01 : 1 [/b](DirtyDishSoap) [b]No Vote : 2 [/b](Darin44, strike wolf) [/list]13 Alive, 7 votes needed to lynch[/color][/quote]

[PepeAtila]

Spoiler

Ok, I think it is time for me to claim my role so that we can use it together to get our scum. If we do not find scum this day, we are going downhill. I am a flavour cop that can taste some info from players at night. Night 1 - Haven't had this role yet Night 2 - I visited Pixar and I tasted lots of feet Night 3 - Visited Swang and I tasted red tape Now lets look at Night 2. Going through the characters I found the 4-legged man and a cockroach with lots of feet. Can it be that Pixar did a false claim and played this game very well putting us on a wrong road? Night 3 still have to look a bit into this, red tape to try and slow things down? Lets hear what you guys make out if this.

Charle is clear it can confirm Night 2- tracker, Night 3- blocker.

[Charle]

I am with Pepe and Sonic,

Vote Bax