Page 5 of 23
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Thu Jun 06, 2013 10:30 am
by StubbsKVM
First of all. Thanks for the info. Gives us some kind of idea what to expect.
However:
kgb007 wrote: i don't know how fun the game would be if all of the town were cops like they were in the show but again i'll defer to the more experienced
This makes me think you're either cop or not town.
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Thu Jun 06, 2013 11:10 am
by kgb007
betiko wrote:Sorry for spoiling but... Forgot about avon, i remembered stringer as the godfather all the way..
haha that's fine, I watched the first 2 seasons so quickly, haven't started season 3 but I was getting that impression since Avon was still in prison and Stringer was starting to overrule him towards the end in season 2 but I didn't know how that would be reflected since this is season 1 mafia
StubbsKVM wrote:First of all. Thanks for the info. Gives us some kind of idea what to expect.
However:
kgb007 wrote: i don't know how fun the game would be if all of the town were cops like they were in the show but again i'll defer to the more experienced
This makes me think you're either cop or not town.
my point in that quote was the way i viewed the show is you either run with avon and stringer's gang, are part of BPD or maybe third party like Omar, and how that might relate to our game
i'll let my original post speak for itself in regards to your cop/not town accusation
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Thu Jun 06, 2013 11:21 am
by Djfireside
Im not sure why Comrade got all up in arms by mentioning a charecter. KGB seems to have gone through a good deal of them for flavor purposes, ty, but Comrades move got me a bit up in the arm.
UNVOTE
FOS Comrade
I am going to be out until tuesday which is why I am removing my joke vote. Sorry for forward absence
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Thu Jun 06, 2013 12:36 pm
by warlord5
Vote Jonty125
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Thu Jun 06, 2013 12:38 pm
by StubbsKVM
kgb007 wrote:betiko wrote:Sorry for spoiling but... Forgot about avon, i remembered stringer as the godfather all the way..
haha that's fine, I watched the first 2 seasons so quickly, haven't started season 3 but I was getting that impression since Avon was still in prison and Stringer was starting to overrule him towards the end in season 2 but I didn't know how that would be reflected since this is season 1 mafia
StubbsKVM wrote:First of all. Thanks for the info. Gives us some kind of idea what to expect.
However:
kgb007 wrote: i don't know how fun the game would be if all of the town were cops like they were in the show but again i'll defer to the more experienced
This makes me think you're either cop or not town.
my point in that quote was the way i viewed the show is you either run with avon and stringer's gang, are part of BPD or maybe third party like Omar, and how that might relate to our game
i'll let my original post speak for itself in regards to your cop/not town accusation
Right, so I'm assuming you meant cop as in "part of the BPD", not as the "cop" role.
Just took that the wrong way, I guess.
You're cleared...for now...
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Thu Jun 06, 2013 2:00 pm
by jonty125
warlord5 wrote:Vote Jonty125
Do you have any thoughts to contribute?
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Thu Jun 06, 2013 2:22 pm
by betiko
unvote vote warlord this scumarining definitely needs a little good cop/bad cop interrogation session
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Thu Jun 06, 2013 4:09 pm
by Iron Butterfly
hey guys....I completely forgot i was signed up for this game so thanks for the reminder.
I have not watched this show but i have played mafia
Not much to they day one discussion so far as I can tell.
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Thu Jun 06, 2013 8:10 pm
by thechuck51
Vote Count 1.3
Comrade Kirk (1) - Jonty125
warlord5 (3) - safariguy5, superkeener, betiko
Jonty125 (2) - spiesr, warlord5
Iron Butterfly (1) - stubbsKVM
kgb007 (1) - lynx_
betiko (1) - Comrade Kirk
Not Voting: Iron Butterfly, rishaed, Djfireside, kgb007
With 13 Alive it takes 7 to Lynch
Deadline is Sunday June 16th at 10pm EST (10 days, 0 hours, 50 minutes remaining)
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Thu Jun 06, 2013 8:13 pm
by Comrade Kirk
I'm not uncomfortable with a discussion about Omar. From what I remember of the show, Omar works with BPD in the first series, so a vig would make much more sense than an sk. It's easy to dismiss my argument as WIFOM but, at that stage of the game, there really was nothing to go on and at least I got a bit of conversation going.
In my experience, character speculation is ok early on but it can quickly get out of hand and serve as a mafia distraction tactic. I'm generally wary of people who focus on the characters because they are leading the conversation away from actual scum hunting.
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Thu Jun 06, 2013 8:13 pm
by safariguy5
I think 3 mafia and 1 SK might be too strong. If there is a SK, maybe 2 mafia to counteract the double kills each night.
It's interesting that the flavor may suggest that we don't have a doc role. Might be a bit of a slippery slope, but we might want to be a bit more leery of doc claims with regards to it fitting flavor.
My vote is on warlord, and I'll leave it there for a lack of reasoning for voting. We've stated that votes should be backed up by rationale already, and you go and vote with no reason right afterwards.
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Thu Jun 06, 2013 8:45 pm
by kgb007
thechuck51 wrote:Vote Count 1.3
Comrade Kirk (1) - Jonty125
warlord5 (3) - safariguy5, superkeener, betiko
Jonty125 (2) - spiesr, kgb007
Iron Butterfly (1) - stubbsKVM
kgb007 (1) - lynx_
betiko (1) - Comrade Kirk
Not Voting: Iron Butterfly, rishaed, Djfireside
With 13 Alive it takes 7 to Lynch
Deadline is Sunday June 16th at 10pm EST (10 days, 0 hours, 50 minutes remaining)
never voted for jonty after my unvote
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Thu Jun 06, 2013 8:53 pm
by thechuck51
kgb007 wrote:never voted for jonty after my unvote
it should be correct now
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Thu Jun 06, 2013 9:11 pm
by rishaed
spiesr wrote:Vote Jonty, his responses to recent actions have given me the vibe that he is trying to jump on everything that comes up. If I extrapolate this, possibly unreasonably, it points towards him hoping that any of that sticks and a "lynch anybody but me" mentality. This vote is weak but should suffice at this time of Day.
I'm not really getting these vibes from his votes/posts. The only serious vote that he had was on comrade at the time. As much as I don't agree with Jonty's voting reasons, they are better than Warlord's beginning BW vote without a justification behind it. I will acknowledge that you have said that it is a "weak" vote, and should be considered as such.
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Fri Jun 07, 2013 1:34 am
by StubbsKVM
unvote
Looks like we're all here now.
I'd like to see some reasoning from warlord about his vote.
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Fri Jun 07, 2013 1:06 pm
by betiko
come on warlord... you surely can be a bit more eloquent!
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Fri Jun 07, 2013 9:15 pm
by thechuck51
Vote Count 1.4
Comrade Kirk (1) - Jonty125
warlord5 (3) - safariguy5, superkeener, betiko
Jonty125 (2) - spiesr, warlord5
kgb007 (1) - lynx_
betiko (1) - Comrade Kirk
Not Voting: Iron Butterfly, rishaed, Djfireside, kgb007, stubbsKVM
With 13 Alive it takes 7 to Lynch
Deadline is Sunday June 16th at 10pm EST (8 days, 23 hours, 45 minutes remaining)
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Fri Jun 07, 2013 11:32 pm
by Iron Butterfly
StubbsKVM wrote:unvote
Looks like we're all here now.
I'd like to see some reasoning from warlord about his vote.
I will concur. Voting without an explanation is suspect in my book.
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Sat Jun 08, 2013 1:45 pm
by thechuck51
rishaed wrote:I will need replaced in all games.... I apologize for the inconvenience, and wish all players a well played game.
Working on a replacement for rishaed
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Sun Jun 09, 2013 7:20 am
by thechuck51
Skillfusniper33 replaces rishaed
Activity is dead, I will be sending out prods tonight
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Sun Jun 09, 2013 12:38 pm
by StubbsKVM
Vote Warlord5
until he has answered
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Mon Jun 10, 2013 1:33 am
by StubbsKVM
yeah I'm still in. Still waiting for warlord though.
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Mon Jun 10, 2013 2:53 am
by jonty125
Prod received.
unvote, vote warlord for voting without a reason
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Mon Jun 10, 2013 3:27 am
by betiko
I m still here too, but i started going after warlord and he disapeared, so nothing much to say, i hate case jumping when my suspect does that. (Oh and great job really, seems like this guy just ask to replace someone just to post "vote jonty" and leave for good. Can we still play mafia here or is it dead?)
Re: The Wire Mafia Day 1 [13/13]
Posted: Mon Jun 10, 2013 7:37 am
by thechuck51
working on a replacement for warlord5