D3 of The Reid technique Mafia Game

[hjelp]

To be clear.
If I got Charle's report then I didn't get Loose Canon's report, hence Loose Canon got no result according to Loose Canon.
If I got Loose Canon's report it would have been Mafia since a hit, hence Loose Canon's claim is false.

[hjelp]

If Loose Canon's claim is false, I can only get Charle's report.
If Loose Canon's claim is true, then I can get Charle's report or Loose Canon's report.
So there are two conditions to consider.

[halrob64]

In a way the only evidence trail we have is EW as Warden having knowledge of Charle's N1 activity where Charle visited me and got a not guilty result which put me as town. I declared as town.
Ew hinted at Charle being cop I think but have not read back through.
Not necessarily cast iron facts but there is an evidence trail.
EW was shot and then confirmed as town.
There could well be 2 town cops/investigators.
One question bothering me is there was only 1 murder N2, who killed EW? Mafia or 3P or one and the same.
Someone received extra powers on N2 Sonic stated that was going to happen, if a cop or someone with town leanings received those power then information should be revealed.
It could have been won by 3P who may have used those powers to investigate someone and will use that information N3 I think this is very IMPORTANT.
So did anyone town orientated get extra powers last night? Is so declare, otherwise it has to be 3P or possibly mafia but knowing Sonics play now I would lean towards 3P.
Also who is likely to have access to poison and have the capability to deliver it?

[hjelp]

Statement analyst report - No result
Question.
Answer 1 true and 0 false.

Loose Canon flips Mafia
Question if report.
LC claim 0, Charle 1

Loose Canon flips Town
LC claim 1 Charle 1

Question my analyst
LC 0 Charle 1
LC 1 Charle 1

Charle is 1 everywhere. Loose Canon is two 0's and two 1's.

[hjelp]

Assuming Charle is Cop as EW said.

[hjelp]

There could well be 2 town cops/investigators.
One question bothering me is there was only 1 murder N2, who killed EW? Mafia or 3P or one and the same.

kongming3 was a Tracker.
EW was shot by Maifa according to

Players:

1. Hjelp
2. Kingm subbed by Devon on 03.11.2025 ODD NIGHT MAFIA GODFATHER lynched D2
3. Loose Canon
4. Halrob
5. Devante
6. RogueTrooper69 subbed by EW on 21.10.2025 TOWN WARDEN - shot by mafia N2
7. Charle
8. Strike Wolf MAFIA FRAMER - poisoned by 3P N1
9. Kongming 3-SHOT TOWN TRACKER - shot by mafia N1
10.Ragian
11. Darin44

subs
Kongming? EW?

[halrob64]

Thanks yes pay attention halob, then 3P most likely received the extra powers from Sonic so 3P probably knows enough to do serious damage N3

[hjelp]

...

I could not do anything last night as my role was not activated yet. But I did receive some info hence I am trying to avoid a lynch and get some discussion going.

...

What info did you receive?

[Loose Canon]

This falls into the category of I've thought it so I'll say it.

Has anyone considered the possibility that this Reid Read thing is a hint of a binary on/off switch that 3P controls?
Theory goes 3P decides whether he wants Hjelp to have report on my activity or report on Charle s activity perhaps with prior knowledge of who each of us have investigated.

Batshit maybe??

[halrob64]

lol Loose you think them up thats for sure, I was more thinking extra power to investigate and gain knowledge

[halrob64]

So where do we go from here Loose, you have always put forward theories, who would you lynch and who do you think is 3P??

[hjelp]

@ Loose Canon
The reason I vote for you is also that Lecter is a former Cop/FBI according to poem - you or Charle can be Lecter.
So, you can be mafia or Lecter. Charle can be townie or Lecter.

[hjelp]

but ok,
Let's assume you are Town Cop for now.

Unvote Loose Canon

[hjelp]

What if there is an Even Night Godfather ?

[Ragian]

See, the thing is...Loose could be a lot of things and maybe worth lynching. I'd say that it's between him and Devante for me today (unless something awful happens). I'm happy that you unvoted, hjelp, we're not in a rush.

@halrob, why would 3p get extra powers? It's much more plausible that 3p was blocked or his target protected.

FP'ed

We can play the "what if" game for a long time and get nowhere. Let's just stick to what we know and what we can infer logically. For the rest, we'll have to rely on people's voting patterns and gameplay.

[hjelp]

That will be 50%

[Loose Canon]

Hjelp - how can Charle be Lecter - I don't get that - (I've asked you this before)

In what scenario is that possible given what we know about Extreme now?
If its possible for Charle its possible for Halrob too?
I'm not seeing its possible though....

Thats an OPEN QUESTION to you Hjelp

Halrob
A number of players haven't claimed - not saying they should - just saying they haven't.

I'm still waiting for someone to give a theory on
HOW DEVANTE COULD BE TOWN??????
- Extreme's shrugging off don't know was part of the reason I wasn't happy with Extreme and so investigated him N2 - and that in turn is part, but not I don't think the major part of the reason I'm on L-1.

Gotta either try to clear myself of mislynch or just accept it - but asking the questions that are bugging me IS what I can try to do.

Fpd

[hjelp]

@Loose Canon

@ Loose Canon
According to Poems - Lecter is a former Cop/FBI

Lecter entered the game after that Charle was cleared by EW. So any Cop/FBI can be Lecter.

[halrob64]

by Ragian » Fri Nov 21, 2025 11:46 am

See, the thing is...Loose could be a lot of things and maybe worth lynching. I'd say that it's between him and Devante for me today (unless something awful happens). I'm happy that you unvoted, hjelp, we're not in a rush.

@halrob, why would 3p get extra powers? It's much more plausible that 3p was blocked or his target protected.

Sonic stated that someone would be up for extra powers N2 I am assuming those powers were going to be granted, I did expect to receive them myself but I didn't so assuming they went somewhere, no one is giving information so I'm assuming it went to mafia or 3p, my money is on 3p

[halrob64]

I have to say that the reason I went for lynch Loose was to push the debate.
Loose why didn't we lynch Devante D2 I offered to back you but you didn't pursue it which made is why I thought/think you are the Lord of Chaos.
I have said before that the Devante situation does not stack up, his powers if any are not in use so what use is he to the game and town other than a nefarious one.
So why are we not going for a Devante lynch?

[halrob64]

3P may well have had his night time activity blocked regarding a kill but extra powers would more likely be investigative so will be useful in N3

[Loose Canon]

All
I think you'll find the quote from Sonic is "MAYBE ex FBI, maybe freelance consultant...etc"

[halrob64]

So I assume you will answer my question in time Loose who do you want to target and why are we not lynching Devante, he seems to be off everyones radar

[halrob64]

What Charle writes, however, is not true. Loose would not have gotten a mafia result on Devon N1. Why would you write that?

Can you elaborate on that Ragian?

[SoN!c]

N1 somebody received an extra PR as announced.
N2 somebody received an extra PR as announced.

The extra PR favors the alignment / matches the flavour of the winner.

N1 a polygraph lie detector kit was granted..

Wether the polygraph lie detector kit was granted to a townie, a mafia or to dr.lecter is for you to figure out.