The Thing TOWN WINS!

[Charle]

Ok, here it what happened to me.

I was very surprised that I did not receive any mail that I am recruited or anything regarding the flamethrower that was found abandoned.

DDS sent me a mail later to informed me that he made a mistake by not sending the mail to me, but I was actually recruited as we all expected. Because of this mistake, I am still Mac at town, but I have lost my power to vig, which is now with Deg.

So I suspect that at the moment there should only be the Thing with the only recruited EW dead.

With a lynch and a vig between 3 people, and say we miss both today, tomorrow we just lynch the 3rd one, game over.

Well, if you say this much then just say who recruited you

I really don't know. It can only between one of the 3 left, so easy.

[Charle]

Well, if you say this much then just say who recruited you

Was it you Sonic?

[degaston]

[SoN!c]

Well, if you say this much then just say who recruited you

Was it you Sonic?

"I was actually recruited as we all expected. Because of this mistake, I am still Mac at town, but I have lost my power to vig, which is now with Deg."

So your still town you say? You "just lost your FT power after being recruited but your not actually recruited"? Your still town, and not a Thing, but your a vanilla town now (instead of vig) if i get this right?.

Anyway, great job you did flaming EW!

I guess pointing at me makes sense if you know who recruited you

----

Perhaps we should ask the three remaining suspects who they think the Ting is and why - after all 2 of them are town..

Strike already said who he thinks it is. He was thinking Votanic after Traf flipped town but he switched his mind fast after Deg voted for me


"the thing is"
idiom

used to introduce an explanation or an excuse:
The thing is,...

[strike wolf]

I changed my mind because you were pushing against the plan that has a pretty much guaranteed chance for us to win. In other words, voting for the plan that gives the recruiter a chance to win.

As for Charle, mod error is possible but unconfirmable without DDS posting in thread that it happened. Even then we don't know if DDS actually allowed Charle to stay town unless DDS outright says that hes town which is very unlikely to happen.

[SoN!c]

I changed my mind because you were pushing against the plan that has a pretty much guaranteed chance for us to win. In other words, voting for the plan that gives the recruiter a chance to win.

As for Charle, mod error is possible but unconfirmable without DDS posting in thread that it happened. Even then we don't know if DDS actually allowed Charle to stay town unless DDS outright says that hes town which is very unlikely to happen.

Ok, thanks for reminding me - i remember this different

I remembered the reason that you said i could not have known EW was the N1 recruit if i did not recruited him myself or someThing like that..

Also your post about EW in relation to Votanic is a lie.

And EW helped you on D2 when Ragian posted to lynch you...

Well, it doesn't matter as you and Deg have this figured out right? "100% town win chance" if we follow you... just hoping you don't have an ace upon your sleeve that Deg is unaware off

Go right ahead then

The Thing is, i think it's you

[degaston]

That was a nice little scene there, Sonic and Charle. Certainly Sonic couldn't be the Thing if the recruit is pointing his finger at him!

But let's look back at how you were trying to create a smokescreen around Charle with speculation that the Thing "knows something":

And Why flame Charle? You got 2 chances out of 3 if you lynch/flame me, Vot or Strike.

If The Thing got game info from the start of the game that there are 2 vig's out there (but just one flamethrower) and the FT from the first vig will stop working after 2 vigs (but the back up vig's FT will at that moment) then The Thing would not have recruited Charle... just like Charle is saying.
...
Could be Charle is still town and thinks his FT is still working...

Not selling anyThing. Just saying "stay on target". Stay on the recruiter: Votanic or Strike (or me). I think The Thing has something up his sleeve too. Game info he got at the start that we don't know.

Charle's post does not make any sense unless it's the truth.

What if Charle flips town because the Thing knew something we don't?

And why doesn't The Thing come clean? Could he have an ace upon his sleeve like a "BT escape thing" just like in the movie or that he got game info we don't know?

You go on and on with this theory that the Thing has hidden information, with absolutely zero evidence. All it does is attempt to sow doubt and confusion on the closest thing we have to a mod-confirmed guilty verdict. No one has been working as hard to protect Charle as you have.
And it's ridiculous to think that the Thing could also be a Godfather when the BT is our only source of information. That would be a completely broken game.


And just to remind everyone:

And If im wrong you can lynch me tomorrow. Short and sweet.

[SoN!c]

If you are sure Deg then flame me tonight.

Lynch Strike

[degaston]

FP'd by Sonic - He's still at it:

just hoping you don't have an ace upon your sleeve that Deg is unaware off

Still with not a shred of evidence.

[SoN!c]

FP'd by Sonic - He's still at it:

just hoping you don't have an ace upon your sleeve that Deg is unaware off

Still with not a shred of evidence.

Then lynch me and see im Fucks, vanilla scientist.

[strike wolf]

Pushing the one route where hed have a chance to win as recruiter. Considering his reason for suspecting EW was the recruit it was either complete coincidence or he knew EW was the recruit because he recruited him.

Vote Son!c

But sure keep omitting facts Son!c

[SoN!c]

[SoN!c]

This is what that looks to me Deg

[degaston]

What about my stupid?

[Votanic]

Wow, everytime I come back it gets weirder.

First, Charle's story is ridiculous.
If DDS canceled the recruitment after getting too drunk to send Charle a message about it, then he needs to permanently turn in his mod badge... but I'll give DDS credit that has not happened.

I don't think Sonic is gullible enough to believe that either.. but his playstyle is crazy enough to pretend he does...

Okay, I'm back on board... Lynch Sonic.

Fast-posted by Sonic, but he isn't saying anything important.

[Votanic]

Correction: fast-posted by Dega, but still not important.

[Ragian]

@Dega, you're saying that it doesn't matter which of Sonic, Strike, or Votanic we lynch, right?

[SoN!c]

What about my stupid?

It stays a game. Littlebit of fun is needed..

But honestly, i think the sequence matters otherwise the Thing would have come clean..

[SoN!c]

3 votes on me so im waiting on Charle to hammer me and Deg can see im Fucks vanilla scientist. Just never say i did not warn you

[TrafalgarLaw01]

Ok forgot to look up all the back ground so quick toughts

I would like to win by lynching the thing but seems deg plan is the safest. Charle explanations is kinda weird so yeah seems like the move Deg.

Sonic - Either the Thing that tried to stirr things up or most lilely bad townplay, tunneling without proof. Cause lest say he is the thing what he would have achieved by lynching me D2 a BT d3 so unlikely thing unless very bad play as the thing too.

Vot - had Ragian behind him and my strongest point to him is he could have hammer me but didnt according to EW he also could have hammer me. So it is likely 2 of them decide not to hammer cause maybe all 5 townies were gonna get it wrong? Maybe but idk

Strike - the lynch vote before BT and when he was fine with me and sonic out seems like scummy. I think its strike. Now he is trying to see where can he jump.

vote strike


If charle is the converted should not matter much so might switch vote to the other 2

[degaston]

@Dega, you're saying that it doesn't matter which of Sonic, Strike, or Votanic we lynch, right?

As the vig, I expect it matters more to me than anyone else. If we get it wrong, I'm most likely to be recruited (though it may be obvious because there could be another message about a lost and found flamethrower). Town should still win no matter who we lynch and who is recruited.

I can find suspicious things for all 3 suspects, but I see more from Sonic (especially after Charle lost the flamethrower) than Vot or Strike, so that's who I'm going with.

[SoN!c]

Ok forgot to look up all the back ground so quick toughts

I would like to win by lynching the thing but seems deg plan is the safest. Charle explanations is kinda weird so yeah seems like the move Deg.

Sonic - Either the Thing that tried to stirr things up or most lilely bad townplay, tunneling without proof. Cause lest say he is the thing what he would have achieved by lynching me D2 a BT d3 so unlikely thing unless very bad play as the thing too.

Vot - had Ragian behind him and my strongest point to him is he could have hammer me but didnt according to EW he also could have hammer me. So it is likely 2 of them decide not to hammer cause maybe all 5 townies were gonna get it wrong? Maybe but idk

Strike - the lynch vote before BT and when he was fine with me and sonic out seems like scummy. I think its strike. Now he is trying to see where can he jump.

vote strike


If charle is the converted should not matter much so might switch vote to the other 2

Vote strike

If Traf wants i'll vote myself

[SoN!c]

@Dega, you're saying that it doesn't matter which of Sonic, Strike, or Votanic we lynch, right?

As the vig, I expect it matters more to me than anyone else. If we get it wrong, I'm most likely to be recruited (though it may be obvious because there could be another message about a lost and found flamethrower). Town should still win no matter who we lynch and who is recruited.

I can find suspicious things for all 3 suspects, but I see more from Sonic (especially after Charle lost the flamethrower) than Vot or Strike, so that's who I'm going with.

Why would the Thing recruit you if the FT will be found by another townie after you flamed your target?

[degaston]

@Dega, you're saying that it doesn't matter which of Sonic, Strike, or Votanic we lynch, right?

As the vig, I expect it matters more to me than anyone else. If we get it wrong, I'm most likely to be recruited (though it may be obvious because there could be another message about a lost and found flamethrower). Town should still win no matter who we lynch and who is recruited.

I can find suspicious things for all 3 suspects, but I see more from Sonic (especially after Charle lost the flamethrower) than Vot or Strike, so that's who I'm going with.

Why would the Thing recruit you if the FT will be found by another townie after you flamed your target?

Maybe out of hope that it will make a difference, or maybe out of spite because I'm in control of the game?

But I don't understand why you would be upset about being lynched when it would guarantee that you win?

If you're town, then just hammer yourself.

That way you can't be recruited, I'll flame Charle, and you'll win with town.

[SoN!c]

@Dega, you're saying that it doesn't matter which of Sonic, Strike, or Votanic we lynch, right?

As the vig, I expect it matters more to me than anyone else. If we get it wrong, I'm most likely to be recruited (though it may be obvious because there could be another message about a lost and found flamethrower). Town should still win no matter who we lynch and who is recruited.

I can find suspicious things for all 3 suspects, but I see more from Sonic (especially after Charle lost the flamethrower) than Vot or Strike, so that's who I'm going with.

Why would the Thing recruit you if the FT will be found by another townie after you flamed your target?

Maybe out of hope that it will make a difference, or maybe out of spite because I'm in control of the game?

But I don't understand why you would be upset about being lynched when it would guarantee that you win?

If you're town, then just hammer yourself.

That way you can't be recruited, I'll flame Charle, and you'll win with town.

And "winning" that way means i get a conquer club clover? This is a game right?

Finding The Thing is the game objective. Winning a conquer club clover is not