Prison Mafia TOWN WIN !!

[*Pixar*]

And now I'm receiving death threats... Who's currently in possesion of that shank again? Come. Have at me. What's left of town, you'll know who to lynch.

Yeah that was me. This message role seems dumb to me, other than trying to see who comes forward and who hides the messages I send them.

GIBBERISH GIBBERISH GIBBERISH...

Here you go Josh buddy - have a whiskey - you'll be right as rain tomorrow.

OK I take back what I said about Josh. I was wondering why there hadn't been a mafia kill so that idea occurred to me but I hadn't yet caught up and read about the shank business.
Makes sense there are town killings and mafia killings and makes sense he might target pixar thinking he was lying about being a ghost. Maybe the scum kill got blocked another way.

HOWEVER - there is something I don't understand about Pixar and I need your help.
Pixar - have you hard claimed ghost or just sort claimed? It's a hard claim right? You see yourself as a town ghost and can send messages. Did your role tell you that you silence people?
Thanks

It makes sense it would - I saw something that froze my blood as I entered pixar's cell on N1.
But what I don't get is that Max who was also silenced said he had info on Pix from the following night - I assumed Max visited Pix on N2 and didn't get frozen.
Is that right Max or am I way off?

Pepe - did you get silenced after visiting pix? I just wanna make sure that is the only cause and there are not other silencing powers.

Also Pixar said this

Also not sure if this helps or not. But if I'm visited by a group only 1 visitor will be muted FYI

yet 3 of us were muted. I wanna get to the bottom of this.

As for other things as I said I'm confused now as to who is scum - I was convinced it was one of these guys before as they didn't vote for scum on D2 - Dukasaur, actorday, cdbridges, general bax. Now we know 3 of them are town and I kind of investigated Dukasaur and the response I got from that seemed like a townie one to me although as I said it's not conclusive. He could be a scum role that investigates as town like godfather, conman etc.
But assuming he's town cause of the result who is left?

I don't think Ragian would come out and admit a kill early on today if he were scum. I think he would just carry on pretending to be helpful - but that confession seems too truthful to be a scum move imo.

Josh I think is town trying to shank non town.
Max went out hard against pixar with seemingly inside info - scum wouldn't normally do that - they tend to bandwagon more.

i-andrei, degaston, darin, fusi, dunk, duke and others seem town to me and were on the hal vote.

It kind of does bring me back to theJmac who hammered but after Josh hammered....
and Pepe who was silenced like me - but on a night that a mafia kill did go through.

Sooo - I don't think I will vote for Ragian due to his seeming honesty today.
I wanna clear up the silencing business and could vote pixar - but honestly I think now that he could be a town ghost - but also 3rd party in which case I am in favour of lynching all 3rd party.

But I think I wanna vote Jmac more than anyone. Not just cause of the scummy double hammer - also cause we know so little about him. He did seem to be participating and making more sense lately - but that was 4 days ago.

Yes hard claimed town, does Casper sound like a 3rd party role? lol. Yes my role told me people get silenced when visiting me, along with being able to send messages.

MOD NOTE.

I have made a mistake wth a role, and it has been picked up.

I post this for fairness.

The person involved has been contacted and it is up to them to disclose my message.

My appologies.. this is a big event with many players, and these small issues can be overlooked

This issue does NOT change the direction of this event.... and its kinda obvious.

OHH and a MOD TIP FOR TOWN.... look at the past.

It is my role that was mistaken. My original role was supposed to only mute one person during the night when multiple people visited me. Looks like Raz muted everyone . So we can probably rule out the fact there is another silencing role out there. So my question is still WHY THE HELL DID JOSH VISIT ME???

[Ragian]

For what it's worth, I would assume that any experienced mafia player would be on the halrob vote D2. And if at least one of the remaining mafia (in the event that we're looking at more than one left, but the numbers would indicate so) is experienced, the rest of the mafia would've been told to vote for halrob D2. That's what I would've done anyway.

I'd be more interested in seeing who voted D1.

DAY 1 VOTE COUNT #2

*Pixar* - Dunk90 halrob64
TrafalgarLaw01 - Dunk90
Loose Canon - Dunk90
Darin44 - no lynch halrob64
Dunk90 - no lynch
Ragian - halrob64
fusibaseball - halrob64
DukeHazzard - halrob64
degaston - halrob64 halrob64
TheJMac - halrob64

2 - Dunk90
7 - halrob64
1 - no lynch

This shows us that JMac and Duke voted halrob D1. I don't know how experienced they are. I think inexperienced scum would do like traffic:

i vote no vote

Confirmed scum stalled.

i-andrei unvoted halrob shortly after.

The day ended with the following (alive players) not voting for halrob (in alphabetical order): Darin, Dukasaur, Dunk, i-andrei, Josh, Maxleod, Pepe, pershy

Of those, I believe pershy and Josh to be town based on play, and I think Maxleod is non-mafia as he was visited last night (again, I don't know how he knows, but he says that he was).

What I'm saying is that between Darin, Dukasaur, i-andrei, and Pepe, I think we could find inexperienced scum. Of the four of them, I would exclude i-andrei based on gut feeling from his gameplay, and I could be swayed to ignore Dukasaur based on pershy's "investigation" (but I don't know if it said too much).

That leaves me with Darin and Pepe. Darin voted for halrob D2. Pepe didn't. He voted Dunk. Now, I'll reiterate that after N1, if I were mafia, I would've instructed my fellow mafia players to get voting for halrob who was a lost cause being caught in a web of lies of his own making.

Any thoughts on that from the rest of the players?

FP'ed by Pix

@Pix, Josh visited you because he didn't believe you. It seems fair not to believe you the way you dripped information on us the more you got cornered instead of just coming clean, which would have looked more town-like.

[Ragian]

@Pepe, why didn't you vote halrob D2?

@Darin, why didn't you vote halrob D1?

[i-andrei]

Not sure why you believe Joshzam to be town, he hasn't shared any info.

[Dukasaur]

Lord almighty JOSH is handing out the shanks. He handed it to me. I never said when. I've been sitting on it (not literally)

Gotta admit this is a funny visual!

[Dukasaur]

I guess it could be a scum role, but Josh isn't scummy in my book so far, so I would think it's not a scum role. Could be any alignment really. I can't tell you why he would target you. It doesn't make sense to me, but hey, maybe I don't know Josh as well as I thought

Anyway, he can't tell us until tomorrow.

Chana was found in his cell dead. No mentioning of a shank, so I would presume that it was a mafia kill.

Good "point" So josh decided to hand off the shank to you instead of using it Night 2. So who is handing out shanks?

I received something else last night but won't say what until i know who gave it to me, just so it can be confirmed.

The clap?

(Sorry. Worked 12 hours last night, then slept only 2 hours before being woken up by jackhammers in front of my door. So I'm super groggy and everything seems funny right now!)

[DukeHazzard]

@ i-andrei

My night action was successful and I learned that YOU are not Mafia.

Someone mentioned that I was late on D2 to vote for Halrob which might point toward scum. That was me sitting back and watching the game play. As a new player, I'm just trying to follow what is going on.

On another note, I have a suspicion that one of the mafia is posing as town. I'm not sure who, but Maxleod, pershy, and Ragian are on that list, in no particular order.

FP by Duk

[Dukasaur]

After so much reading I don't know what more to add.... by now.

Yeah, I know the feeling. It's been less than 48 hours since last I was here and there's like five pages to read.

[degaston]

@ i-andrei

My night action was successful and I learned that YOU are not Mafia.

Someone mentioned that I was late on D2 to vote for Halrob which might point toward scum. That was me sitting back and watching the game play. As a new player, I'm just trying to follow what is going on.

On another note, I have a suspicion that one of the mafia is posing as town. I'm not sure who, but Maxleod, pershy, and Ragian are on that list, in no particular order.

FP by Duk

So you are also claiming to be a cop? Is there some difference between your role and Bax's?

[i-andrei]

@ i-andrei

My night action was successful and I learned that YOU are not Mafia.

Someone mentioned that I was late on D2 to vote for Halrob which might point toward scum. That was me sitting back and watching the game play. As a new player, I'm just trying to follow what is going on.

On another note, I have a suspicion that one of the mafia is posing as town. I'm not sure who, but Maxleod, pershy, and Ragian are on that list, in no particular order.

FP by Duk

So you are also claiming to be a cop? Is there some difference between your role and Bax's?

He said he had negative results previously, whatever that means...?

[Ragian]

On another note, I have a suspicion that one of the mafia is posing as town. I'm not sure who, but Maxleod, pershy, and Ragian are on that list, in no particular order.

FP by Duk

All mafia will be posing as town. That's the idea. (I wanted to ask the cop thing, too, but Dega got in before me.)

@i-andrei, negative results means that he hasn't caught mafia yet.

[degaston]

On another note, I have a suspicion that one of the mafia is posing as town. I'm not sure who, but Maxleod, pershy, and Ragian are on that list, in no particular order.

FP by Duk

All mafia will be posing as town. That's the idea. (I wanted to ask the cop thing, too, but Dega got in before me.)

Except halrob and Bax - they were both posing as scum.

@i-andrei, negative results means that he hasn't caught mafia yet.

Day 2 he said he only learned something he already knew.
Day 3 he said he was 0/2 on night actions.
Day 4 he says his night action was successful, but that i-andre is not Mafia???
My scummy sense is tingling.

[Maxleod]

Can you all start voting? I already voted Jmac, Dukasaur vouched for him even if he admittedly doesn't have enough time to partake in this game, even though he has plenty of time to play his 30+ active games, JOIN new games, and post in the Off-Topics forum. But he somehow knows that Jmac is "trustworthy".

We lynch Jmac, who in all probabilities will be confirmed scum, next day we lynch Dukasaur. TWO BIRDS WITH ONE STONE.

(and no, I haven't forgotten about you Pixar and Ragian)

[Darin44]

@Pepe, why didn't you vote halrob D2?

@Darin, why didn't you vote halrob D1?

You need to get your story straight I voted halro thats why I voted for him day2

DAY 1 VOTE COUNT #2

*Pixar* - Dunk90 halrob64
TrafalgarLaw01 - Dunk90
Loose Canon - Dunk90
Darin44 - no lynch halrob64
Dunk90 - no lynch
Ragian - halrob64
fusibaseball - halrob64
DukeHazzard - halrob64
degaston - halrob64 halrob64
TheJMac - halrob64

2 - Dunk90
7 - halrob64
1 - no lynch

VOTE COUNT - DAY 2

fusibaseball - halrob64
Darin44 - halrob64
i-andrei - halrob64
Ragian - halrob64
*Pixar* - halrob64

You need 10 votes for a lynch

Well I know that 2 people who want to lynch me a are Mafia, i-andrei we know from being named in the missing email, and 1 other. I am monitoring who is wanting to Lynch me, you better hope you get ten because when the second night comes that's when my power comes in to play

I'm thanking halro was ratting you out

fusibaseball - ?
Darin44 - town
i-andrei - town
Ragian - mafia
*Pixar* - 3 party

I vote Ragian

[Darin44]

Plus I thank there was no mafia kill last night because you used the shank to throw everyone off

[Dunk90]

I'm no 3rd party. I am town. I've been super busy with work and family so it's been hard keeping up with these rapid fire posts. I've been trying to help the town by visiting other folks and handing them tazors at night. I wasn't sure I would be able to use them effectively. I am willing to vote Pixar from what I've read so far. Ragian could be scum. Let's do a poll to see who would vote for who.

[Darin44]

Can you all start voting? I already voted Jmac, Dukasaur vouched for him even if he admittedly doesn't have enough time to partake in this game, even though he has plenty of time to play his 30+ active games, JOIN new games, and post in the Off-Topics forum. But he somehow knows that Jmac is "trustworthy".

We lynch Jmac, who in all probabilities will be confirmed scum, next day we lynch Dukasaur. TWO BIRDS WITH ONE STONE.

(and no, I haven't forgotten about you Pixar and Ragian)

I'm not ready for Jmac yet not enough info plus no post will get mod killed

Fd'ed Dunk90

[Darin44]

01. *Pixar* - 3rd Party
02. actorday - TOWN Night Killed Day 3
03. cdbridges - TOWN MOD KILLED DAY 3
04. chanakam2020 - TOWN Night Killed Day 2
05. Cofari - TOWN MOD KILLED DAY 1
06. Darin44 - TOWN
07. degaston - ?
08. Dukasaur - ?
09. DukeHazzard - ?
10. Dunk90 - TOWN
11. fusibaseball - ?
12. General Bax - TOWN LYNCHED DAY 3
13. halrob64 - MAFIA LYNCHED DAY 2
14. i-andrei - TOWN
15. joshzam - ?
16. Loose Canon - 3rd Party Night Killed Day 1
17. Maxleod - ?
18. PepeAtila - 3rd Party
19. pershy - ?
20. Ragian = MAFIA
21. TheJMac - ?
22. TheJonah - TOWN Night Killed Day 1
23.TrafalgarLaw01 - TOWN Night Killed Day 1
24. traffic133 - MAFIA Night Killed Day 1

[degaston]

<list>

For the ones you think you've identified, it would be helpful if you gave your reasoning.

[Darin44]

<list>

For the ones you think you've identified, it would be helpful if you gave your reasoning.

Just a filling thats all

[PepeAtila]

Pepe - did you get silenced after visiting pix? I just wanna make sure that is the only cause and there are not other silencing powers.

Yes I visited *Pixar* and get silenced

[PepeAtila]

@Pepe, why didn't you vote halrob D2?

@Darin, why didn't you vote halrob D1?

I did already explain it: I was not sure he was mafia ... at these moments I did believe harolb was no defended by Mafia.

[Dunk90]

Vote Lynch Pixar Has had it out for me since day 1. Hopefully we get this one right

[DukeHazzard]

@ i-andrei

My night action was successful and I learned that YOU are not Mafia.

Someone mentioned that I was late on D2 to vote for Halrob which might point toward scum. That was me sitting back and watching the game play. As a new player, I'm just trying to follow what is going on.

On another note, I have a suspicion that one of the mafia is posing as town. I'm not sure who, but Maxleod, pershy, and Ragian are on that list, in no particular order.

FP by Duk

So you are also claiming to be a cop? Is there some difference between your role and Bax's?

I don't know how what I said makes you think I'm a cop. But no, I'm not a cop. I don't know what a cop's role is to compare but I'm allowed to ask a question every night.

[DukeHazzard]

All mafia will be posing as town. That's the idea.

Chalk one up for the noob