INTO THE DEEP (COMPLETE - Mafia Win !!)

[blacky365]

This is getting silly, so much talk and no one really prepared to do anything.
my top 3 at the moment are;
Skoff
Chap
Tobi

leaning town towards most of the others but something seems off with Sirius, he was quite vocal but has gone real quiet when shot down about his nonsense posts... perhaps its a newbie not knowing wot to do or he is actually scum and has been called out on his play... time will tell!

I do believe we need a lynch today and so for the reason

UNVOTE
VOTE TOBI

I had to wrestle with the pros and cons of being the hammer, so i invite anyone with an investigative role to check me out tonite and prove i am town

[TX AG 90]

I guess I'm here, sorry with a game such as this I don't have a lot of confident reads.
I think Pika's role would be OP in scum's hands so he's the only real confident read.

One of these (at least) has to be scum because somebody misdirected me:
Chap
Tobi
ZaBeast

Town to townish in no order:
Pika
Skoffin
Strike wolf
Ragian

Iffy to scummy in no order:
Sirius
Blacky
TX

Why does someone misdirecting you = scum?

[Skoffin]

mob

Tx either can't vomprehend what i am sayomg or is intentionally muscharactiring it.

Tobi "guys ive been acting lkke a useless townie thid whole game to get scum killed, i cant believe you think im scummy!" Man you got mad when i used the joke word turnip before, yet you keep calling people dumbshits. Lol someone is mad they got caught

[Tobikera]

That's a lynch. Y'all are supposed to can it.
We'll see how many of my predictions come true.
Good game, scum.

[strike wolf]

This goes for everyone who gets lynched regardless of alignment (especially Dakky). You can either call everyone dumbshits and blame them for your lynch and probably get yourself lynched again in future games until people are tired of your b.s. or you can actually take into account why people wanted to lynch you and try to learn from it to become a better player.

[blacky365]

This goes for everyone who gets lynched regardless of alignment (especially Dakky). You can either call everyone dumbshits and blame them for your lynch and probably get yourself lynched again in future games until people are tired of your b.s. or you can actually take into account why people wanted to lynch you and try to learn from it to become a better player.

Hear hear

[Razorvich]

Thats a lynch.. scene coming soon

[Razorvich]

Town seem no closer to solving the crimes of the reef.. POISON seems to be the theme but the guilty party must be getting some inside info from someone to remain undetected for so long, there is someone that the town just do not trust

Most cards seem to be on the table.... Tobrika becomes the suspicious one, the insider has been discovered, well and truly outed.
Town deal with this apparent treachery with swift Reef justice.

[spoiler=town traitor has been lynched]

Title: Town Traitor
Common Species Name: Squid
Night Action Role: Night Ability Misdirect Master[/spoiler]
_______________________________________


After the storm has passed, the seas settle for a time, then the murky river surges arrive.
Mixing with the ocean, visibility is near impossible. The town are honing in on the guilty party.
Is this the perfect time for town to venture out for further investigations? Only time will tell

It is now NIGHT 4

Send in your night actions by replying to your role PMs.

You also have the option to waive your night action and go for your favorite food .. (may random.org be your friend)
Remain undiscovered and your night actions will succeed... become detected, and all hell may break loose

Those who already know their BONUS action, will still have to get that food to activate it
_______________________________________

You have 48 hours to lodge your night actions
Good luck to all those who choose to travel tonight

[chapcrap]

There's too much goddamn math in this game.

Oh hey ragian what are your opinions

Sorry. Work is fucked. On phone. Only read to this bit. Honestly, I give up on the math because I like scum hunting, and I'm too thick for and lack motivation to do math.

Three things stick out to me (apart from Pika last day):
1) What makes ZB know that Tobi is lying?
2) Why does chap ignore the rules and act as if he can use his special ability again?
3) Why would Tobi's alignment have anything to do with me?

Still catching up, but I have stated I was mistaken already. ZaB keeps bringing it up, not me. And now you're latching on to that.

[chapcrap]

@chap, why do you state that you can use your special ability again? Help me understand!

And just to double check, I PM'ed the mod. Initially, I thought it was an upgrade and could use it like a new night action ad nauseum. I switched that stance based on something ZaB quoted. However, I don't really see where it says on the OP. So, awaiting the mod's answer.

[chapcrap]

on mobile


Tobi was going to be a top lynch choice before chaps plan divided people frim it.
Tobis alignment will tell us about other players while others players lynch would not. If tobi is town then ragoo is scum and chap is town. If tobi is scum then chap is his scum partner. Tobi is best lynch today.
But whatever just do something. Its our last day ffs and im at work for 10 hours. Ill put my vote wherever tf its needed

What?! How am I linked to Tobi at all? None of actions go together and we haven't corroborated anything. Why are you trying to link this? You have been directing people into the group that investigated the whole time after I brought it up. As I stated then, I think that anyone who would do that is scum.

[chapcrap]

I was never a top lynch choice, except among the scum.
Scum know I am town, so look for the ones who are posting most often + mentioning the need to lynch Tobi.

I guess pershy, BuJaber, strike wolf, Metsfanmax, chapcrap, Pikanchion, ZaBeast, and Skoffin is the scum team then?

Can you do something helpful other than try to contradict everything that someone says? Tobi is right as far as me. I have been saying it the whole effing day. That he should not be lynched today. You are WRONG. Again. Taking things out of context. I have no idea where the vote count is right now because I'm still catching up, but

unvote VOTE Pika

[chapcrap]

I guess I'm here, sorry with a game such as this I don't have a lot of confident reads.
I think Pika's role would be OP in scum's hands so he's the only real confident read.

One of these (at least) has to be scum because somebody misdirected me:
Chap
Tobi
ZaBeast

Bad logic. Why does you being redirected mean that one of us is scum?

[chapcrap]

Chap,

What was the wording when you were told the number of scum in your Group of 4?

Was it any kind of scum or just Mafia?

In other words, if Skoffin is 3rd Party would that have been noted? Could it be that 1 out of the other 3 are scum and Skoffin is 3rd Party?

My original night action said I would detect the number of scum. The result specified that there was 1 mafia scum.

[strike wolf]

It's night time chap.

[chapcrap]

I can't see Tobi being scum.

Vote Pika

It's him, Sirius, or Black for me. I'll try to check in later today, but I'll go booze for a bit now.

Dead townie (aage) confirmed that I am town.

Not true.

[chapcrap]

Thats a lynch.. scene coming soon

So sorry for my posts... I thought it was still day because the subject in the OP said Day 4. I'll shut up now.

[Razorvich]

As the sun sets, the murky mud colored water turns into a death blood red.

As confusion takes hold, all head for cover, with no time for directed night actions.

The reef dwellers realize that their greatest fear has arrived... A FEEDING FRENZY

Is this a coordinated attack?
Have town have been sold out, and set up?

IT IS NOW DAY 5

[Pikanchion]

Given it appears we are at LyLo (if the ominous mod messages are anything to go by), it's time for a mass full claim. Everything. Role Title, Night Action Role, Action, Bonus Action, Species, Favourite Food, what you did and whom you targeted each night. Even if you stated this information before you should state it again.

The way this works best is that the most Town-ish person picks the person they find most scummy to claim first, that person full claims and nominates the person they find most scummy, this person does the same, and so on until all have claimed. This way you gain the most information (effectively each nomination is a pseudo-lynch with regard to vote analysis), and the scummiest have least chance of avoiding counter-claims or contradictions. Once the claiming has begun, nobody should comment on any other person's claim (preferably not post at all unless it is your turn to claim) so as to avoid influencing later claims. We should end up with an unbroken chain of 10 full claims, easy to compare and analyse.

I would suggest that BuJaber, as the only person confirmed Town by a confirmed Town, pick the first player to full claim.

[Ragian]

Or!!

We could try to decipher my result from last night. I know that I have found scum (by my bonus action), but I need help pinpointing it Depends if people believe me enough, though. I know a few that don't. If the majority here doesn't think I'm town, I will wait with my results.

Also, several have claimed already. TX, chap, me...right? Who are the unclaimed?

Anyway, let's decide whether we want to take Pika's road before we just blare out new claims.

[chapcrap]

Given it appears we are at LyLo (if the ominous mod messages are anything to go by), it's time for a mass full claim. Everything. Role Title, Night Action Role, Action, Bonus Action, Species, Favourite Food, what you did and whom you targeted each night. Even if you stated this information before you should state it again.

The way this works best is that the most Town-ish person picks the person they find most scummy to claim first, that person full claims and nominates the person they find most scummy, this person does the same, and so on until all have claimed. This way you gain the most information (effectively each nomination is a pseudo-lynch with regard to vote analysis), and the scummiest have least chance of avoiding counter-claims or contradictions. Once the claiming has begun, nobody should comment on any other person's claim (preferably not post at all unless it is your turn to claim) so as to avoid influencing later claims. We should end up with an unbroken chain of 10 full claims, easy to compare and analyse.

I would suggest that BuJaber, as the only person confirmed Town by a confirmed Town, pick the first player to full claim.

One, everyone has already claimed, so what's the point of this one at a time crap? There isn't going to be new information revealed...

Two, BuJ has never been confirmed as town.

Three, glad we lynched someone on my no lynch list. Worked out really well. Thanks for leading that Skoffin and Pika. Skoffin, strike wolf, or Ragian is a mafia scum. Kill one of them. It's definitely not strike wolf. He's a town healer. His role has been proven. If you want to attempt to feign a debate about his alignment, then fine, but you're wrong. unvote vote Skoffin

[chapcrap]

Given it appears we are at LyLo (if the ominous mod messages are anything to go by), it's time for a mass full claim. Everything. Role Title, Night Action Role, Action, Bonus Action, Species, Favourite Food, what you did and whom you targeted each night. Even if you stated this information before you should state it again.

The way this works best is that the most Town-ish person picks the person they find most scummy to claim first, that person full claims and nominates the person they find most scummy, this person does the same, and so on until all have claimed. This way you gain the most information (effectively each nomination is a pseudo-lynch with regard to vote analysis), and the scummiest have least chance of avoiding counter-claims or contradictions. Once the claiming has begun, nobody should comment on any other person's claim (preferably not post at all unless it is your turn to claim) so as to avoid influencing later claims. We should end up with an unbroken chain of 10 full claims, easy to compare and analyse.

I would suggest that BuJaber, as the only person confirmed Town by a confirmed Town, pick the first player to full claim.

One, everyone has already claimed, so what's the point of this one at a time crap? There isn't going to be new information revealed...

Two, BuJ has never been confirmed as town.

Three, glad we lynched someone on my no lynch list. Worked out really well. Thanks for leading that Skoffin and Pika. Skoffin, strike wolf, or Ragian is a mafia scum. Kill one of them. It's definitely not strike wolf. He's a town healer. His role has been proven. If you want to attempt to feign a debate about his alignment, then fine, but you're wrong. unvote vote Skoffin

Was fastposted by Rage. Pika is my number two scummiest after Skoff. I didn't get to choose my night action. It sounds like that was the case for everyone.

If we wanted to choose an order to force people to reveal night actions, I'm fine with that. I think we should start with the claimed healers to see if BuJ was actually healed by anyone. Because he didn't die. So, he either lied about being poisoned or he was healed.

[Ragian]

Wait, what?

So, do you want to try out my result from last night, or...?

[blacky365]

finally i get an actual result!!

I investigated Skoff last night... my result;
Common Species Name: Pufferfish
Night Action Role: Passive Healer

Could she be the scum healer?
Why did she not claim to be a healer along with everyone else?

I am still convinced of her scumminess so...
VOTE SKOFFIN

[blacky365]

Oh, and there it is... my claim!
I can investigate other fish to check out their species and actions.

I was waiting until i had an actual result before claiming (unless forced to do so) and now that I have a result i am happy to share.