Civilization Mafia - Town Victory!

[Skoffin]

That's pretty rude
I'll rek u cunts

[nagerous]

I know Dakky visited Skoffin last night ,that is all I got.

So you tracked Dakky ?

He may have visited skoffin but he hasn't got a gun so pretty sure he couldn't have killed skoffin..

Ragian what did you do in the night?

[madmitch]

@Mitch dakky is gunless so whatever he did to skoffin didn't kill him. He's not cop he's not skum and he's not vig.

MAYBE HE HAD A CANDLESTICK? All I know is that he wanted to hang Skoffin yesterday and he visits last night and somehow Skoffin is dead maybe HE USED HIS SWORD

[nagerous]

Did you track dakky or watch skoffin?

[Ragian]

I know Dakky visited Skoffin last night ,that is all I got.

So you tracked Dakky ?

He may have visited skoffin but he hasn't got a gun so pretty sure he couldn't have killed skoffin..

Ragian what did you do in the night?

I've already breadcrumbed this. I'd rather not say because I feel stupid.

[dakky21]

I don't have much to say except I did visit skoffin and roleblocked her. Was pretty sure she is scum and was pretty sure she may do the kill. Was wrong there, obviously.

[nagerous]

OK well ignoring Mitch's evidence for now I am going to say it is safe to say that it is likely that none of the below killed skoffin in the night phase:

Dakky - doesn't equip a gun as per nagerous, timwoodbury - ragian appears to agree

Djfireside - roleblocked by skittles night three

Ga7 - declared inno by samlen.


That leaves myself, Fircoal, skittles, Mitch, samlen, strike, Tim and ragian who haven't been 'cleared' per se.

Of these remaining players I believe ragian has to be considered the most suspicious.

The other six have all shown strong understanding of the games mechanics, which I just haven't seen in the same way as with ragian. His actions on day one when him and hotshot were pushing the alternate day one lynch of ga7 over benga have to continue to also to be looked at suspicious.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

That's pretty rude
I'll rek u cunts

These guys dont like D1 power couples. The club cant handle us.

[ga7]

Hrm, I blocked DJ also. I'm kinda out of ideas, will reread properly tomorrow.

[ga7]

I'm starting to ponder about massclaiming

[nagerous]

I'm starting to ponder about massclaiming

It's not really a mass claim as most of us haven't claimed our civs, it is just a collation of night actions which can only work to our benefit.

[strike wolf]

Players more or less cleared based on voting pattern, behavior and/or game knowledge

1. Strike
2. Mitch
3. Nag
4. Tim
5. Chu

Players seemingly cleared through actions:

1. Ga7
2. Dakky

Players who have support of not being scum from an action:

1. DjFIRESIDE

Players who seem to have game knowledge but can't prove it due to mostly responding second hand:

1. Ragian
2. Samlen
3. Skittles

I'll reread at least a few of these before I make any decision but based on general game set up, it's likely that there are still two scum. Based on what has happened and what we know, I would not be at all surprised to find the remaining scum within those bottom 4.

Skittles gets some extra town cred because he readily voted Hotshot Day 2 and 3 but based on possible confusion regarding the doc situation and seemingly trying to appear that he did eventually come to realize Benga was scum after the lynch, he loses some credit.

Samlen in particular I would have to read over again.

Ragian was on the wrong side of the Benga Lynch and wasn't on the Hotshot Lynch until Day 3 after Lynch became inevitable. He did speak lightly against the case on Aage and did seem to me to have a decent grasp on town mechanics however with the latter, he was never from what I read the first to point out the things that made Rage appear to know about town mechanics

DJ was blocked last night which supports that he didnt send in the kill but not necessarily that he isn't scum. Beyond that he has done nothing that has left me with a positive impression of his behavior.

[madmitch]

Did you track dakky or watch skoffin?

Tracked Dakky,

[Ragian]

What evidence is pointing to me not understanding the mechanics? True, some of the stuff I built I thought would grant me different powers, but saying that I don't understand town mechanics is bullshit.

[nagerous]

Ragi I wasn't saying that you don't understand the mechanics it is just I have seen posts from all the others previously that have 'cleared' them in my eyes . Consider it a process of elimination if you don't turn out scum then someone has been playing extremely well.

[Djfireside]

Great to see everyone likes to come play with me at night. I appreciate the company. I have been toiling over a few things, mainly night 2 since that seems to have the most questions for me as things are starting to progress. One question I had which I dont know how much it means, but since everyone is coming forth with things, did anyone block Tim N2. From what I have Skittles blocked GA7 and Nag blocked Hotshot and just trying to piece everything else together for that night.

I had issues with Dakky and their stance on Hotshot as noted from yesterday but with the night actions I will give them the benefit of the doubt for today. I have some skeptism but want to see if I can piece my information for N2 first.

[Samlen]

Players more or less cleared based on voting pattern, behavior and/or game knowledge

1. Strike
2. Mitch
3. Nag
4. Tim
5. Chu

Players seemingly cleared through actions:

1. Ga7
2. Dakky

Players who have support of not being scum from an action:

1. DjFIRESIDE

Players who seem to have game knowledge but can't prove it due to mostly responding second hand:

1. Ragian
2. Samlen
3. Skittles

I'll reread at least a few of these before I make any decision but based on general game set up, it's likely that there are still two scum. Based on what has happened and what we know, I would not be at all surprised to find the remaining scum within those bottom 4.

Skittles gets some extra town cred because he readily voted Hotshot Day 2 and 3 but based on possible confusion regarding the doc situation and seemingly trying to appear that he did eventually come to realize Benga was scum after the lynch, he loses some credit.

Samlen in particular I would have to read over again.

Ragian was on the wrong side of the Benga Lynch and wasn't on the Hotshot Lynch until Day 3 after Lynch became inevitable. He did speak lightly against the case on Aage and did seem to me to have a decent grasp on town mechanics however with the latter, he was never from what I read the first to point out the things that made Rage appear to know about town mechanics

DJ was blocked last night which supports that he didnt send in the kill but not necessarily that he isn't scum. Beyond that he has done nothing that has left me with a positive impression of his behavior.

Another point on ragian I saw while rereading is that he quickly jumped on ga while the benga lynch was happening, which could've been an attempt to get that bandwagon going fast enough to save his scumbuddy. Also, a quick note to help your opinion of me:I was the first person to mention building stuff, something that scum do not seem to know about (If the search function is working correctly).

show

[strike wolf]

@samlen: Good point.

[Skittles!]

Skittles gets some extra town cred because he readily voted Hotshot Day 2 and 3 but based on possible confusion regarding the doc situation and seemingly trying to appear that he did eventually come to realize Benga was scum after the lynch, he loses some credit.

To go off Samlen's point, I have been upfront with the building I built on Night 1, and how I have used it. I still don't understand why I have been branded as someone who has "secondhand" responses to the game mechanics and knowledge?

[Djfireside]

Skittles gets some extra town cred because he readily voted Hotshot Day 2 and 3 but based on possible confusion regarding the doc situation and seemingly trying to appear that he did eventually come to realize Benga was scum after the lynch, he loses some credit.

To go off Samlen's point, I have been upfront with the building I built on Night 1, and how I have used it. I still don't understand why I have been branded as someone who has "secondhand" responses to the game mechanics and knowledge?

I have to agree with Skittles on their statement, when I was reading through all the days they were forthcoming and explained what and whom they did their actions to. I missed it on the day it happened but in reading back it is there.

Since im on the topic, The Benga lynch was a little different than Hotshot. Benga we were still getting used to logistics and were unaware of certain game elements and there wasnt much to draw from. Hotshots actions and claim was apparent and could have only been furthered by coming out and saying, Hi Im a barbarian! This was why I questioned Dakky as to how they could not vote for hotshot despite their statements prior.

[dakky21]

Hotshots actions and claim was apparent and could have only been furthered by coming out and saying, Hi Im a barbarian! This was why I questioned Dakky as to how they could not vote for hotshot despite their statements prior.

I didn't vote Hotshot because I really didn't think he is scum. Wrong read there, what else to say.

[Fircoal]

I have strong feelings that Skittles and Tim are town. Going off of that and Strike's post:

show

That'd put Ragian and Samlen as the most suspicious.

That said we should really tabulate all of the night actions I think. It seems like we might be able to catch scum that way.

[Fircoal]

I have strong feelings that Skittles and Tim are town. Going off of that and Strike's post:

show

That'd put Ragian and Samlen as the most suspicious.

That said we should really tabulate all of the night actions I think. It seems like we might be able to catch scum that way.

So I'm making the table. For it to be complete and postable I need:

Both night actions: Ragain,

Night 2 Actions: dakky, mitch, ga7, strike

[Fircoal]

I have strong feelings that Skittles and Tim are town. Going off of that and Strike's post:

show

That'd put Ragian and Samlen as the most suspicious.

That said we should really tabulate all of the night actions I think. It seems like we might be able to catch scum that way.

So I'm making the table. For it to be complete and postable I need:

Both night actions: Ragain, DJ

Night 2 Actions: dakky, mitch, ga7, strike

EBWOP. I missed a line in my table.

[dakky21]

I didn't have a N2 action because being in a war with Skoffin D1. Make your own conclusion why is that so...