Sherwood Forest Mafia - Game Over, Town Wins!

[pancakemix]

The Spamalot bug is spreading. It just happened here.

[XenHu]

OK, I've got another theory.

According to Mandy, he was going to switch over to scum at the end of Day 3, yes? His role came up in blue (see first post). But you will notice, that other power roles, I.E. GT and AK, came up in yellow. The only other one to come up blue was Selin.

Here it comes: Given that info, I may not have been wrong about the switch to scum for Selin. That said, there may have been others that switched as well under our noses.

The one thing that I'm not sure about is Aegnor coming up green. I take that to mean that he was a pro-town power role not in the legend, with Guy Of Gisborne and The Sheriff of Nottingham coming up yellow to indicate legendary/non-switching and the blue to mean legendary/switching.

Thoughts, questions, grave concerns?

AK came up as Yellow because He, and I, plus GT and my bodyguard, make up a group.

-X

You mean the group of supporters for the crown in the legend?

And LSU is your bodyguard, then?

It seems likely, yes. I never took the time to learn the name of my bodyguard.

-X

[pancakemix]

But you DO ave a bodyguard. I suppose that clears LSU as much as I'm clear, which is about 90% by Aegnor's investigation.

[XenHu]

But you DO ave a bodyguard. I suppose that clears LSU as much as I'm clear, which is about 90% by Aegnor's investigation.

Yes, I have a bodyguard.

-X

[pancakemix]

1. pancakemix
2. XenHu
4. nagerous (replaces hecter)
5. dominationnation
7. willis (replaces She Wolf)
8. red bull (replaces dwightschrute)
9. Incandenza (replaces jnd)
10. I GOT SERVED
11. LSU Tiger Josh
12. Guilty Biscuit
13. spinwizard
23. for dummies
24. moz
25. autoload

In orange are the ones who are somewhat cleared by Aegnor's investigations. I think there's one more, but I don't know. I'm only sure about myself and auto.

In green are the ones with roleclaims. That explains itself.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

damn Aegner you did last a lot longer than I thought you would in this game based upon the early situation on having to name yourself. On Xenhu's note I will verify that I was aware of G_T and and Xen being in the same faction based upon their roles. In regards to trying to figure out who is little john and the other merry scum I think I will try to go back and reread the bloody day and see what ideas were thrown out there and try to figure out who may be bad.

[Incandenza]

1. pancakemix
2. XenHu
4. nagerous (replaces hecter)
5. dominationnation
7. willis (replaces She Wolf)
8. red bull (replaces dwightschrute)
9. Incandenza (replaces jnd)
10. I GOT SERVED
11. LSU Tiger Josh
12. Guilty Biscuit
13. spinwizard
23. for dummies
24. moz
25. autoload

In orange are the ones who are somewhat cleared by Aegnor's investigations. I think there's one more, but I don't know. I'm only sure about myself and auto.

In green are the ones with roleclaims. That explains itself.

Now that Robin is dead, I think we can, for the moment, set aside anyone that was in the archery contest, assuming our main focus is finding Little John. I've noted spin and IGS in the quote above in blue (just for record-keeping purposes)... Oh, and for dummies claimed noble 'yesterday', so I've put him in blue as well, since his roleclaim isn't nearly as supported as the others.

That leaves us with the following suspect list: nagerous, willis, red bull, myself, GB, and moz.

Now, the question is: how exactly did the hit on GT go down? did cola call it in, or did Little John have to do so? If it's the former, than any analysis of posting proximity to the hit goes out the window. But if it's the latter, then willis becomes my prime suspect, as he was posting around the time of the hit and had been pretty quiet (he's posted, but hasn't exactly been going out on limbs).

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I haven't reread it yet, but from what I remember G_T apologized after accidently killing the sheriff and then right away was killed. Being that Robin and Little John are "separate roles" I would imagine that Little John had to be the one to call it in since he was the one killing G_T rather then just a random shot coming from somewhere.

[Incandenza]

I haven't reread it yet, but from what I remember G_T apologized after accidently killing the sheriff and then right away was killed. Being that Robin and Little John are "separate roles" I would imagine that Little John had to be the one to call it in since he was the one killing G_T rather then just a random shot coming from somewhere.

That's pretty much how it went down. Tonka killed AK, then 16 minutes later he was killed by little john.

Robin and little john are certainly seperate roles, but it's always possible that robin had some sort of esoteric role given his importance in the overall theme, and as such was the one who called in the tonka hit.

But I'm more inclined toward the idea that Little John had to call in his hit, which is why I specifically mentioned willis, who posted 8 minutes before tonka was killed.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Vote Willis he hasn't posted in a bit so I'll be interested in hearing what he has to say.

[nagerous]

I checked the got tonka kill again and the only ones posting around the time that are still alive were XenHu, Willis and Incandenza. Since the cola lynch I now have more trust for Incandenza. I am leaning towards willis being Little John though.

His last post was at 19.02 and after that he went awfully quiet before 19.10 where got tonka was killed. It seems to me unlikely that cola as robin hood killed him as it would take some guts to be the first to post "in shock" after the kill. If it was Little John that struck, it would be a far better strategy in my eyes to be quiet around the time in order to not arouse suspicion.

vote willis he seems like scum

[nagerous]

vote willis

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Vote Willis damn red color instead of bold. same reason I mentioned couple of post up.

[pancakemix]

1. pancakemix
2. XenHu
4. nagerous (replaces hecter)
5. dominationnation
7. willis (replaces She Wolf)
8. red bull (replaces dwightschrute)
9. Incandenza (replaces jnd)
10. I GOT SERVED
11. LSU Tiger Josh
12. Guilty Biscuit
13. spinwizard
23. for dummies
24. moz
25. autoload

In orange are the ones who are somewhat cleared by Aegnor's investigations. I think there's one more, but I don't know. I'm only sure about myself and auto.

In green are the ones with roleclaims. That explains itself.

Now that Robin is dead, I think we can, for the moment, set aside anyone that was in the archery contest, assuming our main focus is finding Little John. I've noted spin and IGS in the quote above in blue (just for record-keeping purposes)... Oh, and for dummies claimed noble 'yesterday', so I've put him in blue as well, since his roleclaim isn't nearly as supported as the others.

That leaves us with the following suspect list: nagerous, willis, red bull, myself, GB, and moz.

Now, the question is: how exactly did the hit on GT go down? did cola call it in, or did Little John have to do so? If it's the former, than any analysis of posting proximity to the hit goes out the window. But if it's the latter, then willis becomes my prime suspect, as he was posting around the time of the hit and had been pretty quiet (he's posted, but hasn't exactly been going out on limbs).

It was definitely a mafia call. It said he was beaten to death,as did the other scum kills.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

1. pancakemix
2. XenHu
4. nagerous (replaces hecter)
5. dominationnation
7. willis (replaces She Wolf)
8. red bull (replaces dwightschrute)
9. Incandenza (replaces jnd)
10. I GOT SERVED
11. LSU Tiger Josh
12. Guilty Biscuit
13. spinwizard
23. for dummies
24. moz
25. autoload

In orange are the ones who are somewhat cleared by Aegnor's investigations. I think there's one more, but I don't know. I'm only sure about myself and auto.

In green are the ones with roleclaims. That explains itself.

Now that Robin is dead, I think we can, for the moment, set aside anyone that was in the archery contest, assuming our main focus is finding Little John. I've noted spin and IGS in the quote above in blue (just for record-keeping purposes)... Oh, and for dummies claimed noble 'yesterday', so I've put him in blue as well, since his roleclaim isn't nearly as supported as the others.

That leaves us with the following suspect list: nagerous, willis, red bull, myself, GB, and moz.

Now, the question is: how exactly did the hit on GT go down? did cola call it in, or did Little John have to do so? If it's the former, than any analysis of posting proximity to the hit goes out the window. But if it's the latter, then willis becomes my prime suspect, as he was posting around the time of the hit and had been pretty quiet (he's posted, but hasn't exactly been going out on limbs).

It was definitely a mafia call. It said he was beaten to death,as did the other scum kills.

Right although on G_T's death scene it stated that Little John was the one actualy killing him. L.J. probably is the one that does most of the night kills for the scum as I don't think the Godfather would get his hands too dirty in the matter.

[for dummies]

who would the godfather be though? richard the lionheart? actually it didn't say little johns name if i remember correctly, it described him and in the first post afterwards incan yelled at little john for the kill. now based no aimless's description it was obvious that it was little john. but i am suspicious of incan anyway. it seems like a scummy trick, kill him and then be the first to bemoan his death so that you look like you are town.

[moz976]

I am curious to see what willis has to say about his accusations. I am not completely sold on him being mafia yet. willis did vote wrong three times but he was on the cola lynch which helps his case.

But on the other hand wicked seemed upset with how cola was playing the game so mafia could have decided to take the loss and use they lynching on one of their own to look clean afterwards.

I'll save my vote for now but what do you say willis?

[willis]

I am curious to see what willis has to say about his accusations. I am not completely sold on him being mafia yet. willis did vote wrong three times but he was on the cola lynch which helps his case.

But on the other hand wicked seemed upset with how cola was playing the game so mafia could have decided to take the loss and use they lynching on one of their own to look clean afterwards.

I'll save my vote for now but what do you say willis?

On page 141

Yes I was on all 3 lynches, but only because IMO it seemed like they were scummy, and I was wrong. So vote me if you want but it will just be another loss to the town

I voted cola for blatantly submarining in this game, b/c he did the same thing in The departed mafia as mafia.

So like I said before, vote me if you want to, but you will just be killing a simple noble.

[Aegnor]

Bah!!

Well I did last longer than I had thought I would, so I guess I'm somewhat happy after all

Anyway, thanks for the great game Aimless! It's been a real blast.

BTW, I made a post before I died with a list of the players I've tracked. So feel free to take a look there.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

i don't like how fast this wagon on cola has grown. give him some time to defend himself.

Unvote Vote FOS Dummies
While I am still not sure on Willis, I would like to point out that FOS Dummies was protective of Cola when he hadn't defended himself after 24 hours and never did vote for him. FOS has also been in on the bad lynches although he gave an excuse for them a few pages ago.

[XenHu]

Yep I voted on all 3 lynches, with each case on its own I felt the vote was justifiable. What can I say, Mandy was a threat either way with his wild accusations, so I don't think that lynch was unnecessary. For the rest of them, sure I've made some mistakes, but we have to say that Selin's case was rather compelling if you know what I mean. Anyway, I think my contribution to town at this point is crucial since I'm the only one who can provide evidence on other people.
I'll make a list of the people I've investigated so far and what I've come up with:

Night 1 - Exile (confirmed doc) Protected Autoload
Night 2 - Pancake (claimed peasant) No actions taken.
Night 3 - Autoload (claimed peasant) No actions taken.

In case I die tonight just refer to this post for all the evidence that I've gathered thus far.

I'll bring this up front so we don't have to dig for it.

-X

[Selin]

Anybody missing my ballads?......

.

[mandalorian2298]

Anybody missing my ballads?......

.

So sing your song, dead music man.

[for dummies]

i don't like how fast this wagon on cola has grown. give him some time to defend himself.

Unvote Vote FOS Dummies
While I am still not sure on Willis, I would like to point out that FOS Dummies was protective of Cola when he hadn't defended himself after 24 hours and never did vote for him. FOS has also been in on the bad lynches although he gave an excuse for them a few pages ago.

all i was saying was that i don't like to see wagons grow without the accused guy being able to speak. in the rescue mission game that almost cost spin his life on day 1. i never voted for him because when i was about to hammer had already been dropped. and yes i have been on some bad lynches but i already explained about them, if you wish to go back and read my earlier post.

[spinwizard]

i don't like how fast this wagon on cola has grown. give him some time to defend himself.

Unvote Vote FOS Dummies
While I am still not sure on Willis, I would like to point out that FOS Dummies was protective of Cola when he hadn't defended himself after 24 hours and never did vote for him. FOS has also been in on the bad lynches although he gave an excuse for them a few pages ago.

all i was saying was that i don't like to see wagons grow without the accused guy being able to speak. in the rescue mission game that almost cost spin his life on day 1. i never voted for him because when i was about to hammer had already been dropped. and yes i have been on some bad lynches but i already explained about them, if you wish to go back and read my earlier post.

i agree with fd here, i think it was a honest mistake...if i am wrong don't jump on me tho

fos-willis