[Official] Choose Your Own Mafia - TOWN WINS

[Endgame422]

End let the joke vote stage continue for a bit.

I know its a nice icebreaker but its just an excuse for scum to chill for the first half of D1.
I will wait until everyone has been in at least before pushing on anyone in particular.

[Streaker]

We have 1/3 odds of hitting anti town player with lynch today.
Id like 2 claims from who we determine scummiest and we can probably get our chances close to a 50/50 shot.
We need an early scum/SK lynch because 3 anti town NKs will overwhelm us quickly if we make a couple mistakes.
Especially with up to 4/5 kills on N1 we need a good start here.

More NK's means more chance for scum to hit other scum. We aren't as bad off as you make it look. Though there is potential for a destructive bomb this game.
Your generic opening is, well, generic. 'We need to have a couple claims to increase our scum reads'. 'We need a good start or we might lose'. What's your point?

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Unofficial Vote Count

Dakky (1) - Madmitch
Benga (2) - Endgame, WcG
Hotshot (1) - Epitaph
Streaker (1) - Dakky, AoG, Sausage
Sausage (2) - Ptlowe, Mets
Marashu (1) - Sausage
Ptlowe (1) - AoG

No Vote - Streaker
Not commented yet - Tim, Dazza, Virus,

*Note Sausage is voting for the mod.

The reason I wanted the joke phase to continue is see who votes someone high up in the draft list, however End and Streaker have ruined that. Unlike most games we have the knowledge that most likely the stronger roles are near the top of the list. Sausage is draft pick no.8 and the highest draft pick to receive votes.

I agree with Mets that Sausages voting is outright weird with a tendency towards scummy. However, I would say that Ptlowes is even odder. At 2:31 GMT he confirms, and then 50 minutes later votes Sausage for voting Streaker which he wasnt even doing anymore. My gut says hes fabricating a reason, and it also doesnt feel like a true joke vote with both Dakky and AoG voting streaker before him, even more so with AoG votes being sandwiched between Pt's confirm and vote sausage.

Game on.

Unvote Vote Ptlowe

[Endgame422]

My point was to get this past a full page of jokevotes.
Reason being that town doesnt have the oppourtunity to joke around for 25 percent of day one.
Scum might kill each other but odds are much better multiple townies die tonight.
Scum only have a 3/13 chance of hitting the other scum or SK opposed to 10/13 chance of hitting town.
Wing the problem with reading the draft to equal roles is its a double edged sword. The higher drafted players are the more powerful scum as well.

[Epitaph1]

I wouldn't make too much out of these early votes or Endgame's early post, but appreciate those trying to get the ball rolling.

And I can't tell if Mets is serious or not with is vote. Joke voting the mod = scum. Seriously?

[ptlowe]

Unofficial Vote Count

Dakky (1) - Madmitch
Benga (2) - Endgame, WcG
Hotshot (1) - Epitaph
Streaker (1) - Dakky, AoG, Sausage
Sausage (2) - Ptlowe, Mets
Marashu (1) - Sausage
Ptlowe (1) - AoG

No Vote - Streaker
Not commented yet - Tim, Dazza, Virus,

*Note Sausage is voting for the mod.

The reason I wanted the joke phase to continue is see who votes someone high up in the draft list, however End and Streaker have ruined that. Unlike most games we have the knowledge that most likely the stronger roles are near the top of the list. Sausage is draft pick no.8 and the highest draft pick to receive votes.

I agree with Mets that Sausages voting is outright weird with a tendency towards scummy. However, I would say that Ptlowes is even odder. At 2:31 GMT he confirms, and then 50 minutes later votes Sausage for voting Streaker which he wasnt even doing anymore. My gut says hes fabricating a reason, and it also doesnt feel like a true joke vote with both Dakky and AoG voting streaker before him, even more so with AoG votes being sandwiched between Pt's confirm and vote sausage.

Game on.

Unvote Vote Ptlowe

lol, way to much analysis of my actions. unvote streaker vote wingcmdr ginkapo for voting me lol

[ptlowe]

I mean unvote sausage vote wingcmdr

[Army of GOD]

I feel like Endgame is scummy. He's pushing so hard to try to get out of the joke vote stage when he's the only one that sees any danger. I feel like he's scum or an sk trying too hard to act townie

unvote vote endgame

[ptlowe]

Isnt the day stage equal to 10days? Based upon my reading...So we have 9 more days to be serious after today before a vote?

[TimWoodbury]

so home from work now and i say we vote dakky just because hes a bully that made me die in my 1st game but then im not shure maybe vote endgame or pt because they was correct of me in my 2nd game but let me live:) so all in all can i vote dakky endgame and pt in 1 single post?? if not then i make my final joke vote of saying unvote all above vote sausage because he almsot made me die in the last game but saved me

[HotShot53]

Confirmed, seems like I'm late to the party. vote benga since he picked last, probably doesn't have an important role so no need to have him around.

I'm not sure whether I should hope mafia are near the top and so will kill each other, or to hope town is so if they survive they can help a lot. Unlike some choose your own mafia's, we can't use the draft order as any kind of hint, since everyone picked their numbers before the factions were handed out.

[Whatsausage]

Confirmed, seems like I'm late to the party. vote benga since he picked last, probably doesn't have an important role so no need to have him around.

I'm not sure whether I should hope mafia are near the top and so will kill each other, or to hope town is so if they survive they can help a lot. Unlike some choose your own mafia's, we can't use the draft order as any kind of hint, since everyone picked their numbers before the factions were handed out.

First paragraph: surely this is a joke?

Last sentence: statement. fact. so?

I feel like Endgame is scummy. He's pushing so hard to try to get out of the joke vote stage when he's the only one that sees any danger. I feel like he's scum or an sk trying too hard to act townie

unvote vote endgame

I have always been a little fuzzy on what the joke vote stage accomplishes, other than it is a starting point. I suppose it can be used to figure out who is willing to post, but often it comes down to who wants to get past the stage and how they go about it. It does seem a little odd that he talks like there is no time, but I don't fault anyone for trying to find a way past the joke vote stage, especially knowing that it will put them at risk themself.

@tim, not really sure how I almost got you killed, but it worked out no?

@WCG, I think you are reading too much into joke votes, or were at least planning to. I know that I don't put any game thought (Except not piling too much on one person) into who I joke vote for, but I suppose I cannot speak for everyone. It is interesting however that no one above me had a joke vote at that point considering that I am smack in the middle of the order.

Finally, not really sure how joke voting for the mod is any different than joke voting for anyone else.

[Metsfanmax]

I feel like Endgame is scummy. He's pushing so hard to try to get out of the joke vote stage when he's the only one that sees any danger. I feel like he's scum or an sk trying too hard to act townie

unvote vote endgame

At this stage the same could be said for anyone who is pushing Endgame -- the best argument against Endgame is that he's overly paranoid, not overly scummy, and stretching this into a non-town-alignment is itself possibly trying too hard to act townie.

[Army of GOD]

yeah, FOS Mets. trying hard? I'm not the one freaking out and telling everyone to get out of the joke vote stage less than a 10th into the actual day

[Metsfanmax]

yeah, FOS Mets. trying hard? I'm not the one freaking out and telling everyone to get out of the joke vote stage less than a 10th into the actual day

Yes, because immediately drawing attention to yourself right at the beginning of D1 is classic scum play.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

lol, way to much analysis of my actions. unvote streaker vote wingcmdr ginkapo for voting me lol

Can you explain what about my post makes me scum? Omgus much?

[dakky21]

so home from work now and i say we vote dakky just because hes a bully that made me die in my 1st game .........

Don't link the two separate games together.... you didn't die because I hammered you, you died because you were modkilled for posting screenshot of your PM role. And why am I the bully there?

Anyway....

I agree with mets to some extent... endgame is being... just endgame..., last game we played he acted just like he is acting now, so I have no conclusions on his alignment yet.

[Endgame422]

Dakky,
No.
Im not even going there.
AoG theres no danger in the jokevote stage for scum.
The danger to town is that we sit there and not a damn thing happens.
Currently i dont really like HSs first post.

Confirmed, seems like I'm late to the party. vote benga since he picked last, probably doesn't have an important role so no need to have him around.

Benga seems an easy place to drop a vote right now. My vote is still there because id like some posting action out of him,but HS seems to be on trying to get a wagon going before benga even posts by adding on early and "making a case" on benga using the draft order as reasoning then he immediately turns around and says

Unlike some choose your own mafia's, we can't use the draft order as any kind of hint, since everyone picked their numbers before the factions were handed out.

Probably the scummiest opening post of anyone so far.

[madmitch]

@Tim your vote against dakky is unjust, maybe I should against you because you hammered me last game,@ Hotshot just because benga is at the bottom of the list doesn't make him unimportant,I am down there also and my vote still counts,@ endgame why are you trying to get rid of the joke votes so quickly when we have lots of time yet? and mets why are you sticking up for endgame so early? wcg made some good points against him,are you two scum buddies?

[Marashu]

DAILY VOTE COUNT

dakky: madmitch
benga: Endgame, HotShot
Hotshot: Epi
Streaker: dakky
Marashu: deadmeat Whatsausage
Sausage: Mets, Tim
ptlowe: Wing
Wing: ptlowe
Endgame: AoG

Not voting:Streaker, Dazza, virus, Benga

Deadline is 1200CCT, Sept 27. With 15 alive, it takes 8 votes to lynch.

[madmitch]

@Tim, meant to say vote against you.

[TimWoodbury]

@Tim your vote against dakky is unjust, maybe I should against you because you hammered me last game,@ Hotshot just because benga is at the bottom of the list doesn't make him unimportant,I am down there also and my vote still counts,@ endgame why are you trying to get rid of the joke votes so quickly when we have lots of time yet? and mets why are you sticking up for endgame so early? wcg made some good points against him,are you two scum buddies?

so your asking endgame about why he wants to get rid of the joke vote stage yet your saying my own joke vote is a unjust joke vote sounds to me like your doing the same exact thing

[HotShot53]

To those thinking I might have been serious with my vote, I wasn't... it was a pure joke vote. So just to be clear I'll unvote it

[Endgame422]

Dazza,benga,virus are all yet to even confirm.
Weak sauce

[Epitaph1]

I know Dazza's got stuff going on right now, but he should get in here and at least check in.

I'm always a fan of pressuring the quiet ones on D1 but understand sometimes people are plain inactive.

Haven't seen anything that's tripped my scumdar yet. Just the usual struggle between people wanting to joke v. get serious.