[CL5] 1:KORT MVP:josko 2:ID MVP:M Chief 3:AQOH MVP:thelord

[Qwert]

as of 10 september, im no more organiser of CL5, so for any help or questions, you need to contact yours League Directors, and if they can not help you, then i suppose you need to contact CD.

[Leehar]

Keefie will be replacing qwert as CL5 Organiser to see us through to the end of the competition. Bear with us as we work to ensure the competition continues as a great event.

[fishydance]

Keefie will be replacing qwert as CL5 Organiser to see us through to the end of the competition. Bear with us as we work to ensure the competition continues as a great event.

Excellent! He is a good one.

[chemefreak]

Congratulations to [player]thelord[/player] of AQOH for being selected the MVP of the Third League!

[cooldeals]

I posted this in Qwert's thread. Just checked and I think it's the wrong one (since he is no longer responsible for this). Please don't kill me for quoting it here in the relevant thread.

So obviously this will be decided by the Clan and TO Mods who organize this but a little friendly discussion seems fine.

It seems the two most obvious candidates to me for the PL MVP are josko.ri (28/34 82%) and Swifte (42/59 71%)

josko.ri
Total Games played 34
Total Games won 28 - 82%
Home 15/17 (88%)
Away 13/17 (76%)
Total Maps Played 27
Escalating: 6/7 86%
Flat Rate: 0/1 0%
Nuclear: 12/13 92%
No Spoils 10/13 77%
Chained: 12/16 75%
Adjacent 1/2 50%
Unlimited: 15/16 94%

Dubs 4/5 80%
City Mogul W
Dawn of Ages W
Imperium Romanum W
Knights L
Treasures of Galapagos W

Trips 10/12 (83%)
Antartica L
Baltic Crusades L
Chinese Checkers W
Classic Cities: London W
Conquer 4 W
Conquer Man W
Das Schloss W
First Nations Americas W
WWII Australia W
WWII Europe W
Waterloo W
Woodboro W

Quads 14/17 82%
All Your Base Are Belong To Us W
Antartica 2W
Atlantis L
Battle of Acitum W
Classic Cities: Pot Motsbi 2W
Conquer Man: W
First Nations Americas: W
Fractured America: W
Hive L
Pearl Harbor W
Stalingrad W
Supermax: Prison Riot 1W 1L
Waterloo W
World 2.1 W

Swifte
Total Games played 59
Total Games won 42 - 71%
Home 20/30 (67%)
Away 22/29 (76%)
Total Maps Played 52
Escalating: 10/14 71%
Flat Rate: 1/1 100%
Nuclear: 7/11 92%
No Spoils 24/33 73%
Chained: 33/46 72%
Adjacent 7/10 70%
Unlimited: 2/3 67%

Dubs 9/13 69%%
AOR1 L
Austerlitz W
BeNeLux W
Clandemonium W
Conquer 4 W
Eastern Hemisphere W
Europe 1914 W
Macedonia W
South America W
Space L
Three Kingdoms of Korea 1W 1L
Unification Italy L

Trips 17/19 (89%)
Battle of Acitum W
Classic Cities: Sydney W
Cuban Missle Crisis W
Egypt Valley of the Kings W
Eurasia W
Halloween Hallows W
Hive W
Island of Doom W
Lunar War W
Middle Ages W
New Zealand W
Philadelphia L
San Fransisco W
Steamworks W
Tribal War - Florida W
WWII Ardennes W
WWII Europe W
Waterloo L

Quads 16/27 59%
Austerlitz W
Baltic Crusades W
Brazil W
Chinese Checkers W
Cricket 1W 1L
D-Day: Omaha Beach L
Forbidden City W
Fractured America W
Germany W
Hive W
Iberia L
Land and Sea L
Macedonia L
Monsters L
Napoleonic Europe W
Rail Africa W
Rail Asia L
Rail Australia L
Rorke's Drift W
Solar System L
Stalingrad W
Supermax: Prison Riot W
WWII Europe L
WWII Gazala W
World 2.1 1W 1L

josko.ri v Swifte 1-1 (Swifte was on the only team to defeat josko with unlimited reinforcements)

After all that I really don't know who to choose.

Yet there is definitively a disparity in the amount and type of games played. Swifte played almost twice as many maps, played on many away games that were highly luck based, played in more games and somehow pulled 42 wins by far the most of anyone in the premier league.

So I guess it all depends on your definition of Most "Valuable" Player. I wish I had both on my team.

jokso won a whopping 82% of his games including 27% of his clans wins and led his clan to a championship.
Swifte played in 42% of IA's wins, organized all their games and led them to #2 in the league.

josko seems to be the easiest case to defend. His clan won clan league and he has the highest win %. Still I don't think it'd be unreasonable for the CD's and TO's to throw Swifte the award if they consider his value to IA v. josko's value to KORT. I think in that regard if you removed Swifte from this event you would see a more drastic difference (value) v removing josko. Also, Swifte played a lot more luck based maps which in itself is a sacrifice for your team.

Let's see who wins. I'm sure there are other great candidates too, but I can't take any more time for my curiosity. I'm crossing my fingers that these two clans never merge!

[fishydance]

I'm crossing my fingers that these two clans never merge!

[/quote]

You know, that's not a bad idea.....

[chemefreak]

[player]mcshanester29[/player] and the CDs have chosen [player]josko.ri[/player] as the Premiere League MVP! Congrats

[cooldeals]

Congrats josko

[LEQUEEN]

Josko wd as usual

[Keefie]

Well played Josko

[Armandolas]

Congratz to ALL the winners

[chemefreak]

[player]Master Chief[/player] is the MVP of the Second League

And that is all she wrote folks. All medals issued, MVPs awarded, and privs removed. I will let this hang around for a few days then move to complete challenges.

[benga]

[player]Master Chief[/player] is the MVP of the Second League

And that is all she wrote folks. All medals issued, MVPs awarded, and privs removed. I will let this hang around for a few days then move to complete challenges.

I found one with even better win % 2/2=100% Dboeke

[EBConquer]

Congrats guys!

[Caymanmew]

Final Standings

Premier Division
KORT - 33
IA - 31
FALL - 25
LOW - 24
OTP - 21
FOED - 17
MYTH - 16 (better head-to-head)
PIG - 16
TNC - 14
WAR - 12
AFOS - 10

Second Division
ID - 35
OSA - 33
RA - 31
TFFS - 27
OLE - 26
LHDD - 25 (better head-to-head)
MM - 25
TLW - 21
SOH - 15
GR - 13
MB - 11
AOK - 2

Third Division
AQOH - 26
HH - 24
DYN - 23
MB - 21
DB - 20
FISO - 16
UM8 - 15
VDLL - 13
DBC - 12
LOTZ - 10