Game 12102959 SD [CLOSED] KRK

[Reximus]

Norvyn and Eddygp

I suspect that the 2 above are in a secret alliance in the above game. There can to me be no other reason for Norvyn's !st move in this game unless he/she is a complete dingobat and does not understand the basic principles of this game. Please investigate for me. Game 12102959

Thank you Reximus





Accused:

[player]Eddygp[/player]
[player]Norvyn[/player]
[player]xxxxxxx[/player]



The accused are suspected of:

Being Multis
Conducting Secret Diplomacy
Severe PM Abuse
Other: <Explanation>



Game number(s):

[game]xxxxxxx[/game]
[game]xxxxxxx[/game]
[game]xxxxxxx[/game]
[game]xxxxxxx[/game]


Comments:

[Symmetry]

Game 12102959

As Norvyn only has 14 games completed, and has never played on this map before, I can think of several reasons why it might be a bit premature to judge after only a single turn.

I would say hold off on the wall posts, in chat accusations, and C&A posts till you have something more solid.

[clangfield]

I agree - looks like a simple misjudgement/ misdeplyoment to me - thinking one could get to Arabia from Sinai.

[Symmetry]

I agree - looks like a simple misjudgement/ misdeplyoment to me - thinking one could get to Arabia from Sinai.

Aye, or simply a mistake (I've made a few in advancing troops before), or even possibly a legit tactic obliging green, who plays next to do the work. Or perhaps to hold on to a stronghold against yellow- anyone who's played the classic risk map knows how bitter a fight over a territory with a choke point and a bonus can get- it's basically a fight for the map's equivalent of South America.

[Koganosi]

Seems to me this is just a wrong fort. This guy is judging way to fast. Just to judge at your way.

Arent you a multi with Eddygp??? Why didnt you atleast break his bonus??? You have yet completed 6 games and already found you way to the C&A forums?

Second by probably not using the form correctly, mods might not look into this!

Urs

Koganosi

[Reximus]

Just to clear things up folks...
Eddy played first.

Norvyn attacked from sinai with 21 troops against eastern desert(mine) 11 troops. He stopped the failed attack and then attacked israel
(mine) 1 troop, took it and moved in 0 reinforcements, leaving 12 troops on sinai. These troops are trapped to attack only against eastern desert.
He could have gone on to take jordan and Nejd, easily.

Anyway I take the advice of Symmetry.

Reximus

[Koganosi]

Just to clear things up folks...
Eddy played first.

Norvyn attacked from sinai with 21 troops against eastern desert(mine) 11 troops. He stopped the failed attack and then attacked israel
(mine) 1 troop, took it and moved in 0 reinforcements, leaving 12 troops on sinai. These troops are trapped to attack only against eastern desert.
He could have gone on to take jordan and Nejd, easily.

Anyway I take the advice of Symmetry.

Reximus

Still doesnt answer the question why didnt you break him, and probably you 11 just posed a threat to him! And that might be why he atacked you.

Still dont think its secret diplomacy or multies.

Urs

Koganosi

[Reximus]

You think I should have attacked 6 v's 4 to break region when i have 6 defending against 21. My last move was to reinforce western desert with 5 troops from alexandria, making a defence of 11 on western desert. Against such numbers i must make the best defence i can, surely. Anyway understand I am new to this site, the form is incorrectly filled out i know. Never even thought there might be multies involved.

Regards

Reximus

[Karl_R_Kroenen]

perhaps before ANY of your accusations, you can explain this posted on Norvyn's wall->

Why did you not stop eddy from keeping his continent ? Game 12102959 ?

User avatar
by Reximus
on Sat Dec 22, 2012 2:10 pm

[Reximus]

I completely withdraw my accusations, I have made a terrible mistake, I am soo sorry everyone. Eddy is a very Honourable person, he placed his troops from arabia in a different region disallowing his advantage from holding the last round. I will not make this same mistake again. Again my deep apologies.

Reximus.

ps I will refrain from writing on walls in the future, another mistake, was done in anger not for any tactical advantage. Apologies.

[JCR]

can open, worms everywhere!

[eggrollonedolla]

can open, worms everywhere!

grabbing fork!!! Its dinner time!!!

[Karl_R_Kroenen]

I completely withdraw my accusations, I have made a terrible mistake, I am soo sorry everyone. Eddy is a very Honourable person, he placed his troops from arabia in a different region disallowing his advantage from holding the last round. I will not make this same mistake again. Again my deep apologies.

Reximus.

ps I will refrain from writing on walls in the future, another mistake, was done in anger not for any tactical advantage. Apologies.

As per the OP's request = CLOSED and WITHDRAWN