Legioner and Landor / The Math and[CLEARED]es

[thorval]

Accused:

[player]legioner[/player]
[player]landor[/player]
[player]The Math[/player]
[player]chrisabbott79[/player]


The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy
Other: Throwing the game


Game number(s):

Game 12004268


Comments:I am suspisous of the Conduct in this game because its only been 11 rounds and team three is dominating the board. So I looked into it and I noticed that team 2 NEVER attacks team 3. Despite Team three dominating the board so quickly, Team 2 continues to attack Team 1 exclusivly. There is one instance of team 2 attacking team 3, to be honest. It is near the begining of the game, but never again. This is not impossible, but Legioner is such a high ranked player that this outcome is almost unbelievable. Their walls are also suspisiously empty of any coments. All four of them have not one coment on their walls.

[Gillipig]

I don't see any inclination of secret diplomacy here. The game in question is just one game and it could easily be that team two just wanted the areas you were after so you ended up fighting each other. It doesn't help your cause that it's a fog game either. And a lot of people empty their walls, no indication of anything.

[thorval]

So in your world, its perfectly normal to attack just one team for an entire map. And for a high ranking player with a 46% win rate to ignore strategy and simply suicide all game. And we did not compete for the same areas, they just attacked us around the world where ever we were, again, exclusively attacking team 1. Blue and yellow did not put up much fight when I took control of south america. I hope the mods can see the game through the fog and what not or do they not have that ability? I Have no idea what hunters can do.

[Frox333]

ok thorval, there is one thing. they live in 3 different countries, so they dont know eachother, and there seems to be no secret communications...so why would you file this??? eh, the complaints people have these days -_-

[thorval]

Because apparently I am the only one who finds the conduct in that game suspicious Seriously, how am I the only one looking at zero attacks against one team and -suicidal- attacks against another and coming to this conclusion? And all happening in 11 turns. No don't mention fog, because it lists every single one of their moves in the game chat list.

They never had to kill team three to get a bonus in a country? Never held them back? Team 3 certainly didn't seem to have trouble cutting through them from behind.

[legioner]

We where fighting in the NA and Europa in the end and the only active opposition that broke us was team one. We had no regions of our own cos you attacked uss and we attacked back. We are not supposed to defend our self and try to get a region?

I actually tried tailand in the beginning but the dices utterly destroyed me and i had to retreat and we thought that me in Europa and he in USA could lock borders and be back in the game... Just watch when the game ends and the fog lifts who had usa and how much they attacked us.

This was a bad game we saw it from the start but hell no i throw a game. I dont get my rank by giving upp. I have won games that should have been impossible cos of some mistakes on their part or awesome dices. Maybe we did some bad judgments in this one but i still think we did the best strategically judgment we could with the deployments we had.

[Gillipig]

So in your world, its perfectly normal to attack just one team for an entire map. And for a high ranking player with a 46% win rate to ignore strategy and simply suicide all game. And we did not compete for the same areas, they just attacked us around the world where ever we were, again, exclusively attacking team 1. Blue and yellow did not put up much fight when I took control of south america. I hope the mods can see the game through the fog and what not or do they not have that ability? I Have no idea what hunters can do.

In my world it's perfectly normal that two teams end up wanting the same areas and in the proccess end up giving the game to the third team. When there's three teams on the board this happens quite often actually.

[Symmetry]

So in your world, its perfectly normal to attack just one team for an entire map. And for a high ranking player with a 46% win rate to ignore strategy and simply suicide all game. And we did not compete for the same areas, they just attacked us around the world where ever we were, again, exclusively attacking team 1. Blue and yellow did not put up much fight when I took control of south america. I hope the mods can see the game through the fog and what not or do they not have that ability? I Have no idea what hunters can do.

In my world it's perfectly normal that two teams end up wanting the same areas and in the proccess end up giving the game to the third team. When there's three teams on the board this happens quite often actually.

True, but this part of the game log indicates that they were busted for something:

2012-12-21 01:12:42 - landor was kicked out for violating the rules
2012-12-21 01:12:42 - legioner was kicked out for violating the rules

[Gillipig]

So in your world, its perfectly normal to attack just one team for an entire map. And for a high ranking player with a 46% win rate to ignore strategy and simply suicide all game. And we did not compete for the same areas, they just attacked us around the world where ever we were, again, exclusively attacking team 1. Blue and yellow did not put up much fight when I took control of south america. I hope the mods can see the game through the fog and what not or do they not have that ability? I Have no idea what hunters can do.

In my world it's perfectly normal that two teams end up wanting the same areas and in the proccess end up giving the game to the third team. When there's three teams on the board this happens quite often actually.

True, but this part of the game log indicates that they were busted for something:

2012-12-21 01:12:42 - landor was kicked out for violating the rules
2012-12-21 01:12:42 - legioner was kicked out for violating the rules

Honestly I didn't see that. Will be interesting to see what the hunters find.

[Evil Semp]

[quote="Symmetry"
True, but this part of the game log indicates that they were busted for something:

2012-12-21 01:12:42 - landor was kicked out for violating the rules
2012-12-21 01:12:42 - legioner was kicked out for violating the rules

[/quote]

landor and legioner were for being multi's.

Still looking at the secret diplomacy.

[Little Witt]

True, but this part of the game log indicates that they were busted for something:

2012-12-21 01:12:42 - landor was kicked out for violating the rules
2012-12-21 01:12:42 - legioner was kicked out for violating the rules

landor and legioner were for being multi's.

Still looking at the secret diplomacy.

FIX

[therev1957]

nice smiley face sign EVIL SEMP! Can you make me one

[Evil Semp]

Sorry for taking so long. I had internet problems for a few days.

It looks to me that you might have been in the wrong place as far as team 3 is concerned. They wanted the areas you were in but also in the middle of the game you were pretty strong and team 3 ignored the weaker team. Yes it is strange that most of the attacks were against you but not unheard of. Also sometimes in team games one team looks at the locations of the opposing teams [that they can see] and target them. I am going to mark this CLEARED.

[thorval]

Ah well, :/ It looked odd. But you found some multi's, so thats good!