MLP: Friendship is MAFIA! ENDGAME: DISCORD & PINKIE WIN!

[Haggis_McMutton]

I killed soundman N1.

I was actually third party killer when starting the game and could have been recruited by either cult or town. I suspect Victor is the one that could have recruited me for town.

[pmchugh]

Actually the CMC had no kill.

Pinkie Pie (Haggis) and Angel Bunny (PMC) had the kills.

Discord had three collective day/night actions and could only use them three times per day/night cycle. So he could wipe away votes on him but that meant he couldn't do something else, and eventually if you BWed him enough he'd run out of vote wiping abilities.

I laughed when PMC asked for power to vote multiple ponies, because I gave it to him just for fun, and dazza thought PMC was a DV and had his votes wiped.

Yeah IDK why you guys let dazza live. Mason recruiter is not a very common role. Then again it is Fircoal, so you guys really didn't know what to expect.

-SG7 ( )

Yeah it was a bit of a silly decision, although I was kinda hoping I would get recruited by someone. It would have been far easier than winning as SK.

[dazza2008]

Actually the CMC had no kill.

Pinkie Pie (Haggis) and Angel Bunny (PMC) had the kills.

Discord had three collective day/night actions and could only use them three times per day/night cycle. So he could wipe away votes on him but that meant he couldn't do something else, and eventually if you BWed him enough he'd run out of vote wiping abilities.

I laughed when PMC asked for power to vote multiple ponies, because I gave it to him just for fun, and dazza thought PMC was a DV and had his votes wiped.

Yeah IDK why you guys let dazza live. Mason recruiter is not a very common role. Then again it is Fircoal, so you guys really didn't know what to expect.

-SG7 ( )

Yeah it was a bit of a silly decision, although I was kinda hoping I would get recruited by someone. It would have been far easier than winning as SK.

I tried to recruit you night 1 but got roleclocked.

[pmchugh]

Dam roleblockers

[sheepofdumb]

CMC was kind of a scum faction but again, we had no kills. So our goal was more akin to a survivor role where I could keep my team safe (if they didn't die before I could get the tree fort built) and we overpower the rest of the players late game. Unfortunately the fun was entirely sucked out by both of them dying and then made hopeless by angel dying.

CMC was an interesting faction in that with no kill but being scum we would have to change strategies and sides a few times. Come mid-late game when the cop could come out we'd have to stop picking people off at random and go scum hunting. Late game we could go back and dogpile on the town. At least in theory. I would have enjoyed this game if people got luckier. The cop was useless and my faction got blown out of the water. I'd be willing to play this setup again as a CMC. I want to see what we can do.

[shieldgenerator7]

If we did this setup again, I'd make fircoal communicate more. But yeah IDK how it would work w/ same setup, people would easily suspect you of being CMC again if we did this.haha

If I ran another MLP game (with different setup)would you join it if you had the chance to be one of the CMC or for the chance to be part of a no-kill scum faction of 3?

[nagerous]

CMC was kind of a scum faction but again, we had no kills. So our goal was more akin to a survivor role where I could keep my team safe (if they didn't die before I could get the tree fort built) and we overpower the rest of the players late game. Unfortunately the fun was entirely sucked out by both of them dying and then made hopeless by angel dying.

CMC was an interesting faction in that with no kill but being scum we would have to change strategies and sides a few times. Come mid-late game when the cop could come out we'd have to stop picking people off at random and go scum hunting. Late game we could go back and dogpile on the town. At least in theory. I would have enjoyed this game if people got luckier. The cop was useless and my faction got blown out of the water. I'd be willing to play this setup again as a CMC. I want to see what we can do.

Yeah my night actions were infuriating.

[TheForgivenOne]

My win condition was a toughy. But I enjoyed the game (minus all the confusion). I'm still curious what VS's role was all about.

[pmchugh]

I really dislike third party roles, I know I should just play them like town but I just don't have the same motivation. Especially given that there are no conventional mafia to find either.

[/]

Hey, didn't I win too? Fircoal said my win conditions were completely separate, and rarity was kidnapped.

[shieldgenerator7]

Hey, didn't I win too? Fircoal said my win conditions were completely separate, and rarity was kidnapped.

good catch. I'll post your "win" scene soon.

(sorry for the exclusion, co-modding this w/o Fircoal was almost like going through the pokecave without FLASH (which I succesfully did ))

-SG7 ( )

[shieldgenerator7]

The storm of cotton candy clouds raged on as Discord laughed whole-heartedly.

"Ditzy! We have to hurry! Now!" Dr. Whooves yelled at his assisstant as the Tardis got covered with chocolate rain.

Ditzy Doo flew into the Tardis and Dr. Whooves trotted quickly in behind her. He shut the door and started it up.

"Thanks again for breaking me out of pony prison," Ditzy said as she tried to dry off from the rain.

"No problem. I need you, Ditzy." Dr. Whooves said as he flipped switches and pressed buttons.

They went back in time to before Discord ruled, back to D3.

"Now Ditzy, you know what to do?"

"Yes, I do." Ditzy said, confirming.

"Good luck," said Dr. Whooves.

Ditzy flew over to the town gathering.

"And that isn't all!" Rainbow said. "Rarity's gone too!"
"This is just getting worse and worse," Twilight said. "I don't know how much more of this I can withstand."
"I don't know either," Applejack replied. "We need to get done with this, and fast."

Town split up to look for clues at this point, and Applejack remembered something about Rarity's shop. "That's right! Rarity is gone now so I don't have anymore competition! Muahaha!" She strode over to the Carousel Boutique and moved all the colorful dresses over to her barn, where she sold them for a profit. The money she made on top of the usual apple harvest thing brought her enough profits to fix the barn's roof, give Granny Smith a new hip replacement, and replace Big Mac's saggy old plow. Applejack felt mighty happy she could do this for her family.

Oh, and she also adopted Sweetie Belle, too. No sense in letting that little critter live all by her lonesome in that lonely building.

show

But the next day, Applebloom woke up and couldn't find her sister anywhere.

show

Then in the future when everypony gets freed from Angel Bunny's dungeon she comes back but can't do much before Discord takes over

-SG7 ( )

[/]

Better than nothing.
Four scum groups? With 6 initial scummies and growing numbers? Wow! We didn't even have enough potential lynches for that.

My win condition was a toughy. But I enjoyed the game (minus all the confusion). I'm still curious what VS's role was all about.

What was your WC anyhow?

I'm going to abstain on MVP, I don't really know what to say, CMC was screwed on N1, but sheep kept it together alone for a while, half of town didn't understand their roles, dazza was OP as heck, but otherwise played it off decently, Haggis was convincing in keeping dazza alive, PMC seemed very townish up to his claim. I think I did my part, I blocked the cult night one, tried to block the SK Night 2, and kept the scumhunt on for the days I was alive.

[pmchugh]

Yeah my claim was pish, I thought it made sense at the time because my character was both a princess and was responsible for rising the sun + fircoal has a love of them. You guys saw right through it though

I would give MVP to haggis if forced to give to someone.

[sheepofdumb]

Applebloom:
You are Applebloom, the untechical leader of the CMC. mlp.wikia.com/wiki/Apple_bloom
You and Applebloom are tired of being pushed about by your big sisters and figured with this chaos it'd be the perfect time to try to gain authority. Although you can't kidnap you are able to construct a house to hide out in. It'll take a night to create but after that night, the next two nights you'll be able to hide safely and avoid any actions to you. You choose when to start construction.
Your CMC team is Soundman, MeFeDe, and SheepOfDumb
You win when the CMC outnumber the rest of town.

You can not kidnap other players.

However you and Sheep can both use your nighttime powers.

You are 3rd Party.

[TheForgivenOne]

I had to have the game end by Night 3, that way I could audition for the Wonderbolts.

[Haggis_McMutton]

I'll go with PMC for MVP. I thought you played quite well.

Stuff might have actually gotten kind of sticky for me and dazza if we hadn't lynched you last day.

[DoomYoshi]

Vote sheep for MVP

[soundman]

My role PM didn't even include my name. All it said was I was a 'chicken' (which I thought was my name), allied with Sheep and MeDeFe, and we win when we outnumber town. I had no idea who we were or what we could do until I was dead. Communication with Fircoal was also pretty bad. I will unfortunately not be joining any other games hosted by Fircoal. Sorry.

[shieldgenerator7]

My role PM didn't even include my name. All it said was I was a 'chicken' (which I thought was my name), allied with Sheep and MeDeFe, and we win when we outnumber town. I had no idea who we were or what we could do until I was dead. Communication with Fircoal was also pretty bad. I will unfortunately not be joining any other games hosted by Fircoal. Sorry.

Yeah I agree that inside joke did not make a very communicative role PM

[MeDeFe]

Ah yes, the thing with the chicken. I didn't want to post it before while the game was ongoing. But here's the reason for it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bu54kU0ebqE

So, Scootalo = chicken

[Fircoal]

Ah yes, the thing with the chicken. I didn't want to post it before while the game was ongoing. But here's the reason for it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bu54kU0ebqE

So, Scootalo = chicken

Finally someone got it. x3

Also good game everyone.

[Fircoal]

BTW about Dazza. His role wasn't a cult recruiter. He had a recruit but it was made so that it'd fail 100% unless it targeted Pinkie Pie. So DAzza got lucky in that he targeted the one person he needed to target. That also would have failed if Pinkie Pie had been cured by Fluttershy (which is what the healer was btw).

[Fircoal]

My role PM didn't even include my name. All it said was I was a 'chicken' (which I thought was my name), allied with Sheep and MeDeFe, and we win when we outnumber town. I had no idea who we were or what we could do until I was dead.

There are only three cutie mark crusaders. Just looking at the wiki should tell you this. I believe I told you, you were in the CMC. EVen hearing your group members names should have done it. I mean to be honest I thought that was going to be way easier than it seemed to be. There are 3 CMC, and we have 2 by name, so the other is probably the last one. And I figured at least one person would get the joke.

[TheForgivenOne]

My role PM didn't even include my name. All it said was I was a 'chicken' (which I thought was my name), allied with Sheep and MeDeFe, and we win when we outnumber town. I had no idea who we were or what we could do until I was dead.

There are only three cutie mark crusaders. Just looking at the wiki should tell you this. I believe I told you, you were in the CMC. EVen hearing your group members names should have done it. I mean to be honest I thought that was going to be way easier than it seemed to be. There are 3 CMC, and we have 2 by name, so the other is probably the last one. And I figured at least one person would get the joke.

You have to remember Fircoal Most of us are dumb.