[GP] Surrender/Resign/Forfeit Button

[babagonosh]

How can it be abused?

example please

[blakebowling]

How can it be abused?

example please

people with multiple accounts, or point dumpers, can easily give points from one account to another.

[mr. white123]

I don't want to interupt the conversation but I want to support Babagonosh in this. When so many people ask for it, why not implentate it? How could people abuse it when being absent is the same as giving up, abuse could be noticed in the same way as they use multiply accountants and give points from one account to another, it's the same. The moderators should have a script where they can see how many times accountants give up in combination with another account.

[blakebowling]

I don't want to interupt the conversation but I want to support Babagonosh in this. When so many people ask for it, why not implentate it? How could people abuse it when being absent is the same as giving up, abuse could be noticed in the same way as they use multiply accountants and give points from one account to another, it's the same. The moderators should have a script where they can see how many times accountants give up in combination with another account.

it was implemented, and it was removed, due to abuse

[mr. white123]

There is abuse in the whole game so why don't u remove the whole game?

[40kguy]

I don't want to interupt the conversation but I want to support Babagonosh in this. When so many people ask for it, why not implentate it? How could people abuse it when being absent is the same as giving up, abuse could be noticed in the same way as they use multiply accountants and give points from one account to another, it's the same. The moderators should have a script where they can see how many times accountants give up in combination with another account.

it was implemented, and it was removed, due to abuse

Mr.whight has a point. if people wanted to point dump they just create a bunch of speed games then dont play. its the same as giving up.

[Dysthymia]

What is the reason for rejecting this? If the person accepts the loss for surrendering, of course.

[greenoaks]

What is the reason for rejecting this? If the person accepts the loss for surrendering, of course.

point dumping

[SirSebstar]

abuse

[nemezis]

Concise description:

• It should be good, in my opinion, that there is an option in two-player games that could make resigning possible. It happens sometimes that it is apparent that the game is lost for one player even few rounds or more before the end. Playing it without possibility of resigning is a bore for both players. I appreciate the battle heart and faith in tactics and luck, but sometimes you can plainly see that noting can bee done. Good commanders know when battle is lost.

Specifics/Details:

• resign option should be introduced only in two-player games in order not to affect other players in their strategies. If the player submit resign note, the game is ended, he lose and the opponent wins. (maybe it can be even marked in the past games with some sign that the game is lost/won by resignation, but it's not necessary.)

How this will benefit the site and/or other comments:

• I think that this option will speed up some games and avoid long and boring endings

[Evil Semp]

What is to stop someone from resigning without even taking a turn?

[basic_man2010_20]

make the option only avilable after X rounds have been compleated or somethign

[rdsrds2120]

This has been rejected OVERANDOVERANDOVER again. There will never be a forfeit/resign button here, sorry, chap.

-rd

[Frogmanx82]

Concise description:

• There should be a concede button that would allow you to surrender your armies.

Specifics/Details:

• Instead of just missing your turns or having a game drag on you should have a surrender option. A simple concede armies button would be nice.

How this will benefit the site and/or other comments:

• It would keep games from dragging on at the end when the end is obvious or if someone just doesn't want to play, they could surrender instead of hanging up the game for 24 hours 3 times.

[TheForgivenOne]

No, this has been suggested many times and has been rejected each and everytime. This site used to have one, and it was abused too easily. Made it easier to rank up with a multi, makes it easier to point dump, and makes games unenjoyable.

Merged

[Frogmanx82]

Oh that's right, I forgot we're dealing with people. It didn't come up on the search, but I was sure this must have been suggested before.

[ender516]

I don't know how you missed it in the search. I just did an Advanced Search for "concede" in Suggestions and all its subforums and it was right there on the first page of results.

[Frogmanx82]

I must not have specified the suggestions forum.

[rogower]

Consider adding a "Quit Game" and a "Skip Turn" option. I know that we do not want to encourage folks to quit games. However, it's inevitable, people do it, and the ones who suffer the most are the ones who have to sit there and wait for the five minutes (in speed games) or the 24 hours (in regular games) to expire.

In order to encourage quitters to actually hit "Quit Game" rather than to simply drop out and force the remaining players to wait until time has expired on the quitter, the quitter would lose x number of points if s/he exercises the "Quit Game" option and y number of points if s/he quits without exercising the "Quit Game" option. x < y; therefore, the quitter loses points, either way, but loses fewer points by doing the remaining players a favor by clicking on "Quit Game."

Also: One would not be allowed to click on "Quit Game" until a certain amount of time has passed. This would prevent folks from quitting out of frustration and would give them some time to cool off.

As for the "Skip Turn" option: Some players seem to think it's good strategy to skip a turn in certain situations. It's irritating to sit there and wait for the time to elapse when the player has no intention of actually making a play that round.

Just a couple of ideas to make games go more efficiently.

[tennischamp5]

So what would prevent me from joining 8 player terminator games, killing off two guys, and then hitting 'quit' every time so I lose less points and end up with a net gain?

[TheForgivenOne]

Consider adding a "Quit Game" and a "Skip Turn" option. I know that we do not want to encourage folks to quit games. However, it's inevitable, people do it, and the ones who suffer the most are the ones who have to sit there and wait for the five minutes (in speed games) or the 24 hours (in regular games) to expire.

In order to encourage quitters to actually hit "Quit Game" rather than to simply drop out and force the remaining players to wait until time has expired on the quitter, the quitter would lose x number of points if s/he exercises the "Quit Game" option and y number of points if s/he quits without exercising the "Quit Game" option. x < y; therefore, the quitter loses points, either way, but loses fewer points by doing the remaining players a favor by clicking on "Quit Game."

Also: One would not be allowed to click on "Quit Game" until a certain amount of time has passed. This would prevent folks from quitting out of frustration and would give them some time to cool off.

As for the "Skip Turn" option: Some players seem to think it's good strategy to skip a turn in certain situations. It's irritating to sit there and wait for the time to elapse when the player has no intention of actually making a play that round.

Just a couple of ideas to make games go more efficiently.

First off, surrender/forfeit/quit button was here, and is gone forever. It won't be coming back. The webmaster has made this very clear.

And actually, people "skip" turns very rarely. When people DO miss a turn, it is because they actually didn't have time to take the turn.

[vannus]

First off, surrender/forfeit/quit button was here, and is gone forever. It won't be coming back. The webmaster has made this very clear.

Is there a thread or post for this? I'd like to argue for the 'Surrender' button. I've goofed the start of a game, and so I'm helping one player to win, cause its the fastest way to get out of the game.

PS I'm not playing for points, I'm just playing for fun.

[TheForgivenOne]

First off, surrender/forfeit/quit button was here, and is gone forever. It won't be coming back. The webmaster has made this very clear.

Is there a thread or post for this? I'd like to argue for the 'Surrender' button. I've goofed the start of a game, and so I'm helping one player to win, cause its the fastest way to get out of the game.

PS I'm not playing for points, I'm just playing for fun.

There is a page in Rejected with over a 1000 posts in it. The button was abused way too much.

[vannus]

Found it!
viewtopic.php?f=471&t=67152&hilit=quit+game

I shall now go read it - 1342 posts :S

[vannus]

ok. the 'surrender works the same as missed turns (but without having to wait 24hours)' suggestion has already been dismissed.

shame, its a simple solution that doesn't skew points or take much programming.

I guess we'll just have to put up with deadbeats at CC