am i a rat.

[NanoSpores]

for posting this

From: youngbuck876
To: NanoSpores
Posted: 24 Mar 2007 02:14
Subject: 305570
yo the only way to even game 305570 out is to try to mkae our way west these couple of turns or next turn cause if red has a set here it might be over cause i tried to take blue and was 1 army short. So unless you have a set also and are planning to just run through me we have to stop him

[NanoSpores]

maybe, but he's just a noob, and probably hasnt read the rules

[Wisse]

and he should be banned for that

[chessplaya]

nope ur not a rat nano
and nope he shoudlnt be banned for acting noobish , he has to be warned and told that this Pm he sent u should be written in game chat....

[AAFitz]

and, some will say its ok to do this as long is it is posted after a decision is made...

personally Im careful with the alliances I make in a game to make sure they are fair, and would never discuss the terms in pm, but it isnt specifically illegal...as long as it is posted after an alliance is made

not to say its a sporting way to play...its just technically not illegal...unless of course it says, lets nail him and not tell him

[Wisse]

and, some will say its ok to do this as long is it is posted after a decision is made...

personally Im careful with the alliances I make in a game to make sure they are fair, and would never discuss the terms in pm, but it isnt specifically illegal...as long as it is posted after an alliance is made

not to say its a sporting way to play...its just technically not illegal...unless of course it says, lets nail him and not tell him

its illigal, the other people need to know everything about the alliance

[b.k. barunt]

Fitz is right - ignore wisse, she talks a lot about things she knows nothing about. I checked it out when someone approached me by PM. According to the rules, all alliances have to be declared in the game chat, but you can discuss strategy by PM. Like Fitz said, it's legal, but it's cheesy. And yea, that was ratty of you to post on him like that - he might not have known any better, and you could have just schooled him after checking it out for yourself.

[AAFitz]

and, some will say its ok to do this as long is it is posted after a decision is made...

personally Im careful with the alliances I make in a game to make sure they are fair, and would never discuss the terms in pm, but it isnt specifically illegal...as long as it is posted after an alliance is made

not to say its a sporting way to play...its just technically not illegal...unless of course it says, lets nail him and not tell him

its illigal, the other people need to know everything about the alliance

yes wise you are right...and believe me, im not advocating it here...just explaining it...technically you can discuss it in the pm...so far that is not illegal...however...if the details are not posted in the chat, that is illegal, because the other players cant act accordingly....

now if its not clear, I think all discussion of game should be in chat...but i do understand why someone would simply ask for it in the pm.....id love to see a rule that says all talk of all singles must be made in the game chat...Id be all for it...And I do suggest all players voluntarily play by this as a code of ethics, and I know the players that care do, however...the players that dont care arent going to, and thats just how it is...and unless the rule it written, it isnt expressly illegal...

In any game, if two people decide to kill you....you are probably going to die...thats just how it is...alliance or not

[NanoSpores]

Fitz is right - ignore wisse, she talks a lot about things she knows nothing about. I checked it out when someone approached me by PM. According to the rules, all alliances have to be declared in the game chat, but you can discuss strategy by PM. Like Fitz said, it's legal, but it's cheesy. And yea, that was ratty of you to post on him like that - he might not have known any better, and you could have just schooled him after checking it out for yourself.

you have a pattern of rebel worship. you also sweat take2out for being a nuisance. (you probably never use the livechat) And isn't discussing strategy in pm's a form of allying? saying it's cheesy just says it's below you personally, but not wrong. i'm saying it's always shady. anyway, i don't expect him to get busted for it.