Nashville Mafia Wars Mafia Night 3_Terror Subsides

[Victor Sullivan]

You're not gonna like this for a number of reasons, oldrisky:

unvote vote oldrisky

I find your argument against Fircoal and duday a bit of a stretch, and it seems like a decent enough scumtell for me to vote for you, though ircoal didn't. I don't like the way you've been leading the lynch charge. I'd like to see a role claim, myself.

[duday53]

duday non-post again. ????? Come on I just listed your activity as non-posting and you non-post.

I don't care how "busy" you are you could at least make a real post.

unvote...vote duday

Sorry for non-posting, however its hard to get back into a game after being so out of it. I barely remember what my role is in this game.

I won't OMGUS vote you... But calm down man, I can assure you that I am town. FOS oldrisky

[AceArtemis]

I pushed for a no lynch when we had got rid of one scum, I was honestly not expecting us to hit another yesterday.

In mafia, usually the value of the information gained by lynching outweighs the value of the townie you can potentially save by not lynching. This is why I will almost always oppose a no lynch.

Victor really does switch votes a lot...I don't know what to make of that. He could be legitimately trying to catch scum, but it looks like he's just throwing accusations around until one sticks, sending the suspicion off himself. Victor's cop claim doesn't necessarily clear him since a mafia cop is completely reasonable for this type of game, especially considering colton put some underwhelming town roles in this game.

oldrisky does seem a little suspicious though, since shifting the attention to people who we would be better off replacing is a common scum tactic. This could be an actual scumtell, or this could be due to inexperience, I'm not sure.

Usually the mafia isn't the person barely posting at all due to RL issues; usually the mafia is the person who posts often to look like they are town, but doesn't actually add anything to the discussion; they post a lot of obvious and redundant information.

For example, this is obvious and redundant information:

The good news....

There was only one killing overnight. Perhaps there are 2 mob members per faction and we were able to eliminate one entire family - The Claw!

Although lala's parting words make me suspect there may be one more Claw family member out there and perhaps he decided to not kill in order to protect his existence.

I'm going to FoS here, but I will keep my vote on Victor for now because I'm still suspicious of him and I don't want to let him off the hook just yet.

Duday, you can't hide behind the RL excuse forever; you need to add something to the discussion...who do you find the most suspicious, and why?

[aage]

Well, you people just keep FoS'ing, but that's not gonna scare a role outta him...
vote olderisky

You know why.

[oldrisky44]

Ok maybe I am getting a little pushy, but the three of them, duday, fircoal, and victor have been suspicious to me the entire game, check the posts. And victor's cop claim is unproven. How could he prove it? There are no surprises here.

I said I would not claim the noob excuse any more, but ace just said my postings show either noob logic OR scum. I am a noob, but not scum, and have said that from the start.

As far as my claim, what do you want me to say, I am town, can't prove it, I have a weak night power (don't we all?).

I think if you read my postings, you will see consistent fosing of the three named above, who all now seem to be working together against me in broad daylight.

What else can I say?

String me up and lose a townie or review the postings and come to your own conclusion.

[colton24]

Vote Count
oldrisky44(2)L-3-Victor Sullivan, aage
AceArtemis(1)-???
duday53(1)-oldrisky44

Not Voting: cena-rules, AceArtemis, spiesr, freezie, duday53, Fircoal

With 9 alive it take 5 to lynch

[colton24]

Announcement
Two more rules
I reserve the right to change and/or make a new rule at any time
If you fake breaking a serious rule (Such as quoting your role pm, but it is one you made up, or putting EDIT: in your post even though you didn't edit it, etc. IS punishable by, immediate modkill, -------->or the funniest PR I can think of<--------Best option

[AceArtemis]

Vote Count
oldrisky44(2)L-3-Victor Sullivan, aage
AceArtemis(1)-???
duday53(1)-oldrisky44

Not Voting: cena-rules, AceArtemis, spiesr, freezie, duday53, Fircoal

With 9 alive it take 5 to lynch

I believe my vote is on Victor right now.

[aage]

I said I would not claim the noob excuse any more, but ace just said my postings show either noob logic OR scum. I am a noob, but not scum, and have said that from the start.

I'm considering the option where you are both scum and noob. I don't like how you're claiming you can't be scum solely because you're a noob. It sounds even more scum to me than the vote on Duday.

String me up and lose a townie or review the postings and come to your own conclusion.

I think we all did come to our own conclusions... Which lead to some people Fos'ing and some people voting for you.

[oldrisky44]

Colton gave me permission to claim as long as I don't quote his PM.

But again, I can say who I am and you will either believe me or not.

I am a bus driver. Town. Now you will either lynch me or the scum will shoot me.

[oldrisky44]

I said I would not claim the noob excuse any more, but ace just said my postings show either noob logic OR scum. I am a noob, but not scum, and have said that from the start.

I'm considering the option where you are both scum and noob. I don't like how you're claiming you can't be scum solely because you're a noob. It sounds even more scum to me than the vote on Duday.

I am not "claiming you can't be scum solely because you're a noob". I am simply stating the fact that I have made the same claim from the start. It is certainly possible that I am both (based on random role appointment), but I am not both. See my claim above.

[cena-rules]

Colton gave me permission to claim as long as I don't quote his PM.

But again, I can say who I am and you will either believe me or not.

I am a bus driver. Town. Now you will either lynch me or the scum will shoot me.

Did you do anything last night?

[oldrisky44]

I used my power, but I don't know what effect it had.

[cena-rules]

I used my power, but I don't know what effect it had.

Does it not state in your role what your power is?

[aage]

I suppose he means he doesn't know what actions were busdriven.

Tell us what players you targeted.

[duday53]

Duday, you can't hide behind the RL excuse forever; you need to add something to the discussion...who do you find the most suspicious, and why?

Yeah, sorry. Um, I already said my part about oldrisky. However Victor's claim is also a little unstable. There could be mafia cops. But I do think it is more likely that the town, which is pretty much the police and witnesses, would have their fair share of cops and other power roles.

Anyways, I think the best option right now is oldrisky. Yes, you may be new and your claim is plausible.. and that is why I won't vote yet. If another scumtell comes up, then I'm afraid you will have my vote.

[oldrisky44]

Man you guys are brutal. I can switch 2 players night effects. Last night was cena and victor. I don't know the results of my switcheroo. Do you?

[cena-rules]

Well, if anyone targeted me, their action went to Victor, and vice versa

[oldrisky44]

Correct, I though that if victor was a cop he might be targeted for something and I would deflect that action to cena.

[aage]

I can't confirm that but I'd like to know who can. i don't need your role, I just want to know if your target changed.

[Victor Sullivan]

Hmm... Strange. It just doesn't add up... So someone must have tried to roleblock cena last night, in turn roleblocking me? Why would someone do that? You didn't make a claim D1, did you, cena?

[Victor Sullivan]

Hmm... Strange. It just doesn't add up... So someone must have tried to roleblock cena last night, in turn roleblocking me? Why would someone do that? You didn't make a claim D1, did you, cena?

Of course, assuming oldrisky's telling the truth...

[aage]

I can't see why Cena would get roleblocked. But then, I cant see why anyone should get roleblocked, so thats no argument...

[oldrisky44]

Remember though, I was not trying to block cena, but protect victor.

[cena-rules]

Didn't claim Day 1, must just be a random choice for block