Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon and Contest!

[Doc_Brown]

At which point will this suggestion be considered "Rejected"? The poll which showed that there was only about even support for even changing the icon at all has now been trashed...is there a point to continuing with this suggestion?

I doubt anything will happen either way with this anytime soon simply because there is no consensus. The polls have shown roughly 50% in favor of changing the symbol and 50% wanting to keep the question mark. I think one of the discussion moderators noted that he'd like to see either overwhelming support (in which case it would likely move quickly towards becoming a submitted suggestion) or overwhelming opposition (in which case it would be summarily rejected). As it stands, I think it's going to sit here until QH can move the support level one way or the other.

[00iCon]

Where's the option for "don't change anything about it, leave it a question mark"???
That's what I vote for. You can't have an honest vote without allowing for opposing views.

You'd lost.
now don't vote.

[Woodruff]

At which point will this suggestion be considered "Rejected"? The poll which showed that there was only about even support for even changing the icon at all has now been trashed...is there a point to continuing with this suggestion?

I doubt anything will happen either way with this anytime soon simply because there is no consensus. The polls have shown roughly 50% in favor of changing the symbol and 50% wanting to keep the question mark. I think one of the discussion moderators noted that he'd like to see either overwhelming support (in which case it would likely move quickly towards becoming a submitted suggestion) or overwhelming opposition (in which case it would be summarily rejected). As it stands, I think it's going to sit here until QH can move the support level one way or the other.

But that's precisely the problem - Queen_Herpes has clearly shown that if she doesn't like the result, she's just going to trash it and start over. This cannot possibly have a legitimate ending to it now, in my opinion, due to this dishonesty.

[Army of GOD]

the "change the symbol" group won it, so this poll should be the decider to what it is changed too

[Woodruff]

the "change the symbol" group won it, so this poll should be the decider to what it is changed too

Is a 53% number in favor of a change really enough to carry a change through? I would hope it isn't.

[Queen_Herpes]

At present, the currnet poll shows the following results:
JefJef's Feather concept 5 votes 28%
Queen_Herpes/JefJef's horn/bugle concept No votes
Alex's Dog Tags concept 5 votes 28%
qwert's NR symbol concept 8 votes 44%

This post also serves as another request to keep on topic.

Reminder that this poll will be pulled up at the end of the month, at which time the replacement with the least votes will be removed from the poll. Current loser is the Queen Herpes/JefJef Horn-Bugle Concept.

[JoshyBoy]

Due to the huge amount of interest in this thread, I am moving this to the Submitted Suggestions forum. It is clear that there is a divide in the community about whether or not the new recruit icon should be changed/replaced, so it is, as always, going to be left to the admin to make the final decision. I for one, oppose this suggestion, but it's not up to me to make the final decision.

In other words, as with any other suggestion made on Conquer Club, just because it has been submitted does not mean it will be implemented. We should all wait with eager anticipation to see what our lord and saviour [player]lackattack[/player] decides to do regarding this matter.

Please feel free to continue debating in a orderly and pleasant fashion, if you feel you must, as I would hate to have to lock this thread. Any questions or comments, just speak to me.

[Queen_Herpes]

Due to the huge amount of interest in this thread, I am moving this to the Submitted Suggestions forum. It is clear that there is a divide in the community about whether or not the new recruit icon should be changed/replaced, so it is, as always, going to be left to the admin to make the final decision. I for one, oppose this suggestion, but it's not up to me to make the final decision.

In other words, as with any other suggestion made on Conquer Club, just because it has been submitted does not mean it will be implemented. We should all wait with eager anticipation to see what our lord and saviour [player]lackattack[/player] decides to do regarding this matter.

Please feel free to continue debating in a orderly and pleasant fashion, if you feel you must, as I would hate to have to lock this thread. Any questions or comments, just speak to me.

Congratulations everyone! The suggestion was submitted! Keep up the great work on the contest! Qwert is in the lead!

[Woodruff]

Due to the huge amount of interest in this thread, I am moving this to the Submitted Suggestions forum. It is clear that there is a divide in the community about whether or not the new recruit icon should be changed/replaced, so it is, as always, going to be left to the admin to make the final decision. I for one, oppose this suggestion, but it's not up to me to make the final decision.

In other words, as with any other suggestion made on Conquer Club, just because it has been submitted does not mean it will be implemented. We should all wait with eager anticipation to see what our lord and saviour [player]lackattack[/player] decides to do regarding this matter.

Please feel free to continue debating in a orderly and pleasant fashion, if you feel you must, as I would hate to have to lock this thread. Any questions or comments, just speak to me.

Congratulations everyone! The suggestion was submitted! Keep up the great work on the contest! Qwert is in the lead!

As you have already been told many times, Queen_Herpes, THERE IS NO CONTEST. None. Zero. No contest.

[shanksdigs]

Congratulations everyone! The suggestion was submitted! Keep up the great work on the contest! Qwert is in the lead!

As you have already been told many times, Queen_Herpes, THERE IS NO CONTEST. None. Zero. No contest.

Actually, I read the suggestion, she is awarding free prmium to the winner of the contest. Sounds like a contest to me.

[Woodruff]

Congratulations everyone! The suggestion was submitted! Keep up the great work on the contest! Qwert is in the lead!

As you have already been told many times, Queen_Herpes, THERE IS NO CONTEST. None. Zero. No contest.

Actually, I read the suggestion, she is awarding free prmium to the winner of the contest. Sounds like a contest to me.

All that shows is that Queen_Herpes has continued her assault of passive aggressive behavior against the Suggestions Moderators in this thread.

[alex951]

vote for me

[JoshyBoy]

vote for me

I shall. Just to watch [player]Queen_Herpes[/player] have to spend $25 she could have saved. Go alex!

[jaimito101]

so let me get this straight.. QH is going to pay a premium at the end of this month for this self enstated contest? Queen could you confirm this?

[natty dread]

Boggles the mind.

[Qwert]

I shall. Just to watch Queen_Herpes have to spend $25 she could have saved. Go alex!
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
What abouth "go Qwert !" ?

[TheForgivenOne]

And the final poll ended with an amazing 18 votes...

[Woodruff]

And the final poll ended with an amazing 18 votes...

Considerably fewer than the poll that was summarily deleted. <sigh>

(As I know you know.)

[Queen_Herpes]

so let me get this straight.. QH is going to pay a premium at the end of this month for this self enstated contest? Queen could you confirm this?

Close. A better read of the original post shows that I will keep reducing the number of options in the poll each month until we are down to two options. The winner of that final poll will receive free premium for a year!

[Queen_Herpes]

And the final poll ended with an amazing 18 votes...

Why did the poll end? I put in for the poll to last 30 days.

Please put the controls back in my hands. If that means taking this suggestion out of "submitted," then please do so. There were still people voting and still people commenting in support of replacing the question mark.

By forcing this into submitted, it appears that TFO and JB were/are simply trying to silence the members of conquerclub who have affirmative support for this suggestion.

Unfortunately, if your behavior continues, I will simply have no choice but to submit a formal complaint to the administration of the site. This will not be limited to you, TFO, and you, JB, but will include those members who are simply flaming this suggestion.

[AAFitz]

And the final poll ended with an amazing 18 votes...

Why did the poll end? I put in for the poll to last 30 days.

Please put the controls back in my hands. If that means taking this suggestion out of "submitted," then please do so. There were still people voting and still people commenting in support of replacing the question mark.

By forcing this into submitted, it appears that TFO and JB were/are simply trying to silence the members of conquerclub who have affirmative support for this suggestion.

Unfortunately, if your behavior continues, I will simply have no choice but to submit a formal complaint to the administration of the site. This will not be limited to you, TFO, and you, JB, but will include those members who are simply flaming this suggestion.

You were officially warned multiple times you were completely and obviously circumventing the suggestions policy. You cant possibly be surprised by this. Be sure to include this tidbit in your "formal complaint"

[JoshyBoy]

This topic has been locked due to the excessive amounts of reports which are being logged. This suggestion has been submitted and we shall await the ruling of the admin.