Chuck Mafia, Game over, Town Wins!

[icedagger]

The assumption was that by the time we're in a position to lynch someone everyone who's likely to post will have posted

[AceArtemis]

No, we need to wait. Once he says who he targeted, then it would be too easy for the person to just show up and say, ya my role changed.

If they are mafia, they still wouldn't know what their role was supposed to have changed to.

[strokem1257]

Sorry guys for the inactivity as of late... this week has been hectic so far. I just started up college again this week so I may not be near as active. sorry. oh and as far as i know I didn't get a PM stating my role changed but that doesnt mean I didnt accidently delete it when cleaning out my inbox earlier... :S

[Nzen]

I'm pretty sure they would get a PM stating that their role changed, and informing them what it changed to.

The only person who knows that is whoever LSU targeted night one. Still, it isn't difficult to figure out what the new role would be called, something along the lines of informant or protected witness. If I'm thinking it, the mafiosi is and may take the risk.

In lieu of waiting, I see some reasons to suspect captainwalrus. (Both on page 15)

I fell like if I post now people will realize I have been lurking...
but anyways, Um lus, how do you know if his role didn't change? What lets you know that it was used on scum or not?
(...)
vote falko someone said he was fairly certain he was scumm, so lets lynch move the game along

He hammered without waiting for falkomagno's inevitable quibbling, then acted as though he didn't remember who founded the bandwagon despite misspelling lsu. I wouldn't put it past him to bus a teammate with such a successful bandwagon to divert attention. I vote for captainwalrus

[icedagger]

I'm pretty sure they would get a PM stating that their role changed, and informing them what it changed to.

The only person who knows that is whoever LSU targeted night one. Still, it isn't difficult to figure out what the new role would be called, something along the lines of informant or protected witness. If I'm thinking it, the mafiosi is and may take the risk.

What? LSU almost certainly knows what the role is, and it could be named hundreds of things, the chances of scum correctly guessing it are slim at best

Sorry guys for the inactivity as of late... this week has been hectic so far. I just started up college again this week so I may not be near as active. sorry. oh and as far as i know I didn't get a PM stating my role changed but that doesnt mean I didnt accidently delete it when cleaning out my inbox earlier... :S

PM / and ask him to resend anything you might have been sent at night?

[icedagger]

Oh think I misread your post Nzen... you're saying we don't know whether the target gets told what their new role is. Seems very likely they do though

[sam_levi_11]

I'm CIA director Langston Hughes. Each night I can select a player and if they aren't scum, their role changes to a certain role(would prefer not stating at this time). If they are scum, then they don't change roles.

This does not seem to say that they would know if their role changes, more that lsu gets told if he has sucessfully changed them or not...

[pmchugh]

I'm CIA director Langston Hughes. Each night I can select a player and if they aren't scum, their role changes to a certain role(would prefer not stating at this time). If they are scum, then they don't change roles.

This does not seem to say that they would know if their role changes, more that lsu gets told if he has sucessfully changed them or not...

How could your role change without your own knowledge of it? What if you were a cop?

[LSU Tiger Josh]

first off / says that they will be told if their role changes.
secondly VOTE PMC as you were the one I sent the role change to last night. if someone roleblocked me or busdrove pmc please let us know. otherwise there is only one reason other than him being scum on why his role wouldn't change and it would be that he already had that role.

[pmchugh]

first off / says that they will be told if their role changes.
secondly VOTE PMC as you were the one I sent the role change to last night. if someone roleblocked me or busdrove pmc please let us know. otherwise there is only one reason other than him being scum on why his role wouldn't change and it would be that he already had that role.

My role did not change, there must be roleblocker or busdriver out there. In fact if mafia had a roleblocker surely they would use it on you? That way no matter who you investigate will be scum. No one jump to conclusions and bandwaggon me before people have a chance to say if they blocked lsu or busdrove etc. I am town and have a solid claim to back it up, I will give it once a few more people have posted and no one owns up to switching or blocking.

[AceArtemis]

first off / says that they will be told if their role changes.
secondly VOTE PMC as you were the one I sent the role change to last night. if someone roleblocked me or busdrove pmc please let us know. otherwise there is only one reason other than him being scum on why his role wouldn't change and it would be that he already had that role.

My role did not change, there must be roleblocker or busdriver out there. In fact if mafia had a roleblocker surely they would use it on you? That way no matter who you investigate will be scum. No one jump to conclusions and bandwaggon me before people have a chance to say if they blocked lsu or busdrove etc. I am town and have a solid claim to back it up, I will give it once a few more people have posted and no one owns up to switching or blocking.

If you have a solid claim, lets hear it. Until then, Vote: pmc as the current evidence points to pmc being scum.

[Nzen]

This is exactly why I didn't want to rely on LSU's role to solve the case for us. I hadn't had any particular suspicions about pmchugh, but let's see if I can't hang him by his words.
page 13

Vote Falco I have good evidence to believe that he is scum.

Care to share it? How do i know ur not a lyncher?

page 14

I'm CIA director Langston Hughes. Each night I can select a player and if they aren't scum, their role changes to a certain role(would prefer not stating at this time). If they are scum, then they don't change roles.

(...)

Dammit guys I told you!! SUPER DUPER QUADUPLE FOS on pmchugh for acting like blind pete to the whole falko matter Vote Falko

unvote vote falko Sorry for my decline in actvity ppl.

(...)

Falko definitely needs to claim. Vote: Falko

Yes he does, there i strong evidence against him.

He moved from warranted suspicion to tight-lipped agreement and support. The only person to mention falkomango's prior behavior was william18. While I dislike it, others did the same in response to LSU's accusation with no counter-claim. Pmchugh has initated several lynches, but that is his way. The evidence is ambiguous. as usual.

Between pmchugh and captainwalrus both accrued sins - LSU's accusation and a rushed hammer. A mafia roleblock is possible. They have had a doctor, recruiter, and cop. If so, he won't admit to it and we rely on pmchugh's claim, a fragile state whatever his alignment. For the moment, captainwalrus' guilt is more certain to me, so my vote stands pending a clearer path.

[captainwalrus]

Umm... Well, I won't vote unill we hear from a roleblocker.

[Talapus]

At this point in time it is apparent that there has to be a roleblocker in the game. I have no reason to doubt LSU's claim based on him being such a prominent character in the show. No one counterclaimed, so I'm thinking he knows what he's talking about. Come on peeps. not the end of the world saying you roleblocked someone....unless of course you are a roleblocking scum.....which is very possible.

[icedagger]

At this point in time it is apparent that there has to be a roleblocker in the game..

Not really, it's apparant pmc is probably scum. Highly unlikely a pro-twon roleblocker would block LSU

Vote pmc

[Talapus]

At this point in time it is apparent that there has to be a roleblocker in the game..

Not really, it's apparant pmc is probably scum. Highly unlikely a pro-twon roleblocker would block LSU

Vote pmc

True, also likely. But since people still haven't spoken up yet I'll lean more towards roleblocker at this point in time.

[Nzen]

Umm... Well, I won't vote unill we hear from a roleblocker.

If LSU was roleblocked it had to be mafia. Any town roleblocker would have seen him ferret out falkomagno yesterday. The only thing that can save pmchugh is his next claim. Unless someone busdrove him with another.

there is only one reason other than him being scum on why his role wouldn't change and it would be that he already had that role.

[pmchugh]

This is exactly why I didn't want to rely on LSU's role to solve the case for us. I hadn't had any particular suspicions about pmchugh, but let's see if I can't hang him by his words.
page 13

Vote Falco I have good evidence to believe that he is scum.

Care to share it? How do i know ur not a lyncher?

page 14

I'm CIA director Langston Hughes. Each night I can select a player and if they aren't scum, their role changes to a certain role(would prefer not stating at this time). If they are scum, then they don't change roles.

(...)

Dammit guys I told you!! SUPER DUPER QUADUPLE FOS on pmchugh for acting like blind pete to the whole falko matter Vote Falko

unvote vote falko Sorry for my decline in actvity ppl.

(...)

Falko definitely needs to claim. Vote: Falko

Yes he does, there i strong evidence against him.

He moved from warranted suspicion to tight-lipped agreement and support. The only person to mention falkomango's prior behavior was william18. While I dislike it, others did the same in response to LSU's accusation with no counter-claim. Pmchugh has initated several lynches, but that is his way. The evidence is ambiguous. as usual.

Between pmchugh and captainwalrus both accrued sins - LSU's accusation and a rushed hammer. A mafia roleblock is possible. They have had a doctor, recruiter, and cop. If so, he won't admit to it and we rely on pmchugh's claim, a fragile state whatever his alignment. For the moment, captainwalrus' guilt is more certain to me, so my vote stands pending a clearer path.

Its pretty clear i wasnt following the game, when i do you will see in depth posts from me, hell i didnt even see will accuse me. I even said it in my post.

And there could still be a town busdriver, so i will wait for a few more posts before claiming. I will claim if needed, whats the rush? There is no deadline and I know there has been a mistake here, if it is not explained soon i will assume a scum roleblocker and gladly claim to clear my name.

[Nzen]

Please, pmchugh, take your time defending yourself. While we wait for someone else to exonerate you of this terrible mistake I unvote captainwalrus to vote pmchugh.

[pmchugh]

Ok i may as well go ahead and claim my character name at least. Im Sarah Walker, I'm a townie and I don't think i need to say more than that.

[Fircoal]

Ok i may as well go ahead and claim my character name at least. Im Sarah Walker, I'm a townie and I don't think i need to say more than that.

[/quote]

[quote="/"]
13.lord voldemort (Agent Sarah Walker Town Elite Bodygaurd) Killed Night One

Riiiiiight... Vote: Pmc

[Fircoal]

Ok i may as well go ahead and claim my character name at least. Im Sarah Walker, I'm a townie and I don't think i need to say more than that.

13.lord voldemort (Agent Sarah Walker Town Elite Bodygaurd) Killed Night One

Riiiiiight... Vote: Pmc

EBWOP

[pmchugh]

Well that was a failed claim, ok i give up i amone of two remaining mafia members but here the secret I actualyl a survivor. Talapus is the other mafia member kill him and we all win. Sorry tal it had to be done.

unvote vote tal

[Fircoal]

Well that was a failed claim, ok i give up i amone of two remaining mafia members but here the secret I actualyl a survivor. Talapus is the other mafia member kill him and we all win. Sorry tal it had to be done.

unvote vote tal

Guess who's trying to trick us?

YOU!

Guess who we're going to lynch?

YOU!

DIE SCUMBADG!

[strokem1257]

Ok i may as well go ahead and claim my character name at least. Im Sarah Walker, I'm a townie and I don't think i need to say more than that.

13.lord voldemort (Agent Sarah Walker Town Elite Bodygaurd) Killed Night One

Riiiiiight... Vote: Pmc

wow PMC. that is sad. I can't believe you tried that kind of a claim... do you seriously think none of us would notice that lord v was already killed with that role... tsk tsk... pay attention please.

unvote?? vote PMC