AFC Mafia Game TOWN WINS!

[Its Bolt]

I would love to know how this game was supposed to be considered balanced.

Seriously, town doc, cop, masonier, vig, PGO, limited vig, vig spawn, conditional PGO and then something else wins D1 if they massclaim.

Maybe bump janitor to normal level where its one shot but learns of what it cleaned, and throw in a mafia doctor and you have yourself a fair game. Mafia need to have town self-destruct on the PGO though to have any shot of winning this. You saw how vauge I needed my claim to be, its because every town power is taken already. I wouldnt be surprised if Thez was a town-RB since that is the only thing missing.

[derfderf34]

Bolt was convincing the rest of the town to vote for someone else by claiming that he himself was mafia. The town didnt agree and he was lynched. Its Bolt (Denver Broncos)(Mafia goon) has been lynched!

The town wins!

[Its Bolt]

I still think balance was an issue in this game given that theory says all PGO roles should claim on the first day, which effectively would cause a massclaim given the presence of two and from there on out the self-destructiveness of the town in the sense of multiple PGO related deaths would be over and they cakewalk to a win.

This is also the first time I have seen the janitor role used like this. It normally shows up more like

You are a mafia janitor, each night you will be told who died and what they are. Once per game, you can clean up the deaths before everyone else wakes up, and no role reveal will occur in the morning for any dead players

The one you had is closer to this version

You are a mafia janitor, each night you can clean up all the kills, and no one will be able to identify what they are untill the following morning.

[Thezzaruz]

I'd say that here the second version is the norm, don't think I've even seen the first one at all tbh.


Was quite interesting to see all the wifom discussions on day 2 when I knew who drench had targeted.

Also I think that the balance could have used a SK instead of the jester.

[Thezzaruz]

Seriously, town doc, cop, masonier, vig, PGO, limited vig, vig spawn, conditional PGO and then something else wins D1 if they massclaim.

Forgetting the fact that it isn't a believable claim.

[derfderf34]

ACTION REPORT

Night 1:
spiesr Shoot (Nobody)
/ Investigate Its bolt (Guilty)
Drench Recruit Bolt (Died)
Mafia Kill and Janitor Thezz

Night 2:
spiesr Shoot (Nobody)
/ Investgate norse (Innocent)
animorpher Gives bomb to spiesr
Mafia Kill LSU

Night 3:
spiesr Shoot (Nobody)
spiesr Give bomb to Sam
norse kill sheep (Died)
/ Investigate Sam (Innocent)
Pmc Protect Bolt
Sam gets the bomb and chooses to become 1 shot Vig
Mafia kill /

Night 4:
spiesr Shoot (Nobody)
pmc save animorpher
Mafia kill animorpher (Saved)

Night 5:
spiesr Shoot (Nobody)
Mafia Kill animorpher


Town & Jester have won.

[pmchugh]

Grumble grumble was obvious grumble.

[SEAsportsfan]

you know, I'd really like to see you do an NFC one, or maybe an AL/NL one for baseball season?

[spiesr]

The NFC One

[SEAsportsfan]

oh, i wish i would have joined that...i really like this idea...oh well, maybe next football season

[norsemsn1066]

Thank you to derf for modding and for allowing me to sub in.

GG Town.