The Thing - Mafia Style [Winner=The Thing]

[Its Bolt]

hey fifth an you vote? It will kinda help me reach a conclusion

[nagerous]

there were two people going against fifth, and both got killed. I think this is a set up and I am going with my gut.

vote ani[/b

he hops around with his votes, never makes a clear distinction about who he is after, makes sure not to be the first or last vote, and is very vague.

I don't know what anyone else thinks but this post reeks scum, you talk about a possible set up but sounds to me like you and f1fth targetted people that were against f1fth as clearly indicated and then throw in a WIFOM that mafia wouldn't target people that are against them..


Then you have the nerve to throw a vote against ani for being a noob.. Ani is a noob, he will always be a noob, is he scum? Probably not.. my own personal view anyway. Its Bolt, has given off quite a town vibe in my eyes too so I am going to put good money on the mafia partnership being you and f1fth. Pushing for the easy lynch of ani on the final day is low and sounds exactly like something scum would do!

[b]vote spaceghst and a pre-emptive vote on f1fth ready for the next day once one mafia is lynched!

Its Bolt please read...

I never voted ani, I have always been very suspicious of space. Ani is a n00b and an easy target, I am just not convinced he is scummy, if he was scum he would have slipped up by now (yes he is that bad a player, just look at Natewolfman's Triple Cult game or any other game he has been in in the past )

All my logic for space is right here.

[F1fth]

Ok, so one thing that's been bothering me has been Bolt's reluctance to make a decision before I vote. Since space is only a vote away from being lynched, one can only assume Bolt is waiting for me to vote for someone so he can hammer, and the only person that could possibly be is Nagerous. The key though is figuring out why he's hesitating. Is it because he's scum with space? Or is it because he's town and assumes I'm waiting to hammer Nag? The second makes less sense to me because I've made it quite clear that I thought Nag was scum, and mentioned that I though the space and bolt pairing sounded unlikely. It was quite intentional and I was much less deadset on it, but I was trying to get an interesting reaction. I have to make the call, so I've decided on the Bolt-Space pairing.



Vote Space

[Natewolfman]

GAME OVER

Vote Count

nagerous - 1 vote (spaceghst44)
spaceghst44 - 3 votes (nagerous, animorpherv1, F1fth)

spaceghst44 (Killed VIA lynch) Human

nagerous & animorpherv1 are the thing, in the night they will choose to kill either F1fth or Its Bolt, and the following day they have the 2-1 advantage for the win.

Great game everyone! (play by play soon to come)

[ace1217]

Oh well, this game was basically screwed for town the moment the doctor died. And WTH was I not protected?

[Natewolfman]

A few things to note for this play by play
1) ace who was confirmed a power role was never once protected
2) ga7 basically the only confirmed regular townie was lynched
3) only regular humans were lynched, the thing was never lynched or vig'd

This was very interesting to watch, and i learned from this one and already know how to make this senario much better

Play by Play
Day 1
Confimations
Night 1
animorpherv1 assimilates pancakemix
doctor and rogue do not get an action in the first night
Day 2
Scoffin Lynched
Night 2
'The Thing' attempts to attack ga7
ga7 is protected by the doctor (dunc_2007)
ace1217(Rogue) kills Fircoal
Day 3
switchblade Lynched
dunc_2007 protects ga7
Night 3
'The Thing' attempts to attack pmchugh, fail, and pmchugh is killed
ga7 is protected by the doctor (dunc_2007)
ace1217(Rogue) chooses not to kill tonight
Day 4
william18 is lynched
Night 4
ga7 is protected by the doctor (dunc_2007)
'The Thing' attacks LSU
Day 5
ga7 is lynched
Night 5
'The Thing' attacks ace1217
ace1217 kills /
the doctor does not protect (no responce)
Day 6
ga7 lynched
Night 6
spiesr assumeings Dr. Roll as dunc went inactive
spiesr protects animorph
animorph/nag (the thing) attacks spiesr
Day 7
sam_levi_11 lynched
Night 7
'The Thing' attacks and kills Thezzaruz
Day 8
space_ghst44 is lynched

The thing Wins!

[animorpherv1]

I won ??

BTW, most of those kills were my idea. The only way I won, is because of in early game, I killed some people that caused major contrevesy, where I would have been lynched. I sent in ALL the kills, and about 6 of them were my idea. (PCM chose ga7, and nag chose Thez). I chose these specific people because they seemed to be the smartest, wisest, or something that made them stand out. It worked.

Great game by Nate.
Nice try town.

[pmchugh]

I won ??

BTW, most of those kills were my idea. The only way I won, is because of in early game, I killed some people that caused major contrevesy, where I would have been lynched. I sent in ALL the kills, and about 6 of them were my idea. (PCM chose ga7, and nag chose Thez). I chose these specific people because they seemed to be the smartest, wisest, or something that made them stand out. It worked.

Great game by Nate.
Nice try town.

Yeah the only way you won is by killing me, very smart move

[spiesr]

:| Oh well, this game was basically screwed for town the moment the doctor died. And WTH was I not protected?

It's not my fault!

[/]

Town did worse than if it was random.
Oh well, congratulations Ani and Nag, especially animorph, you really outsmarted the majority of active mafia players on the site.

[ace1217]

:| Oh well, this game was basically screwed for town the moment the doctor died. And WTH was I not protected?

It's not my fault!

Erm technically it is since if I wasn't dead we might actually have had a chance.

[spiesr]

:| Oh well, this game was basically screwed for town the moment the doctor died. And WTH was I not protected?

It's not my fault!

Erm technically it is since if I wasn't dead we might actually have had a chance.

I didn't take over as doc until after you died...

[ga7]

Heh I was expecting it but not in that way. I thought Ani and Nag were fucking blatant and was surprised F1fth picked Space being an idiot over them. I thought Its Bolt had about 50% chances to make the wrong choice since he was going around in circles about it so much, kinda ironic it caused F1fth to disbelieve him
Anyway about the game in itself... The fact the only power roles were completely misused cost town the game, we probably would have won else. Even though we lacked an investigative role to start with, but the problem about it is more that all the lynches felt random so it became pretty boring IMO. Well, I didn't see any particular mishap else you did a good job Nate. For the next games... NV FTW

[Natewolfman]

NV FTW

huh? lol

If I run another one of these I will have more power roles, and I will also give 'the thing' more ability to take someone over, either raise the %'s or make each night change like from 20% to 50% or so to make it more randomized... not sure yet

[ga7]

NV= non vanilla. No powerless townie roles basically.

[Natewolfman]

NV= non vanilla. No powerless townie roles basically.

ya, I still thought it was interesting to watch, basically it was all based on what was said, in fact i was tempted to have NO roles aside from the thing, put all the power in the lynching, it was interesting to watch the thown lynch vanilla after vanilla and discuss... More so because basically the way it went was

Player 1 accuses Player 2, town bandwagons a lynch, finds Player 2 is actually innocent, Player 3 leads revolt against Player 1 for killing Player 2, Player 1 found innocent, Player 4 leads against Player 3, ect. it was quite funny that anyone who tried to voice anything was wrong and therefor lynched the next day

[ga7]

Lol yeah it went pretty much like that. I played a good part in it too but my lynch was still quite silly especially since Spiesr pushed for it if I recall well when he was the only one knowing I was town

[Natewolfman]

Lol yeah it went pretty much like that. I played a good part in it too but my lynch was still quite silly especially since Spiesr pushed for it if I recall well when he was the only one knowing I was town

no, dunc was the town Dr at that time, later dunc went inactive and i was having troubles finding replacments so i shifted the role to spiesr (as it wasnt fair to the town to be down there last power role do to inactivity)

[ga7]

Nah I just checked back by curiosity and it was Spiesr active when I was lynched and when Ace died. Geez...

[Natewolfman]

Nah I just checked back by curiosity and it was Spiesr active when I was lynched and when Ace died. Geez...

no lol what im saying is that spiesr wasnt the Dr roll when you were killed, spiesr only had 1 night as Dr (and was killed that night) it was dunc that was Dr. when you were killed and the only one who could confirm 100% that it was you

[ga7]

Ah I never noticed Spiesr had another role before he replaced Oh well, who knows if it would have changed anything.

[Thezzaruz]

Ah I never noticed Spiesr had another role before he replaced

spiesr didn't replace. He got the doc powers while nate looked for a replacement for dunc.

[animorpherv1]

Confusion FTW?