[Abandoned] - Iron Curtain
Moderator: Cartographers
Forum rules
Please read the Community Guidelines before posting.
Please read the Community Guidelines before posting.
Re: IRON CURTAIN (Big Update 1st & 5th pg)
Great update, but i dont love the way the impassables look, and i really liked the other map you had with the three main bonuses split into smaller sub-bonuses. That looked a lot more fun IMO.
- Juan_Bottom
- Posts: 1110
- Joined: Mon May 19, 2008 4:59 pm
- Location: USA RULES! WHOOO!!!!
Re: IRON CURTAIN (Big Update 1st & 5th pg)
Welp, my comment is once you have the graphics wrapped up, and maybe do something with the impassables, then this map is done. It's a frickin' sweet map too, so I'd bet that's why there are so few comments.
Re: IRON CURTAIN (Big Update 1st & 5th pg)
I would be more than happy to play this map right now, it's awesome. Other than a few minor touch up's here and there with the graphics (for example the Kaliningrad text bugs me) I don't know what else to comment on...
- Mr. Squirrel
- Posts: 157
- Joined: Fri Nov 02, 2007 3:18 pm
- Location: up a tree
Re: IRON CURTAIN (Big Update 1st & 5th pg)
Juan_Bottom wrote:Welp, my comment is once you have the graphics wrapped up, and maybe do something with the impassables, then this map is done. It's a frickin' sweet map too, so I'd bet that's why there are so few comments.
Yea, just fix the impassables and the graphics will be perfect.
The thing I think you need to work on is the bonuses. Many of them are less or greater than they should be. For example, Veroezh and Byelorussia should have higher bonuses. Volgorad should be a +2 and Latvia could debated to +3
- gimil
- Posts: 8599
- Joined: Sat Mar 03, 2007 12:42 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: United Kingdom (Scotland)
Re: IRON CURTAIN (Big Update 1st & 5th pg)
[adv. idea]
RJ you continue to create pure art.
RJ you continue to create pure art.
What do you know about map making, bitch?
Top Score:2403
natty_dread wrote:I was wrong
Top Score:2403
- Juan_Bottom
- Posts: 1110
- Joined: Mon May 19, 2008 4:59 pm
- Location: USA RULES! WHOOO!!!!
- The Viking
- Posts: 148
- Joined: Fri Feb 15, 2008 10:58 am
Re: IRON CURTAIN (Big Update 1st & 5th pg)
RjBeals wrote:This is going to prove rather difficult. The size restrictions on this site really do hold us back from so many possibilities. At first I was going to include all of USSR during the cold-war (Soviet Union), including Western Europe. Qwert's WW2 Europe map made me nervous, but I think ours is different enough to continue with, as most of ours is Russian Republic. I couldn't fit all of Russia. So I zoomed in enough to include Western Europe, and at least half of Russia.
I may be crazy, but I don't see western europe in your map.
Re: IRON CURTAIN (Big Update 1st & 5th pg)
The Viking wrote:RjBeals wrote:This is going to prove rather difficult. The size restrictions on this site really do hold us back from so many possibilities. At first I was going to include all of USSR during the cold-war (Soviet Union), including Western Europe. Qwert's WW2 Europe map made me nervous, but I think ours is different enough to continue with, as most of ours is Russian Republic. I couldn't fit all of Russia. So I zoomed in enough to include Western Europe, and at least half of Russia.
I may be crazy, but I don't see western europe in your map.
Opps - I mean Eastern Europe.

- wcaclimbing
- Posts: 5598
- Joined: Fri May 12, 2006 10:09 pm
- Location: In your quantum box....Maybe.
- Contact:
Re: IRON CURTAIN (Big Update 1st & 5th pg)
I should have probably given this a day or two ago, but here it is:

This map looks pretty awesome. Good luck with it.
Now we just wait for one of the CAs to move this thread to the main foundry.

This map looks pretty awesome. Good luck with it.
Now we just wait for one of the CAs to move this thread to the main foundry.

- sam_levi_11
- Posts: 2872
- Joined: Mon Dec 11, 2006 2:48 pm
- Gender: Male
Re: IRON CURTAIN (Big Update 1st & 5th pg) [I]
can we have a proper update now with the changes
Re: IRON CURTAIN (Big Update 1st & 5th pg) [I]
Perhaps Sam.
I haven't had much time recently -
I'm torn between... xml for Charleston, redoing the borders again for Brazil, or updating this map. I might bring my laptop to bed with me tonight and work on one of these.
I haven't had much time recently -
I'm torn between... xml for Charleston, redoing the borders again for Brazil, or updating this map. I might bring my laptop to bed with me tonight and work on one of these.

- gimil
- Posts: 8599
- Joined: Sat Mar 03, 2007 12:42 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: United Kingdom (Scotland)
Re: IRON CURTAIN (Big Update 1st & 5th pg) [I]
RjBeals wrote:I might bring my laptop to bed with me tonight and work on one of these.
RJ's dirty little secret!
What do you know about map making, bitch?
Top Score:2403
natty_dread wrote:I was wrong
Top Score:2403
Re: IRON CURTAIN (Big Update 1st & 5th pg) [I]
RjBeals wrote:Perhaps Sam.
I haven't had much time recently -
I'm torn between... xml for Charleston, redoing the borders again for Brazil, or updating this map. I might bring my laptop to bed with me tonight and work on one of these.
Might as well wait for Charleston to reach FF for the xml... probably won't see live play soon anyway.
- gimil
- Posts: 8599
- Joined: Sat Mar 03, 2007 12:42 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: United Kingdom (Scotland)
Re: IRON CURTAIN (Big Update 1st & 5th pg) [I]
The only thing RJ that is bothering me on this is the mesh fench you have used. It just doesn't please my athetical eye.
What do you know about map making, bitch?
Top Score:2403
natty_dread wrote:I was wrong
Top Score:2403
- wcaclimbing
- Posts: 5598
- Joined: Fri May 12, 2006 10:09 pm
- Location: In your quantum box....Maybe.
- Contact:
Re: IRON CURTAIN (Big Update 1st & 5th pg) [I]
gimil wrote:The only thing RJ that is bothering me on this is the mesh fench you have used. It just doesn't please my athetical eye.
I agree.

Re: IRON CURTAIN (Big Update 1st & 5th pg) [I]
How's this for the impassables? I gave it a lot of thought and placed them where I think make the most sense. Still a lot of open borders, but there's no impassables in World 2.1, and thats still a popular map.
I also added Moldavia (kind of a part of Ukraine). I'm not sure what to do about this. It needs to be there, but it's so damn small. I might exclude it on the legend, and give it a 0 bonus.
I also touched up the colors again, and some border areas, and lighting effects. Is the font still legible?
(EDIT)
O yeah, adding Modavia gives me 97 territs now. I really wanted only 96 as that's a great whole number for the game (48x2). Can anyone see an area I could get rid of, or combine into another region? Or maybe I'll just keep it at 97 - not really a big deal with this many territs if 1 is neutral.
[bigimg]http://www.rjbeals.com/ironcurtain/IronCurtain_Rev-04a.jpg[/bigimg]
I also added Moldavia (kind of a part of Ukraine). I'm not sure what to do about this. It needs to be there, but it's so damn small. I might exclude it on the legend, and give it a 0 bonus.
I also touched up the colors again, and some border areas, and lighting effects. Is the font still legible?
(EDIT)
O yeah, adding Modavia gives me 97 territs now. I really wanted only 96 as that's a great whole number for the game (48x2). Can anyone see an area I could get rid of, or combine into another region? Or maybe I'll just keep it at 97 - not really a big deal with this many territs if 1 is neutral.
[bigimg]http://www.rjbeals.com/ironcurtain/IronCurtain_Rev-04a.jpg[/bigimg]

Re: IRON CURTAIN (Update pg. 1 & 7) [I]
Do you know what's confusing me at the mo about this map...
What is it?
It's half or europe - half of russia - half of something else...
Don't get me wrong - the GFX are awesome - and I love the huge map thing...
But I'm struggling to understand the theme properly!?
C.
What is it?
It's half or europe - half of russia - half of something else...
Don't get me wrong - the GFX are awesome - and I love the huge map thing...
But I'm struggling to understand the theme properly!?
C.

Highest score : 2297
Re: IRON CURTAIN (Update pg. 1 & 7) [I]
It's Eastern Europe and Western Russia, and it's the communist countries prior to the fall of the communism.
First Post wrote:...I couldn't fit all of Russia. So I zoomed in enough to include Eastern Europe, and at least half of Russia. Soviet Union Administrative Divisions (1989).

Re: IRON CURTAIN (Update pg. 1 & 7) [I]
RjBeals wrote::evil:
It's Eastern Europe and Western Russia, and it's the communist countries prior to the fall of the communism.First Post wrote:...I couldn't fit all of Russia. So I zoomed in enough to include Eastern Europe, and at least half of Russia. Soviet Union Administrative Divisions (1989).
Yeah I read that... still left me with the feeling that it's not a map of anywhere specific...
C.

Highest score : 2297
Re: IRON CURTAIN (Update pg. 1 & 7) [I]

How's that for specific.
Do you have any suggestions?
My plan was to still title it the iron curtain.
Maybe the title will make it more clear?
Maybe I could make Russia all close shades of red? I prefer the colors all neutral earthy tones, and sporadic.

Re: IRON CURTAIN (Update pg. 1 & 7) [I]
RjBeals wrote:
How's that for specific.
Do you have any suggestions?
My plan was to still title it the iron curtain.
Maybe the title will make it more clear?
Maybe I could make Russia all close shades of red? I prefer the colors all neutral earthy tones, and sporadic.
Ha ha - I like what you did there (Although you're a few pixels out
So - what IS that region?
You map proves it even more - it just seems to be a random snapshot of a random set of countries... Tell me more - Build some story... what is the Iron Curtain? Is all of this map behind said curtain? - what about the other bits that are missing?
Do you see what I'm driving at?
C.

Highest score : 2297
-
rustlemania
- Posts: 89
- Joined: Thu Jul 12, 2007 5:05 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: here... and there.
Re: IRON CURTAIN (Update pg. 1 & 7) [I]
Seems clear to me.... the areas under Soviet control during the Cold War... these areas, while not being part of Russia proper, were forced into the Soviet Union, and were said to fall under the Iron Curtain of communism.
Title sounds perfect to me... I also love the graphics.
I was actually partial to the fence.... if people don't like it, i'd like to see some other graphic representing the iron curtain... something harsh like that fence fits well. I'll try to think of suggestions in the meantime.
Title sounds perfect to me... I also love the graphics.
I was actually partial to the fence.... if people don't like it, i'd like to see some other graphic representing the iron curtain... something harsh like that fence fits well. I'll try to think of suggestions in the meantime.

Re: IRON CURTAIN (Update pg. 1 & 7) [I]
rustlemania wrote:Seems clear to me.... the areas under Soviet control during the Cold War... these areas, while not being part of Russia proper, were forced into the Soviet Union, and were said to fall under the Iron Curtain of communism.
Title sounds perfect to me... I also love the graphics.
The problem is - that it's not ALL of those areas... There's half of russia in there - and some areas the other side of Russia that are missing...
C.

Highest score : 2297


