best mafia player

[Fircoal]

Subjectively i can only make a poll with players ive played with....so my top 5.

1)selin -though you could make the claim that this more recent bias, i dont know of a player who is as good at figuring out who is who. Probably an asset to his side, no matter what side it is.
2)Incandenza -probably the player who would have been number 1 before selin, but i havent played with him in a while, but i remember thinking he was top notch.
3)Aimless - pretty tough for town to defeat if he is scum and is very sharp at managing the impression he wants within a game.
4)MountainLion -probably had the best introductory performance ive seen and hasnt really lost a step since. You could probably make a pretty good argument he is number 3, but a top flight player nonetheless.
5)Sierra_Leon -imo the best of the newer players after selin and ML, someone who like aimless is very good at portraying themselves in the light that they wish to be seen. tough to beat no matter what affiliation.

Other players who are right about at that point...
Nagerous, Talapus, exile, ga7,mando.

where am I on this list oh great tonka?

[Fircoal]

your only saying that becasue you have 1 vote. Mine was Fircoal, I think he is the best mafia player around, and one of the most active on their.

well it's not just activeness, because if it was who played in the most games and moddest the most, it'd be me in a FAR lead ahead of anyone else. Though I haven't played as much in this time, my earlier times make up for it. (I remember back when I joined every single game, 10+ games at a time. )

[fireedud]

Where's the option for NESqonquerer jk

[Incandenza]

Thanks, GT... especially since it's prolly been about a year since my last mafia foray (the legendary Bad Poets Society).

[Fircoal]

Thanks, GT... especially since it's prolly been about a year since my last mafia foray (the legendary Bad Poets Society).

I don't think a year yet. Still Incan you are one of the best players here.

[mandalorian2298]

Thanks, GT... especially since it's prolly been about a year since my last mafia foray (the legendary Bad Poets Society).

I don't think a year yet. Still Incan you are one of the best players here.

You two were my favorites in Bad Poets. Firc (because of his Pikachu avatar combined with rondolets) sounded like wind-up toy and that totaly cracked me up while Inca sounded like Dante with a beer in his hand, reciting while he watches baseball . That whole game is work of art (except for Talpus' fake claim. That was lying and thus plain wrong! ).

[jnd94]

I remember that. Wicked was free verse and we thought she was scum.

[Fircoal]

I'm not up there

Where is Mountain Lion? Anyway, it will be hard to decide as long as Lion and Talapus keep geting the only Scum roles and Tonka keeps geting Town roles.

Tonka was scum once, and I lynched him for it

Once isn't enough. Mods, make Tonka evil! (Just so that Fircoal doesn't paste this in my upcoming game, roles will be asigned RANDOMLY.)

I wonder who gets this?

and yet you guys don't get this. It's reference to when I called Selin scum because he had a haiku poem type, and Aimless said he wouldn't put it in.

[mandalorian2298]

I remember that. Wicked was free verse and we thought she was scum.

And the game ended with Wicked being annoyed with me and LSU still haven't forgiven me for lynching him.

[Talapus]

I remember that. Wicked was free verse and we thought she was scum.

And the game ended with Wicked being annoyed with me and LSU still haven't forgiven me for lynching him.

In the end though, you made the right choice mandy ...I thank you

[Incandenza]

Inca sounded like Dante with a beer in his hand, reciting while he watches baseball

It's like you're reading my mind. Most of the time, my verses were composed with beer in hand while watching baseball. Creeeeeepy. And if you think it's easy to just toss off terza rima while drinking and watching baseball, you'd be incorrect!