best mafia player

[kwanton]

You can compare baseball players because they all play the same game, very rarely do mafia games carry any sort of consistences other then some rules and a few roles.

No consistencies? That's not completely true. Mandy is always scum and fircoal is always dumb. Always.

[derfderf34]

why arent i on the list

or spiesr he isnt horrible

[diddle]

i chose the 'me' option, assuming that it meant 'me', as in diddle

[mandalorian2298]

You can compare baseball players because they all play the same game, very rarely do mafia games carry any sort of consistences other then some rules and a few roles.

No consistencies? That's not completely true. Mandy is always scum and fircoal is always dumb. Always.

I think that you got that backwards.

[Fircoal]

I voted me, of course.

Though I think others really are better.

[0ojakeo0]

i chose the 'me' option, assuming that it meant 'me', as in diddle

of course

[nagerous]

How is fircoal winning this poll?

[lord voldemort]

How is fircoal winning this poll?

that poll is so incomplete

[nagerous]

How the hell does jake have 2 votes, whilst koesen, kalish and tal etc. have 0.


STOOOOOOOPID!

[Fircoal]

How is fircoal winning this poll?

don't know, but you have a bit of a point about the rest, but really I'm not THAT bad at playing. not THAT good either though.

[lord voldemort]

How is fircoal winning this poll?

don't know, but you have a bit of a point about the rest, but really I'm not THAT bad at playing. not THAT good either though.

ill agree with that but imo the best player when he is active is prolly french...
others not far behind, kal, ml, talp, nag

[mandalorian2298]

I have more points then Tonka, ML and Tal combined! Go me! (and go bad polls that boost my ego)

[jnd94]

lolcats, jake just made this so he could put his name up there. If I had to choose someone who has been EXCELLENT in my mafia career, it would have to be autoload. Can't believe he wasn't mentioned yet. Great player.

[pmchugh]

I voted for pcm despite not having a clue who it was, only voted for them because their name is close to mine.

In my short time here ive been most impressed with ga7, selin and ML.

Dont think Ive ever played withTalp but hes has made a great game in Grimms.

[ga7]

My pick would be Selin, he's dreadfully pwning in general. Else Nag got his touch back lately

[Fircoal]

I'm not up there

Where is Mountain Lion? Anyway, it will be hard to decide as long as Lion and Talapus keep geting the only Scum roles and Tonka keeps geting Town roles.

Tonka was scum once, and I lynched him for it

Once isn't enough. Mods, make Tonka evil! (Just so that Fircoal doesn't paste this in my upcoming game, roles will be asigned RANDOMLY.)

I wonder who gets this?

[Fircoal]

I voted me, of course.

Though I think others really are better.

Ok honest opinion I'd say Frenchie-chan, Nag, Selin, Mandy, and ML.

Probably best I'd say Frenchie-chan

[mandalorian2298]

I'm not up there

Where is Mountain Lion? Anyway, it will be hard to decide as long as Lion and Talapus keep geting the only Scum roles and Tonka keeps geting Town roles.

Tonka was scum once, and I lynched him for it

Once isn't enough. Mods, make Tonka evil! (Just so that Fircoal doesn't paste this in my upcoming game, roles will be asigned RANDOMLY.)

I wonder who gets this?

That has been written before my NJO Mafia, my forgetfull little buddy.

[militant]

I am suprised no one has mentioned AD before now

[mr. incrediball]

i'd say the player who has most interested me has to be... bryguy.

[Talapus]

How is Fircoal winning this . Unless of course you meant to say, "Best mafia player(For a first day lynch)". Because in that context, it makes total sense

[animorpherv1]

your only saying that becasue you have 1 vote. Mine was Fircoal, I think he is the best mafia player around, and one of the most active on their.

[got tonkaed]

Subjectively i can only make a poll with players ive played with....so my top 5.

1)selin -though you could make the claim that this more recent bias, i dont know of a player who is as good at figuring out who is who. Probably an asset to his side, no matter what side it is.
2)Incandenza -probably the player who would have been number 1 before selin, but i havent played with him in a while, but i remember thinking he was top notch.
3)Aimless - pretty tough for town to defeat if he is scum and is very sharp at managing the impression he wants within a game.
4)MountainLion -probably had the best introductory performance ive seen and hasnt really lost a step since. You could probably make a pretty good argument he is number 3, but a top flight player nonetheless.
5)Sierra_Leon -imo the best of the newer players after selin and ML, someone who like aimless is very good at portraying themselves in the light that they wish to be seen. tough to beat no matter what affiliation.

Other players who are right about at that point...
Nagerous, Talapus, exile, ga7,mando.

[Fircoal]

Once isn't enough. Mods, make Tonka evil! (Just so that Fircoal doesn't paste this in my upcoming game, roles will be asigned RANDOMLY.)

I wonder who gets this?

That has been written before my NJO Mafia, my forgetfull little buddy. [/quote]

I know... I mean the refernse of when I did that.

[Fircoal]

How is Fircoal winning this . Unless of course you meant to say, "Best mafia player(For a first day lynch)". Because in that context, it makes total sense

you make me sad.