The Werewolves of Miller's Hollow Wolves win

[swang918]

I doubt dega can protect the same person two nights in a row. Does dega know?

Either way i dont see any way really that devante survives tonight

[Devante]

No I expect I'm puppie chow at this point

[Votanic]

Curious what EW thinks, surprising he's been staying off the radar so much

Me too. I thought he was more gung-ho about Mafia games...

And yes, it did cross my mind that if the Bear-Tamer role could get a false signal from a Townish Third Party, then maybe the Confessor and Seer roles could also get a false signal from a Townish Third Party...
However, Confessor and Seer are told role and alignment, while the Bear-Tamer only gets told that the players in question are not wolves...

FPed by swang and Devante.
Dega probably knows, but you may be right about no two nights in a row...

[Votanic]

So this is what I'm guesstimating now... and yes, I could be totally wrong.

• Ewebasher is Town
• Thor60 is a Third-party who wins with the wolves (or maybe just wins by not being killed.)
• Either Pixar or swang is a Wolf.... and I'm leaning slightly towards swang, which is why I'm voting for him.

[Devante]

I don't know, very torn here...

[SoN!c]

End of the day will be February 1rst at 18:00 CC time

It's Januari 30th 02.13 CCT now so we have a small 40 hours to decide..

I suggest Ragian catches up on reading and Deg put's his idea in here too. EW is probably too many pages behind by now?

Are we Swinging for Swang? Looks like it..

Dega already posted he had a light preference for Swang if i remember correctly?

[Ragian]

I suggest you harass someone else

I think I wrote that I was caught up a couple of pages ago. I don't like Thor's play. The simplest explanation is that he is bad for town. He might be something else, but he'll continue to be an interruption. I think he is the best way to go. He might even be a wolf. In which case Ewe is a wolf.

I don't think Swang is a wolf.

Vote Thor

[*Pixar*]

I suggest you harass someone else

I think I wrote that I was caught up a couple of pages ago. I don't like Thor's play. The simplest explanation is that he is bad for town. He might be something else, but he'll continue to be an interruption. I think he is the best way to go. He might even be a wolf. In which case Ewe is a wolf.

I don't think Swang is a wolf.

Vote Thor

Not sure about the whole swang ordeal but yeah I wouldn't put too much thought on Thor's posts, seems to me Traf reached out to him telling him to post OR ELSE, so he came in here with some mumbo jumbo. Also, I want to state more than happy enough to have Devante check me tonight and not in a sexual way

Vote Thor

[SoN!c]

Also, I want to state more than happy enough to have Devante check me tonight and not in a sexual way

Still a few questions to be answered first.., to start you very well know that Deve (seer) is gonna get wolf targetted tonight right? So why do you even say this?

Second, the wolf radio is still a very good clue; we should exploit it more: im suprised you didn't do it yourself? Only you know if its true or not after all..

Night 1 Chat: "i'm happy to go with whatever you guys choose including nominating me to eat someone."

Night 2 Chat: "I reckon I should be the one todo the dirty again though whoever it is as chances are my game is up tomorrow?"

Night 3 Chat: "im going to stay on the low low for next day as I feel this game is coming to an end for us soon."

On night 3 chat LC was dead as a doornail (Razored Day 3) so this - if the wolf radio chat is true - is said by the remaining wolves..(plural) Why chat if your the last one standing right? So we are looking for 2 wolves for sure

Now with "i reckon" in there (said by LC on N2) i believe the wolf radio is genuine - at least until N2

So either Pix made up the Little Girl and posted his own chat or we are looking for 2 wolves. I said before if it's 2 wolves left its Ewe and Thor but after the Thor HELL show im not so sure anymore..

Because if its true one of them said he was going to stay "on the low-low" on D4 (in deviation of his previous D1-D2-D3 activity)?

Night 3 Chat: "im going to stay on the low low for next day as I feel this game is coming to an end for us soon."

Was this said by Thor? He was on the "low low" all game long as far i can remember?

And LC as wolf should have had a safe counterclaim provided by Traf. But he didn't - he used seer. So with no counterclaim provided i can't see EWE (Stu) coming up with the beartamer sniff?

[*Pixar*]

Also, I want to state more than happy enough to have Devante check me tonight and not in a sexual way

Still a few questions to be answered first.., to start you very well know that Deve (seer) is gonna get wolf targetted tonight right? So why do you even say this?

Second, the wolf radio is still a very good clue; we should exploit it more: im suprised you didn't do it yourself? Only you know if its true or not after all..

Night 1 Chat: "i'm happy to go with whatever you guys choose including nominating me to eat someone."

Night 2 Chat: "I reckon I should be the one todo the dirty again though whoever it is as chances are my game is up tomorrow?"

Night 3 Chat: "im going to stay on the low low for next day as I feel this game is coming to an end for us soon."

On night 3 chat LC was dead as a doornail (Razored Day 3) so this - if the wolf radio chat is true - is said by the remaining wolves..(plural) Why chat if your the last one standing right? So we are looking for 2 wolves for sure

Now with "i reckon" in there (said by LC on N2) i believe the wolf radio is genuine - at least until N2

So either Pix made up the Little Girl and posted his own chat or we are looking for 2 wolves. I said before if it's 2 wolves left its Ewe and Thor but after the Thor HELL show im not so sure anymore..

Because if its true one of them said he was going to stay "on the low-low" on D4 (in deviation of his previous D1-D2-D3 activity)?

Night 3 Chat: "im going to stay on the low low for next day as I feel this game is coming to an end for us soon."

Was this said by Thor? He was on the "low low" all game long as far i can remember?

And LC as wolf should have had a safe counterclaim provided by Traf. But he didn't - he used seer. So with no counterclaim provided i can't see EWE (Stu) coming up with the beartamer sniff?

I've basically stated that Thor was on the "low low" all game already, after I revealed my role. There's not much more to dissect. But being a newish mafia host do you really think Traf gave the wolves safe counterclaims? I doubt it, especially after LC claimed a role, he probably was hoping didn't have a counter to it. Claiming Seer when swang wasn't really giving me any vibes that he would use his barber action on him just yet was a BALLSY move.

[*Pixar*]

Also I might have missed something, why can't degaston defend Devante tonight?

[Ragian]

Sometimes, a proctecting role isn't allowed to protect the same player twice (in a row). Sometimes, a protecting role isn't allowed to protect herself. Both might be the case here. One might be the case here. Neither might be the case here. It is only for dega to know, and he should not share that information with anyone. Leave the wolves guessing. Maybe we can thwart yet another wolf attack.

[*Pixar*]

Sometimes, a proctecting role isn't allowed to protect the same player twice (in a row). Sometimes, a protecting role isn't allowed to protect herself. Both might be the case here. One might be the case here. Neither might be the case here. It is only for dega to know, and he should not share that information with anyone. Leave the wolves guessing. Maybe we can thwart yet another wolf attack.

Ahhh thanks makes sense, I'm use to a doc role and not so much a defender.

[degaston]

I started a new job this week, so my time is a bit limited. I don't know what the deal with Thor is, but I think we may as well find that out first. I won't vote at the moment (I don't even know how many he has right now) so we can continue to discuss, but he seems like as good a target as any.

[*Pixar*]

Believe it's just me and Ragian so far so 3 votes.

[SoN!c]

I started a new job this week, so my time is a bit limited. I don't know what the deal with Thor is, but I think we may as well find that out first. I won't vote at the moment (I don't even know how many he has right now) so we can continue to discuss, but he seems like as good a target as any.

If Thor is a wolf it's game over but what if Thor flips town/3P?

I think the vote count is:

Thor: 2 votes; Ragian, Pixar
Swang: 3 votes; Ewebasher, Thor, Votanic

[Ragian]

@Son!c, Pix is the Sheriff.

[TrafalgarLaw01]

Vote count:

Thor - 3 votes - Ragian, Pixar
Pixar - 1 vote - swang
Swang - 3 votes - Ewe, Thor, Votanic

Reminder EoD is February 1rst at 18:00 CC time.

[Ewebasher]

Because if its true one of them said he was going to stay "on the low-low" on D4 (in deviation of his previous D1-D2-D3 activity)?

Night 3 Chat: "im going to stay on the low low for next day as I feel this game is coming to an end for us soon."

Was this said by Thor? He was on the "low low" all game long as far i can remember?

So (admittedly assuming this chat is real) who among the remaining possible wolves has been consistently active?

Rules me out as I was getting suspected purely for being quiet at the beginning of the day (doesn't prove I'm not a wolf admittedly just that I didn't say the quote from the 'chat')

EW has been quiet as well (in fact when did we last hear from him?)

Swang, Pixar & Vot (the lab must be backed up on that DNA test) have been fairly consistently active (at least that's my impression, I must confess I haven't gone back and checked post counts on each day) so no one has suddenly gone on the "low low" but maybe developments have meant they've had to be more active than intended?

[swang918]

I still think ewe is a better lynch than thor, to capture the chance that wolf ewe “cleared” a town thor.

I get that im not cleared with the rest of town. But from my perspective, i know that im town. Therefore the remaining wolves-and theres most likely two— are between pix, ewe, and thor. In that case, the possible combos are pix and ewe, or ewe and thor. Pix and thor is not possible.

[SoN!c]

@Son!c, Pix is the Sheriff.

Yes got FP by Pix but didnt noticed it.. sometimes there pops up the screen where you can see the FP before submitting but sometimes it doesnt.. no idea why

FP by Swang - it pops up now lol

[SoN!c]

February 1rst at 18:00 CC time is more then time enough to decide so these are the candidates:

Thor - 3 votes - Ragian, Pixar (sheriff)
Pixar - 1 vote - swang
Swang - 3 votes - Ewe, Thor, Votanic
Ewebasher - 0 votes

If Pixar is town the chat indicates LC was leading the wolves until his demise D3. I just can't see the very experienced players being put in that rear "back seat" position. His death then also explains the N3 chat.. "as I feel this game is coming to an end for us soon."

Again, if Pix is town, we are looking for 2 wolves (nobody - except Loose perhaps - would chat to himself). It rules out the "last lone wolf" possibility Swang to me.

Vote Ewebasher


Sorry Stu - if im wrong beers -or a good red wine- are on me

Sorry but i already said that last line sounds as you

[Ewebasher]

No apology required SoN, all part of the game. Not quite sure how you think the last line could be me though (see my previous post).

I may hold you to that red wine offer though

[SoN!c]

No apology required SoN, all part of the game. Not quite sure how you think the last line could be me though (see my previous post).

I may hold you to that red wine offer though

I think you answered that already yourself "but maybe developments have meant they've (you in fact) had to be more active than intended?"

PM your adres i'll ship a nice bottle out to Scotland if im wrong ofcourse

[Ewebasher]

Because if its true one of them said he was going to stay "on the low-low" on D4 (in deviation of his previous D1-D2-D3 activity)?

Night 3 Chat: "im going to stay on the low low for next day as I feel this game is coming to an end for us soon."

Was this said by Thor? He was on the "low low" all game long as far i can remember?

Bit in bold is the part that I was using as my argument...

Developments and more active related to those that had been active and were hoping to take a back seat...