Page 38 of 55
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Sun Jun 12, 2011 1:21 pm
by strike wolf
It actually seems like there were a lot of stopped lips last night. Cadfael, the demon hunter who's probably van helsing, whoever nam's target was( I don't find it worthy of speculating as the scene is too vague on the group's alignment, who they are character or player wise or anything else that might be of usem) and it seems nosferatu may have dodged death from the first attacker only to be killed by a second. That last one I find particularly interesting if true.
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Sun Jun 12, 2011 3:03 pm
by VioIet
strike wolf wrote:I wouldn't say that iliad. The shadow was injured last night and the scene specifically said that Nosferatu was still injured from the previous night. Great night for town. It seems someone saved a townie from being Nosferatu's target, nosferatu later killed and the original werewolf killed by a "demon hunter"
I disagree.
freezie wrote:Good job town
Alright, I am here only for a small moment ( got a very busy day ahead: Driver's license, gf coming over and bunch of stupid work around the house ) but I'll re-read tonight and tomorow and see if something catches my eye...Or if strike has another stroke of genius

. Anyway, I need to note something about someone who has been acting..yea, you know:
VioIet wrote:Freezie is on this bandwagon, and if Rodion turns up town, I will make a note of that.
Now that Rodion turned out to be a vampire, what do you have to say violet? Still hate me like you can't stand garlic? Or maybe you'll finally spit out what you've been hiding so well, well enough to prevent you to post anything most of the time?
I still say the same exact thing. You are dangerous for town.
strike wolf wrote:It actually seems like there were a lot of stopped lips last night. Cadfael, the demon hunter who's probably van helsing, whoever nam's target was( I don't find it worthy of speculating as the scene is too vague on the group's alignment, who they are character or player wise or anything else that might be of usem) and it seems nosferatu may have dodged death from the first attacker only to be killed by a second. That last one I find particularly interesting if true.
QFT
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Sun Jun 12, 2011 3:47 pm
by Talapus
Ok all, I took over for someone(Not sure who, maybe Steaker....lol). But as 62 pages is a lot I need to look back more thuroughly and see what I find. I read once through already but hard to absorb details from 62 pages of posts....lol. I hope to post sosmething a bit more thought provoking later on tonight or early tomorrow though, promis.
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Sun Jun 12, 2011 3:55 pm
by DoomYoshi
VioIet wrote:freezie wrote:Good job town
Alright, I am here only for a small moment ( got a very busy day ahead: Driver's license, gf coming over and bunch of stupid work around the house ) but I'll re-read tonight and tomorow and see if something catches my eye...Or if strike has another stroke of genius

. Anyway, I need to note something about someone who has been acting..yea, you know:
VioIet wrote:Freezie is on this bandwagon, and if Rodion turns up town, I will make a note of that.
Now that Rodion turned out to be a vampire, what do you have to say violet? Still hate me like you can't stand garlic? Or maybe you'll finally spit out what you've been hiding so well, well enough to prevent you to post anything most of the time?
I still say the same exact thing. You are dangerous for town.
Could you perhaps elaborate on why you think this?
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Sun Jun 12, 2011 5:16 pm
by strike wolf
VioIet wrote:strike wolf wrote:I wouldn't say that iliad. The shadow was injured last night and the scene specifically said that Nosferatu was still injured from the previous night. Great night for town. It seems someone saved a townie from being Nosferatu's target, nosferatu later killed and the original werewolf killed by a "demon hunter"
I disagree.
freezie wrote:Good job town
Alright, I am here only for a small moment ( got a very busy day ahead: Driver's license, gf coming over and bunch of stupid work around the house ) but I'll re-read tonight and tomorow and see if something catches my eye...Or if strike has another stroke of genius

. Anyway, I need to note something about someone who has been acting..yea, you know:
VioIet wrote:Freezie is on this bandwagon, and if Rodion turns up town, I will make a note of that.
Now that Rodion turned out to be a vampire, what do you have to say violet? Still hate me like you can't stand garlic? Or maybe you'll finally spit out what you've been hiding so well, well enough to prevent you to post anything most of the time?
I still say the same exact thing. You are dangerous for town.
I am not sure what you are getting at here vio...the first part you disagree with me but offer no rebuttal as to why my conclusion could be false almost as if you are just disagreeing to disagree. Then you have continued your campaign against freezie but while admitting to having an agenda against him and stating matter of factly that he is a danger to the town, you have not sufficiently gone into how or why. I am saying this because even if you are being truthful and freezie is scum of some kind if you continue down this road you are probably going to be lynched.
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Sun Jun 12, 2011 6:46 pm
by safariguy5
While I personally have no real love for freezie this game either, I haven't seen any real evidence to prove that he's scum. He presented a somewhat true case on me that made me at least back off a little bit, but besides that, not much that can really be considered scummy.
Do you have any evidence for freezie being mafia Vio?
Also, I wonder why the Night 1 scene abbreviated some things (like Rodion being recruited) while the Night 2 scene was much more descriptive. I'm thinking it could be a power of a role's, but I'm not sure.
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Sun Jun 12, 2011 9:21 pm
by freezie
VioIet wrote:freezie wrote:Good job town
Alright, I am here only for a small moment ( got a very busy day ahead: Driver's license, gf coming over and bunch of stupid work around the house ) but I'll re-read tonight and tomorow and see if something catches my eye...Or if strike has another stroke of genius

. Anyway, I need to note something about someone who has been acting..yea, you know:
VioIet wrote:Freezie is on this bandwagon, and if Rodion turns up town, I will make a note of that.
Now that Rodion turned out to be a vampire, what do you have to say violet? Still hate me like you can't stand garlic? Or maybe you'll finally spit out what you've been hiding so well, well enough to prevent you to post anything most of the time?
I still say the same exact thing. You are dangerous for town.
[sarcasm]
Yea I know I am quite the danger in town..However I am not dangerous FOR the town. Slight wording mistake there
[/sarcasm]
Vote: VioletI reread the thread a little and for now I'll set my eyes on Violet, who keeps acting scummier and scummier by the minute.
But, anyway:
FoS: Doomyoshi for speedy skimming
FoS: Safari for contradicting himself on his gaming behavioursafariguy5 wrote:While I personally have no real love for freezie this game either, I haven't seen any real evidence to prove that he's scum. He presented a somewhat true case on me that made me at least back off a little bit, but besides that, not much that can really be considered scummy.
Dude...I said half of day 2 my only accusations that remained from me is the fact you CONTRADICTED yourself. true I said you were going for an easy lynch, especially against nam..But I backed off from that. I am neither Target nor Ndrs, mind you.
Hence why I am been focusing on other stuff...And well because going after the same guy a whole day without any other support from the town is useless.
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Sun Jun 12, 2011 10:17 pm
by safariguy5
freezie wrote:VioIet wrote:freezie wrote:Good job town
Alright, I am here only for a small moment ( got a very busy day ahead: Driver's license, gf coming over and bunch of stupid work around the house ) but I'll re-read tonight and tomorow and see if something catches my eye...Or if strike has another stroke of genius

. Anyway, I need to note something about someone who has been acting..yea, you know:
VioIet wrote:Freezie is on this bandwagon, and if Rodion turns up town, I will make a note of that.
Now that Rodion turned out to be a vampire, what do you have to say violet? Still hate me like you can't stand garlic? Or maybe you'll finally spit out what you've been hiding so well, well enough to prevent you to post anything most of the time?
I still say the same exact thing. You are dangerous for town.
[sarcasm]
Yea I know I am quite the danger in town..However I am not dangerous FOR the town. Slight wording mistake there
[/sarcasm]
Vote: VioletI reread the thread a little and for now I'll set my eyes on Violet, who keeps acting scummier and scummier by the minute.
But, anyway:
FoS: Doomyoshi for speedy skimming
FoS: Safari for contradicting himself on his gaming behavioursafariguy5 wrote:While I personally have no real love for freezie this game either, I haven't seen any real evidence to prove that he's scum. He presented a somewhat true case on me that made me at least back off a little bit, but besides that, not much that can really be considered scummy.
Dude...I said half of day 2 my only accusations that remained from me is the fact you CONTRADICTED yourself. true I said you were going for an easy lynch, especially against nam..But I backed off from that. I am neither Target nor Ndrs, mind you.
Hence why I am been focusing on other stuff...And well because going after the same guy a whole day without any other support from the town is useless.
Then why the FoS again? You said you're dropping the rest of the case and won't continue to pursue me, but why continue to bring up the contradiction as grounds for a FOS? Now you're either flip flopping or contradicting yourself.
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Sun Jun 12, 2011 10:31 pm
by freezie
safariguy5 wrote:freezie wrote:VioIet wrote:freezie wrote:Good job town
Alright, I am here only for a small moment ( got a very busy day ahead: Driver's license, gf coming over and bunch of stupid work around the house ) but I'll re-read tonight and tomorow and see if something catches my eye...Or if strike has another stroke of genius

. Anyway, I need to note something about someone who has been acting..yea, you know:
VioIet wrote:Freezie is on this bandwagon, and if Rodion turns up town, I will make a note of that.
Now that Rodion turned out to be a vampire, what do you have to say violet? Still hate me like you can't stand garlic? Or maybe you'll finally spit out what you've been hiding so well, well enough to prevent you to post anything most of the time?
I still say the same exact thing. You are dangerous for town.
[sarcasm]
Yea I know I am quite the danger in town..However I am not dangerous FOR the town. Slight wording mistake there
[/sarcasm]
Vote: VioletI reread the thread a little and for now I'll set my eyes on Violet, who keeps acting scummier and scummier by the minute.
But, anyway:
FoS: Doomyoshi for speedy skimming
FoS: Safari for contradicting himself on his gaming behavioursafariguy5 wrote:While I personally have no real love for freezie this game either, I haven't seen any real evidence to prove that he's scum. He presented a somewhat true case on me that made me at least back off a little bit, but besides that, not much that can really be considered scummy.
Dude...I said half of day 2 my only accusations that remained from me is the fact you CONTRADICTED yourself. true I said you were going for an easy lynch, especially against nam..But I backed off from that. I am neither Target nor Ndrs, mind you.
Hence why I am been focusing on other stuff...And well because going after the same guy a whole day without any other support from the town is useless.
Then why the FoS again? You said you're dropping the rest of the case and won't continue to pursue me, but why continue to bring up the contradiction as grounds for a FOS? Now you're either flip flopping or contradicting yourself.
I fos you for the contradiction, I dropped the rest of the case which made me vote you before.
Still suspicious, but not worth avote against other stuff?
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Sun Jun 12, 2011 10:36 pm
by safariguy5
Fair enough I guess, and I would like to see what sort of case Vio can build before I make any decisions.
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Sun Jun 12, 2011 11:25 pm
by Commander9
Apologies - yesterday I was extremely tired after writing the scene and today I have been out the whole day. I will update and fix everything tomorrow.
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Mon Jun 13, 2011 12:14 pm
by DoomYoshi
@freezie: Speedy Skimming? Is this a continuation of your previous case against me, or do you have some new evidence?
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Mon Jun 13, 2011 2:08 pm
by Commander9
Commander9 wrote:Apologies - yesterday I was extremely tired after writing the scene and today I have been out the whole day. I will update and fix everything tomorrow.
Thread updated.
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Mon Jun 13, 2011 2:11 pm
by TheSaxlad
I also have to ask are there any more pokemon out there?
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Mon Jun 13, 2011 3:41 pm
by Bleed_Green
strike wolf wrote:I wouldn't say that iliad. The shadow was injured last night and the scene specifically said that Nosferatu was still injured from the previous night. Great night for town. It seems someone saved a townie from being Nosferatu's target, nosferatu later killed and the original werewolf killed by a "demon hunter"
Reading the scene over, I do not show were it reads that the Shadow was injured last night.
As they rode away, the Shadow cursed his luck - he was almost ready with his poison dart, but he understood that attracting too much attention would have been a mistake. "Oh well, there's always another day" he thought to himself and retreated back into the woods.
I would have to think that the Shadow and Nosferatu are 2 different people. Nosferatu obviously has met his fate. Could it possibly be Lycius was the one that killed him and this was the task the Lycaon asked him to complete since a werewolf was present prior to his beheading.
Here is just a general question since this being just my second game. In a game this large how may parties can there be, the reason I ask is there is obviously the town, and a scum, but with it coming up with werewolves and vampires which seem to be 2 different parties.
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Mon Jun 13, 2011 3:43 pm
by DoomYoshi
Apparently Commander has had 5 different factions in a game before.
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Mon Jun 13, 2011 3:46 pm
by safariguy5
DoomYoshi wrote:Apparently Commander has had 5 different factions in a game before.
That would be Post Apoc mafia. I haven't seen two anti town cult factions before though.
That said, I don't think the Knights Templar are anti-town, just a mason faction possibly?
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Mon Jun 13, 2011 4:12 pm
by strike wolf
Bleed_Green wrote:strike wolf wrote:I wouldn't say that iliad. The shadow was injured last night and the scene specifically said that Nosferatu was still injured from the previous night. Great night for town. It seems someone saved a townie from being Nosferatu's target, nosferatu later killed and the original werewolf killed by a "demon hunter"
Reading the scene over, I do not show were it reads that the Shadow was injured last night.
last night as in night 1. Should I point out where the night 1 scene showed that there was an attempt on his life and how night 2's scene clearly said Nosferatu was still injured from last night's attempt on his life? Perhaps where it said the shadow attacked Jacque Chevalier and Jacque was lynched and turned up vamperized? I do not think it is bad to overestimate scum in most instances but chasing phantoms isn't going to do us any good.
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Mon Jun 13, 2011 5:17 pm
by Bleed_Green
safariguy5 wrote:DoomYoshi wrote:Apparently Commander has had 5 different factions in a game before.
That would be Post Apoc mafia. I haven't seen two anti town cult factions before though.
That said, I don't think the Knights Templar are anti-town, just a mason faction possibly?
I would agree have to agree that the Knights Templar are some other fraction then anti-town.
I think with Rodions character being converted to a vampire would but them as an anti town fraction, as for the werewolves I am not to sure where they would stand since one just attempted to kill Nosferatu but that is there only attempt for a kill.
Strike Wolf - sorry I went back and reread the N1 scene and it shows that there was then attempt on the shadow but his reflex saved him, did not say anything about injury but with Nosferatu N2 death scene pointing out with the attempt on his life failing I would have to agree with that the Shadow has been found.
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Mon Jun 13, 2011 7:57 pm
by freezie
DoomYoshi wrote:@freezie: Speedy Skimming? Is this a continuation of your previous case against me, or do you have some new evidence?
I'll ask you a question in answer to your's:
Did I post any new evidence?
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Mon Jun 13, 2011 11:25 pm
by gimli1990
hey all i do not have anything concrete this being one of 3 games i am in and them being the only i have plaued i am a little confused on this one.
and on top of that i have a new little brother born at 12:41 AM today so i am a little tired.
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Tue Jun 14, 2011 12:17 am
by DoomYoshi
freezie wrote:DoomYoshi wrote:@freezie: Speedy Skimming? Is this a continuation of your previous case against me, or do you have some new evidence?
I'll ask you a question in answer to your's:
Did I post any new evidence?
You didn't, but usually one doesn't reFOS somebody. Furthermore, you never actually found evidence of my skimming.
You claimed multiple times that you explained something, but you never satisfactorily explained it. If wanting a further explanation is scummy, or an example of skimming, then I am guilty. I think I have probably read your posts more carefully than anyone else in this game; you were the one who was skimming (such as when you claimed that you had unvoted, when you clearly hadn't) and using unjustified pronouns.
In any case, that argument is so yesterday I am not sure why it was brought up again.
We got the original vamp and original werewolf, but there is one thing we are overlooking. They probably got a recruit last night that still counted. WARNING: This argument does contain some WIFOM. If I was the vampire (or werewolf) I would recruit Bleed, simply because Rodion flipping scum would clear Bleed in town's eyes. Obviously, with both of them dead, we can't ask them. However, I would suggest that Bleed be the number one investigation target tonight.
Congratulations to your mother Gimli... unless she is also your wife

Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Tue Jun 14, 2011 12:17 am
by nagerous
TheSaxlad wrote:I also have to ask are there any more pokemon out there?
Isn't that pushing for others to claim? I don't really like that policy.
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Tue Jun 14, 2011 12:49 am
by Talapus
nagerous wrote:TheSaxlad wrote:I also have to ask are there any more pokemon out there?
Isn't that pushing for others to claim? I don't really like that policy.
Ya, it's rather early for anything like that. And quite honestly with the variety of roles I've seen posted in the day scenes it would be too early to verify much af anything at this point.
Re: [UNKNOWN] Mafia Day 3 - Divina Commedia.
Posted: Tue Jun 14, 2011 1:41 am
by TheSaxlad
nagerous wrote:TheSaxlad wrote:I also have to ask are there any more pokemon out there?
Isn't that pushing for others to claim? I don't really like that policy.
No. But I can see how knights templars, vampires and werewolfs, and pokemon fit in the same mafia game.