Game of Thrones Mafia 9/24 Night 6: End Game Vote 4 MVP

[IAmRobik]

Getting maf RB should be HUUUUUUUUUUGE for us.

[strike wolf]

A major win for town. That makes two days in a row.

[betiko]

Hehe! Can I get doc tonight please? Between mafia and a psych vig on my back I m gonna need it.

Also, unfortunately Y told us that his tracking is random and he doesn t get to chose. If we re lucky, randomness will make him track X again, but I doubt it.

[legionnare]

Well that's certainly interesting so Betiko's theory stacks up then. Seems a bit OP to me that all Player X has to do is visit a town and know who is the Anti in there, maybe it was random though, ah well a solid theory keep it up!

FP'd by Betiko

[27ninjabunnies]

Okay things I would watch out for.

Betiko should be medic saved since he has the most information on who X is, and can further help the game.

Everyone else in KL is cleared, so we might be the next one's today. (In a way, I'm okay with this).

SW, Boone, you can't read me for shit. Rob however can. GJ

Also Rob is town Back off of him people. Even tho I didn't like JAK, I can read Rob a whole lot better.

Another thing, I think Boone, I, and SW should have a list of town and mafia to give out before the end of the night. This makes it easier and something town can use in case one of us, or multiples of us, die.

[27ninjabunnies]

Actually, if there is a jailkeeper that can protect a night kill, you should probably be on one of the KL people too.

[Zivel]

Update:

Spoiler

Towns:

Braavos
Zivel (Arya Stark, can kill once per cycle if knows character and username)
IAmRobik
kgb007
Army of God

Kings Landing
Iron Butterfly (Brienne Tarth, self sacrifice bodyguard)
HotShot (Stannis Baratheon, Alignment Match Cop)
boonetown
27ninjabunnies
Strike Wolf
pershy (Shae, roleblocker)

The Dread Fort
crasp (Petyr Baelish, knows where the throne is)
firth4eva (Gregor Clegane, bulletproof)
Betiko (tree stump?)
mtamburini (TheonGreyjoy, busdriver)

Storms End
Jonty (Margaery Tyrell, Lover/Watcher of sorts?)

Unknown
MudPuppy, SiriusCowKing, pancakemix, Nebuchadnezer, charm, Epitaph1, jwiedlin, legionnare, pretender77 and that bloody throne.

Fine Print: if it is in brackets then I hold no responsibility if its wrong

[pershy]

Noooo - you got me.
Well done!

Gg all. Thanks Storr et all for a great game. Enjoy the rest of it but remember that Winter is coming!
Go scum!

[strike wolf]

Well most of these are more feeling anything but I may not have time to reread and form better opinions so I will go ahead and post this. Town should be obvious.

Town
Boone
27ninjabunnies
Betiko
whoever the tracker is.

Leaning Town
Mudpuppy-This is because I played against him when he was mafia in CYOC III. It could just be because he learned from that game but his behavior here appears different to me.
Crasp
Zivel-still some question of his alignment but his ability is proven.
Nebuchadnezer

Neutral
IAmRobik
Siriuscowking
Pancake-If certain people turn up mafia, I am more willing to believe he is scum but for now. I am willing to consider him neutral pending a reread.
AoG
Charm-Ambivalent on this one. Certain things make me think she is town. others make me think she is mafia. I don't like her last night reasons for why she should be considered indisputable town or the whole Secret QT thing but the role block thing seemed like misguided town chat.
KGB

Leaning Scum
Legionaire-His argument against Betiko about the whole Pershy/x/y issue seemed to be a distraction at best and borderline intentional. It struck me more as a failed attempt to try and protect a scummate.
Pretender77
Jweidlin
Epitaph

Scum

[IAmRobik]

What makes Betiko town?

[betiko]

Noooo - you got me.
Well done!

Gg all. Thanks Storr et all for a great game. Enjoy the rest of it but remember that Winter is coming!
Go scum!

Hehe, good D there mate, you were unlucky that X and Y decided to talk and that I came up with that crazy theory that definitely needed to be tested!

Fp

[pretender77]

All I've gotta say is that THE THRONE has placed votes twice and both times it has been on scum. THE THRONE must have some sort of investigative power that gets mafia and also.....I think it's pretty safe to say the throne is town. SAVE BETIKO

fp by rob betiko...And can we kill rob tomorrow? pleaseeee
fp betiko

[strike wolf]

Technically mafia does know who X and Y are.

[betiko]

Well most of these are more feeling anything but I may not have time to reread and form better opinions so I will go ahead and post this. Town should be obvious.

Town
Boone
27ninjabunnies
Betiko
whoever the tracker is.

Leaning Town
Mudpuppy-This is because I played against him when he was mafia in CYOC III. It could just be because he learned from that game but his behavior here appears different to me.
Crasp
Zivel-still some question of his alignment but his ability is proven.
Nebuchadnezer

Neutral
IAmRobik
Siriuscowking
Pancake-If certain people turn up mafia, I am more willing to believe he is scum but for now. I am willing to consider him neutral pending a reread.
AoG
Charm-Ambivalent on this one. Certain things make me think she is town. others make me think she is mafia. I don't like her last night reasons for why she should be considered indisputable town or the whole Secret QT thing but the role block thing seemed like misguided town chat.
KGB

Leaning Scum
Legionaire-His argument against Betiko about the whole Pershy/x/y issue seemed to be a distraction at best and borderline intentional. It struck me more as a failed attempt to try and protect a scummate.
Pretender77
Jweidlin
Epitaph

Scum

i like your list, I feel pretty much the same. I don t know where to put zivel though, too many strange things. If I die just look back at how he has been reacting to my mtam and pershy cases. His power seems a bit strange for scum but could explain the double kill last night (learning a name through the special qt?)
What do you think of X? I hardly could think he s scum.
Legionare is the highest on my scum list right now. He tried everything he could against my pershy case (on my ipad, can t look back to verify but pretty sure he tried to make me claim who X and Y are.. Either him or zivel or both). Pershy was definitely something worth trying and he tried real hard.

Yeah, PCM has been posting way too little. I know he is a great player and he has been way too poker face so far, don t know what this is hidding. I m glad you are pretty cleared in my books strike, as it s hard to deal with you when I don t have a good read.

[IAmRobik]

All I've gotta say is that THE THRONE has placed votes twice and both times it has been on scum. THE THRONE must have some sort of investigative power that gets mafia and also.....I think it's pretty safe to say the throne is town. SAVE BETIKO

fp by rob betiko...And can we kill rob tomorrow? pleaseeee
fp betiko

Please justify why you want me dead if you want me dead. So far there has not been a single accusation against me other than that I'm an asshole (true) and that I'm being disruptive, jokey, and not taking this game serious (100% untrue)

[IAmRobik]

I also still want to get an explanation for why betiko is town. If people are calling him town because he is transferring information from x and y to the thread, that's really really bad justification. He pretty much has to do it, and it's a really easy way to appear town and be helping, but like HE HAS to do it, even if he's town or scum. This shouldn't be alignment indicative.

[strike wolf]

I'll take that as a compliment.

Anyways, yeah. There is a small chance that X is trying to pull the wool over our eyes but with an important role like a Role blocker and visiting Pershy (technically kingslanding) I would lean town. The tracker is almost certainly town.

Betiko also seems town because of his role. Unlynchable is almost certainly town and despite early questions about his actions, he seems town to me.

[pancakemix]

Yeah, PCM has been posting way too little. I know he is a great player and he has been way too poker face so far, don t know what this is hidding. I m glad you are pretty cleared in my books strike, as it s hard to deal with you when I don t have a good read.

What makes you say that?

I also still want to get an explanation for why betiko is town. If people are calling him town because he is transferring information from x and y to the thread, that's really really bad justification. He pretty much has to do it, and it's a really easy way to appear town and be helping, but like HE HAS to do it, even if he's town or scum. This shouldn't be alignment indicative.

We can't lynch him, for one. If he's unlynchable, he's likely town, as strike said. If he's a tree stump, it doesn't matter anyway. Even if we thought he was scum, we wouldn't be able to do anything about it.

[betiko]

Technically mafia does know who X and Y are.

No, this is far from being sure. Storr has confirmed via PM that that antitown includes all third parties.
Out of the 4 in the dread fort we know who the third party is, and so far there is no reason not to trust him. He/she made a pretty legit full claim that doesn t seem to be a danger for town. Basically a character that is one of the good ones with a role that fits well, he/she could ve just said he/she is town but he/she spoke the truth so I will protect his/her ass.
The whole XY conversation started after mtam s death, so mtam could not have reported anything, and the second dread fort antitown is third party..
I think that the dread fort and king s landing are freed cities that can plot together, hope you guys have some cool complementary stuff too.

Fp many times

[betiko]

I also still want to get an explanation for why betiko is town. If people are calling him town because he is transferring information from x and y to the thread, that's really really bad justification. He pretty much has to do it, and it's a really easy way to appear town and be helping, but like HE HAS to do it, even if he's town or scum. This shouldn't be alignment indicative.

I don t know what my alignment is, maybe I m town, maybe i m third party, maybe I m scum.
What I know is that the best thing for you would be to read the thread to make your own opinion. I would be happy if you took this seriously, and I don t mind if you joke around at all, but claiming that you are vig and that you are about to shoot half of the players alive when we don t even know you isn t a smart move. You really felt like a loose canon who would shoot anyone for fun.

[betiko]

Yeah, PCM has been posting way too little. I know he is a great player and he has been way too poker face so far, don t know what this is hidding. I m glad you are pretty cleared in my books strike, as it s hard to deal with you when I don t have a good read.

What makes you say that?

I have a neutral/ leaning town read on you right now and I really don t know what to think about you as you are you and you could be hidding anything.
I think i will put you in the neutral category till very far in the game.

[crasp]

I also still want to get an explanation for why betiko is town. If people are calling him town because he is transferring information from x and y to the thread, that's really really bad justification. He pretty much has to do it, and it's a really easy way to appear town and be helping, but like HE HAS to do it, even if he's town or scum. This shouldn't be alignment indicative.

I know you and betiko have a thing going here but its not helping. betiko was on MT's case in the dreddfort long before it hit the main forum. he has also continuously hunted scum when it would have been easy to just lurk. its not 100% but i would put my hat in there that he is town and pretty useful town. hopefully whatever protection roles town has recognise this and act accordingly.

[crasp]

FP'd betiko

[kgb007]

Rob, I accept him as town bc he is unlynchable, without a vote during the day, which is too overpowering for scum and he unlocked (at least in the main thread) I forgot his role in the mtam case but I think he was correctly on that too

Fp'd by Sw, betiko, crasp

[pretender77]

All I've gotta say is that THE THRONE has placed votes twice and both times it has been on scum. THE THRONE must have some sort of investigative power that gets mafia and also.....I think it's pretty safe to say the throne is town. SAVE BETIKO

fp by rob betiko...And can we kill rob tomorrow? pleaseeee
fp betiko

Please justify why you want me dead if you want me dead. So far there has not been a single accusation against me other than that I'm an asshole (true) and that I'm being disruptive, jokey, and not taking this game serious (100% untrue)

you are absolutely insane. You are asking questons whose answers are obvious if you've read everything