Conquer Club

wicked wrote:ok puff whatever. good luck with that theory of yours.

gee thanks wicked. I think I already mentioned that it's not going to work

Puff can you use your superduperstealthscumfinder to ask fircola what side he's on? Do you think he could be scum?

wicked wrote:Puff can you use your superduperstealthscumfinder to ask fircola what side he's on? Do you think he could be scum?

did you even read this?

Puff wrote:

wicked wrote:ok puff whatever. good luck with that theory of yours.

gee thanks wicked. I think I already mentioned that it's not going to work

Well I'll be off now.

I think I'll back on before the deadline but in case I'm not I'll Vote Fircoal and hope he's scum

Yes I read it. But I'm still laughing that you'd think that would ever work.

You can interpret what fircoal said about we should stop trying to find the names, basicly trying to ask people not to role-claim.


I beleive you asked the same thing a few pages ago Wicked..What would make fircoal more suspicious than you?

True, but he didn't say "don't roleclaim", he said "telling names won't help find scum". Big difference. Plus he hasn't really been participating that much, on day 1 had a lot of joking banter with Mandy where they voted each other (that's a common scum tactic on day 1 to try to distance yourself from your scum buddies and I know Mandy does that), and he's posted nothing really of substance that I saw. He's not on here trying to find scum, he's lying low.

wicked wrote:gamemod: Can we get prods/replacements for willis

As I said in the sherwood game I have had exams the past week and some this week.

and I'm supposed to know that? good luck with exams.

IGS & Spin, I see ya lurking... come on and post.

sorry, i am checking other games and doing 2 vote counts, will be back in later

sorry for "spamming" but willy or no willy there is evidence of mafia janitor as there are unknown roles and its not because hes scottish, I am 75% scottish myself :p

as for this fircoal thing I agree he looks suspicious, however I still think we should lynch firth today, he still is not providing a balanced defence and immediately when wicked says someone else hes like "good point vote fircoal" to attempt measely to get the pressure off himself

nagerous wrote:sorry for "spamming" but willy or no willy there is evidence of mafia janitor as there are unknown roles and its not because hes scottish, I am 75% scottish myself :p

as for this fircoal thing I agree he looks suspicious, however I still think we should lynch firth today, he still is not providing a balanced defence and immediately when wicked says someone else hes like "good point vote fircoal" to attempt measely to get the pressure off himself

you never actually thought that this was my first game and i just agree with everyone who makes a good point.
im not scum

It's hard to say whether firth is just a noob or he's a noob scum. Fircola I'd expect more from. Let's see what he says.

i agree, fircoal post...

i am just a n00b. trust me.

playing the noob argument can pay off but there is just as much chance of noobs being mafia as experience being mafia. it would be nice to hear from fircoal but maybe leave the lynch for another day and see what the night kill brings us

nagerous wrote:playing the noob argument can pay off but there is just as much chance of noobs being mafia as experience being mafia. it would be nice to hear from fircoal but maybe leave the lynch for another day and see what the night kill brings us

only scum want a no lynch

vote nagerous

I'm seeing trends with some of the newer mods to handpick good and/or established players with the mafia roles. That's another reason I'm looking towards Fircola.

hasn't Nag already proven his worth Tres? Or are you just trying to deflect attention from me going after fircola. Tell me what you think of my theories on him.

And BTW, that "only scum want a no lynch" is total BS. I've been scum a LOT, and have ALWAYS wanted a lynch. Best to have the townies do the work for you when you're scum.

wicked wrote:And BTW, that "only scum want a no lynch" is total BS. I've been scum a LOT, and have ALWAYS wanted a lynch. Best to have the townies do the work for you when you're scum.

Only noob scum want a no lynch near the beginning of the game.

Nope, don't agree. noob or not, scum want a lynch. unfortunately, townies need a lynch too to discern any scum tells (e.g. bandwagonning, not voting, etc...).

firth4eva wrote:unvote fircoal

why?

haven't you figured out by now you need to back up your votes and unvotes with sound reasoning?