Page 4 of 30
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 6:22 pm
by william18
Y is probably the sk who has a grudge against the mafia ( vowels) and perhaps is a vig. Or town sk.
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 6:24 pm
by Fircoal
william18 wrote:Y is probably the sk who has a grudge against the mafia ( vowels) and perhaps is a vig. Or town sk.
town sk??? Isn't that the same thing as a vig. And also what gives you that idea, wouldn't he have an equal grudge against the town. Me thinks you might be trying to make it safer for Y.
Fos: William
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 6:27 pm
by animorpherv1
Fircoal's right, a town SK is a vig, a SK has no alinment.
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 6:51 pm
by cmckinney
this is true...so was this some kind of noobihsh mistake by william or what?
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 6:55 pm
by Anarkistsdream
cmckinney wrote:this is true...so was this some kind of noobihsh mistake by william or what?
I think it's a noob mistake... That would be too weird to type when trying to keep something a secret...
On the other hand... *shrug*
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 7:13 pm
by FloresDelMal
i think is a newbie mistake, if i didnt had the frenchy handy for solve this kind of doubts i couldnt have a clue what SK or VIG is, and i think if you never played before is easy to get them wrong.
anyway, as mea culpa for spam with the word of the prophet gunther i counted every single player that posted and how many post did, because the theory of the "submarines" being fishy made much sense to me and this are my results:
12. Suika
13. neoteny
14. CoheedCambria09
17. /
This is the people who have made no post whatsover til now, and those i find more suspiscious, so UNVOTE Fircoal VOTE /
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 7:16 pm
by FloresDelMal
8. lighteningbrain have 0 posts too, i forgot put it in the previous post
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 7:18 pm
by Anarkistsdream
FloresDelMal wrote:i think is a newbie mistake, if i didnt had the frenchy handy for solve this kind of doubts i couldnt have a clue what SK or VIG is, and i think if you never played before is easy to get them wrong.
anyway, as mea culpa for spam with the word of the prophet gunther i counted every single player that posted and how many post did, because the theory of the "submarines" being fishy made much sense to me and this are my results:
12. Suika
13. neoteny
14. CoheedCambria09
17. /
This is the people who have made no post whatsover til now, and those i find more suspiscious, so UNVOTE Fircoal VOTE /
FloresDelMal wrote:8. lighteningbrain have 0 posts too, i forgot put it in the previous post
Flores! That's awesome! I'd dare say you may be a natural at this game.
That is EXACTLY the kind of stuff we look at on Day 1... However, what you have to remember is that not all of these people may be mafia... They may have just become busy with real life or they may not like their role. A lot of new people just won't play if they don't like their role, even though it may be vital for the town.
But EXCELLENT job!
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 7:19 pm
by cmckinney
big fos at all on flores' list
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 8:09 pm
by /
Yeah, sure, sorry I'm late but I hate day one conversations people can get bandwagoned for anything.
Not that more theories really help, but If I were to pick an alignment for "Y" I would think it would be suited as either Town or Mafia traitor, probably the later since 5 or 6 mafia out of 20 town is completely one-sided against the town.
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 8:18 pm
by william18
First I don't consider myself a newbie since i've played almost 20 games on this site. Second of all it's not a mistake if I put vig next to the bracket, (please people don't skim). And fircoal with the classic SAS which is very suspiscious.
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 8:25 pm
by /
william18 wrote:First I don't consider myself a newbie since i've played almost 20 games on this site. Second of all it's not a mistake if I put vig next to the bracket, (please people don't skim). And fircoal with the classic SAS which is very suspiscious.
What bracket are you talking about? That doesn't change the fact there's no such thing as "town sk".
Though either way I don't see how that's suspicious.
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 8:27 pm
by william18
/ wrote:william18 wrote:First I don't consider myself a newbie since i've played almost 20 games on this site. Second of all it's not a mistake if I put vig next to the bracket, (please people don't skim). And fircoal with the classic SAS which is very suspiscious.
What bracket are you talking about? That doesn't change the fact there's no such thing as "town sk".
Though either way I don't see how that's suspicious.
The bracket that said vowels. And Y would obviosly hate the vowels ( mafia) more since he's supposed to be a vowel but technically isn't.
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 8:30 pm
by /
william18 wrote:The bracket that said vowels. And Y would obviosly hate the vowels ( mafia) more since he's supposed to be a vowel but technically isn't.
Yeah, but still I believe you must the one who is skimming, no one was criticizing you for that, they were saying that there is no such thing as a "Town SK" which you suggested as a possibility for "Y".
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 8:52 pm
by william18
OK sure. I let you believe what you want to beleive.
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 9:07 pm
by /
That seems strangely troubling, almost as if you know Y's role for sure rather than a guess, but whatever, I'm not so sure myself right now.
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 9:09 pm
by FloresDelMal
william18 wrote:First I don't consider myself a newbie since i've played almost 20 games on this site. Second of all it's not a mistake if I put vig next to the bracket, (please people don't skim). And fircoal with the classic SAS which is very suspiscious.
First i didnt intend call you "newbie" as an offense,if you took it that way, but still your comment seemed well weird, and now could you please explain what SAS means? frenchy couldnt help me with this one.
Anarkist: thanks, ill try to keep it up, but i dont promise anything
today was my free day but since tomorrow is back to work for me so ill be a little less active (and therefor, less spammy
) and again, thanks for remind me that real life sometimes have a way to get between our games and us heh
now about the 0 post people, i still find it fishy
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 9:13 pm
by Neoteny
Holy shit! I'm in this game!
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 9:14 pm
by william18
FloresDelMal wrote:william18 wrote:First I don't consider myself a newbie since i've played almost 20 games on this site. Second of all it's not a mistake if I put vig next to the bracket, (please people don't skim). And fircoal with the classic SAS which is very suspiscious.
First i didnt intend call you "newbie" as an offense,if you took it that way, but still your comment seemed well weird, and now could you please explain what SAS means? frenchy couldnt help me with this one.
Anarkist: thanks, ill try to keep it up, but i dont promise anything
today was my free day but since tomorrow is back to work for me so ill be a little less active (and therefor, less spammy
) and again, thanks for remind me that real life sometimes have a way to get between our games and us heh
now about the 0 post people, i still find it fishy
SAS: Scum Attention Shift. It when someone acuses you of something light/phrase that they thought was a slip up, usually trying to start a bandwagon a shifting attention, hence the name.
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 10:02 pm
by LSU Tiger Josh
lightning and coheed have both yet to read their pms so they may need to be replaced
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 10:03 pm
by walelia2
I am so beyond confused right now.
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 10:10 pm
by LSU Tiger Josh
LSU Tiger Josh wrote:Vote Count 20 alive 11 to lynch 10 to get a kick to the balls
2 Fircoal (Joodoo, Flores)
2 Sam (Ink, AD)
2 Flores (MIB, Sam)
1 Joodoo (William)
1 Animo (Borox)
1 CMK (Walelia
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 10:17 pm
by Anarkistsdream
William, I firmly believe you...
So, who do you think is Y?
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2008 12:59 am
by Fircoal
william18 wrote:FloresDelMal wrote:william18 wrote:First I don't consider myself a newbie since i've played almost 20 games on this site. Second of all it's not a mistake if I put vig next to the bracket, (please people don't skim). And fircoal with the classic SAS which is very suspiscious.
First i didnt intend call you "newbie" as an offense,if you took it that way, but still your comment seemed well weird, and now could you please explain what SAS means? frenchy couldnt help me with this one.
Anarkist: thanks, ill try to keep it up, but i dont promise anything
today was my free day but since tomorrow is back to work for me so ill be a little less active (and therefor, less spammy
) and again, thanks for remind me that real life sometimes have a way to get between our games and us heh
now about the 0 post people, i still find it fishy
SAS: Scum Attention Shift. It when someone acuses you of something light/phrase that they thought was a slip up, usually trying to start a bandwagon a shifting attention, hence the name.
That's a new one, and also how was I trying to start a bandwagon by pointing out how you may have slipped. I want to take any leads I can, but I want to get the best one to be the lynch. Notice how I didn't vote you but only FOS you. That's awfully unbandwagonish.
Re: Alphabet Mafia Day 1 Begin
Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2008 1:01 am
by Fircoal
Anarkistsdream wrote:FloresDelMal wrote:i think is a newbie mistake, if i didnt had the frenchy handy for solve this kind of doubts i couldnt have a clue what SK or VIG is, and i think if you never played before is easy to get them wrong.
anyway, as mea culpa for spam with the word of the prophet gunther i counted every single player that posted and how many post did, because the theory of the "submarines" being fishy made much sense to me and this are my results:
12. Suika
13. neoteny
14. CoheedCambria09
17. /
This is the people who have made no post whatsover til now, and those i find more suspiscious, so UNVOTE Fircoal VOTE /
FloresDelMal wrote:8. lighteningbrain have 0 posts too, i forgot put it in the previous post
Flores! That's awesome! I'd dare say you may be a natural at this game.
That is EXACTLY the kind of stuff we look at on Day 1... However, what you have to remember is that not all of these people may be mafia... They may have just become busy with real life or they may not like their role. A lot of new people just won't play if they don't like their role, even though it may be vital for the town.
But EXCELLENT job!
Really it's not as good as you think. There are many exceptions that could happen. Though in Rots, it did provide a fair way to start conversation.