Page 23 of 31

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Three - Drawn On and Flipped Off

Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2016 1:12 pm
by strike wolf
For the record, I am the envelope from Clue.

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Three - Drawn On and Flipped Off

Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2016 5:23 pm
by madmitch
@ Strikewolf get stuffed :lol: I never said I was any of them characters you mentioned, I was told I was a deductive reasoned and only allowed to ask yes and no questions, the only bummer is that I can't ask the same question again .You should also noticed that I have not changed my mind about Mets, but it looks like it would be better to go after the cult now and get Mets later, UNVOTE VOTE I.B.

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Three - Drawn On and Flipped Off

Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2016 4:53 am
by Ragian
strike wolf wrote:LSU and Hotshot pretty much have it right. IB is cult recruiter. He recruited me night 2. Why? I guess because he thought I might have something on him which I did. I am the cop and had him as third party/cult after night 1. Why confess? I become third party survivor if IB is lynched or killed. I wanted to help cult win but that doesn't seem likely any more so I'll go with trying to win it on my own. Note: I don't trust madmitch. Im a cop and we have a tracker and watcher. Too many investigative roles. Already have 3 with a role that could have replaced one.
unvote

Right, so this is obviously I.B. vs. strike today. We have Strike saying that I.B. is the recruiter. Hotshot says that I.B. is lying about his P.R. Both damnit evidence. But how do we know that Strike isn't the recruiter? I.B could be a JOAT as he claims (hence he was out and about) while Strike could be the cult recruiter. We can't know for certain.

I'll be back later today.

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Three - Drawn On and Flipped Off

Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2016 5:02 am
by rizky_biznezz
didnt mitch already hammer... unless i missed an unvote

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Three - Drawn On and Flipped Off

Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2016 5:41 am
by Ragian
Don't know. Haven't been counting to be honest.

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Three - Drawn On and Flipped Off

Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2016 2:59 pm
by /
Final Vote Count

Metsfanmax: (1 vote) Ragian
Iron Butterfly: (6 votes) HotShot53, Army of GOD, BuJaber, LSU Tiger Josh, Metsfanmax, madmitch
HotShot53: (1 vote) Iron Butterfly

And that's a lynch!

The sounds of marching echoed against the floors; over plastic, cardboard, and tin alike. There were no more dice, this would be war. Unfortunately, the red army's march was a bit more slight than predicted. The soldier turned conqueror was immediately turned over as the tides of town pieces overwhelmed it. Apparently there was not a whole lot of strategic possibility for a plastic representation of an army off the game map. They pulled until there was red everywhere... But it's okay, because it's all recyclable.

Iron Butterfly Red Risk Soldier, cult recruiter had been lynched!

Night Three begins! You have until Saturday the 30th

Re: Board Game Mafia: Night Three - Take the Risk

Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2016 3:24 pm
by BuJaber
BOOOOOOM

Well done everyone!

Re: Board Game Mafia: Night Three - Take the Risk

Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2016 8:49 pm
by Army of GOD
Amazing how we haven't mislynched yet

Re: Board Game Mafia: Night Three - Take the Risk

Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2016 11:21 pm
by Iron Butterfly
GG guys. Sorry I could not be present to argue but health has been pure suckage.

Re: Board Game Mafia: Night Three - Take the Risk

Posted: Thu Apr 28, 2016 2:18 am
by Ragian
Get well soon, buddy.

Re: Board Game Mafia: Night Three - Take the Risk

Posted: Thu Apr 28, 2016 2:40 am
by BuJaber
Iron Butterfly wrote:GG guys. Sorry I could not be present to argue but health has been pure suckage.
Take care of yourself, that's the most important thing. :) Was great having you around Day 1.

Re: Board Game Mafia: Night Three - Take the Risk

Posted: Sat Apr 30, 2016 4:47 pm
by /
Ready, Aim, Fire!
Another volley was launched into the air that night, this time hitting one of the seven spaces occupied by a rather loquacious and sesquipedalian individual, right between the Q 10 and the D 2. This voluminous Pinoideae framework served as the receptacle for minuscule alphabetic slates. As such, it often dragooned individuals in speech that fell into a desideratum, then passed adjudication and punitive effects upon them upon unsuccess. Despite these considerable endowments, the wooden rack fell into oblivion with a thundering fissure.

HotShot53 Scrabble Rack, Town PR JOAT has been killed!

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch!

Day Four Start!

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Four - Rack 'em Up

Posted: Sat Apr 30, 2016 6:13 pm
by BuJaber
I think I believe Mets, so it's possible mitch got the wrong answer back. Ragian behaved a little strangely in my eyes during day 3. I think he's mafia.

Vote Ragian

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Four - Rack 'em Up

Posted: Sat Apr 30, 2016 6:15 pm
by madmitch
Well guys who do we go after ? the confirmed Mafia , or try to find another cult. Oh by the way my question last night was , Is Ragian cult ? NO !!!

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Four - Rack 'em Up

Posted: Sat Apr 30, 2016 6:35 pm
by BuJaber
You should have asked if he was town. we don't care what faction he is; if he isn't town he's an enemy. Now we don't know if he's town or not and we have to go with our guts.

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Four - Rack 'em Up

Posted: Sat Apr 30, 2016 8:36 pm
by madmitch
I already asked that question. so I cannot ask it again, How many mafia is there ? I still stand buy my Mets answer. But you are right I should have worded my question different, I will next time.

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Four - Rack 'em Up

Posted: Sat Apr 30, 2016 10:08 pm
by LSU Tiger Josh
Strike just to verify you are now just a plain survivor with IB dead correct?

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Four - Rack 'em Up

Posted: Sat Apr 30, 2016 11:26 pm
by HotShot53
Well, looks like my work is done here... good luck to the rest of town to finish the job!

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Four - Rack 'em Up

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 1:14 am
by Ragian
BuJaber wrote:I think I believe Mets, so it's possible mitch got the wrong answer back. Ragian behaved a little strangely in my eyes during day 3. I think he's mafia.

Vote Ragian
Riddle me this, son:
1) Why do you think we only had one death this night?
2) How many mafia do you think this game has that also has a cult?
madmitch wrote:Well guys who do we go after ? the confirmed Mafia , or try to find another cult. Oh by the way my question last night was , Is Ragian cult ? NO !!!
Good man. It was a waste of a question, though, if we take strike's words as the truth.

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Four - Rack 'em Up

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 2:39 am
by madmitch
@ Ragian new you were not mafia , just wanted to make sure you were not cult, now I know.

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Four - Rack 'em Up

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 2:48 am
by Metsfanmax
Ragian wrote: Good man. It was a waste of a question, though, if we take strike's words as the truth.
Why should we? Normal behavior when the Cult Recruiter dies is for the cult to remain as a faction, not to splinter off into individual third-party survivors. Given this fact, strike would have a reason to mislead us into thinking he's a survivor, namely that a survivor poses much less threat than a still-active cult faction (especially given that mafia is nearly or entirely wiped out).

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Four - Rack 'em Up

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 4:16 am
by rizky_biznezz
I haven't played with a cult before so I don't know if what strike said is likely or not.. But the game hasn't ended so we still are searching for cult and they do not go to 3p or we still have mafia who were blocked or their target saved..

Can mafia choose to not take a kill?

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Four - Rack 'em Up

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 9:25 am
by strike wolf
Survivor just has to do with my win condition. I still have my cop abilities.

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Four - Rack 'em Up

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 10:04 am
by BuJaber
strike wolf wrote:Survivor just has to do with my win condition. I still have my cop abilities.
So what did you in the night?
Ragian wrote: Riddle me this, son:
1) Why do you think we only had one death this night?
2) How many mafia do you think this game has that also has a cult?
1. Not sure. Possibly HotShot's JOAT had one or 2 vig kills. And TWR could have possibly given someone one shot earlier. That could explain the double deaths N1, double deaths N2, and attempted shot at rizky. I agree, there's not much to back this up. That's why I have no idea. We know for sure there is a cult. The recruiter is dead, so they won't grow. I am not saying there is definitely more mafia, but in the event that there is still one more mafia, I'd rather take a chance by lynching you and stopping a potential night kill. I could be convinced to switch to mets, but I'll need more to back up mitch's claim about him.

Re: Board Game Mafia: Day Four - Rack 'em Up

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 12:26 pm
by Ragian
Metsfanmax wrote:
Ragian wrote: Good man. It was a waste of a question, though, if we take strike's words as the truth.
Why should we? Normal behavior when the Cult Recruiter dies is for the cult to remain as a faction, not to splinter off into individual third-party survivors. Given this fact, strike would have a reason to mislead us into thinking he's a survivor, namely that a survivor poses much less threat than a still-active cult faction (especially given that mafia is nearly or entirely wiped out).
So, by that logic, you should be voting for Strike, yes?

@BuJ, those are scenarios, yes, but I'm confident that's not the reason.

vote mets

@Strike, what did you do last night, then?