Page 3 of 18
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 4:18 am
by mandalorian2298
Fircoal wrote:everywhere116 wrote:Can you explain your reasoning?
Of why I hate no lynches. They don't give any information to the town. We skip the only time we have to get the mafia, unless a vig is in the game, but if we keep on no lynching, we'll never get any info.
Fircol is right. Somebody has gotta go or we are effectivly giving up a turn and mafia gets a free kill. I agree that we shouldn't vote randomly, but saying No lynch in the begining of the day helps only the mafia guys.
That beeing said,
I FOS everywhere and unit_2 for starting all this No lynch nonsense.
BTW Mod, could you give us "Time remaining" in the next count, pretty please?
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 4:49 am
by Wisse
mandalorian2298 wrote:Fircoal wrote:everywhere116 wrote:Can you explain your reasoning?
Of why I hate no lynches. They don't give any information to the town. We skip the only time we have to get the mafia, unless a vig is in the game, but if we keep on no lynching, we'll never get any info.
Fircol is right. Somebody has gotta go or we are effectivly giving up a turn and mafia gets a free kill. I agree that we shouldn't vote randomly, but saying No lynch in the begining of the day helps only the mafia guys.
That beeing said,
I FOS everywhere and unit_2 for starting all this No lynch nonsense.
BTW Mod, could you give us "Time remaining" in the next count, pretty please?
we have all the time we want, until he says that if we haven't lynched someone before then then there will eb a no lynch
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 10:34 am
by unriggable
Dangit the only person I am really suspicious about is fircoal but thats because he's so anti-lynch.
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 10:36 am
by mandalorian2298
unriggable wrote:Dangit the only person I am really suspicious about is fircoal but thats because he's so anti-lynch.
Read more carefully. He is anti no lynch, wich IMO stands to reason. No lynch is something that is advantegus to mafia.
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 10:39 am
by unriggable
mandalorian2298 wrote:unriggable wrote:Dangit the only person I am really suspicious about is fircoal but thats because he's so anti-lynch.
Read more carefully. He is anti no lynch, wich IMO stands to reason. No lynch is something that is advantegus to mafia.
Haha that's what I meant.
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 10:39 am
by unriggable
Isn't no lynch bad for mafia? Their job gets done slower?
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 10:43 am
by Fircoal
unriggable wrote:Isn't no lynch bad for mafia? Their job gets done slower?
Nope, no suspicion is gained on the no lynch, on a lynch, there is information in the voting record.
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 10:44 am
by unriggable
No lynch = the paradox of mafia games...
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 12:02 pm
by dcowboys055
Day 1 will end on March 7th at 10:22 A.M. US Central time (i believe GMT-6) if there isn't a decision reached.
Since you asked so nice mandalorian.
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 12:11 pm
by Anarkistsdream
I would like to see more activity from the following players:
CBlake
Fircoal
Huguenots
cmckinney
beastly
shultz
what, me worry?
If I do not, my vote will go to one of you for not participating in the discussions, as it obviously means you do not care enough about this game to remain in it...
And I do not mean one little post crying about how you've been busy and can't get on the internet... We are ALL fucking busy... Don't sign up if you can't participate...
I will make my choice on Monday afternoon.
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 12:33 pm
by red bull
fircaols always anti no lynch
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 12:47 pm
by unriggable
red bull wrote:fircaols always anti no lynch
whatever. I never really know how to react with people who are that stuck to their decisions (like jay)
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 3:07 pm
by what,me worry?
Anarkistsdream wrote:I would like to see more activity from the following players:
CBlake
Fircoal
Huguenots
cmckinney
beastly
shultz
what, me worry?
If I do not, my vote will go to one of you for not participating in the discussions, as it obviously means you do not care enough about this game to remain in it...
And I do not mean one little post crying about how you've been busy and can't get on the internet... We are ALL fucking busy... Don't sign up if you can't participate...
I will make my choice on Monday afternoon.
Some of us have to work while others spend their friday nights on the computer. And as much as mandalorian and fircoal seem to be pointing fingers, I dont have enough to vote an innocent member out....at least not yet....
No Lynch
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 3:17 pm
by Anarkistsdream
what,me worry? wrote:Anarkistsdream wrote:I would like to see more activity from the following players:
CBlake
Fircoal
Huguenots
cmckinney
beastly
shultz
what, me worry?
If I do not, my vote will go to one of you for not participating in the discussions, as it obviously means you do not care enough about this game to remain in it...
And I do not mean one little post crying about how you've been busy and can't get on the internet... We are ALL fucking busy... Don't sign up if you can't participate...
I will make my choice on Monday afternoon.
Some of us have to work while others spend their friday nights on the computer. And as much as mandalorian and fircoal seem to be pointing fingers, I dont have enough to vote an innocent member out....at least not yet....
No Lynch
Today is Sunday... There has been ample opportunities in over 48 hours worth of time to read through these... Again, if you don't have time to participate, don't sign up...
Also, you will see that I didn't even FOS anyone... Merely pointed out my feelings.
And I agree with you about the no lynching, aspect, as you will see from my vote, as well.
Don't worry, WMW, I have no reason to think you are mafia or to vote you... Just stating the truths of the time.
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 3:18 pm
by unriggable
Dang, can we please argue this somewhere else?
VOTE NO LYNCH
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 3:19 pm
by Anarkistsdream
unriggable wrote:Dang, can we please argue this somewhere else?
VOTE NO LYNCH
Argue this somewhere else??? Like where? This is completely about the game...
FOS: Unriggable
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 3:21 pm
by unriggable
Anarkistsdream wrote:unriggable wrote:Dang, can we please argue this somewhere else?
VOTE NO LYNCH
Argue this somewhere else??? Like where? This is completely about the game...
FOS: Unriggable
But that case does not apply specifically to this mafia game, it includes all mafia games. Anarkis you should make a thread saying that (why, if you dont have time to play mafia, you shouldnt sign up), its a good point.
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 4:00 pm
by mandalorian2298
dcowboys055 wrote:Day 1 will end on March 7th at 10:22 A.M. US Central time (i believe GMT-6) if there isn't a decision reached.
Since you asked so nice mandalorian.
Thank you very much (since this is your game I will try to behave for a change
)
what,me worry? wrote:Some of us have to work while others spend their friday nights on the computer. And as much as mandalorian and fircoal seem to be pointing fingers, I dont have enough to vote an innocent member out....at least not yet....
No Lynch
Ok, I admit that I am a bit on the irresponsible side wich gives me more time to hang here and post. But WMW, this is the second game that you start by posting a vote. Why don't you spend a LITLLE time discussing your ideas before you making your mind up? It' the whole point of this game.
Ok, back to buisness, at this point the guy that rings my suspicion alarm loudest is unit_2. First he voted No lynch without a second thought, but as soon as Firecol opposed that notion he changed his mind and voted for him. It looks to me like he was just waiting for someone to give him a cause.
I am also suspicius about everywhere, but he, at least, elaborated his decision while unit_2 just threw his votes and took shelter. I expect an answer to my FOS from you two by tomorow or I am voting one of you.
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 4:05 pm
by what,me worry?
mandalorian2298 wrote:dcowboys055 wrote:Day 1 will end on March 7th at 10:22 A.M. US Central time (i believe GMT-6) if there isn't a decision reached.
Since you asked so nice mandalorian.
Thank you very much (since this is your game I will try to behave for a change
)
what,me worry? wrote:Some of us have to work while others spend their friday nights on the computer. And as much as mandalorian and fircoal seem to be pointing fingers, I dont have enough to vote an innocent member out....at least not yet....
No Lynch
Ok, I admit that I am a bit on the irresponsible side wich gives me more time to hang here and post.
But WMW, this is the second game that you start by posting a vote. Why don't you spend a LITLLE time discussing your ideas before you making your mind up? It' the whole point of this game.
Ok, back to buisness, at this point the guy that rings my suspicion alarm loudest is unit_2. First he voted No lynch without a second thought, but as soon as Firecol opposed that notion he changed his mind and voted for him. It looks to me like he was just waiting for someone to give him a cause.
I am also suspicius about everywhere, but he, at least, elaborated his decision while unit_2 just threw his votes and took shelter. I expect an answer to my FOS from you two by tomorrow or I am voting one of you.
.........I posted a
no lynch......... And if you really want my point of view Mandalorian, I didnt trust you from the last game and I sure dont trust you in this one, especially when your so quick to vote . Like I said, I dont have enough to vote for an innocent person but your not looking all too innocent lately. FOS Mandalorian
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 4:21 pm
by mandalorian2298
what,me worry? wrote:mandalorian2298 wrote:what,me worry? wrote:Some of us have to work while others spend their friday nights on the computer. And as much as mandalorian and fircoal seem to be pointing fingers, I dont have enough to vote an innocent member out....at least not yet....
No Lynch
Ok, I admit that I am a bit on the irresponsible side wich gives me more time to hang here and post.
But WMW, this is the second game that you start by posting a vote. Why don't you spend a LITLLE time discussing your ideas before you making your mind up? It' the whole point of this game.
Ok, back to buisness, at this point the guy that rings my suspicion alarm loudest is unit_2. First he voted No lynch without a second thought, but as soon as Firecol opposed that notion he changed his mind and voted for him. It looks to me like he was just waiting for someone to give him a cause.
I am also suspicius about everywhere, but he, at least, elaborated his decision while unit_2 just threw his votes and took shelter. I expect an answer to my FOS from you two by tomorrow or I am voting one of you.
.........I posted a
no lynch......... And if you really want my point of view Mandalorian, I didnt trust you from the last game and I sure dont trust you in this one,
especially when your so quick to vote . Like I said, I dont have enough to vote for an innocent person but your not looking all too innocent lately. FOS Mandalorian
You VOTED no lynch. It's a vote.
As for my being "quick to vote":
1. I didn't vote, yet!!!
2. Every night (unless we have a REAL good doctor) a townie dies. So we should give our best to nail a mafia during the day, else we loose by default. They may be some circumstances when no lynch is a good option. BUT, everywhere and unit_2 voted no lynch after only one person posted before them. Now there are about 6 no lynch votes. Two more and mafia gets a day off. Again, I don't suggest random lynching. I am just saying thet we should play activly and try to lynch mafia from day 1, instead of just giving up.
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 5:32 pm
by Beastly
I shouldn't have been included on your dumb list... I have been participating...
you should read the back post...
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 5:33 pm
by Beastly
and what does FOS stand for?
finger of suspicion?
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 5:36 pm
by Beastly
VOTE WHAT ME WORRY
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 5:41 pm
by CBlake
Anarkistsdream wrote:what,me worry? wrote:Anarkistsdream wrote:I would like to see more activity from the following players:
CBlake
Fircoal
Huguenots
cmckinney
beastly
shultz
what, me worry?
If I do not, my vote will go to one of you for not participating in the discussions, as it obviously means you do not care enough about this game to remain in it...
And I do not mean one little post crying about how you've been busy and can't get on the internet... We are ALL fucking busy... Don't sign up if you can't participate...
I will make my choice on Monday afternoon.
Some of us have to work while others spend their friday nights on the computer. And as much as mandalorian and fircoal seem to be pointing fingers, I dont have enough to vote an innocent member out....at least not yet....
No Lynch
Today is Sunday... There has been ample opportunities in over 48 hours worth of time to read through these... Again, if you don't have time to participate, don't sign up...
Also, you will see that I didn't even FOS anyone... Merely pointed out my feelings.
And I agree with you about the no lynching, aspect, as you will see from my vote, as well.
Don't worry, WMW, I have no reason to think you are mafia or to vote you... Just stating the truths of the time.
Hi
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2007 6:41 pm
by Fircoal
Anarkistsdream wrote:I would like to see more activity from the following players:
CBlake
Fircoal
Huguenots
cmckinney
beastly
shultz
what, me worry?
If I do not, my vote will go to one of you for not participating in the discussions, as it obviously means you do not care enough about this game to remain in it...
And I do not mean one little post crying about how you've been busy and can't get on the internet... We are ALL fucking busy... Don't sign up if you can't participate...
I will make my choice on Monday afternoon.
Why am I on that list? I've been posting a lot.
