Page 19 of 26

Re: AFC Mafia Game Day 3 POST!! Replacements Needed!

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 4:09 pm
by baggins994
Its Bolt wrote:Vote Baggins unless someone can explain why the day scene would basically come up with him being called scum (I have seen a cop-mod role that does something like this actually). I would also look to sam for a lynch given how the end of yesterday went down.

Also ani... giving spies the bomb over sam or even a useless player?

sorry, guys, i didn't realize it was day yet.

ya i did kill him but im not allowed to say why (or can i tell now derf?)
but i have no idea why he said anything about i told people, it must be something about my weird role (which is not scum, to make things clear)

Re: AFC Mafia Game Day 3 POST!! Replacements Needed!

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 5:18 pm
by derfderf34
pmchugh wrote:Does it not mean that the person who made the kill pm'ed baggins instead of derf by accident?

Derf can you clear this up?

baggins sent in his night action to me by replying to a prod so there were others that got this pm, which said kill lsu, and i decided that it wouldnt be fair for these that also got this message to be the only ones who know

i am not pinning the blame on baggins or saying that he is mafia all i said was he sent me a pm saying kill lsu

Re: AFC Mafia Game Day 3 POST!! Replacements Needed!

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 5:45 pm
by pmchugh
Care to claim/ tell us why you killed lsu?

Re: AFC Mafia Game Day 3 POST!! Replacements Needed!

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 7:53 pm
by /
Wait, that's a bit confusing, I thought if you reply to a mass PM, it only goes back to the original sender unless you manually type everyone else's names.
anyways it does look bad, LSU being the only one dead and all.

Re: AFC Mafia Game Day 3 POST!! Replacements Needed!

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 8:27 pm
by Its Bolt
/ wrote:Wait, that's a bit confusing, I thought if you reply to a mass PM, it only goes back to the original sender unless you manually type everyone else's names.
anyways it does look bad, LSU being the only one dead and all.


Well baggins is mod confirmed killing role already, and LSU looked fairly pro-town in his interactions with space yesterday. Baggins is either going to flip mafia or outside chance third party killing. The only way he can be pro-town is a vig who targeted drench and LSU respectively and a doctor type role was successful last night.

Occamz razor says we lynch baggins.

(It also says throw sam the bomb)

Re: AFC Mafia Game Day 3 POST!! Replacements Needed!

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 9:34 pm
by sheepofdumb
A either way one less killing role is good for us. Plus there's a good chance that he's mafia. Sorry baggins Vote baggins.

Re: AFC Mafia Game Day 3 POST!! Replacements Needed!

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 9:46 pm
by spiesr
derfderf34 wrote:baggins sent in his night action to me by replying to a prod so there were others that got this pm, which said kill lsu, and i decided that it wouldnt be fair for these that also got this message to be the only ones who know

i am not pinning the blame on baggins or saying that he is mafia all i said was he sent me a pm saying kill lsu

Well that sort of clears some stuff up.
Baggins has four vote so one more will lynch him. I say lynch him but perhaps let him post once before we do so, provided that he posts in a reasonable amount of time. He will have to come up with something pretty convincing to save himself though, and I doubt he will...

Re: AFC Mafia Game Day 3 POST!! Replacements Needed!

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 10:00 pm
by Its Bolt
Unless he did something off the charts wierd, he is a killing role. That much should be painfully obvious. It is more of a question of what killing role, which is mafia, SK, vig if we exclude some really bizzare wierd third party role.

A vig however just doesnt make sense given that stroop tried to pull a LSU wagon on his way out. In the event that he wasnt going to be lynched, it just screws up his options since he had established suspcicion on LSU to start. Basically for a vig to of killed LSU they would of needed to believe that he was not only being bussed by LSU (why anyone would want to buss the janitor in what appears to be a power heavy game is beyond me) but also returned fire immediately upon replacing in.

Even if he claims vig I would still push for the lynch instead of risking outing a town aligned killing role.

Re: AFC Mafia Game Day 3 POST!! Replacements Needed!

Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 4:45 am
by sam_levi_11
well then, this is an odd situation. My vote is already on his tho so i cant lynch him.

Re: AFC Mafia Game Day 3 POST!! Replacements Needed!

Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 8:33 am
by baggins994
look, im not scum, i have a weird role with some weird rules. i cant claim unless derf says so and i killed lsu because i thought he was scum, thats all there is to it

Re: AFC Mafia Game Day 3 POST!! Replacements Needed!

Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 8:44 am
by spiesr
baggins994 wrote:look, im not scum, i have a weird role with some weird rules. i cant claim unless derf says so and i killed lsu because i thought he was scum, thats all there is to it
I don't believe you...

Re: AFC Mafia Game Day 3 POST!! Replacements Needed!

Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 9:28 am
by norsemsn1066
vote:baggins

Not much more I can add to this right now except that I agree. Let us see what his death reveals.

Re: AFC Mafia Game Day 3 POST!! Replacements Needed!

Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 4:05 pm
by animorpherv1
Its Bolt wrote:Vote Baggins unless someone can explain why the day scene would basically come up with him being called scum (I have seen a cop-mod role that does something like this actually). I would also look to sam for a lynch given how the end of yesterday went down.

Also ani... giving spies the bomb over sam or even a useless player?


I get the feeling that sometimes the players who are trynig to help the MOST may be scum, and I'v been right.

Re: AFC Mafia Game Day 3 POST!! Replacements Needed!

Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 6:00 pm
by pmchugh
norsemsn1066 wrote:vote:baggins

Not much more I can add to this right now except that I agree. Let us see what his death reveals.


Thats a lynch, and I understand why you did it but you could have waited for a claim.

Re: AFC Mafia Game Day 3 POST!! Replacements Needed!

Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 6:23 pm
by derfderf34
After a rather short day it was decided that baggins must be guilty for killing lsu. He may now know that teling other people that he is killing people may not be the best idea. Since there was much time left before sundown he was lynched to death by poking the upside down "T" on his shirt. After poking through his shirt and arm he fell over dead and a gun fell out. With this they knew he was actually the killer of LSU. baggins994 (San Diego Chargers)(Mafia Godfather) has been lynched!

Night 3 begins!

Re: AFC Mafia Game Night 3 SEND IN ACTIONS!!

Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 6:27 pm
by pmchugh
well that was easy

Re: AFC Mafia Game Night 3 SEND IN ACTIONS!!

Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 9:35 pm
by sheepofdumb
Wow, that was sad.

Re: AFC Mafia Game Night 3 SEND IN ACTIONS!!

Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 10:20 pm
by baggins994
omg that was BS. why did you have to tell them i killed lsu? derf you suck lard. besides, though the thing about replying to a prod is true, the only other person that got the message was the person i killed and we sorted things out on our own. derf, i you need not be expecting me to play in another one of your games.

Re: AFC Mafia Game Night 3 SEND IN ACTIONS!!

Posted: Tue Feb 24, 2009 11:54 pm
by sheepofdumb
Yeah derf, for that I'm really thinking about never playing another game you host. Unless the theme is freaking sweet. :P

Re: AFC Mafia Game Night 3 SEND IN ACTIONS!!

Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 8:39 am
by derfderf34
baggins994 wrote:omg that was BS. why did you have to tell them i killed lsu? derf you suck lard. besides, though the thing about replying to a prod is true, the only other person that got the message was the person i killed and we sorted things out on our own. derf, i you need not be expecting me to play in another one of your games.

I wa pretty sure that there were others who got it

Re: AFC Mafia Game Night 3 SEND IN ACTIONS!!

Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 4:01 pm
by baggins994
nope, checked, you are a terrible mod

Re: AFC Mafia Game Night 3 SEND IN ACTIONS!!

Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 5:30 pm
by spiesr
[quote="baggins994"you are a terrible mod[/quote]We already knew that, but the dead should stop talking at night...

Re: AFC Mafia Game Night 3 SEND IN ACTIONS!!

Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 5:43 pm
by pmchugh
spiesr wrote:[quote="baggins994"you are a terrible mod
We already knew that, but the dead should stop talking at night...[/quote]

Ahh brotherly love and shit quoting.

Re: AFC Mafia Game Night 3 SEND IN ACTIONS!!

Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 6:27 pm
by Thezzaruz
You guys suck at quoting. :mrgreen: :-^ :mrgreen:

Re: AFC Mafia Game Night 3 SEND IN ACTIONS!!

Posted: Wed Feb 25, 2009 7:37 pm
by pmchugh
[quote="Thezzaruz"]You guys suck at quoting. :mrgreen: :-^ :mrgreen:[/quote

No i don't ;) it was all speisrs fault cause his first one was wrong.