Page 19 of 45
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 4:15 pm
by william18
Dito? Are you going to unvote or are you still checking out my role?
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 4:24 pm
by cmckinney
william18 wrote:Dito? Are you going to unvote or are you still checking out my role?
william...do u have any sort of defense against what pmc and others have said against u?
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 4:45 pm
by /
sorry I had needed to be prodded.....for missing part of one day phase, er I've been keeping up, honest!
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 4:49 pm
by cena-rules
Hmmm I believe him
unvote
was this the game blue was needed?
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 4:51 pm
by Ditocoaf
william18 wrote:Dito? Are you going to unvote or are you still checking out my role?
I never voted you; and it turns out it's a good thing. If I had, you'd be lynched already. But don't take that to mean I don't suspect you...
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 4:53 pm
by Ditocoaf
Alright, that bandwagon mushroomed quickly because of one scumtell, and now people are jumping off it just as quickly. I'm looking at some of those bandwagoners as people just looking for an easy lynch.
The best way to ensure a scum lynch day one is to consider it carefully, and don't do anything rash. Nobody likes day 1, but it can be the most important day. Make sure we're sure as possible about a person before lynching them.
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 4:56 pm
by /
By the way Ana Lucia was one of the most vengeful angry suspicious people in the show, so don't be surprised if even if william is telling he truth, there is a good chance he's either paranoid or insane.
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 4:57 pm
by william18
Ok vigs out there. Im proabably your #1 night kill but just wait one sec. Give me a night and I will get you guys the results I get.
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 4:58 pm
by william18
/ wrote:By the way Ana Lucia was one of the most vengeful angry suspicious people in the show, so don't be surprised if even if william is telling he truth, there is a good chance he's either paranoid or insane.
Probably. I guess any other cop is probably sane.
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 4:59 pm
by william18
cmckinney wrote:william18 wrote:Dito? Are you going to unvote or are you still checking out my role?
william...do u have any sort of defense against what pmc and others have said against u?
Isn't my claim defence enough, or are you trying to spark some more flames?
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 5:04 pm
by jnd94
If your claim was "enough" than whenver someone needed to stay alive another night to do their dirty work, they would use that excuse. So no.
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 5:11 pm
by pmchugh
Hmm Anna Lucia wasnt the nicest person but i am sure she is pro-town as in the show she killed an 'other' and was herself killed by someone on a mission for the others. Her job in the flashbacks is a cop however i would have probably made her vig, it suites her more. I suppose she could be SK but i highly doubt it, unless their is a counter claim then unvote
Of course there is a chance she isnt in this game, as she is dead on the show at season 4 so still fos william. You have acted scummy but i think i believe your claim for the moment.
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 5:19 pm
by william18
pmchugh wrote:Hmm Anna Lucia wasnt the nicest person but i am sure she is pro-town as in the show she killed an 'other' and was herself killed by someone on a mission for the others. Her job in the flashbacks is a cop however i would have probably made her vig, it suites her more. I suppose she could be SK but i highly doubt it, unless their is a counter claim then unvote
Of course there is a chance she isnt in this game, as she is dead on the show at season 4 so still fos william. You have acted scummy but i think i believe your claim for the moment.
If you ask anyone that has played with me before, they know that I always act scummy. It's just my style.
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 5:21 pm
by william18
Don't worry, hopefully I investigate scum and get irrifusble info. Unless im paraniod, random, or naive.
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 5:26 pm
by Anarkistsdream
OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT!
(3) Mandalorian2298 - Fircoal, William18, rebelman
(1) dittoeevee8888 - Mandalorian2298
(7) William18 - nagerous, neoteny, CMCKinney, Iliad, LSU Tiger Josh, Got Tonkaed, Selin
With 20 Alive it takes 11 to lynch!
Thanks for the activity, guys!
This game has been great for me to mod...
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 5:27 pm
by cena-rules
been great to play
cant wait to see how many people die
I reckon 3-4
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 5:38 pm
by william18
Woops. Am I still on mando?
Unvote
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 6:21 pm
by cmckinney
eh...i guess i'll buy what William is saying for now. Ana Lucia was a cop off the island on the show, so his role claim makes sense. So, unless there is a counter claim, Unvote
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 6:22 pm
by Selin
Ana Lucia was not alive in Season 4. She was killed either in season 2 or 3, i don't remember exactly. Claiming a cop is the easiest way to survive. And I don't think that AD will have such a deviation from the real storyline. This seems to me being a "found role" from wiki or somewhere else. I will keep my vote on william taking the risk that he may be a cop with a small probability.
.
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 6:30 pm
by cmckinney
william18 wrote:cmckinney wrote:william18 wrote:Dito? Are you going to unvote or are you still checking out my role?
william...do u have any sort of defense against what pmc and others have said against u?
Isn't my claim defence enough, or are you trying to spark some more flames?
oops i didnt see ur role claim. But still...do you have anything to say for your rather sporadic voting?
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 6:33 pm
by Iliad
william18 wrote:Srry about the delay. Seems like pmchugh has made a pretty convincing case against me. Am I lynched? Well if you want a roleclaim here it is im a cop! Nice job pmchugh, exposing a cop. Im not sure how long i'll be alive during the night. Don't remember the name of the charecter wiat one sec. Yeah I'm a...cop guys, so don't lynch me. Let me check wiki again
william18 wrote:Ok this is who I am. Finally I found a character who is an obvious cop
Im am Ana Lucia Cortez. The cop. I used to work in the Los Angeles Police Department.
(This is just a brief description of myself)
Don't blame me if she dies before this timeline, im confused too. Remember, Animoprh charecter wasn't from the fourth season aswell.
I myself not too impressed
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 6:35 pm
by cmckinney
william18 wrote:Ok this is who I am.
Im am Ana Lucia Cortez. The cop. I used to work in the Los Angeles Police Department.
(This is just a brief description of myself)
Don't blame me if she dies before this timeline, im confused too. Remember, Animoprh charecter wasn't from the fourth season aswell.
wow...are you saying that juliet isn't in the fourth season?
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 6:36 pm
by Iliad
Anarkistsdream wrote:OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT!
(3) Mandalorian2298 - Fircoal, William18, rebelman
(1) dittoeevee8888 - Mandalorian2298
(7) William18 - nagerous, neoteny, CMCKinney, Iliad, LSU Tiger Josh, Got Tonkaed, Selin
With 20 Alive it takes 11 to lynch!
Thanks for the activity, guys!
This game has been great for me to mod...
better than the people in my game

At least this late into the game
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 6:41 pm
by Selin
william18 wrote:Ok this is who I am.
Im am Ana Lucia Cortez. The cop. I used to work in the Los Angeles Police Department.
(This is just a brief description of myself)
Don't blame me if she dies before this timeline, im confused too. Remember, Animoprh charecter wasn't from the fourth season aswell.
In fact, I got more sure than before that you are lying after reading your posts once again.
You first posted that you are a cop, but couldn't remember your name. After 9 minutes you posted above text, but can remember exactly that she died before Season 4.
Also
Dr. Juliet (Animo) is one of the main characters in Season 4, so your statement about animo is misleading all players who are not familiar with the show. Probably you didn't search wiki well.
.
Re: LOST Mafia - Day 1 (20 alive/11 to lynch) Juliet Killed!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 6:45 pm
by Ditocoaf
Also, claiming "cop" right off the bat, then coming up with the character that was a cop in their past life... doesn't quite sound right. Because I'm sure Anark knows enough about the show that he wouldn't put her as just a cop, because she didn't play anything like that role. That sounds like some poorly thought-out BS to me...
I'm actually going to go against the current trend, and vote william18 now.