Conquer Club

william18 wrote:

cmckinney wrote:and we're supposed to just take your word for it and automatically assume / is scum?

How do we know ur not the scum?

I never said / was scum. Don't skim!

I might have assumed he was scum do too his actions but I never said he was guaranteed scum, just that he was acting fishy.

here is my point of view
william claimed v night cop he got me night 1 as 3rd party
i am 3rd party letter y. this means william cant be not sane or it could mean that he got lucky on a shot in the dark/scum lying
/ claims n for night cop night 1 investigates william gets as scum
william could be insane/paranoid/scum lying he also could of had a shot in the dark be lying or be the cop

so far i dont know who to trust.

Wow this mafia has gotten really active rescently.

lord voldemort wrote:here is my point of view
william claimed v night cop he got me night 1 as 3rd party
i am 3rd party letter y. this means william cant be not sane or it could mean that he got lucky on a shot in the dark/scum lying
/ claims n for night cop night 1 investigates william gets as scum
william could be insane/paranoid/scum lying he also could of had a shot in the dark be lying or be the cop

so far i dont know who to trust.

if he got your alignment right insane and paranoid are out of the question, he can only be Town cop, or Scum cop.

/ wrote:

lord voldemort wrote:here is my point of view
william claimed v night cop he got me night 1 as 3rd party
i am 3rd party letter y. this means william cant be not sane or it could mean that he got lucky on a shot in the dark/scum lying
/ claims n for night cop night 1 investigates william gets as scum
william could be insane/paranoid/scum lying he also could of had a shot in the dark be lying or be the cop

so far i dont know who to trust.

if he got your alignment right insane and paranoid are out of the question, he can only be Town cop, or Scum cop.

agreed he can only be town cop or scum cop
and as scum are most likely vowels this means he has faked or is the cop
so now we wait to see if there is a counter

lord voldemort wrote:

/ wrote:

lord voldemort wrote:here is my point of view
william claimed v night cop he got me night 1 as 3rd party
i am 3rd party letter y. this means william cant be not sane or it could mean that he got lucky on a shot in the dark/scum lying
/ claims n for night cop night 1 investigates william gets as scum
william could be insane/paranoid/scum lying he also could of had a shot in the dark be lying or be the cop

so far i dont know who to trust.

if he got your alignment right insane and paranoid are out of the question, he can only be Town cop, or Scum cop.

agreed he can only be town cop or scum cop
and as scum are most likely vowels this means he has faked or is the cop
so now we wait to see if there is a counter

The odds of me faking are slim. Plus gettig one of the five consanants are slimmer. I can assure you my role but we'll wait for someone to counter claim.

william...can u please explain about /'s earlier argument about ur whole sudden switch on Animo?

cmckinney wrote:william...can u please explain about /'s earlier argument about ur whole sudden switch on Animo?

Didn't I already? Please reread and do not skim. I said I lynched him from getting possibly blacklisted from the game.

jesus christ...enough with the skimming thing. Please forgive me if i'm not completely understanding every minute detail of what's going on.

Im not the only one that attacked animorph after he claimed, you voted him of aswell so I don't think you should be accusing me of voting a townie.

cmckinney wrote:jesus christ...enough with the skimming thing. Please forgive me if i'm not completely understanding every minute detail of what's going on.

Lol srry. I'll try not to go overboard next time.

william18 wrote:

lord voldemort wrote:unvote

that checks out

/ wrote:Er......*cough* So no one else has V?

What you don't unvote even when the person I investigated confirmed my investigation! Scum!

u say u never accuse him of being scum?

william18 wrote:

cmckinney wrote:jesus christ...enough with the skimming thing. Please forgive me if i'm not completely understanding every minute detail of what's going on.

Lol srry. I'll try not to go overboard next time.

haha no problem

cmckinney wrote:jesus christ...enough with the skimming thing. Please forgive me if i'm not completely understanding every minute detail of what's going on.

I agree... I'm going to have to go back and read everything once again... I still don't see enough evidence to unvote him... The fact that he is getting crazy defensive is making me more suspecious...

Also, why does everyone say there are "five missing consonants" the only way anyone could know that is if they are part of a five vowel mafia, it could just as easily be 4 scum, 4 missing, three scum, three missing, etc.
FOS whoever said that in this game.

Until I can take the time to re-read everything, I am going to UNVOTE for the moment. Just want to make sure I make an educated decision. KWIM?

/ wrote:Also, why does everyone say there are "five missing consonants" the only way anyone could know that is if they are part of a five vowel mafia, it could just as easily be 4 scum, 4 missing, three scum, three missing, etc.
FOS whoever said that in this game.

agreed however no fos
setup wise and balancing wise this makes sense 21 players 4-5 scum 5 vowels...its not a far strength
true we cannot know how many scum there are but it is logical reasoning that the 5 vowels are scum

lord voldemort wrote:

/ wrote:Also, why does everyone say there are "five missing consonants" the only way anyone could know that is if they are part of a five vowel mafia, it could just as easily be 4 scum, 4 missing, three scum, three missing, etc.
FOS whoever said that in this game.

agreed however no fos
setup wise and balancing wise this makes sense 21 players 4-5 scum 5 vowels...its not a far strength
true we cannot know how many scum there are but it is logical reasoning that the 5 vowels are scum

or at least thats what i got from the opening scene

lord voldemort wrote:

/ wrote:Also, why does everyone say there are "five missing consonants" the only way anyone could know that is if they are part of a five vowel mafia, it could just as easily be 4 scum, 4 missing, three scum, three missing, etc.
FOS whoever said that in this game.

agreed however no fos
setup wise and balancing wise this makes sense 21 players 4-5 scum 5 vowels...its not a far strength
true we cannot know how many scum there are but it is logical reasoning that the 5 vowels are scum

That makes quite a bit of sense.

ok first thing i notice is that william is almost certainly innocent unless he is scum cop. He got lovo as third party which was correct. Of course they could be scum buddies. Im not so sure about / but i can tell you my letter does not correspond to my role as far as i can see, except maybe a loose connection.

So this brings me to Lovo i reckon he is SK we know he is third party so of course he is going to say something like "im a surviver" (no song reference meant). We know there is another killer out there as sam died last night of course this could be a vig,( someone claimed V didnt they?) but i doubt it. I say we lynch lovo, if he is scum we know william is too, if he is SK then we got one less kill tonight, if he is other 3rd party then that nearly clears will and at least we didnt kill townie, and he is certainly not town why would someone admit to being 3rd party when they are town. This way we are garunteed to avoid lynching a townie and potential cop.

unvote vote lord voldemort.

yeah i was thinking along the same lines...

Wait, sorry, but how does Lynching Lovo prove William to be town? Even if he third party that only proves Will has investigation abilities, scum faction would want SK dead just as much as town.

/ wrote:Wait, sorry, but how does Lynching Lovo prove William to be town? Even if he third party that only proves Will has investigation abilities, scum faction would want SK dead just as much as town.

but wouldn't that prove that william is sane and that / is insane or something?

pmchugh wrote:ok first thing i notice is that william is almost certainly innocent unless he is scum cop. He got lovo as third party which was correct. Of course they could be scum buddies. Im not so sure about / but i can tell you my letter does not correspond to my role as far as i can see, except maybe a loose connection.

So this brings me to Lovo i reckon he is SK we know he is third party so of course he is going to say something like "im a surviver" (no song reference meant). We know there is another killer out there as sam died last night of course this could be a vig,( someone claimed V didnt they?) but i doubt it. I say we lynch lovo, if he is scum we know william is too, if he is SK then we got one less kill tonight, if he is other 3rd party then that nearly clears will and at least we didnt kill townie, and he is certainly not town why would someone admit to being 3rd party when they are town. This way we are garunteed to avoid lynching a townie and potential cop.

unvote vote lord voldemort.

there is no sense in lynching me
it wont prove williams innocence i am 3rd party yes i wont deny it and im a survivor
why would i claim unchallenged if i wasnt
i say there is more chance of there being a vig than an sk....why cause there are 5 scum
that puts it at my count 5:15:1 assuming no other 3rd party...in a nv game its almost a guarantee to have the vig in there
lynching me learns you nothing from this day

and im not a sk. i f i was i would of stayed under the shadows much more
cause im survivor i can win with town which im quite happy to do
ive done nothing but help town

cmc if william was not sane he'd have got me as scum or town. instead he got me as 3rd party which means he is sane or guessed correctly

cmckinney wrote:

/ wrote:Wait, sorry, but how does Lynching Lovo prove William to be town? Even if he third party that only proves Will has investigation abilities, scum faction would want SK dead just as much as town.

but wouldn't that prove that william is sane and that / is insane or something?

we've already confirmed that Will is telling the truth about his sanity, it's his alignment we need to know.