The Thing TOWN WINS!

DirtyDishSoap · Post by **DirtyDishSoap** » Thu Nov 09, 2023 7:37 pm

EBWOP: 15 Hours remain!

DirtyDishSoap · Post by **DirtyDishSoap** » Thu Nov 09, 2023 7:48 pm

Woops, I'm an idiot. Also drunk, but 29 hours remain.

degaston · Post by **degaston** » Thu Nov 09, 2023 8:31 pm

@SoN!c
Obviously no one is going to volunteer for the lynch, but I notice that you, who insists that we need a lynch on day 1, haven't even voted for anyone. (except yourself

)

SoN!c · Post by **SoN!c** » Fri Nov 10, 2023 1:34 am

degaston wrote:@SoN!c
Obviously no one is going to volunteer for the lynch, but I notice that you, who insists that we need a lynch on day 1, haven't even voted for anyone. (except yourself )

I explained why. But obviously we are going nowhere it seems.

And i proposed to follow your plan but with a twist (the designated votes on D3 and D4) = also no lynch today so no volunteer needed. The volunteers are asked to volunteer for BT. That's a World of difference i say. Volunteer for BT or volunteer for lynch is not the same

Look if we are not going with the designated votes D3 and D4 to have as a sort of contingency plan then we have to be like 90% sure on every lynch / BT. We won't get many chances. And how can you be like 90% sure?

Like i said: town= Deg, Ragian, Charle, Strike, me, and i think Votanic too. To my opinion.

So then we have 4 players im not so sure about.

Swang : "coasting along" but is it because he is the Thing or is it just "coasting along"? I think the second part
Traf: i explained why
EW= don't think so but im not so sure on him after his Ragian clash
Pixar: don't think so either but not so sure either because of his absense and the little voice saying "it's always the quiet ones"

Then it's Traf for me. But that just means he is safe right

So im with the Plan. It's the only way out of this mess.

SoN!c · Post by **SoN!c** » Fri Nov 10, 2023 2:06 am

Also, we don't have to vote for the D3 and D4 names. It's sufficient that you post them today (or we vote tomorrow). But 1 player posting those names should be way more easy and the only one who can do that on D1 is the BT'one (you). You can't do it tomorrow because you know why

Ragian · Post by **Ragian** » Fri Nov 10, 2023 8:14 am

There is no consensus. Maybe a no lynch is for the best...

strike wolf · Post by **strike wolf** » Fri Nov 10, 2023 5:12 pm

Yea. Today's going to end in a standstill. Does anyone other than Sonic have anything they want to say before night?

Extreme Ways · Post by **Extreme Ways** » Fri Nov 10, 2023 6:13 pm

strike wolf wrote:Yea. Today's going to end in a standstill. Does anyone other than Sonic have anything they want to say before night?

Lmao.

I was going to vote Swang but I think his recent posts read towny.

DirtyDishSoap · Post by **DirtyDishSoap** » Fri Nov 10, 2023 6:15 pm

I might be too drunk to post at the deadline so I'll extend it tomorrow at 3pm -utc7 i should be sober enough then.

Votanic · Post by **Votanic** » Fri Nov 10, 2023 7:46 pm

I'm not blind to the possible benefit of a 'no lynch' on Day 1... but I'm not convinced either.
I'll keep my vote on Sonic because of all the reason I already stated.

degaston · Post by **degaston** » Fri Nov 10, 2023 8:08 pm

I'm sure no one will believe me on D2 no matter what I say, so I'll say right now that I think we should BT Sonic tomorrow.
89% chance I'm wrong about that, but I don't have much of a read on most others.

If Sonic is town, then my next target might be Traf for overreacting when there was no actual pressure on him.

swang918 · Post by **swang918** » Fri Nov 10, 2023 11:00 pm

degaston wrote:I'm sure no one will believe me on D2 no matter what I say, so I'll say right now that I think we should BT Sonic tomorrow.
89% chance I'm wrong about that, but I don't have much of a read on most others.

If Sonic is town, then my next target might be Traf for overreacting when there was no actual pressure on him.

I'm against BTing Sonic. Part of the benefit of the BT is that if they're cleared then we get a valuable confirmed non-scum voice for the day. But with Sonic we won't get that benefit, even if he gets cleared he's still just gonna be goofy random.

Agree that Trafalgar might be a good target. I did notice that he got triggered by sonic here when he didn't react to sonic all last game, and sonic is not playing any differently.

Ragian · Post by **Ragian** » Sat Nov 11, 2023 12:49 am

I see a lot of people going for Traf. Should we lynch him, then? Would you be up for lynching him? Swang, Dega?

degaston · Post by **degaston** » Sat Nov 11, 2023 1:18 am

Ragian wrote:I see a lot of people going for Traf. Should we lynch him, then? Would you be up for lynching him? Swang, Dega?

I don't think that Sonic ever had any real case against Traf, so I'm not inclined to change my vote.

So here's an idea... how about we lynch Sonic, and then tomorrow we can BT Traf (unless Sonic wants to name someone else before the lynch).
Then if Traf is human, we lynch whoever he wants, and so on until we find the recruiter or lose.
That's the only way I can think of to guarantee that we're not being influenced by a Thing.
It would also make it impossible for the Thing to plan more than one day ahead.

degaston · Post by **degaston** » Sat Nov 11, 2023 1:32 am

Another option is to no-lynch today and BT Sonic on D2, but don't lynch if he's human.
Then D3, BT Traf (or whoever Sonic wants), and if he's human we lynch whoever Traf wants.
Same for D4, and if we don't lynch the recruiter then, we lose.
That way we get 4 BT's, and if we find the recruiter, then the worst case is we'd be at 5v3 on day 5, and have to find the three converted things.

SoN!c · Post by **SoN!c** » Sat Nov 11, 2023 4:24 am

Look Traf is the only player that made strange moves to me.

First he was active until his "lets not BT Pixar but somebody else" post.

Traf is always very calculated and wants to be sure on anything before he acts.

But he admitted later that he had no idea 'to be honest" who that other person to BT should be?

This is not Traf his style. Why would Traf say something like that "test somebody else" if he doesnt even know who that "somebody else is"?

It's by itself very unlike Traf. Saying "test somebody else" but not knowing who or why.

It does not make any sense to me Traf says something like this, unless its a strategy meaning he is the Thing and he wants to score good creds.

Then later on he had an emotial outburst. The only time i notice emotional outbursts on Traf is when he is about to lose a game..Why did he have that emotional outburst?

Then after that he went through different stages : being very silent, making fun of the comments (what is also a very good defence strategy) before finally sheeping behind Deg. Also he could have hammered me on the lynch vote but he did not.

I think he did not because he knows he would be hammering himself for BT on D2 that way.

And why would you be afraid of a BT?

Also, by elemination, i don't think the others are the Thing either.. And if you think 9 are not and it's only 10 players then..yes again it must be Traf.

For all these reasons i wanted to BT Traf today. It was a good choice to me: if he is The Thing we would have won and if he's not we have an experienced player that can plot the lines for D2.

___

So we go with the Plan (with the designated names for D3 / D4 to be made today by Deg or tomorrow by the BT'one) or we dont go with the Plan but then we need to lynch today i say.

And i don't see the consensus on The Plan so Lets lynch Traf. And If im wrong you can lynch me tomorrow. Short and sweet.

vote Traf

Extreme Ways · Post by **Extreme Ways** » Sat Nov 11, 2023 6:29 am

Ragian wrote:I see a lot of people going for Traf. Should we lynch him, then? Would you be up for lynching him? Swang, Dega?

Always been up for a Traf lynch even if his posting improved.

Post by **Charle** » Sat Nov 11, 2023 7:10 am

Who are all in favour of Traf lynch?

Post by **TrafalgarLaw01** » Sat Nov 11, 2023 8:09 am

Oh dear if somehow Sonic and Charle get people to it. I Can assure the recruiter is there in the people who vote me and maybe even morw the ones that have to rush things. Otherwise BTme D2

Post by **Charle** » Sat Nov 11, 2023 8:26 am

I must say, I actually believe you Traf, my vote stay where it is for now. Looks like we will end up in a No Lynch day. Still wondering what Pixar has got to say about all of this.

Ragian · Post by **Ragian** » Sat Nov 11, 2023 8:45 am

Well, I want to lynch Extreme, but I'm stading quite alone with that.

strike wolf · Post by **strike wolf** » Sat Nov 11, 2023 9:20 am

@Son!c what experience do you have with Traf losing? As far as I know, you've only played the Tick Mafia with him.

SoN!c · Post by **SoN!c** » Sat Nov 11, 2023 10:25 am

strike wolf wrote:@Son!c what experience do you have with Traf losing? As far as I know, you've only played the Tick Mafia with him.

Not in mafia games that is true. But if you can't stand losing in other games it's the same thing right

You can ask Traf if he can't stand losing, pretty sure he won't deny that fact.

But that by itself doesnt make him the Thing neither.

SoN!c · Post by **SoN!c** » Sat Nov 11, 2023 10:48 am

TrafalgarLaw01 wrote:Oh dear if somehow Sonic and Charle get people to it. I Can assure the recruiter is there in the people who vote me and maybe even morw the ones that have to rush things. Otherwise BTme D2

If you are so sure "the recruiter is there in the people who vote me" then why didn't you hammer me when you could.? Im the only one voting for you..

Post by **TrafalgarLaw01** » Sat Nov 11, 2023 11:09 am

I don't like losing, ever. But not sure what that has to do. As long as I got a shot I'll do what I can to win and in mafia as townie I will always do what is in my hands to make town wins even if it means i got killed, luckly I won in School and Tick alive till the end, but in prison you can see I was genuilly happy about town winning even if I died D1 cause if I am town a town wins counts like a win to me.

Certainly if i were the Thing would have not drawn attention to myself.
I got really tired of Sonic with his nonsense theory, but even more than it, people still buying them or even worst deviating attention from other people. I did not vote for Sonic cause I honestly believe him not the Thing, and as I said I'll do what is in my hands for town to win, and killing a townie does not help town.

If I'll vote for someone to be lynched today would be Charle or EW, if Deg choose one of them I'll vote him, otherwise wont vote for a lynch today.

The Thing TOWN WINS!

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1

Re: The Thing Day 1