Conquer Club

cairnswk wrote:

Gilligan wrote:The Bigali/Chunuk Bair border is still there (on the Bigali side)

Fixed.

I still see that BS can bombard those 4 territories i mentioned above (Gaba Tepe, F8, Serafim, Krithia)

Yeh? so as stated above, they should be there...the fire images were accidentally deleted in previous version.
So you think they shouldn't be there and what is your evidence if so?

thenobodies80 wrote:Going to do the final check of files....anyone has further comments? If not this one will be in Beta within 2/3 days.

thenobodies80 wrote:I will send the files tomorrow, sorry for the delay.

Beta - Quenching

i_Cypher wrote:Pre-dreadnought battleship Vengeance is spelled incorrectly. (c.f. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Al ... _Gallipoli)

perchorin wrote:Looks like another quality cairnswk product, I'm looking forward to getting my first games on this map underway. At first blush the only thing I might like to see changed is the forts are quite hard to distinguish for my poor old eyes, do you think there could be a way to make them more easily identifiable?

Also there seems not to be an actual map in the little box on the games menu at the moment. It's just a white box that says "BETA".

butleroftokyo wrote:Love this map already - encapsulates the savagery of the real battle

Just one point - if using trenches, the armies on the ships in the dardanelles become worthless, as the can only advance onto the mines and nowhere else. As i discovered....

kizkiz wrote:

butleroftokyo wrote:Love this map already - encapsulates the savagery of the real battle

Just one point - if using trenches, the armies on the ships in the dardanelles become worthless, as the can only advance onto the mines and nowhere else. As i discovered....

You can advance through killer neutrals in trench. Did you try or is it a bug in coding?

Very early impression is how unbalanced the drop can be.
Game 13500686 - blue only dropped 2 land territs and i could bombard both first turn.
Would make a lot more sense to make each player drop at least one non-bombard land territ. The amount of troops you can get to land turn 1 makes it only initial deploy that is a problem

butleroftokyo wrote:Love this map already - encapsulates the savagery of the real battle

Just one point - if using trenches, the armies on the ships in the dardanelles become worthless, as the can only advance onto the mines and nowhere else. As i discovered....

With trench warfare you can only assault from regions held continuously since the start of your turn. If you conquer a region (or re-conquer a region) you cannot assault further from that region during the same turn. The one exception being 'killer neutrals' (explained on the Gameplay Notes page) from which you may continue assaulting. The game no longer involves steamrolling across the board. Instead you gradually advance your front!

butleroftokyo wrote:Love this map already - encapsulates the savagery of the real battle

Just one point - if using trenches, the armies on the ships in the dardanelles become worthless, as the can only advance onto the mines and nowhere else. As i discovered....

2013-10-26 18:41:39 - agentcom: I don't get why I'm getting a bonus troop for "Any land territ" I don't see that anywhere on the key. (Yes, I see the 1 auto, I'm talking about the 1 deploy)

cairnswk wrote:

kizkiz wrote:

butleroftokyo wrote:Love this map already - encapsulates the savagery of the real battle

Just one point - if using trenches, the armies on the ships in the dardanelles become worthless, as the can only advance onto the mines and nowhere else. As i discovered....

You can advance through killer neutrals in trench. Did you try or is it a bug in coding?

Very early impression is how unbalanced the drop can be.
Game 13500686 - blue only dropped 2 land territs and i could bombard both first turn.
Would make a lot more sense to make each player drop at least one non-bombard land territ. The amount of troops you can get to land turn 1 makes it only initial deploy that is a problem

Mmm, interesting freedback.
with the drop...as harsh as it might sound...this is possibly how Gallipoli was.
Some got to land and then were forced back by the Turks..others didn't even make it that far. Some Turks were pummeled from the battleships.
Johnny Turkey [b0060] in your game happened to drop in an area that was bombardable from the battleships...you made the decision to bombard him before he could get a go.
Nothing wrong in that, but not the issue with game design rather than player decision.
Relective of the battle....i'd say very.
From my experience everyone is never going to be totally satisfide with the drop whether by design or by the nature of lady luck.

Gilligan wrote:

2013-10-26 18:41:39 - agentcom: I don't get why I'm getting a bonus troop for "Any land territ" I don't see that anywhere on the key. (Yes, I see the 1 auto, I'm talking about the 1 deploy)

cairnswk wrote:

Gilligan wrote:

2013-10-26 18:41:39 - agentcom: I don't get why I'm getting a bonus troop for "Any land territ" I don't see that anywhere on the key. (Yes, I see the 1 auto, I'm talking about the 1 deploy)

What are you saying here Gilligan?

<continent>
<name>Any Land Territory</name>
<bonus>1</bonus>
<components>
<territory>KK Beach</territory>
<territory>Kum Kale</territory>
<territory>In Tepe</territory>
<territory>Halil-eli</territory>
<territory>F5</territory>
<territory>Dumbrek</territory>
<territory>Erenkui</territory>
<territory>Kizil-chilali</territory>
<territory>F6</territory>
<territory>Dardanos</territory>
<territory>Cephez Pt.</territory>
<territory>F7</territory>
<territory>Sari Saglar Beach</territory>
<territory>Saraijik</territory>
<territory>Chanak Kale</territory>
<territory>F8</territory>
<territory>Beach W</territory>
<territory>Beach V</territory>
<territory>Beach X</territory>
<territory>Sedd el Bahr</territory>
<territory>Beach S</territory>
<territory>Gully Beach</territory>
<territory>Tekke Burnu Trenches</territory>
<territory>Beach Y</territory>
<territory>Krithia</territory>
<territory>F4</territory>
<territory>Kum Tepe</territory>
<territory>Achi Baba</territory>
<territory>Fistkush</territory>
<territory>Seri Tepe</territory>
<territory>F3</territory>
<territory>Gaba Tepe</territory>
<territory>Kilid Baar Plateau</territory>
<territory>Feshkesh</territory>
<territory>F2</territory>
<territory>F1</territory>
<territory>Madios</territory>
<territory>Serafim</territory>
<territory>3rd Ridge</territory>
<territory>Lone Pine Ridge</territory>
<territory>Anzac Cove</territory>
<territory>Quinn's Post</territory>
<territory>Kehlia Beach</territory>
<territory>Kojadere</territory>
<territory>Bigali</territory>
<territory>Chunuk Bair</territory>
<territory>Monash Gully</territory>
<territory>H60 - Hill60</territory>
<territory>Beach C</territory>
<territory>Beach B</territory>
<territory>CH - Chocolate Hill</territory>
<territory>Scimitar Hill</territory>
<territory>Anafarta Sagir</territory>
<territory>Biylak Anaka</territory>
<territory>Gelibolu III Corp</territory>
<territory>Tepe</territory>
<territory>Turchten Keui</territory>
<territory>Kavak Tepe</territory>
<territory>Ejelmar Beach</territory>
<territory>Gendarmerie</territory>
<territory>Lower Suvla Plain</territory>
<territory>Nubresi Point</territory>
<territory>Beach A</territory>
<territory>Suvla Point</territory>
<territory>Seri Tepe Ridge</territory>
<territory>Kiretch Tepe</territory>
</components>
<required>1</required>
</continent>

sempaispellcheck wrote:...
Still, to be eliminated from a game before you even get a chance to go is not exactly fair.
Yes, I know "all's fair in love and war" but CC is not actual war - and I'm willing to bet that not many people will be willing to play this map once they find out that could happen.
sempai