Conquer Club

codierose wrote:so whom do i investigate tonight my thoughts pershy what do you think

why would you say if there may be a framer?

Iron Butterfly wrote:

codierose wrote:so whom do i investigate tonight my thoughts pershy what do you think

why would you say if there may be a framer?

ignore. I posted seeing top of page...its been adressed.

I am not buying cat's claim...seems too unpredictable to me (even for the twisted mind of dazza).

As for cod's investigation...we should not provide direction...sets up too many risks that it can be messed with.

Investigated whomever you suspect cod and share any results tomorrow.

catnipdreams wrote:

Ragian wrote:Let me get this straight. You are forced to act and last night you targeted edoc who died? So you either blocked, investigated, vigged or protected edoc. So you either blocked or vigged him and you chose him based on his behaviour on D1.

What makes me iffy is that when you choose whom to target tonight, you might choose cod given that you don't entirely trust him, right? You might accidentally vig the cop then :shock

I also might have investigated him, but the mod did not send me a report, because he was dead. I don't know. I suspect I roleblocked him, because he did not act, and the night scene flavor goes on about him being aware something was wrong.

If Town does not want me to target codierose tonight, I won't target him tonight.

The beef is that whoever you target, you might kill. Happy days if its mafia, but no fun if it's a townie, let alone a power role.

Ragian wrote:The beef is that whoever you target, you might kill. Happy days if its mafia, but no fun if it's a townie, let alone a power role.

Of course, that is exactly the problem. However, before Town lynches me, please consider all aspects of this; I realize Town has no way of knowing for sure that I am Town until I flip Town, but I am Town and would like to help Town win if I can. Here are two ways that I think I can be of help to town; perhaps there are other ways that more experienced players can come up with, also?

(1) We must have a real doc here - not just my 25% random doc ability... Perhaps the real doc can protect codierose, and I can target codierose? That way codierose definitely does not die during the night, and I have a 25% chance of discovering if codierose is Town or not. Although if I am killed during the night, I can't report my investigation results. The real doc would protect the claimed cop, though, right? So this is one way to keep a Town player (me) alive and at least able to keep Town numbers up. if mafia kills me during the night, at least it spares another Town player from being killed.

(2) We can develop a list for me to select from for my night action. Perhaps if someone's name is on my short list, they will say something that will help Town. I will not contribute in any way to such a list, so that there isn't any way I influence the choices. Purely up to Town, and by having me pick from the choices on the list, mafia won't know exactly what I will do.

Just lynching me, eh, seems like a waste of a potential resource, that, if used properly, could benefit Town.

codierose wrote:so whom do i investigate tonight my thoughts pershy what do you think

I'm not sure, and as has been said I think it's something you should choose and not make public in case there IS a framer out there or mafia role blocker etc.

Nebuchadnezer wrote:My list would look different:

1. pershy
2. tenbar
3. MoB deadly
4. soundman
5. ragian
6. Iron butterfly
7. DJfireside
8. Some7hing CLEVER

I'm concerned about those that are fairly quiet.

Why am I at the TOP of your list Nebu...???

cat so if we don't lynch you tonight who do we lynch today
@ragian after your prod you said have had a busy weekend day 2 started thurs does your weekend start thurs lucky basrstool
@some7hing after prod you said same thing hmm then still added nothing
@pershy gone very quite
have these guys been flying under the scumdar much yes imo
so who do we lynch cat because of guilty verdict not sure im happy with it seems to convenient for mafia or she's very good at lying say that she is a she
i would more happy lynching one of the above and get cat to use her possible power on one of the others above if that makes any sense lol
my vote would be some7thing what has he actually added to this game
fastposted pershy nice to see you back

@Cod, no my weekend starts Fridays, but I have been very busy since Thursday. I think I have contributed a lot though.

codierose wrote:cat so if we don't lynch you tonight who do we lynch today
@ragian after your prod you said have had a busy weekend day 2 started thurs does your weekend start thurs lucky basrstool
@some7hing after prod you said same thing hmm then still added nothing
@pershy gone very quite
have these guys been flying under the scumdar much yes imo
so who do we lynch cat because of guilty verdict not sure im happy with it seems to convenient for mafia or she's very good at lying say that she is a she
i would more happy lynching one of the above and get cat to use her possible power on one of the others above if that makes any sense lol
my vote would be some7thing what has he actually added to this game
fastposted pershy nice to see you back

Sorry - had a busy weekend too.
Weelll.....I'm up for getting Cat to prove her power. The whole % stuff she was talking about made me a bit suspicious too though. I haven't come across JOAT's abilities b4 that has such and such a chance of success. This could be a tactic for mafia to hide behind in case it "didn't work". Having said that we could give her a chance to prove herself. If that is the consensus I will remove my vote, but to be honest I'm still not sure if I believe her claim.

Ragian wrote:@Cod, no my weekend starts Fridays, but I have been very busy since Thursday. I think I have contributed a lot though.

Just did a search on Ragian's contributions. Turns out he has been on a fair bit


search.php?keywords=Dazza%27s+1st&terms=all&author=ragian&sc=1&sf=all&sr=posts&sk=t&sd=d&st=0&ch=300&t=0&submit=Search

pershy your missing my point from your list of posts day 2 weds pops in votes then nothing until sat now active again only after prod and says busy weekend fully understand but last post was weds and it was only a vote post.
i don't know how to make a list like you have done for ragian would be interesting to see yours and some7thing.

Nebuchadnezer wrote:

codierose wrote:oh yes didnt think of that lol
so a list
1.MoB Deadly
2.Iron Butterfly
5.Ragian
6.pershy
9.Nebuchadnezer
10.Djfireside
11.soundman
12.tenbar
13.Some7hingCLEVER
i will investigate one of these scummy guys

My list would look different:

1. pershy
2. tenbar
3. MoB deadly
4. soundman
5. ragian
6. Iron butterfly
7. DJfireside
8. Some7hing CLEVER

I'm concerned about those that are fairly quiet.

Why am I on the quiet list? I may not post a whole lot of posts but I'm consistent. I don't usually post a lot of posts because I hate one liners and fluff posts. If I'm going to post something I want it to be meaningful and add to the discussion.

pershy wrote:The whole % stuff she was talking about made me a bit suspicious too though. I haven't come across JOAT's abilities b4 that has such and such a chance of success.

I was told the mod would randomly choose between the four night actions. If someone randomly chooses between one of four actions, there is a 25% chance of getting a particular action.

soundman wrote:

Nebuchadnezer wrote:

codierose wrote:oh yes didnt think of that lol
so a list
1.MoB Deadly
2.Iron Butterfly
5.Ragian
6.pershy
9.Nebuchadnezer
10.Djfireside
11.soundman
12.tenbar
13.Some7hingCLEVER
i will investigate one of these scummy guys

My list would look different:

1. pershy
2. tenbar
3. MoB deadly
4. soundman
5. ragian
6. Iron butterfly
7. DJfireside
8. Some7hing CLEVER

I'm concerned about those that are fairly quiet.

Why am I on the quiet list? I may not post a whole lot of posts but I'm consistent. I don't usually post a lot of posts because I hate one liners and fluff posts. If I'm going to post something I want it to be meaningful and add to the discussion.

the list was originaly a joke list copy and pasted from page 1 of who i should i investigate it included everyone but now you pointed out something i didn't see when neb posted his list he's put it into some sort of order where has this come from

Wow! Post a list and people start paying attention, eh? Had I known, I would have posted a list earlier...

Let's dissect it, shall we?

Nebuchadnezer wrote:
My list would look different:

1. pershy - I already brought a case against you pershy. You played it off, but I'm still not comfortable with you.
2. tenbarThis may be left over feelings from Raston, but you seem to just pop in to vote.
3. MoB deadly He's been all over the board, and was bent on killing our cop early.
4. soundmanMeh...no idea.
5. ragian Again...no idea.
6. Iron butterfly He seems townish, but I'm not sure.
7. DJfireside Umm...on second look he could move up, but he's not done anything really that I can think of.
8. Some7hing CLEVER If I was thinking, he would move up quite a bit. I read all the mafia games going on, and he is much more active in those other ones. Not at all active here...
As for myself, codie and catnipdreams...well no need to put them on the list, right?

I'm concerned about those that are fairly quiet.

Everyone happy? Good, you shouldn't be.

Anyway...it's been all day, and not one person has posted, "Hey, Neb, don't hammer Cat. That's a bad idea." In fact, you've been more interested in my list.

So...let's get some cards on the table...

UNVOTE. VOTE CATNIPDREAMS

Codierose...don't bother investigating me tonight...the pressure will be on me tomorrow, I'm sure. And I'm okay with that.

classic

Nebuchadnezer wrote:Wow! Post a list and people start paying attention, eh? Had I known, I would have posted a list earlier...

Let's dissect it, shall we?

Nebuchadnezer wrote:
My list would look different:

1. pershy - I already brought a case against you pershy. You played it off, but I'm still not comfortable with you.
2. tenbarThis may be left over feelings from Raston, but you seem to just pop in to vote.
3. MoB deadly He's been all over the board, and was bent on killing our cop early.
4. soundmanMeh...no idea.
5. ragian Again...no idea.
6. Iron butterfly He seems townish, but I'm not sure.
7. DJfireside Umm...on second look he could move up, but he's not done anything really that I can think of.
8. Some7hing CLEVER If I was thinking, he would move up quite a bit. I read all the mafia games going on, and he is much more active in those other ones. Not at all active here...
As for myself, codie and catnipdreams...well no need to put them on the list, right?

I'm concerned about those that are fairly quiet.

Everyone happy? Good, you shouldn't be.

Anyway...it's been all day, and not one person has posted, "Hey, Neb, don't hammer Cat. That's a bad idea." In fact, you've been more interested in my list.

So...let's get some cards on the table...

UNVOTE. VOTE CATNIPDREAMS

Codierose...don't bother investigating me tonight...the pressure will be on me tomorrow, I'm sure. And I'm okay with that.

So I guess your town traffic cop? Why would you not be investigated? She comes up town..damn sure investigate.

Well guys, I will come up town, so if anyone wants to discuss anything about night actions, best do it as soon as possible before we go to night...

Yes. Please investigate me. I'm sure mafia won't frame me.

Nebuchadnezer wrote:Yes. Please investigate me. I'm sure mafia won't frame me.

I just dont like how you act like you should be above suspicion. Why would you tell him not to?

Because if Cat actually is town, then his investigation was crap. Plus, I'm an easy target for a lynch the next day, so the investigation won't matter, will it? Somewhere, we need to find people we can trust, that won't be killed. I'm the easy target for the investigation and if there is a framer out there, guess who he's framing? So, don't waste the investigation on me...pick someone else at random...or he should use his own theories. I'm too obvious.

lets hope i get protected tonightl

Are we okay to post, even though we hit a lynch? Or do we get until Dazza tells us it's night? What's the protocall?

Codie: If our doc is worth anything, you will be...

oh oh just had a thought can i investigate codierose then i know whether or not im a paranoid cop
i already know who i will investigate
fastposted lets hope its not some7 I've seen him lurking but not posting

codierose wrote:pershy your missing my point from your list of posts day 2 weds pops in votes then nothing until sat now active again only after prod and says busy weekend fully understand but last post was weds and it was only a vote post.
i don't know how to make a list like you have done for ragian would be interesting to see yours and some7thing.

At the top of this page on the right is a button called advanced search options. Click on it and put in Dazza's 1st in the first search bar and the name of the player you want to see all contributions from. Very handy when trying to confirm your suspicions. Am at work now but will be checking back in later today and catch up with latest developments.