sorry.. somehow lost what I was writing in the quote above!!
Was saying that I was not implying that there were no keyowrds. I was implying that with cornering senfive there is a pretty high probability that wicked was tying to find a way to establish a win condition for herself - especially that she had side stepped the issue on multiple occastions.
I think either Senfive or Wicked is mafia. I am willing to try Senfive first, but if he is clean my next vote goes to wicked. makeout ot not.
Senfive wrote:Ok since everyone is being rash because I am not specificly quoting my win condition, last game I did and I got modkilled. I guess I must state my role.
all I ask is that the doc protect me tonight, assuming I make it that far.
I am the Cop. I don't know what else to say, in all the other games you still lynch the cop, but I will plead my case anyhow. I have only had one night to investigate and came up empty. RK is the Vig. I investigated him to be sure he was telling the truth. Before my deputy died he investigated wicked and she was pure vanilla. I was hoping for at least one more night to investigate Hos and Supercram. But without my deputy and me about to be lynched, that isn't looking possible.
All I ask is for protection tonight, and one more chance to prove my worth.
Senfive wrote:Ok since everyone is being rash because I am not specificly quoting my win condition, last game I did and I got modkilled. I guess I must state my role.
all I ask is that the doc protect me tonight, assuming I make it that far.
I am the Cop. I don't know what else to say, in all the other games you still lynch the cop, but I will plead my case anyhow. I have only had one night to investigate and came up empty. RK is the Vig. I investigated him to be sure he was telling the truth. Before my deputy died he investigated wicked and she was pure vanilla. I was hoping for at least one more night to investigate Hos and Supercram. But without my deputy and me about to be lynched, that isn't looking possible.
All I ask is for protection tonight, and one more chance to prove my worth.
I know for a fact that you are lying because cops do not get to find out what a persons role is, they only get to find out if a person is mafia or not.
I still put my life on the line even after this claim.
Also, now that Senfive has split the game open a bit, I feel it is safe to post a theory that I have.
As for the two s- I bet we have a serial killer among us.
If you are a townie who is familiar with the game of mafia this will make a lot of sense to you. I'll explain this later, try to figure it out on your own.
Senfive wrote:Ok since everyone is being rash because I am not specificly quoting my win condition, last game I did and I got modkilled. I guess I must state my role.
all I ask is that the doc protect me tonight, assuming I make it that far.
I am the Cop. I don't know what else to say, in all the other games you still lynch the cop, but I will plead my case anyhow. I have only had one night to investigate and came up empty. RK is the Vig. I investigated him to be sure he was telling the truth. Before my deputy died he investigated wicked and she was pure vanilla. I was hoping for at least one more night to investigate Hos and Supercram. But without my deputy and me about to be lynched, that isn't looking possible.
All I ask is for protection tonight, and one more chance to prove my worth.
I know for a fact that you are lying because cops do not get to find out what a persons role is, they only get to find out if a person is mafia or not.
I still put my life on the line even after this claim.
Ok let me spell it out for you. If what RK claimed was true about him being like a cop but not a cop and he came back townie, its pretty save to assume that he has that Power role. Also him picking someone randomly to kill fits his motive.
Machiavelli wrote:I know for a fact that you are lying because cops do not get to find out what a persons role is, they only get to find out if a person is mafia or not.
I still put my life on the line even after this claim.
This would be very important. do we have a way of confirming though? (this is only my 3rd mafia game). Also, if I understand correctly, Autoload can do anything he wants with the role.
Having said that - this could be similar to the time we lynched autoload - if we kill him AND he turns out to be the cop, then we can trust everything he said (and he said a lot). If he turns out to be dirty, then we can go through the list of names and lynch their asses.
Senfive wrote:Ok let me spell it out for you. If what RK claimed was true about him being like a cop but not a cop and he came back townie, its pretty save to assume that he has that Power role. Also him picking someone randomly to kill fits his motive.
ok.. this sounded both flip floppish and defensive. I say we pull an autoload on him.. I still don't think it was wrong in the other game.
A very useful mafia trick is to claim doc/cop to make the person who actually is those roles come forward. Just throwing that out there. If you are the actual cop (and not Sen), do not claim, we'll figure it out w/o risking you.
Can someone who played in Auto's last game say if he gave the role out of the investigated person? I've only ever played in Andy's games, and he doesn't do that.
Having both a cop and a deputy and a vigilante in a 12 person game? Seems a bit over-the-top pro-town to me. We know there's a deputy, and it's safe to assume there's another independent killing role b/c of the two deaths.
wicked wrote:Having both a cop and a deputy and a vigilante in a 12 person game? Seems a bit over-the-top pro-town to me. We know there's a deputy, and it's safe to assume there's another independent role b/c of the two s.
I was just thinking the exact same thing. Having cop masons in a 12 person game would be way to helpful for the town, even if there are two parties.
wicked wrote: Having both a cop and a deputy and a vigilante in a 12 person game? Seems a bit over-the-top pro-town to me.
and a serial killer!! Looks like everyone has a power role apparently. Auto is gnereous
I am starting to warm to the idea of Senfive going - we will gain a lot of info one way or the other. I do think Mac is TOTALLY sure- to a point where I think he might know something we don't. Can you hint?
Sen, WHY did you CLAIM when all you had to do was mention a keyword from your win condition????????????????????????????????????? That's ALL you had to do to get us off your back, not even quote anything! This stinks like mafia.
wicked wrote:Sen, WHY did you CLAIM when all you had to do was mention a keyword from your win condition????????????????????????????????????? That's ALL you had to do to get us off your back, not even quote anything! This stinks like mafia.
