Page 2 of 5

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Mon Jan 23, 2012 5:09 pm
by sherkaner
TheGeneral2112 wrote:Is there a private forum somewhere that we can work through this? I can be of help here, but this whole thing has me a little boggled. I've checked out the source on github, and I think that if we could put several minds to work (instead of a contest) we could make a difference.


I'll be available if help is needed, but since the github-setup hasn't lead to any commits other than my own, I'm kinda skeptical.
But if you have any questions or have any thoughts to share, just fire away at me first or put it in a thread in the tools development subforum.

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Mon Jan 23, 2012 10:21 pm
by ThrushAAX
Is the bounty competition still ongoing? I haven't worked on this since my submission... and I don't really want to do more work on something that someone else may be doing at the same time... ;)

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2012 8:55 pm
by ender516
sherkaner wrote:
TheGeneral2112 wrote:Is there a private forum somewhere that we can work through this? I can be of help here, but this whole thing has me a little boggled. I've checked out the source on github, and I think that if we could put several minds to work (instead of a contest) we could make a difference.


I'll be available if help is needed, but since the github-setup hasn't lead to any commits other than my own, I'm kinda skeptical.
But if you have any questions or have any thoughts to share, just fire away at me first or put it in a thread in the tools development subforum.

I am still trying to install git, so don't give up hope yet.

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Thu Jan 26, 2012 11:44 am
by Leehar
Do we have a stop-gap yet to move on from the old one even if a lot of new features aren't in yet?

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Thu Jan 26, 2012 1:47 pm
by ISN2
Leehar wrote:Do we have a stop-gap yet to move on from the old one even if a lot of new features aren't in yet?

From me, nothing yet, I could not even start working on it after tweaking the code ...

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Sat Jan 28, 2012 7:08 am
by sherkaner
ISN2 wrote:
Leehar wrote:Do we have a stop-gap yet to move on from the old one even if a lot of new features aren't in yet?

From me, nothing yet, I could not even start working on it after tweaking the code ...

Yeah, it is a bit daunting when you inspect the code. I've asked Dako to give a status update or something like it, but that hasn't happened yet.

I actually think I'll try a complete rewrite, since I have some spare time coming up.
Most important features as I see it:
- Overview of scores per map
- Indication of how close people are to specific medal(s).

What I want to change/remove:
- No popup any more, but an overlay or something like it (Probably the most controversial, some people won't like this).
- No graphs (at least at first)
- No ratings / display icons options
- Chrome support
- No fetching data twice when still on the same page.
- Easier data model, essentially what you get back from the API (and filling other structures with it as needed).

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Sat Jan 28, 2012 11:46 am
by chapcrap
I support you sherk!! =D>

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Wed Feb 08, 2012 1:23 pm
by agentcom
I know nothing about code, so I will be of no help on this. I just wanted to drop by and mention my support for updating Map Rank.

I have a wishlist and just want to get my voice out there. I'm sure many people have mentioned these same things, but here is what I would love to see Map Rank do.

1. Be able to Map Rank by Game Type (i.e. doubles, trips, assassin, etc.)
2. Be able to calculate Random medal numbers
3. Not close just because you navigate away from the page on which you opened Map Rank

Glad to hear that someone is at least working on it though. Good luck to all those that are undertaking this task.

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Thu Feb 09, 2012 12:43 pm
by ender516
agentcom wrote:I know nothing about code, so I will be of no help on this. I just wanted to drop by and mention my support for updating Map Rank.

I have a wishlist and just want to get my voice out there. I'm sure many people have mentioned these same things, but here is what I would love to see Map Rank do.

1. Be able to Map Rank by Game Type (i.e. doubles, trips, assassin, etc.)
2. Be able to calculate Random medal numbers
3. Not close just because you navigate away from the page on which you opened Map Rank

Glad to hear that someone is at least working on it though. Good luck to all those that are undertaking this task.

Regarding your wishlist:
  1. I thought Map Rank by Game Type was available by going through the Game Finder page, but a quick test on myself shows it only restricting the statistics based on the map, and possibly the players. Did this work before and get broken somehow?
  2. Calculations for Random medals were key to this competition. I wish I had had more time to crack this.
  3. I agree. I wish I knew a quick fix for this.

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Thu Feb 09, 2012 1:46 pm
by sherkaner
Hmm, now I have to reply. 1st broke because of a site-change in the last version chipv did, fixed in the newer version. 2nd was introduced in that version, 3rd is not possible.

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Thu Feb 09, 2012 2:05 pm
by Leehar
Would 3rd be fixable if it wasn't a pop-up? Either opened on same page, or a new tab?

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Thu Feb 09, 2012 4:44 pm
by chapcrap
I'm fine with the third option not being available. If you have the ability and now how to want to navigate away while you have the Map Rank pop up open, then you should be able to open a new tab. Not very difficult. Work on Map Rank should be saved for things that are more important.

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Thu Feb 09, 2012 4:57 pm
by ISN2
chapcrap wrote:I'm fine with the third option not being available. If you have the ability and now how to want to navigate away while you have the Map Rank pop up open, then you should be able to open a new tab. Not very difficult. Work on Map Rank should be saved for things that are more important.

Since the contents of the Map Rank are on the fly, there is no way to have it in a new tab, the only possible options are still a such pop up or an overlay in current tab (something like when you click on a map's image), anything else would need a server side content provider and can't be done on the fly ...

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Thu Feb 09, 2012 5:07 pm
by chapcrap
ISN2 wrote:
chapcrap wrote:I'm fine with the third option not being available. If you have the ability and now how to want to navigate away while you have the Map Rank pop up open, then you should be able to open a new tab. Not very difficult. Work on Map Rank should be saved for things that are more important.

Since the contents of the Map Rank are on the fly, there is no way to have it in a new tab, the only possible options are still a such pop up or an overlay in current tab (something like when you click on a map's image), anything else would need a server side content provider and can't be done on the fly ...

I wasn't advocating putting it in a new tab. I'm advocating keeping it the same in that regards.

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Thu Feb 09, 2012 5:11 pm
by ISN2
chapcrap wrote:
ISN2 wrote:
chapcrap wrote:I'm fine with the third option not being available. If you have the ability and now how to want to navigate away while you have the Map Rank pop up open, then you should be able to open a new tab. Not very difficult. Work on Map Rank should be saved for things that are more important.

Since the contents of the Map Rank are on the fly, there is no way to have it in a new tab, the only possible options are still a such pop up or an overlay in current tab (something like when you click on a map's image), anything else would need a server side content provider and can't be done on the fly ...

I was advocating putting it in a new tab. I'm advocating keeping it the same in that regards.

Oh sorry, I just did read from the wrong way, my bad :oops:

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Mon Feb 27, 2012 8:51 am
by Dako
Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition has ended!


After a long wait, at last, the Tech Team is closing this bounty. Unfortunately we didn't find a new maintainer for this tool but we have a clear winner of the bounty.


Please congratulate [player]ThrushAAX[/player]! =D> =D> =D>


New code is now hosted here. I have also updated the threads with this link so people can install this latest version that supports Clan and Training medals, and long awaited Random medals!


Thank you everyone!

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Mon Feb 27, 2012 10:09 am
by Dukasaur
Dako wrote:Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition has ended!


After a long wait, at last, the Tech Team is closing this bounty. Unfortunately we didn't find a new maintainer for this tool but we have a clear winner of the bounty.


Please congratulate [player]ThrushAAX[/player]! =D> =D> =D>


New code is now hosted here. I have also updated the threads with this link so people can install this latest version that supports Clan and Training medals, and long awaited Random medals!


Thank you everyone!


Congratulations ThrushAAX!


=D> =D>

This is one of the most-used tools on CC, so it is damn good news that it has been fixed!

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Mon Feb 27, 2012 2:48 pm
by Gilligan
At long last, very nice Thrush! =D>

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Mon Feb 27, 2012 9:01 pm
by Victor Sullivan
Sweet! :D

-Sully

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Mon Feb 27, 2012 9:13 pm
by perchorin
This is great news, thanks Thrush. I have a question though--why am I able to download this script for chrome but it doesn't actually work? I mean, I get the box in the sidebar and everything but if you try to maprank someone you just get an empty field pop-up.

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Mon Feb 27, 2012 10:39 pm
by Gilligan
perchorin wrote:This is great news, thanks Thrush. I have a question though--why am I able to download this script for chrome but it doesn't actually work? I mean, I get the box in the sidebar and everything but if you try to maprank someone you just get an empty field pop-up.


+1, I eventually just downloaded it on Firefox.

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Mon Feb 27, 2012 11:14 pm
by greenoaks
Dako wrote:Unfortunately we didn't find a new maintainer for this tool

what is required to maintain it ?

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Tue Feb 28, 2012 12:53 am
by EagleofGreenErth
love it but is there any chance of the medal icons being added?

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Tue Feb 28, 2012 2:20 am
by Dako
greenoaks wrote:
Dako wrote:Unfortunately we didn't find a new maintainer for this tool

what is required to maintain it ?

Somebody who will continuously support it. The only req is to know JavaScript.

EagleofGreenErth wrote:love it but is there any chance of the medal icons being added?

I shall see what can be done here.

Re: Map Rank GL Support Bounty Competition

Posted: Tue Feb 28, 2012 2:43 am
by greenoaks
Dako wrote:
greenoaks wrote:
Dako wrote:Unfortunately we didn't find a new maintainer for this tool

what is required to maintain it ?

Somebody who will continuously support it. The only req is to know JavaScript.
so we can't just have a bounty when the site adds some new features ?