Page 2 of 8
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Mon Jan 25, 2010 10:25 am
by Qwert
When turning in your spoils, an automatic one troop will be placed on the territory.
- If you already own the territory you are turning in and the troop level is higher than one,
it will still drop to one troop upon you turning in the spoils.
then there its no diference of Nuke spoils-what its use of these spoils,if you can not take all enemy troops.
People need to understand that they decide what option to play,and if they decide to play ninja spoil option,then they realised,that its possible to lost without armies in this games.Like in nuke spoils,people play games,and only can blame self for losing games with this spoils.
Only if you take all opponents armies with this spoils,then its worth to create these type of spoils,all other sugestions,who decrease numbers of troop achive in this way,its almost equal with nuke spoils.
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Mon Jan 25, 2010 3:26 pm
by Blitzaholic
WinklesMghee wrote:As a fan of nuclear spoils, I think logically people will also like the exact opposite.
When you turn in a set of spoils, you take over the territories. I would like to see it where you inherit however many troops are already on the region. Or you could just take over the territory and be given an automatic two.
What do you guys think?
ok, but, I think you would need to come up with a name to match the spoils. Naming it ninja does not make much sense.
This seems like theft, so maybe Robbing spoils or Hijacking spoils.
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Mon Jan 25, 2010 5:49 pm
by AndyDufresne
There was a reference to paratroopers earlier---something like that for a name might be the most fitting, depending on of course whatever details you all hammer out for the suggestion.
--Andy
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Mon Jan 25, 2010 6:49 pm
by Queen_Herpes
This is such a great idea, I can't stop posting about it.
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Mon Jan 25, 2010 7:45 pm
by AAFitz
Options
propaganda spoils 40's version
spy spoils 80's version
sleeper cell spoils or (just sleeper spoils) millenium version
or conquer spoils; use CC's own name.....it fits, it makes sense... cant ask for much more than that
very cool idea, regardless of the name....though I have to agree that ninja doesnt exactly fit.
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Mon Jan 25, 2010 8:07 pm
by AndyDufresne
Conquer Spoils is not too bad. But I'd still like to see someone wrangle in all the suggestions an ideas into one formulated and posted finalization!
--Andy
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Mon Jan 25, 2010 8:35 pm
by Corno4825
This is what I've gathered so far-
Variation 1:
If you turn in a card that's not yours, it becomes yours, armies and all.
If you turn in a card that's not yours, you add +2 to that country.
Play resumes as normal.
Variation 2:
All cards you turn in become yours. Army counts drop to 1 (or 2 or 3...)
Variation 3:
All cards you turn in become yours. Army counts on territories depend on Card Set turned in (1R, 2G, 3B, 4RGB on each)
Variation 4:
All cards you turn in become yours. Army counts drop to 1
Flat Rate deployment rules.
Any more ideas or discussions?
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Tue Jan 26, 2010 12:30 am
by WinklesMghee
Variation 5.
All cards you turn in become your territories.
All troops already on the territories become your troops.
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Tue Jan 26, 2010 10:20 am
by Qwert
by WinklesMghee ยป Tue Jan 26, 2010 7:30 am
Variation 5.
All cards you turn in become your territories.
All troops already on the territories become your troops.
Yes,that variation its right.Totaly diferent from Nuke spoils
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Thu Jan 28, 2010 1:27 am
by edwinissweet
Blitzaholic wrote:WinklesMghee wrote:As a fan of nuclear spoils, I think logically people will also like the exact opposite.
When you turn in a set of spoils, you take over the territories. I would like to see it where you inherit however many troops are already on the region. Or you could just take over the territory and be given an automatic two.
What do you guys think?
ok, but, I think you would need to come up with a name to match the spoils. Naming it ninja does not make much sense.
This seems like theft, so maybe Robbing spoils or Hijacking spoils.
i like plundering. it just seems to fit with the CC lingo
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Thu Jan 28, 2010 10:27 am
by 2dimes
qwert wrote:When turning in your spoils, an automatic one troop will be placed on the territory.
- If you already own the territory you are turning in and the troop level is higher than one,
it will still drop to one troop upon you turning in the spoils.
then there its no diference of Nuke spoils-what its use of these spoils,if you can not take all enemy troops.
People need to understand that they decide what option to play,and if they decide to play ninja spoil option,then they realised,that its possible to lost without armies in this games.Like in nuke spoils,people play games,and only can blame self for losing games with this spoils.
Only if you take all opponents armies with this spoils,then its worth to create these type of spoils,all other sugestions,who decrease numbers of troop achive in this way,its almost equal with nuke spoils.
No, the idea is, I have 1- 1000000 troops on France. You turn in the France card and it changes to You have 1-3 on France. Convesely if you have 10 guys on France and turn in the same card you're reduced to 1 then. Though if it's not too difficult I'd rather see your own territory changed to nuetral just too make it more annoying. The biggest problem with nuke right now is the same teriitory is being hit 4 times while others are being spared completely. This will get worse if the strongest guy not only has his bonus spared but then gets to drop his extra guys inside your areas. [tone=seethingsarcasm]That will be fabulous.[/tone]
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Thu Jan 28, 2010 5:12 pm
by Qwert
No, the idea is, I have 1- 1000000 troops on France. You turn in the France card and it changes to You have 1-3 on France. Convesely if you have 10 guys on France and turn in the same card you're reduced to 1 then. Though if it's not too difficult I'd rather see your own territory changed to nuetral just too make it more annoying. The biggest problem with nuke right now is the same teriitory is being hit 4 times while others are being spared completely. This will get worse if the strongest guy not only has his bonus spared but then gets to drop his extra guys inside your areas. [tone=seethingsarcasm]That will be fabulous.[/tone]
That why you had options to decide before play, if you want to play Escalating,you use these option,if you want to play Nuke,you take that, if you want to play Ninja Spoil,you will try that. If you want to play something unique and new, then you need to have something totaly diferent from NUke,and this will not be if you Kill 2-3 opponents and get 2-3 yours(and this can hepend in begining).
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Fri Jan 29, 2010 12:56 am
by Blitzaholic
AAFitz wrote:Options
propaganda spoils 40's version
spy spoils 80's version
sleeper cell spoils or (just sleeper spoils) millenium version
or conquer spoils; use CC's own name.....it fits, it makes sense... cant ask for much more than that
very cool idea, regardless of the name....though I have to agree that ninja doesnt exactly fit.
that's a lot of spoils
so many options, might as well create a few different variations, we have a lot go with. Keep em coming.
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Fri Jan 29, 2010 1:01 am
by Kid_A
oooo,i like this idea!
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Fri Jan 29, 2010 1:45 am
by 2dimes
qwert wrote:That why you had options to decide before play, if you want to play Escalating,you use these option,if you want to play Nuke,you take that, if you want to play Ninja Spoil,you will try that. If you want to play something unique and new, then you need to have something totaly diferent from NUke,and this will not be if you Kill 2-3 opponents and get 2-3 yours(and this can hepend in begining).
Right, that why we suggest adding this more option. Because right now if I want play Ninja Spoil we not can take Ninja Spoil choice.
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 10:39 pm
by WinklesMghee
So how about when you take over the territories you absorb the troops that already are on the territories.
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2010 2:38 am
by karelpietertje
Why don't we call them Pirate Spoils?
Pirates steal, just like these spoils do!
YARRRR!
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Fri Feb 12, 2010 3:12 pm
by Queen_Herpes
Ninja Spoils is a great new name for it!
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Sat Feb 13, 2010 5:29 pm
by Queen_Herpes
This suggestion sounds so great....jumping territories with spoils! It is an awesome suggestion! Thank you for posting it!
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Sat Feb 13, 2010 7:58 pm
by Little Witt
i really hope they put this type of spoils in the games this would be an awesome new type of game play and think of what would happen in a build game lol. a guy has a big stack of troops say 1000 troops next thing he knows hes being destroy by the troops that were his lol
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Sat Feb 13, 2010 9:15 pm
by AAFitz
Blitzaholic wrote:AAFitz wrote:Options
propaganda spoils 40's version
spy spoils 80's version
sleeper cell spoils or (just sleeper spoils) millenium version
or conquer spoils; use CC's own name.....it fits, it makes sense... cant ask for much more than that
very cool idea, regardless of the name....though I have to agree that ninja doesnt exactly fit.
lol...no, they were just name options for the same type... and personally, I like "conquer spoils"...the others were more for fun
that's a lot of spoils
so many options, might as well create a few different variations, we have a lot go with. Keep em coming.
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Fri Feb 19, 2010 6:39 pm
by Aalmeida17
i like this idea
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Fri Feb 19, 2010 7:44 pm
by Queen_Herpes
WinklesMghee wrote:As a fan of nuclear spoils, I think logically people will also like the exact opposite.
When you turn in a set of spoils, you take over the territories. I would like to see it where you inherit however many troops are already on the region. Or you could just take over the territory and be given an automatic two.
What do you guys think?
There have been a few variations offered. Of the variations, I'd like to see the following:
Turn in a set of spoils. If owned, add two armies to the owned territory. If unowned, the territory becomes yours with 3 armies on the territory.
A "ninja" not only jumps you, but pretty much pwns you as well...so...
In addition to the jumped territories, player receives additional armies to deploy wherever. I'm torn as to how many, flat rate seems like too much. Escalating eventually awards too many. Perhaps a modified flat rate for ninja where a red set is 2, green is 4, blue is 6, and mixed is 8. If not that, then I would like to see a true flat rate of 5 armies awarded no matter what the color of the set. After all, with the jumping of the territories, the player is increasing the troops count by as many as 9 if all three are "unowned."
-----
This also brings up an interesting point. Will the territory count bonus (usually awarded at the beginning of the turn) award armies based on how many territories you hold before or after you deploy your ninja spoils?
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Fri Feb 19, 2010 8:17 pm
by MrBenn
The best name would be Trojan Spoils...
Re: Ninja Spoils
Posted: Fri Feb 19, 2010 9:32 pm
by Queen_Herpes
MrBenn wrote:The best name would be Trojan Horse Spoils...
Corrected.