A Game of Thrones (Day 4)

[pmchugh]

Sailor - I uundertstand that the firat mafia game can be a bit tough, but just go along, and read some of the stuff that comes up. Complaining you don't know how to play is usual, but at least try to put in a decent affort into your games.

ani giving out advice

Ani I understand your first 30 games can be a bit tough but just go along and I'm sure you'll get their eventually.

[captainwalrus]

This is one of my first games and I have yet to finnish one but even I know that the object it not to get lyinched unless your jester. My personal predgidous against seals aseide, I'm not a big fan of sailor, but I want to wait for him to post before I am sure he is not jester. Some more usefull advice from a fellow noob, Don't lurk. I often see you post in the foundery so I'm sure you have time to just drop in and grace us with your presence every now and then.

[animorpherv1]

Sailor - I uundertstand that the firat mafia game can be a bit tough, but just go along, and read some of the stuff that comes up. Complaining you don't know how to play is usual, but at least try to put in a decent affort into your games.

ani giving out advice

Ani I understand your first 30 games can be a bit tough but just go along and I'm sure you'll get their eventually.

[sailorseal]

Sailorseal might want to post something useful soon, or I may place my vote on him.

Sailorseal, what do you think about this game? Who seems scummy to you, and why? Can you defend your in-game actions so far? Why shouldn't we lynch you?

These questions should get you started, if you can't think of a way to contribute useful content to the game.

I bring life to the thread, you lynch me and there will be an empty spot in your heart...

[Stroop]

unvote vote sailorseal, I think you've had about enough chances to actually say something of use

I don't think SS is a jester, simply because I can't think of anyone in the books that would fit that role.

[captainwalrus]

unvote vote sailorseal, I think you've had about enough chances to actually say something of use

I don't think SS is a jester, simply because I can't think of anyone in the books that would fit that role.

How sure are you, cause I never read the books and he is almost at L-1 at which point he can lynch himself.I don't want to just hand the game over.

[Stroop]

I bring life to the thread, you lynch me and there will be an empty spot in your heart...

unvote vote sailorseal, I think you've had about enough chances to actually say something of use

I don't think SS is a jester, simply because I can't think of anyone in the books that would fit that role.

How sure are you, cause I never read the books and he is almost at L-1 at which point he can lynch himself.I don't want to just hand the game over.

*quote fixed, hope no-one minds*

Well, I read the books twice, but last time was still at least a year ago. I'm not entirely sure, but I really can't remember any character that would be a jester.

But, without relying on the theme, I'd still lynch him. If he really is a jester, I'd rather lynch him now than having him play games with us later on in the game. The first day lynch isn't likely to get us scum anyway and we've got a deadline.

[ga7]

Why is Sailor still noy lynched? He's the perfect day 1 lynch!
Seriously the jester argument is farfetched, he's a scummy noob that's all there is to it I believe. The fact he doesn't seem to want to claim is enough.

[Natewolfman]

Vote Count

sailorseal - 9 votes (ga7, pmchung, Suspect101, The Fuzzy Pengui, Simon Viavant, LSU Tiger Josh, icedagger, gimpyThewonder, Stroop)
captainwalrus - 5 votes (sailorseal, gimpyThewonder, AceArtemis, Iliad, icedagger)
derfderf34 - 2 votes (john9blue, animorpherv1)
ga7 - 2 votes (ace1217, Minister Masket)
animorph - 1 vote (sheepofdumb)
Suspect101 - 1 vote (jesterhawk)

with 24 players it takes 13 to lynch
sailorseal is at -4

[Suspect101]

Vote Count

sailorseal - 9 votes (ga7, pmchung, Suspect101, The Fuzzy Pengui, Simon Viavant, LSU Tiger Josh, icedagger, gimpyThewonder, Stroop)
captainwalrus - 5 votes (sailorseal, gimpyThewonder, AceArtemis, Iliad, icedagger)
derfderf34 - 2 votes (john9blue, animorpherv1)
ga7 - 2 votes (ace1217, Minister Masket)
animorph - 1 vote (sheepofdumb)
Suspect101 - 1 vote (jesterhawk)

with 24 players it takes 13 to lynch
sailorseal is at -4

you posted this as I was counting votes. I got all the way through all of them and then come to this post.... what a waste of 20 mins. At least I know you are right.

[/]

Hmmm, I guess we do need a lynch, after rereading, the whole thing seems more annoying than scummy (since he's not cooperating), still we aren't getting any info from having him alive, then Vote Sailorseal.
Still the jester has been winning day one every game lately, so if he does come up jester, I will refuse to put any faith in everyone on the bandwaggon for the remainder of the game.

[derfderf34]

actually form what i got from what nate has said you need to figure out your own role and all that you have been given is if you are town or scum so he cant really claim, but he cant be jester either so... vote ss
i am aware that that doesnt really make too much sense but that is really how i have unserstood it

[ace1217]

actually form what i got from what nate has said you need to figure out your own role and all that you have been given is if you are town or scum so he cant really claim, but he cant be jester either so... vote ss
i am aware that that doesnt really make too much sense but that is really how i have unserstood it

Wait, what? Did you just reveal info about your own role?

[AceArtemis]

I bring life to the thread, you lynch me and there will be an empty spot in your heart...

If you are not contributing anything useful to the game, people will think you are scum. If you are scum, I don't care if you bring life to the thread, I want you outta here. Plus, not contributing to the game does not help the town in any way, and it will be more difficult for us to hunt the scum.

I am reluctant to vote for you right now, because that would put you at L-1, and I want one or two more days of discussion before someone hammers. However, if by tomorrow nothing useful comes out of your computer, I guarantee you, you will get my vote.

To those saying SS is a jester, who really cares? IMO the jester is a good use of a Day 1 lynch. If we remove the jester from the game early, the jester won't be around to cause confusion later in the game, helping out the mafia and possibly forcing us to waste more useful lynches later in the game.

[icedagger]

Anyone else think Stroop is coming across all newbie scum?

SS- claim your role please

[jesterhawk]

This is a game of treachery and deceit with a theme based on a book full of treachery and deceit. Not roleplaying. Seriously what do you expect me to do: pm people and offer to marry my daughter to them to sign our new alliance?

Ah yes, I see your point, my bad, and I will be expecting the PM with the marriage proposal

JH

[Minister Masket]

Sailorseal might want to post something useful soon, or I may place my vote on him.

Sailorseal, what do you think about this game? Who seems scummy to you, and why? Can you defend your in-game actions so far? Why shouldn't we lynch you?

These questions should get you started, if you can't think of a way to contribute useful content to the game.

I bring life to the thread, you lynch me and there will be an empty spot in your heart...

Obvious trap is obvious.

C'mon guys, if sailorseal is the Jester (and I think he is), then he's playing it like a master. He's trying to get you riled up so you vote for him by posting nonsense. It's a classic dupe, and you people are falling for it.

[Iliad]

Firstly who is a jester? I can think of no character who wants to kill himself or get himself killed.

Secondly-if it was a more experienced person maybe. This way he looks like simply very inexperienced.

[Suspect101]

Sailorseal might want to post something useful soon, or I may place my vote on him.

Sailorseal, what do you think about this game? Who seems scummy to you, and why? Can you defend your in-game actions so far? Why shouldn't we lynch you?

These questions should get you started, if you can't think of a way to contribute useful content to the game.

I bring life to the thread, you lynch me and there will be an empty spot in your heart...

Obvious trap is obvious.

C'mon guys, if sailorseal is the Jester (and I think he is), then he's playing it like a master. He's trying to get you riled up so you vote for him by posting nonsense. It's a classic dupe, and you people are falling for it.

You are missing the point.

We don't care if he is jester.

[ace1217]

Vote SS

[icedagger]

Firstly who is a jester? I can think of no character who wants to kill himself or get himself killed.

Moon Boy possibly?

Not that it matters

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Who cares if he is a jester. Get the idiot out the game and move on as he won't be helping us.

[Stroop]

Who cares if he is a jester. Get the idiot out the game and move on as he won't be helping us.

[Strider24]

I doesn't really matter anyway if he is the jester then it's better to get him out of the game now rather than to confuse us when we have a good leed on someone.

SS has rarely posted and when he has it's been complete nonsense or he has used his inexperience as an excuse. I would rather loose a townie who is confusing everyone and accidentally helping the scum than to keep that townie alive. Just because they have a good alliegence doesn't mean they are good for that side. If that made any sense.

So with that Vote SS

[AceArtemis]

There's the hammer. I was going to hammer in a couple of hours, but maybe I'm just too generous about giving him opportunities to defend himself.