Page 9 of 22
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Tue Feb 20, 2024 9:45 pm
by swang918
Sounds like a tracker type role. Why couldnt it have been Loose poisoning vot that you saw? I think vot is a likely target for Loose given Loose’s post about vot being strong and MVP as either town or scum
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Tue Feb 20, 2024 9:47 pm
by Kingm
swang918 wrote:Sounds like a tracker type role. Why couldnt it have been Loose poisoning vot that you saw? I think vot is a likely target for Loose given Loose’s post about vot being strong and MVP as either town or scum
It was Vot who visited LC.
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Tue Feb 20, 2024 9:51 pm
by swang918
Kingm wrote:swang918 wrote:Sounds like a tracker type role. Why couldnt it have been Loose poisoning vot that you saw? I think vot is a likely target for Loose given Loose’s post about vot being strong and MVP as either town or scum
It was Vot who visited LC.
Oh ok now that's pretty damning. Looks to be a likely votanic lynch today. I'll hold off voting though until he gets a chance to defend.
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Tue Feb 20, 2024 10:19 pm
by DirtyDishSoap
Can i get a VC before i cast my vote? Don't want to prematurely hammer before Vot says his peace.
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Tue Feb 20, 2024 10:29 pm
by strike wolf
Vote Count
*pixar* (1)-PMC
Vot (2)-Kingm, Fusi
Trafalgar
Swang
Fusi
Son!c
Dds
EWebasher
PMC
Kingm
Charle
Devante
With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Deadline Monday.
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Tue Feb 20, 2024 10:50 pm
by DirtyDishSoap
Cool. Vote Vot
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 2:01 am
by Votanic
Woww... Now I have to knock half you players down a peg, for taking flying noob-tard leaps onto the wrong bandwagon.
...but first VOTE Kingm for totally lying.
Kingm wrote:It was Vot who visited LC.
@ Kingm: The only other possibility is somebody else has a power role that makes you see things that aren't there...
@ Fusi: You didn't do a joke vote Day 1, you did the second vote on a
real bandwagon, and unlike pmchugh, you never even removed yours. You left it up for the whole Day. Now today you are doing it again.
A strong FOS at you.
@ DDS: It doesn't matter if you are the final hammer or not. Irresponsibly adding a vote to a bad bandwagon is either scummy or bad towny,
only you know which.
TrafalgarLaw01 wrote:
Hmmm have you got any info? I mean I kinda want Votanic as well cause I kinda agree with what ewe posted before. And feel his defense on 2 votes were kinda odd especially when later he tried to push a "joke" wagon for jokes with sword.
@ Traf: I already explained how ewe was wrong (perhaps deliberately so..?). Also, my vote on DDS was
not a joke vote. It was a
real vote based on his scummy tendency to not let a distracting joke drop.
Seriously, stop acting like Day 1 votes (in red) are jokes. Don't you remember how Sonic started a bad vote on you on Day 1 in the Thing Game. It was pure Sonic (so
total 'joke), but even still,you were never able to shake it the whole game, nevermind the fact that you were actually Town.
@ Sonic: No, wrong. I am
not the only one talking about city and village... and almost every time I do, I also add that it
might not mean anything... So don't act like I'm building it up to be either more
or less than what it is.
@EVERYBODY: If/when I die, and you find out I'm town, go back and take another look at Fusi and DDS's votes for me. Cause they're either '
scum'... or '
dumb'.
But whatever the heck you do, lynch Kingm today because he is a total liar!!!
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 2:19 am
by Charle
I have a feeling that Loose poisoned Vot. I would also think that I would like to hear Vot's defence before I cast my vote. If Vot is poisoned, the worst case if we lynched him (if he turns town) is that we only loose one town. I might be wrong, but it looks like the cards on the table is showing towards Vot as scum.
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 2:20 am
by Charle
Sorry, I wrote my post before I have seen Vot's response.
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 2:39 am
by SoN!c
Votanic wrote:
@EVERYBODY: If/when I die, and you find out I'm town, go back and take another look at Fusi and DDS's votes for me. Cause they're either 'scum'... or 'dumb'.
But whatever the heck you do, lynch Kingm today because he is a total liar!!!
Wow! GREAT red-handed CATCH

! Pretty open-and-shut case here.
Also Vot is certainly playing different in here to the great guide he was in the werewolf game
Vote Vot
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 2:58 am
by Charle
Votanic wrote:
...but first VOTE Kingm for totally lying.
Kingm wrote:It was Vot who visited LC.
I am battling with the fact that why would Kingm lie regarding something like this? It is not as if he is against a corner or have to fight for survival or anything else. Surely he must be on to something. Let's find out.
Vote Vot
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 3:01 am
by Charle
I see bold in my vote was deleted by mistake, so here it is again Vote Vot
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 3:04 am
by pmchugh
strike wolf wrote:Vote Count
*pixar* (1)-PMC
Vot (2)-Kingm, Fusi
Trafalgar
Swang
Fusi
Son!c
Dds
EWebasher
PMC
Kingm
Charle
Devante
With 12 alive, it takes 6 to lynch. Deadline Monday.
Shouldn't it be 7 to lynch?
I make vot on 5, so don't want to hammer yet. Vot, time for role claim if you have any.
Unvote pixar
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 3:23 am
by Votanic
Oh yeah, and if you want me to role claim... how about Vanilla Townie (from the City...)
...and that should be all any town player would want me to claim anyway.
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 3:39 am
by pmchugh
Yeah unlucky vot I think you have just been caught. Between the SK kill and this we are killing it.
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 3:42 am
by Votanic
SoN!c wrote:Votanic wrote:
@EVERYBODY: If/when I die, and you find out I'm town, go back and take another look at Fusi and DDS's votes for me. Cause they're either 'scum'... or 'dumb'.
But whatever the heck you do, lynch Kingm today because he is a total liar!!!
Wow! GREAT red-handed CATCH

! Pretty open-and-shut case here.
Also Vot is certainly playing different in here to the great guide he was in the werewolf game
Vote Vot
Gosh... for a second there, Sonic, I though you were congratulating
me for catching
kingm!
Then I saw who you were voting for...
ugh.
I must say, watching you completely ignore/misinterpet everything I just wrote and then
immediately (and thoughtlessly) do a flying leap onto my bandwagon just fully exemplifies everything I remember about your play style,
and I mean that in the worst way possible...
@ Charle: I don't know why kingm is making stuff up about me either...
Maybe scum thinks it is worth sacrificing kingm tomorrow if they can get rid of me today?
Maybe in this game, scum actually has a detective role? Like a bad, evil detective?
Who know, maybe this game really is City vs. Village...
FPed by pmchugh
If you are town, you will eat those words with your hat... but if you are scum, I guess I should say '
well played'.
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 3:56 am
by Votanic
Seriously, if you are town, unvote me...
Several players haven't even shown up today, maybe those are the players with common sense...
So let's wait for Devante and whomever else hasn't posted in awhile.
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 4:13 am
by DirtyDishSoap
Votanic wrote:I made a really long OMGUS without explaining why I would visit LC in the first place.
Summarized for all those out there. I feel like this is our best lead currently, not taking it off without a claim since King came out.
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 4:16 am
by Ewebasher
VOTE VOTANIC
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 4:22 am
by Votanic
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 4:23 am
by Votanic
One more good idea: Make kingm claim too.
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 4:33 am
by Votanic
...and one more question too.
Some of you said you were not going to vote for me until I defended myself, which I did, as completely and truthfully as possible.
So now, what makes you so sure my defense is a lie?
Of course, I'm talking to the town players among you...
The scum players know exactly why they are pretending to not believe me.
...and they are probably totally amazed at how easy it was to get clueless townies to hop aboard.
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 4:44 am
by DirtyDishSoap
So wait...What did you claim? Don't give me this Sonic/LC bread crumb crap. Either you claimed, or you didn't, and I'm like 99% sure, you haven't and if you did before, why the hell would you to begin with? Wut
King did claim, albeit, soft claim tracker which to me is a hell of alot more then what you've so "claimed."
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 4:52 am
by Votanic
DirtyDishSoap wrote:So wait...What did you claim? Don't give me this Sonic/LC bread crumb crap. Either you claimed, or you didn't, and I'm like 99% sure, you haven't and if you did before, why the hell would you to begin with? Wut
King did claim, albeit, soft claim tracker which to me is a hell of alot more then what you've so "claimed."
I claimed Vanilla Townie.
And whatever Mking 'softclaimed', I know he's lying...
I agree, in a regular Mafia game, having a scum player expose himself as a liar, just to take out one townie, doesn't make sense.
..but maybe,
just maybe, the underlying team/role dynamics in this set-up, are very different from those of standard Mafia...
Re: The Wild Beyond the Walls Mafia (D2) 12/13
Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2024 5:11 am
by Ewebasher
To be fair I've now found your claim... it was initially in the post where you accidentally posted within your SoN!c quote so I missed it... (yes maybe did skim the following post where you reposted because you'd commented above the quote as well as below in that one)
But to come out on D1 saying 'Even though I'm not confirmed, I am happy to claim town and try to be a nucleus around which town might be able to develop some trust.' feels a bit scummy to me to be honest? Maybe trying too hard?