SoC 1v1 Ladder Challenge (CLOSED)

[dhallmeyer]

I challenge ganguscalm.

Game 15529633
Game 15529635

my home Game 15531117

I have defeated ganguscalm, 2-1.

That takes me to 6. I shall then challenge der Laddermeister, celliottii, for a spot in the dibs range.

Game 15567616
Game 15567627

[celliottii]

I challenge ganguscalm.

Game 15529633
Game 15529635

my home Game 15531117

I have defeated ganguscalm, 2-1.

That takes me to 6. I shall then challenge der Laddermeister, celliottii, for a spot in the dibs range.

Game 15567616
Game 15567627

And here's my game: Game 15570014

I've recorded the match result with ganguscalm and the new challenge at me...towards me...for me...well, it's recorded.

[ElricTheGreat]

Time to make the jump up ... MGSteve lets do this !!!

Home: Game 15556696
Random: Game 15556698

Action at last! You're on, Big E: Game 15556742

Whew! Glad I was one rung up....I felt Elric's claws up here....Got the challenge recorded for you.

I took the series 2-1 .... hhmmm who will be my next target???

[iAmCaffeine]

I beat ganguscalm 2-1.

[ganguscalm]

I challenge dhallmeyer to my old spot on the ladder
random Game 15567800
home Game 15567801
pw : elvis--------------------------------------------------------------------uh huh huh-------------------------------------->>>

[ElricTheGreat]

Steve ... hurry up and win your challenge so you jump ahead of me so I can challenge you to a rematch ...

[dhallmeyer]

I challenge dhallmeyer to my old spot on the ladder
random Game 15567800
home Game 15567801
pw : elvis--------------------------------------------------------------------uh huh huh-------------------------------------->>>

I think we have a Rule 10 problem here. I'll wait to accept games until we get a ruling.

10. If you challenge someone AND lose, you will retain your Ladder rung, but you cannot re-challenge that player until after you have challenged someone else. For example, you are #9 and challenge and lose to the #6 player, you cannot challenge the #6 player until you challenge either #7 or #8.

How does it work if I challenged and won, and now I'm being challenged by the same player, with no intervening challenge from him?

[ben.cleuch]

I challenge the good Captn B.

My game Pelops War standard foggy chained Game 15546555

Random game Auto Esc Chained Sunny Game 15546558

Good luck Captn B

ben.cleuch

Capt B was victorious,
ben.cleuch

[ganguscalm]

I challenge dhallmeyer to my old spot on the ladder
random Game 15567800
home Game 15567801
pw : elvis--------------------------------------------------------------------uh huh huh-------------------------------------->>>

I think we have a Rule 10 problem here. I'll wait to accept games until we get a ruling.

10. If you challenge someone AND lose, you will retain your Ladder rung, but you cannot re-challenge that player until after you have challenged someone else. For example, you are #9 and challenge and lose to the #6 player, you cannot challenge the #6 player until you challenge either #7 or #8.

How does it work if I challenged and won, and now I'm being challenged by the same player, with no intervening challenge from him?

I see it as a NEW challenge , my last challenge was to iAmCaffeine -------------uh hmmm hmmm.....................???

[dhallmeyer]

I challenge dhallmeyer to my old spot on the ladder
random Game 15567800
home Game 15567801
pw : elvis--------------------------------------------------------------------uh huh huh-------------------------------------->>>

I think we have a Rule 10 problem here. I'll wait to accept games until we get a ruling.

10. If you challenge someone AND lose, you will retain your Ladder rung, but you cannot re-challenge that player until after you have challenged someone else. For example, you are #9 and challenge and lose to the #6 player, you cannot challenge the #6 player until you challenge either #7 or #8.

How does it work if I challenged and won, and now I'm being challenged by the same player, with no intervening challenge from him?

I see it as a NEW challenge , my last challenge was to iAmCaffeine -------------uh hmmm hmmm.....................???

I see your point, but I am not sure whether it is correct. I will accept the invites and let Chuck settle it.

[ben.cleuch]

i challenge ben.cleuch
Game 15554277
Game 15554280
PM sent

I won 2-1
ben.cleuch

[celliottii]

Time to make the jump up ... MGSteve lets do this !!!

Home: Game 15556696
Random: Game 15556698

Action at last! You're on, Big E: Game 15556742

Whew! Glad I was one rung up....I felt Elric's claws up here....Got the challenge recorded for you.

I took the series 2-1 .... hhmmm who will be my next target???

Got the match recorded for ETG...

I beat ganguscalm 2-1.

Got this match recorded as well...

I challenge dhallmeyer to my old spot on the ladder
random Game 15567800
home Game 15567801
pw : elvis--------------------------------------------------------------------uh huh huh-------------------------------------->>>

This is legit....and I've recorded it...

Without re-posting all the Rule 10 quotes from above, let me state that Ganguscalm challenged iAmCaffeine and lost....therefore, he is free to rechallenge dhallmeyer.

I challenge the good Captn B.

My game Pelops War standard foggy chained Game 15546555

Random game Auto Esc Chained Sunny Game 15546558

Good luck Captn B

ben.cleuch

Capt B was victorious,
ben.cleuch

Got the match recorded...

[ElricTheGreat]

ah ha ... I see an opening ... my next victim iAmCaffeine

Game 15581841 - Home
Game 15581846 - Random

[ben.cleuch]

i challenge ben.cleuch
Game 15554277
Game 15554280
PM sent

I won 2-1
ben.cleuch

celliottii
did you get this one?

[MGSteve]

I challenge dhallmeyer to my old spot on the ladder
random Game 15567800
home Game 15567801
pw : elvis--------------------------------------------------------------------uh huh huh-------------------------------------->>>

I think we have a Rule 10 problem here. I'll wait to accept games until we get a ruling.

10. If you challenge someone AND lose, you will retain your Ladder rung, but you cannot re-challenge that player until after you have challenged someone else. For example, you are #9 and challenge and lose to the #6 player, you cannot challenge the #6 player until you challenge either #7 or #8.

How does it work if I challenged and won, and now I'm being challenged by the same player, with no intervening challenge from him?

I see it as a NEW challenge , my last challenge was to iAmCaffeine -------------uh hmmm hmmm.....................???

But this isn't a rule 10 matter the way I see it. dhall challenged the first time and gang challenged the 2nd time so it's not a matter of losing and challenging again without challenging someone else. It's a matter of a successful challenge by dhall followed by a challenge by gang. Not to beat a dead horse.

[MGSteve]

Steve ... hurry up and win your challenge so you jump ahead of me so I can challenge you to a rematch ...

nyuk nyuk! Yeah, you wanna get me again while my dice are in vacuum mode. Never pass up a tactical advantage.

[celliottii]

ah ha ... I see an opening ... my next victim iAmCaffeine

Game 15581841 - Home
Game 15581846 - Random

Sorry for the delay...got the challenge recorded for you...

i challenge ben.cleuch
Game 15554277
Game 15554280
PM sent

I won 2-1
ben.cleuch

celliottii
did you get this one?

yep...just did...

But this isn't a rule 10 matter the way I see it. dhall challenged the first time and gang challenged the 2nd time so it's not a matter of losing and challenging again without challenging someone else. It's a matter of a successful challenge by dhall followed by a challenge by gang. Not to beat a dead horse.

then stop beating it and grind it up already...my dog is hungry!

[celliottii]

I beat dhallmeyer 2 to 1 in our match...Ladder is updated...

[dhallmeyer]

Thanks for setting me straight guys.

I thought Rule 10 was a broad, no-tag-backs policy, but it appears I was wrong. Rule 10 only means that the challenger cannot re-challenge the same person.

It does not apply to a person losing their spot and then challenging to reclaim it.

Is that right?

[celliottii]

Thanks for setting me straight guys.

I thought Rule 10 was a broad, no-tag-backs policy, but it appears I was wrong. Rule 10 only means that the challenger cannot re-challenge the same person.

It does not apply to a person losing their spot and then challenging to reclaim it.

Is that right?

Dhallmeyer, I think I can best explain it this way, using our latest match as the example...

Prior to our match you were #7 and I was #4, so you challenged me. Since I won the match, I moved up one spot to #3 and you stayed at #7.

With Rule #10, you have to challenge someone at #6 (MGSteve), #5 (ElricTheGreat), or #4 (tamaynet...but you can't because he's being challenged by MGSteve) BEFORE you can re-challenge me.

Now once you challenge another player (regardless of you winning or losing that match), you could then challenge me, provided that I am still within the three ladder rung range.

If you had won the match, you would have moved up to #4 and I would move down to #5. I could challenge you to reclaim my spot, since you made the challenge in the prior match.

I hope this clears up Rule #10 for you.

Chuck

[ElricTheGreat]

Chuck ... I think you need to take a look at the ladder .... somehow dhallmeyer has turned bi-polar or something ... he is listed at 7 and 10

Thinking you oppsed during a copy / paste

[MGSteve]

Game 15551791 and Game 15551794 are for tamaynet. Walled

Challenge accepted.
My game is 15554251

I haven't finished cleaning up the 3rd game yet but tam won the first 2 so I lost that challenge.

[celliottii]

Chuck ... I think you need to take a look at the ladder .... somehow dhallmeyer has turned bi-polar or something ... he is listed at 7 and 10

Thinking you oppsed during a copy / paste

Good catch, Elric...I sent Vinyl-Taliban into limbo when I updated the Ladder last week. The Ladder has been restored with all players in their correct positions...I only needed to re-add Vinyl to the #10 spot.

Game 15551791 and Game 15551794 are for tamaynet. Walled

Challenge accepted.
My game is 15554251

I haven't finished cleaning up the 3rd game yet but tam won the first 2 so I lost that challenge.

Got the Ladder results recorded...

[MGSteve]

Since tam just kicked my butt, I challenge his ladderness, Chuck with Game 15606711 and Game 15606712.

[celliottii]

Since tam just kicked my butt, I challenge his ladderness, Chuck with Game 15606711 and Game 15606712.

I woke this morning...took my shower...logged on and the first thing I saw was an invite for Jamaica from Steve...(sigh)...nice way to start my day, you dear dear friend....

Challenge accepted...Here's my game: Game 15607011

Ladder is updated...

Good luck....