Conquer Club

Iron Butterfly wrote:

Nebuchadnezer wrote:lol...you know it's only L-1. I'm not sure playing the pity card before an actual lynch helps you. While I would love to get a claim from spiesr, I figured outing the doc was bad enough...although I can't for the life of me figure out who he would be...Hagrid? Why not suggest mass claim earlier? I would have gone with that...nothing to lose there.

While I did agree with some of your arguments, you started to seem desperate and wild in pointing to everyone around the board...

Wait...UNVOTE

TAILS...green part of your message please.

Once I have that, I'll vote Iron again...I hate being ignored.

Not at all.

I knew it inevitable I would be lynched. I simply did the job that no one else has wanted to do. Question those that have flaws in their stories. You cant tell me there have not been flaws in both MC and Chap. So you lynch me..what then? You going to revisit chap or MC?

At this point of the game it doesn't matter if the Doc is outed or not. There are enough power roles to figure out who is who. I would however be curious as to who the doc protected. There were three nights with no kills. Last night especially. If we find out who Everywhere blocked there may be a better understanding of what they are targeting.

Day three Neb was blocked by hippo and Mafia would not block its own. So either mafia was a no show or Everywhere had a good save.

LOL and if you have a were wolf who can recruit...well you have a whole new game on your hands.

If you think I am wrong in targeting Chap and MC...who exactly would you trust after that.
If Tails cant post a PM that passes a sniff test then he is connected to MC.

GOD...I got home around 4pm and have been thinking...I am punch crazy...wish me luck I go get an angio gram tomorrow to clean out my heart.

These are the little things that bother me...Everywhere did post his actions...

And hippo was the town role blocker.

strike wolf wrote:And hippo was the town role blocker.

Yes. As soon as Tails gets that green part of his PM out there...just trying to tidy everything up before going into night.

Who should I roleblock/protect tonight? I'm thinking about Neb...but for which one?!

chapcrap wrote:Who should I roleblock/protect tonight? I'm thinking about Neb...but for which one?!

Oh, man...please don't roleblock me...

Oh, man...please don't protect me...

chapcrap wrote:Who should I roleblock/protect tonight? I'm thinking about Neb...but for which one?!

Being that he appears to have been both Doc'd and blocked Night 3, I would say it is probably hard to determine what course of action was more important.

Nebuchadnezer wrote:Oh, man...please don't roleblock me...

Any reason?

It's kind of hard to decide...we have 4 roles that need to be protected (cop, doc, watcher and JOAT) but unless there's another protective role we can only protect three of them. Two if chap decides to use his role block rather than protect and I'm not sure we should tell anyone who we are protecting with absolute clarity to keep mafia from wifoming our actions. I'm unsure of Neb but with two innocent investigation results, I have to cautiously label him as town.

Yup you guys have it figured out.

LOL "who should I block?"

Make sure you send it in and have the action first.

Unvote

There seems to be some information that is being requested by others.

My bad everywhere.

I think IB is the direction to go in the short term. Unless tails comes up with something unexpected...that's the way i will vote.

As requested...

You are Lily Potter ( Wizard Watcher )

Mother of the Chose One, Harry Potter, and wife of James Potter, you have been betrayed
by Pewter when your son was barely 1 year old. Sielding him with your own life, you granted
Harry a powerful protection against Voldemort, which has however faded today. You, however,
have been brought back by mysterious events to shield your son once again against your
murderer.

-Tails

TA1LGUNN3R wrote:As requested...

You are Lily Potter ( Wizard Watcher )

Mother of the Chose One, Harry Potter, and wife of James Potter, you have been betrayed
by Pewter when your son was barely 1 year old. Sielding him with your own life, you granted
Harry a powerful protection against Voldemort, which has however faded today. You, however,
have been brought back by mysterious events to shield your son once again against your
murderer.

-Tails

I'm not sure what we gain by him posting, but I found errors.

chapcrap wrote:

TA1LGUNN3R wrote:As requested...

You are Lily Potter ( Wizard Watcher )

Mother of the Chose One, Harry Potter, and wife of James Potter, you have been betrayed
by Pewter when your son was barely 1 year old. Sielding him with your own life, you granted
Harry a powerful protection against Voldemort, which has however faded today. You, however,
have been brought back by mysterious events to shield your son once again against your
murderer.

-Tails

I'm not sure what we gain by him posting, but I found errors.

I see the errors and those are to be expected which we have found but the main part that I found a bit disturbing was the green section. It states they were brought back to shield him but is a watcher which can be more WIOFM but still noted.

and who is pewter? Im not hardcore HP but never heard of it.

Djfireside wrote:and who is pewter? Im not hardcore HP but never heard of it.

It should be Peter. as in Peter Pettigrew.

strike wolf wrote:

Djfireside wrote:and who is pewter? Im not hardcore HP but never heard of it.

It should be Peter. as in Peter Pettigrew.

Thank you. That clears it up for some reason just couldnt put my finger on what it could be

On the one hand, the errors could be evidence of blatant forgery. On the other hand, Tail has shown himself to be capable of forming cohesive thoughts using proper spelling and grammar, and if he was going to forge it he probably would not have made the errors, so it could be a sign that he did really copy paste it......overall a very WIFOMy proposition and I see no reason not to believe him anyway.

More simplu anyone could make typoea att any tiem

Thot woorks to!

I can not see anything new. I am thinking of just double vote and kill IB and move on. In any case he is my no2 suspected and he keeps trying to put my name in the list of the suspected which makes me mad .

mc05025 wrote:I can not see anything new. I am thinking of just double vote and kill IB and move on. In any case he is my no2 suspected and he keeps trying to put my name in the list of the suspected which makes me mad .

I am ok with this.

Same here.

UNVOTE

Realized my vote was still on everywhere and since I would have to believe there to be a doc and no counter, would have to state that would clear it. Your N4 action failing I have to read back through just to understand.

As for IB, I tend to believe them for whatever reason and their statements seem to fit which is why I havent jumped the bandwagon and I have been looking since day 2 to find something on them and have been trying to get them scummy but havent been able to.

We are at a impass and I am trying to see the best point. I have been rattling Chap's statements around they are still not fitting and the last statement that he made about who they should protect/Roleblock tonight kinda tipped it. The whole game they have been back and forth claiming defense against the mod but each time somehow keeps getting it flipped back around and now coming off with that just pushed me over at this point.

Vote Chap

So what do we do now? Knocking off IB would get us into the next day and give us more information and enough people seem to have thoughts against him. As they were called earlier, a glorified VT is true now since he has to know the name of the person he is going for. Or do we try to see one of the 3 that are still unknown and see if anything doesnt match. With a recruiter now I am more on edge of what could be out there.

Lol...i think town is a bit befuddled due to some terrible play, plenty of lies, and nothing ever coming out right the first time.

I'm all for a mass claim at this point...there its only three of us left. I would suggest spiesr, me, alt. Anyone have thoughts on this? I think I may need to refresh all the night actions and find the holes...

Djfireside wrote:Vote Chap

So what do we do now? Knocking off IB would get us into the next day and give us more information and enough people seem to have thoughts against him. As they were called earlier, a glorified VT is true now since he has to know the name of the person he is going for. Or do we try to see one of the 3 that are still unknown and see if anything doesnt match. With a recruiter now I am more on edge of what could be out there.

You vote me and then ask about other people?

strike, I think you are right to look funny at DJ. However, I still think IB is the best option for many reasons. First, the investigation I got on him, along with the alleged Death Eater result that he got. Not only that, IF, he is telling the truth, it is a minimal loss to town. I really believe he is scum, but even if I am wrong, it's not a great loss for town at all.

Borrowing from my previous post and updating for Everywhere's claim. New stuff in RED


Alive:

1) Nebuchadnezer – unclaimed, investigated twice by Strike Wolf, came up wizard both times.
2) Chapcrap – Professor McGonigal, JOAT; Night one investigated Iron Butterfly (got Non-wizard); (attempted to kill Iron Butterfly) Nothing night 2.; night 3 tracked Neb, got role blocked. N6 Claimed to doc someone, but then never sent in doc message. Also claims to have a doctor and a roleblocker ability left.
3) Tails – Lily Potter; watcher. N1 Hippo, nobody. N2 Spartacus, nobody. N3 Chapcrap visited by PCM. N4 Iron visited by Hippo and PCM. N5 MC05025, nobody. N6 Strike, nobody. Again, I have to note that PCM visited both Chap and Iron...why would he do this, if either one is mafia? Third party maybe...
4) Strike Wolf – Kingsley Shacklebolt, cop. N1 Hippo, innocent. N2 Neb, innocent. N3 Spiesr, innocent. N4 Neb, innocent. N5 Alt1978, innocent. N6 Everywhere, innocent. Not sure every result won't be innocent...
8 ) Victor SullivanReplaced by Everywhere116 - Madam Pomfrey, Doctor N1 Jonty, N2 Iron, N3 Neb, N4 Chapcrap, N5 TAILS, N6 TAILS.
9) Spiesr - ?????
13) Mc05025 – James Potter, double voter.
15) DJfireside – Ginny Weasley, secret backup role???
17) Alt - ?????
18) Iron Butterfly – Firenze, Death Eater Hunter (for lack of better term). Found Dazza on night one. Either was blocked on second investigation, or never used it??

So, again, here are my conclusions. If we trust that Strike Wolf is telling the truth, then we have the following:

Clear:

1. Strike Wolf – This assumption is built on him being the cop...so we have to assume he’s clear.
2. Neb – two investigations coming back innocent.
3. Alt1978 – investigate as innocent.
4. Spiesr – investigated as innocent.
5. Everywhere – investigated as innocent.

Not cleared, but look town:
1. Iron Butterfly – killed busdriver, been pretty good at chasing mafia.
2. Tails – He seems to be town. His night actions make sense. He’s paired up with MC05025, and his counter part, Lily.
3. MC05025 – The only thing saving him is his claim. Otherwise he’s disappeared from this game. Drops in to make a small comment and then nothing.
4. Chapcrap – claims JOAT, but can’t accept his own investigation of Iron as “not a wizard”, when Strike clearly state the three options of “wizard” “not a wizard” and “death eater.”
5. DJfireside – unforced claim, and has an unknown condition “if something happens”