Conquer Club

nagerous wrote:Also, who knows whether the entire fellowship is in the game. I would certainly hope that the moderator has not done such a thing as a mass claim could just win the game straight away, which takes away from the excitement of the game.

karelpietertje wrote:

nagerous wrote:Also, who knows whether the entire fellowship is in the game. I would certainly hope that the moderator has not done such a thing as a mass claim could just win the game straight away, which takes away from the excitement of the game.

I have read of very complicated characters that are townies but can become the bad guys.
now i dont know the books that well... have any characters become bad?

Minister Masket wrote:

karelpietertje wrote:

nagerous wrote:Also, who knows whether the entire fellowship is in the game. I would certainly hope that the moderator has not done such a thing as a mass claim could just win the game straight away, which takes away from the excitement of the game.

I have read of very complicated characters that are townies but can become the bad guys.
now i dont know the books that well... have any characters become bad?

Oh yes. Primarily Boromir.

nagerous wrote:Also, who knows whether the entire fellowship is in the game. I would certainly hope that the moderator has not done such a thing as a mass claim could just win the game straight away, which takes away from the excitement of the game.

pmchugh wrote:

Minister Masket wrote:Oh yes. Primarily Boromir.

But wasn't that just a breif thing cause of the ring, you wouldn't call Galadrial bad but I distinctly remember her going nuts cause of the ring.

pmchugh wrote:

Minister Masket wrote:

karelpietertje wrote:

nagerous wrote:Also, who knows whether the entire fellowship is in the game. I would certainly hope that the moderator has not done such a thing as a mass claim could just win the game straight away, which takes away from the excitement of the game.

I have read of very complicated characters that are townies but can become the bad guys.
now i dont know the books that well... have any characters become bad?

Oh yes. Primarily Boromir.

But wasn't that just a breif thing cause of the ring, you wouldn't call Galadrial bad but I distinctly remember her going nuts cause of the ring.

tbh I think a mass claim would win us this game no bother but I would rather try and play it properly. In these games there should be a rule against it.

Mr. Squirrel wrote:What's a mass claim?

Suspect101 wrote:The problem with mass claiming is that it takes all the fun out of the game.

Mr. Squirrel wrote:

Suspect101 wrote:The problem with mass claiming is that it takes all the fun out of the game.

Sounds like it. I take it that mass claiming doesn't happen often?

Suspect101 wrote:so...............

pmchugh wrote:Found this while looknig about:

spiesr wrote:So, are pmc and Suspect scum buddies having an angry, but ultimately futile, argument on day 1 to distance themselves from each other?

And now you seem to be suggesting that he is a lyncher out to get me.

Do not mistake our over enthusiasm for our roles, and suggesting we are scum buddies trying to distance ourselves from each other it would be a ridiculous plan as we put both of our selves in the spotlight where we could easily have been lycnhed. It would be far too big a sacrafice and a stupid plan. You seem to be slighly trying to start a bandwagon on suspect and I am suspicious becasue of that, because you are trying to influence other people without having the guts to do the voting yourself.

unvote vote speisr

pmchugh wrote:

Suspect101 wrote:so...............

Yeah cause that helps us with the game.

pmchugh wrote:

Suspect101 wrote:so...............

Yeah cause that helps us with the game.

pmchugh wrote:Found this while looknig about:

spiesr wrote:So, are pmc and Suspect scum buddies having an angry, but ultimately futile, argument on day 1 to distance themselves from each other?

And now you seem to be suggesting that he is a lyncher out to get me.

Do not mistake our over enthusiasm for our roles, and suggesting we are scum buddies trying to distance ourselves from each other it would be a ridiculous plan as we put both of our selves in the spotlight where we could easily have been lycnhed. It would be far too big a sacrafice and a stupid plan. You seem to be slighly trying to start a bandwagon on suspect and I am suspicious becasue of that, because you are trying to influence other people without having the guts to do the voting yourself.

unvote vote speisr

speisr you never answered this, your theorys seem ridiculous surely no-one would think that either me or speisr were stupid enough to do either of the things you suggested so then I wonder, what was your motovation behind your accustations?

Clive wrote:I don't like this wagon on Pmc. His deductions were logical.

Unvote;
Vote: Iliad

Clive wrote:

It is day 1. We have nothing to go on. If you are the person acting scummy, even a little bit, you will get the votes and the questions thrown your way.

Not true, just because it's D1 doesn't mean there's nothing to go on. And I really hate your second sentence. D1 is not just about a random lynch. You also seem to imply that only one person can act scummy on D1, which doesn't make any sense.

I find your attempt to generate a wagon on Pmc scummy, I fail to see how speculating on what we might be up against is a scumtell.

Iliad: It didn't sound much like a joke vote, but i'll let it go.

Unvote;
Vote: Suspect

Clive wrote:

Suspect101 wrote:

Suspect101 wrote:

Clive wrote:

It is day 1. We have nothing to go on. If you are the person acting scummy, even a little bit, you will get the votes and the questions thrown your way.

Not true, just because it's D1 doesn't mean there's nothing to go on. And I really hate your second sentence. D1 is not just about a random lynch. You also seem to imply that only one person can act scummy on D1, which doesn't make any sense.

No, we do have nothing to go on, no sound proof of anything, if you know something we don't please do tell. I never said it was about a random lynch nor did I imply that only one person could be scummy. I said PMC looks the scummiest, meaning there could be more than one. He is the one I want to pressure, because as he even admits, he has been acting scummy. Voting for someone does not mean you want to lynch them, it can also mean that you want to pressure them into proving they are innocent, which I am doing.

Clive wrote:I find your attempt to generate a wagon on Pmc scummy, I fail to see how speculating on what we might be up against is a scumtell.

Why do you find my "attempt to bandwagon PMC" scummy? Any reasons or just to try and pass the blame? The reason you do not know why speculating is a scum tell is because you do not read or your are scum and trying make PMC look innocent. If you read all the posts more than just me explained why speculating is scummy.

Vote Clive

He still has not answered my questions, probably because he still is only skimming. Not only this he seems to be lurking.

I am not lurking, I have posted eveyday.

Why do you find my "attempt to bandwagon PMC" scummy?

Because I think the way he speculated on the setup was a pro-town thing to do, and you are isisting it's scummy and pushing a bandwagon on him for it.

Any reasons or just to try and pass the blame?

This has been my stance from the get go, I have no blame to shift.

The reason you do not know why speculating is a scum tell is because you do not read or your are scum and trying make PMC look innocent.

No, it's because i'm town, and i've tried to think about it logically.

If you read all the posts more than just me explained why speculating is scummy.

I strongly disagree.

However, now that i've read more, i'm starting to feel you're actually a misguided townie.

Unvote

Clive wrote:If I think someone being wagonned is town then I am going to defend that person. And if I think people wagonning him are scummy, I am going to attack them.

Clive wrote:If I think someone being wagonned is town then I am going to defend that person. And if I think people wagonning him are scummy, I am going to attack them.

I fail to see how consistency is a scumtell.

Vote: Suspect

pmchugh wrote:

pmchugh wrote:You seem to be slighly trying to start a bandwagon on suspect and I am suspicious becasue of that, because you are trying to influence other people without having the guts to do the voting yourself.

unvote vote speisr

speisr you never answered this, your theorys seem ridiculous surely no-one would think that either me or speisr were stupid enough to do either of the things you suggested so then I wonder, what was your motovation behind your accustations?

spiesr wrote:

Minister Masket wrote:I agree that spiesr has been making very little actual sense, and is generally voting without proper reason.

I have just been trying to find something worthwhile to go with. So far I haven't had much luck...

Suspect101 wrote:

Clive wrote:If I think someone being wagonned is town then I am going to defend that person. And if I think people wagonning him are scummy, I am going to attack them.

I fail to see how consistency is a scumtell.

Vote: Suspect

LOL, you take your vote off me, once I point this out, you put it right back on.......

Mr. Squirrel wrote:I agree with suspect here. Clive took his vote off suspect originally because he thinks him to be a "misguided townie" but as soon as Suspect pointed out his voting history, he quickly put the vote back on. Seems awfully strange to me.

pmchugh wrote:speisr you never answered this, your theorys seem ridiculous surely no-one would think that either me or speisr were stupid enough to do either of the things you suggested so then I wonder, what was your motovation behind your accustations?

spiesr wrote:Sorry, busy day. Anyhow I don't believe that I have really been trying to influence people yet, what I intended to do was to throw out my mediocre ideas and see if anybody thought they had any merit. Just for something to discuss.

pmchugh wrote:speisr you never answered this, your theorys seem ridiculous surely no-one would think that either me or speisr were stupid enough to do either of the things you suggested so then I wonder, what was your motovation behind your accustations?

I had ideas that turned out to be quite lame That I felt like mentioning for possible discussion, I posted my thoughts that I had as that was about all I could come up with at that moment.