Page 7 of 11
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [10/?]
Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2016 9:00 am
by rockfist
This may be a bad idea, but if we can't have 8 or 16 participants why not do a round robin tournament, that way there are no byes and all have equal chance?
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [10/?]
Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2016 9:42 am
by uckuki
rockfist wrote:This may be a bad idea, but if we can't have 8 or 16 participants why not do a round robin tournament, that way there are no byes and all have equal chance?
it doesn't look doable. with 10 clans round robin would take like 2 years to finish, way too long.
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [10/?]
Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2016 9:43 am
by Keefie
Sorry guys but I just can't stand the tinkering that's going on with this tournament.
It was mean't to be run along the same lines as the 1v1, but it's morphing into something else. We can now have 1 player playing in 4 home and 4 away sets !!!!!
HH will consider withdrawing over the next couple of days.
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [10/?]
Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2016 9:47 am
by Keefie
Keefie wrote:Sorry guys but I just can't stand the tinkering that's going on with this tournament.
It was mean't to be run along the same lines as the 1v1, but it's morphing into something else. We can now have 1 player playing in 4 home and 4 away sets !!!!!
HH will consider withdrawing over the next couple of days.
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [10/?]
Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2016 9:49 am
by uckuki
Keefie wrote:Sorry guys but I just can't stand the tinkering that's going on with this tournament.
It was mean't to be run along the same lines as the 1v1, but it's morphing into something else. We can now have 1 player playing in 4 home and 4 away sets !!!!!
HH will consider withdrawing over the next couple of days.
it's not 4 + 4. limit is still 4 total (w/out tie-breaker).
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [10/?]
Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2016 9:56 am
by Donelladan
Keefie wrote:Sorry guys but I just can't stand the tinkering that's going on with this tournament.
It was mean't to be run along the same lines as the 1v1, but it's morphing into something else. We can now have 1 player playing in 4 home and 4 away sets !!!!!
HH will consider withdrawing over the next couple of days.
Yes basically the only thing that changed is from a best of 5 to a best of 3 to have less games to play and attract more clans.
Also some restriction about the setting ( unlimited for example).
What I was asking, and hasn't been accepted yet I think, is that someone can play 4 games, either 4 homes, or 4 away, or 2 away and 2 home, or 3/1, total 4 games, but doesn't matter if home or away. But that was a personal request because I think as long as we put 4 games max per player it doesn't matter if they are home or away.
But no one speak about 8 games per players - that is a misunderstanding.
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [10/?]
Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2016 10:02 am
by Keefie
We should stick with 2 sets of home maps and 2 sets of away maps as the limit.
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [10/?]
Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2016 10:35 am
by Tazzy_J
Keefie wrote:We should stick with 2 sets of home maps and 2 sets of away maps as the limit.
My understanding is that it still is that (not incl the tie breaker)
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [10/?]
Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2016 10:46 am
by Keefie
Tazzy_J wrote:Keefie wrote:We should stick with 2 sets of home maps and 2 sets of away maps as the limit.
My understanding is that it still is that (not incl the tie breaker)
uckuki mentioned that he could make it negotiable
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [10/?]
Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2016 11:08 am
by uckuki
Limit is 4. the question is how flexible we wanna be with 2/2 split?
once, in random league, I gave 3 home and 1 away sets to one of my guys
by mistake. I didn't gain any advantage or lose anything by doing so.
if a player uses all 4 for home series then that player is not available for away
games.
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [10/?]
Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2016 2:27 pm
by IcePack
I think 4 max is easier for the clans with 10-12 guys (use them where they can as most will get maxed). It keeps them competitive.
For the rest it's probably not a big difference, I'm fine either way for FALL. 4 or 2/2.
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [10/?]
Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2016 2:30 pm
by Keefie
2/2 for me
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [10/?]
Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2016 4:27 pm
by Donelladan
Keefie wrote:2/2 for me
Hey, I am just wondering, why does it make a difference ? It's not such a big deal, as IcePack said, it's just to make it easier for me in case I need it, definitely not essential.
Btw the 2/2 or 4 always been negotiable from the OP. At the moment the default rule is 2/2 and if both clan agree they can make it 4 max but doesn't matter away or home.
I am fine with it anyway, but just wondering why it matter for some people.
Btw, I am happy to announce you that LHDD is in !!!!!
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [10/?]
Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2016 5:56 pm
by IcePack
Wow, the competition is going to be fierce here. 11 sign ups, and 8/11 right now are Top 10 clans.
F400 Top 10 (April 1st)
FALL - joined
TOFU - joined
LHDD - joined
FOED - joined
TOP
S&M - joined
ATN - joined
ACE - joined
LOW
RET - joined
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [10/?]
Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2016 7:23 pm
by josko.ri
IcePack wrote:Wow, the competition is going to be fierce here. 11 sign ups, and 7/11 right now are Top 10 clans.
F400 Top 10 (April 1st)
FALL - joined
TOFU - joined
LHDD - joined
FOED - joined
TOP
S&M - joined
ATN
ACE - joined
LOW
RET - joined
Isn't Atn also in?
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [10/?]
Posted: Wed Apr 13, 2016 7:32 pm
by IcePack
josko.ri wrote:IcePack wrote:Wow, the competition is going to be fierce here. 11 sign ups, and 8/11 right now are Top 10 clans.
F400 Top 10 (April 1st)
FALL - joined
TOFU - joined
LHDD - joined
FOED - joined
TOP
S&M - joined
ATN - joined
ACE - joined
LOW
RET - joined
Isn't Atn also in?
Yep, I missed it in the OP. I'll edit!
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [11/?]
Posted: Thu Apr 14, 2016 11:07 am
by benga
Uck, osa has joined couple of posts ago, don't be afraid to add us
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [11/?]
Posted: Thu Apr 14, 2016 11:21 am
by IcePack
That makes 12
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge - SIGNUPS [11/?]
Posted: Mon Apr 18, 2016 12:28 pm
by uckuki
benga wrote:Uck, osa has joined couple of posts ago, don't be afraid to add us
ups osa
ur in.
md said they'll skip. I haven't got any replies asking to delay it little more.
I think this is it folks, 12 teams - 8 play-in round, 4 byes, random draw.
I can do the draw, or we can ask Lx to do it?
we can move the thread to the Active Challenges section?
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge [12/12]
Posted: Mon Apr 18, 2016 1:10 pm
by Keefie
I'm sure Lx would be happy to do it.
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge [12/12]
Posted: Mon Apr 18, 2016 2:55 pm
by Lindax
S&M VS OSA
ATN > Bye
RET > Bye
HH vs FALL
LHDD > Bye
FAD > Bye
FISO vs TOFU
FOED vs ACE
There were 16 items in your list. Here they are in random order:
S&M
OSA
ATN
BYE
BYE
RET
HH
FALL
LHDD
BYE
BYE
FAD
FISO
TOFU
FOED
ACE
Timestamp: 2016-04-18 19:51:33 UTC, IP: 189.151.8.56
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge [12/12]
Posted: Tue Apr 19, 2016 4:15 am
by benga
goody!
when can we start?
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge [12/12]
Posted: Tue Apr 19, 2016 4:20 am
by josko.ri
And I am interested which are the latest deadlines for starting the opening round. I would like to have this going after Random League ends to not have overlapping, which is 2.5 weeks after now.
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge [12/12]
Posted: Tue Apr 19, 2016 5:55 am
by bergy1
Starting to rather like Lindax
Lindax wrote:S&M VS OSA
ATN > Bye
RET > Bye
HH vs FALL
LHDD > Bye
FAD > Bye
FISO vs TOFU
FOED vs ACE
There were 16 items in your list. Here they are in random order:
S&M
OSA
ATN
BYE
BYE
RET
HH
FALL
LHDD
BYE
BYE
FAD
FISO
TOFU
FOED
ACE
Timestamp: 2016-04-18 19:51:33 UTC, IP: 189.151.8.56
Re: [POLY] 1st POLY Clan Challenge [12/12]
Posted: Tue Apr 19, 2016 7:42 pm
by uckuki
POLY is now active, you can start your wars right away. the sooner the better, we've already had enough delay as it is.
I haven't set specific deadlines. if things are stalling let me know.